Facing guilt: Role of negative affectivity,need for reparation,and fear of punishment in leading to prosocial behaviour and aggression

Abstract

The present study aims to further corroborate and to extend the scope of previous findings regarding the path of influence between negative affectivity, need for reparation and fear of punishment when examining the determinants and the motivational components of guilt. Data were collected from three different European countries (i.e. Italy, Hungary, and the Czech Republic). About 1100 young adolescents were involved in the research. The generalizability of a nomological network linking individual differences in Negative Affectivity to Need for Reparation, Fear of Punishment, Prosocial Behaviour, and Aggression has been investigated across countries and gender, by means of structural equation modelling. Need for Reparation turns out to be positively related to Prosocial Behaviour and negatively related to Aggression. Fear for Punishment turns out to be positively related to Aggression and negatively related to Prosocial Behaviour, with the exception of Hungary. Alternative paths of influence among considered variables have been examined. Practical implications for prevention and education are underlined. Copyright © 2001 John Wiley & Sons, Ltd.

References

American sychiatric Association.1987. Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders 3rd edn, rev. American Psychiatric Association: Washington, DC.

Bandura

Barbaranelli

Caprara

Pastorelli

.1996a.Mechanisms of moral disengagement in the exercise of moral agency. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology 71:364–374.

Bandura

Barbaranelli

Caprara

Pastorelli

.1996b.Multifaceted impact of self‐efficacy beliefs on academic functioning. Child Development 67:1206–1222.

Bandura

Walters

,.1963. Adolescent Aggression. Ronald: New York.

Barbaranelli

Caprara

Rabasca

.1998.BFQ‐C. Big Five Questionnaire Children. Manuale. Organizzazioni Speciali: Firenze.

Baumeister

Stillwell

Heatherton

.1994.Guilt: an interpersonal approach. Psychological Bulletin 115:243–267.

Baumeister

Stillwell

Heatherton

.1995. Interpersonal aspects of guilt: evidence from narrative studies. In Self‐Conscious Emotions, Tangney JP , Fisher KW (eds). Guilford: New York;255–273.

Bentler

.1990.Comparative fit indexes in structural equations models. Psychological Bulletin 107:238–246.

Bentler

.1995. EQS Structural Equations Program Manual. Multivariate: Encino, CA.

10.

Bentler

Bonett

,.1980.Significance tests and goodness of fit in the analysis of covariance structures. Psychological Bulletin 88:558–606.

11.

Berkowitz

.1993. Aggression: its Causes, Consequences, and Control. McGraw‐Hill: New York.

12.

Bollen

.1989. Structural Equations with Latent Variables. Wiley: New York.

13.

Browne

Cudeck

,.1993. Alternative ways of assessing model fit. In Testing Structural Equation Models, Bollen KA , Long JS (eds). Sage: Newbury Park, CA;136–162.

14.

Byrne

.1994.Testing the factorial validity, replication, and invariance of a measuring instrument: a paradigmatic application based on the Maslach Burnout Inventory. Multivariate Behavioral Research 29:289–311.

15.

Caprara

.1987.The disposition–situation debate and research on aggression. European Journal of Personality 1:116.

16.

Caprara

Barbaranelli

Borgogni

.1993. BFQ. Big Five Questionnaire. Organizzazioni Speciali: Firenze.

17.

Caprara

Barbaranelli

Comrey

.1992.A personological approach to the study of aggression. Personality and Individual Differences 13:77–84.

18.

Caprara

Barbaranelli

Incatasciato

Pastorelli

Rabasca

.1997. Emotional instability, physical and verbal aggression and prosocial behavior as precursors of scholastic achievement and social adjustment. In Biological and Social Determinants of Aggression, Feshbach S , Zagrodzka J (eds). Plenum: New York;111–120.

19.

Caprara

Barbaranelli

Livi

.1994.Mapping personality dimensions into the Five Factor Model. European Review of Applied Psychology 44:9–15.

20.

Caprara

Barbaranelli

Pastorelli

.2001. Prosocial behavior and aggression in childhood and early adolescence. In Constructive and Destructive Behavior: Implications for Family, School and Society, Stipek D , Bohart A (eds). APA: Washington, DC.

21.

Caprara

Barbaranelli

Pastorelli

Bandura

Zimbardo

.2000.Prosocial foundations of children's academic achievement. Psychological Science 11:302–306.

22.

Caprara

Cinanni

D'Imperio

Passerini

Renzi

Travaglia

.1985.Indicators of impulsive aggression: present status of research on irritability and emotional susceptibility scales. Personality and Individual Differences 6:665–674.

23.

Caprara

Cinanni

Passerini

Renzi

Zelli

.1983.Caratteristiche e sviluppi di due scale per la misura dell'irritabilita' e della suscettibilita' emotiva: indicazioni di ricerca in ambito clinico [Characteristics and development of two scales for measuring irritability and emotional susceptibility: research suggestions in clinical domain]. Psicologia Clinica 3:323–346.

24.

Caprara

Manzy

Perugini

.1992.Investigating guilt in relation to emotionality and aggression. Personality and Individual Differences 13:519–532.

25.

Caprara

Pastorelli

,.1993.Early emotional instability, prosocial behavior and aggression: some methodological aspects. European Journal of Personality 7:19–36.

26.

Caprara

Pastorelli

Weiner

.1994.At‐risk children's causal inferences given emotional feedback and their understanding of excuse giving process. European Journal of Personality 8:31–43.

27.

Caprara

Perugini

Barbaranelli

.1994. Studies of individual differences in aggression. In The Dynamics of Aggression, Potegal M , Knutson JF (eds). Erlbaum: Hillsdale, NJ;123–153.

28.

Caprara

Perugini

Pastorelli

Barbaranelli

.1990.Esplorazione delle dimensioni comuni della colpa e dell' aggressivita' [Exploration of common dimensions of guilt and aggression]. Giornale Italiano di Psicologia 17:665–681.

29.

Dienstbier

.1984. The role of emotion in moral socialization. In Emotions, Cognition and Behavior, Izard C , Kagan J , Zajonc R (eds). Cambridge University Press: New York.

30.

Eisenberg

Fabes

,.1998. Prosocial development. In Handbook of Child Psychology. Fifth Edition. Social, Emotional, and Personality Development, Eisenberg N (ed.). Wiley: New York;701–778.

31.

Feingold

.1994.Gender differences in personality: a meta‐analysis. Psychological Bulletin 116:429–456.

32.

Fenichel

.1945. The Psychoanalytic Theory of Neurosis. Norton: New York.

33.

Fischer

Tangney

,.1995. Self‐conscious emotions and affect revolution: framework and overview. In Self‐Conscious Emotions, Tangney JP , Fisher KW (eds). Guilford: New York;3–22.

34.

Freud

.1915. Character‐Types in Psychoanalytic Work: III Criminality from a Sense of Guilt, Standard edn, Vol. XIV. Hogarth: London.

35.

Freud

.1924. The Economic Problem of Masochism, Standard edn, Vol. XIX. Hogarth: London.

36.

Harder

.1995. Shame and guilt assessment and relationships of shame and guilt proneness to psychopathology. In Self‐Conscious Emotions, Tangney JP , Fisher KW (eds). Guilford: New York;368–392.

37.

Harder

Cutler

Rockart

.1992.Assessment of shame and guilt and their relationship to psychopathology. Journal of Personality Assessment 55:729–745.

38.

Hoffman

.1976. Empathy, role taking, guilt, and development of altruistic motives. In Moral Development and Behavior, Lickona T (ed.). Holt, Rinehart and Winston: New York;124–143.

39.

Hoffman

.1982. Development of prosocial motivation: empathy and guilt. In The Development of Prosocial Behavior, Eisenberg N (ed.). Academic: San Diego, CA;281–313.

40.

Klein

.1948.On the theory of anxiety and guilt. International Journal of Psycho‐analysis 29.

41.

Klein

.1957. Envy and Gratitude. Tavistock: London.

42.

Kochanska

.1991.Socialization and temperament in the development of guilt and conscience. Child Development 62:1379–1392.

43.

Kugler

Jones

,.1992.On conceptualizing and assessing guilt. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology 62:318–327.

44.

Lebovici

.1971. Les Sentiments de Culpabilitè chez l'Enfant et chez l'Adult [Guilt Feelings in Children and Adults]. Hachette: Paris.

45.

Lewis

.1971. Shame and Guilt in Neurosis. International Universities Press: New York.

46.

Lewis

.1991.Self‐conscious emotions and the development of self. Journal of the American Psychoanalytic Association 39:45–73.

47.

Mosher

.1966.The development of a multitrait‐multimethod matrix analysis of three measures of three aspects of guilt. Journal of Consulting Psychology 30:25–29.

48.

Ortony

.1987.Is guilt an emotion? Cognition and Emotion 1:283–298.

49.

Pastorelli

Barbaranelli

Cermak

Rosza

Caprara

.1997.Measuring emotional instability, prosocial behavior and aggression in pre‐adolescents: a cross‐national study. Personality and Individual Differences 23:691–703.

50.

Patterson

.1982. Coercive Family Process. Castalia: Eugene, OR.

51.

Rawls

.1971. A Theory of Justice. Oxford University Press: London.

52.

Sandler

..1987.The past unconscious, the present unconscious and the vicissitude of guilt. International Journal of Psycho‐Analysis 68:697–702.

53.

Scott‐Lennox

,.1995. Sex–race differences in social support and depression in older low‐income adults. In Structural Equation Modeling. Concepts, Issues, and Applications, Hoyle RH (ed.). Sage: Thousand Oaks, CA;199–216.

54.

Steiger

.1990.Structural model evaluation and modification: an interval estimation approach. Multivariate Behavioral Research 25:173–180.

55.

Tanaka

.1993. Multifaceted conceptions of fit in structural equation models. In Testing Structural Equation Models, Bollen KA , Long JS (eds). Sage: Newbury Park, CA;10–39.

56.

Tangney

.1990.Assessing individual differences in proneness to shame and guilt: development of the Self‐Conscious Affect and Attribution Inventory. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology 59:102–111.

57.

Tangney

.1995.Recent advances in the empirical study of shame and guilt. American Behavioral Scientist 38:1132–1145.

58.

Tangney JP , Fisher KW (eds).1995. Self‐Conscious Emotions. Guilford: New York.

59.

Tangney

Wagner

Fletcher

Gramzow

.1992.Shame into anger? The relation of shame and guilt to anger and self‐reported aggression. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology 62:669–675.

60.

Taylor

.1985. Pride, Shame and Guilt. Clarendon: Oxford.

61.

Tucker

Lewis

,.1973.The reliability coefficient for maximum likelihood factor analysis. Psychometrika 38:1–10.

62.

Watson

Clark

,.1992.Affects separable and inseparable: on the hierarchical arrangement of the negative affects. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology 62:489–505.

63.

Watson

Clark

Tellegen

.1988.Development and validation of brief measures of positive and negative affect: the PANAS scales. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology 54:1063–1070.

64.

Watson

Tellegen

,.1985.Toward a consensual structure of mood. Psychological Bulletin 98:219–235.

65.

Weiner

.1986. An Attributional Theory of Motivation and Emotion. Springer: New York.

66.

Weiner

.1995. Judgments of Responsibility: a Foundation for a Theory of Social Conduct. Guilford: New York.

67.

Zahn‐Waxler

Kochanska

,.1990. The origins of guilt. In 1988 Nebraska Symposium on Motivation, Thompson RA (ed.). University of Nebraska Press: Lincoln, NE;183–258.