The Regulatory,Technology and Market ‘Dark Arts Trilogy’ of High Frequency Trading: A Research Agenda

Abstract

Computerization has transformed financial markets with high frequency trading displacing human activity with proprietary algorithms to lower latency, reduce intermediary costs, enhance liquidity and increase transaction speed. Following the “Flash Crash” of 2010 which saw the Dow Jones Industrial Average plunge 1000 points within minutes, high frequency trading has come under the radar of multi-jurisdictional regulators. Combining a review of the extant literature on high frequency trading with empirical data from interviews with financial traders, computer experts and regulators, we develop concepts of regulatory adaptation, technology asymmetry and market ambiguity to illustrate the ‘dark art’ of high frequency trading. Findings show high frequency trading is a multi-faceted, complex and secretive practice. It is implicated in market events, but correlation does not imply causation, as isolating causal mechanisms from interconnected automated financial trading is highly challenging for regulators who seek to monitor algorithmic trading across multiple jurisdictions. This article provides information systems researchers with a set of conceptual tools for analysing high frequency trading.

Keywords

high frequency trading regulation asymmetry financial markets algorithms

References

Ahmed

(2015). The market is rigged-Michael Lewis, [www article] http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/business-32246655 (accessed 8 June 2015).

Aitken

M. J.

, dimming

D. J.

, & Zhan

(2014). Trade Size. High Frequency Trading, and Co-Location Around the World, European Journal of Finance, 6, 1–21.

Aldridge

(2013). High Frequency Trading: A Practical Guide to Algorithmic Strategies and Trading Systems. Hoboken: Wiley Trading, John Wiley & Sons.

Angel

J. J.

(2014). When Finance Meets Physics: The Impact of the Speed of Light on Financial Markets and their Regulation. The Financial Review, 49(2), 1–15.

Avison

, & Malaurent

(2014). Is Theory King? Questioning the Theory Fetish in Information Systems Research, Journal of Information Technology, 29, 327–336.

Bamberger

K. A.

(2009). Technologies of Compliance: Risk and Regulation in a Digital Age. Texas Law Review, 88, 669.

Baron

, Brogaard

, and Kirilenko

(2014). Risk and Return in High Frequency Trading, [www document] http://www.cftc.gov/idc/groups/public/@economicanalysis/documents/file/oce_riskandreturn0414.pdf (accessed 8 June 2015).

Bell

H.A.

(2013). Policy Analysis: High Frequency Trading, CATO Institute, No. 731, 22: 1–11, [www article] http://object.cato.org/sites/cato.org/files/pubs/pdf/pa731_web_l.pdf (accessed 8 June 2015).

Biais

, & Foucault

(2014). HFT and Market Quality. Bankers, Markets & Investors, 128, 5–19.

10.

Biais

, Foucault

, and Moinas

(2011). Equilibrium Algorithmic Trading, Working Paper, Universite of Toulouse.

11.

Blocher

, Cooper

R. A.

, Seddon

, & Van Vliet

(2016). Phantom Liquidity and High Frequency Quoting. Journal of Trading, 11(3), 6–15.

12.

Bodek

(2013). The Problem of HFT: Collected Writings on High Frequency Trading & Stock Market Structure Reform. Decimus Capital Markets.

13.

Brogaard

, Hagströmer

, Nordén

, & Riordan

(2015). Trading Fast and Slow: Colocation and Liquidity. Review of Financial Studies, 28(12), 3407–3443.

14.

Brogaard

, Hendershott

, & Riordan

(2014). High-frequency Trading and Price Discovery. Review of Financial Studies, 27, 2267–2306.

15.

Budish

, Cramton

, & Shim

(2015). The High-Frequency Trading Arms Race: Frequent Batch Auctions as a Market Design Response. The Quarterly Journal of Economics, 140(4), 1547–1621.

16.

Cadwalder. (2015a). CME and ICE Disruptive Trading Practices Rules Summary, [www document] http://www.cadwalader.com/uploads/media/020615CME_and_ICE_Disruptive_Trading_Practices_Rules_Summary_Chart.pdf (accessed 8 June 2015).

17.

Cadwalder. (2015b). New Exchange Rules on Disruptive Trading Practices Summary Chart, [www article] http://www.cadwalader.com/resources/clients-friends-memos/new-exchange-rules-on-disruptive-trading-practices-summary-chart?utm_source=Mondaq&utm_medium=syndication&utm_campaign=View-Original (accessed 8 June 2015).

18.

Carlo

J. L.

, Lyytinen

, & Rose

G. M.

(2011). Internet Computing as a Disruptive Information Technology Innovation: The Role of Strong Order Effects. Information Systems Journal, 21(1), 91–122.

19.

CESR - The Committee of European Securities Regulators. (2007). Best Execution under MiFID, CESR/07–320, [www document] https://www.esma.europa.eu/sites/default/files/library/2015/11/07_320.pdf.

20.

CFTC. (2012). CFTC Technology Advisory Committee on Automated and High Frequency Trading, [www document] http://www.cftc.gov/idc/groups/public/@newsroom/documents/file/tac103012_wg1.pdf.

21.

CFTC-SEC. (2011). Summary Report of the Joint CFTC-SEC Advisory Committee on Emerging Regulatory Issues, [www document] http://www.sec.gov/spotlight/seccftcjointcommittee/021811-report.pdf.

22.

Chaboud

A. P.

, Chiquoine

, Hjalmarsson

, & Vega

(2014). Rise of the Machines: Algorithmic Trading in the Foreign Exchange Market. The Journal of Finance, 69(5), 2045–2084.

23.

Chung

K.H.

, and Chuwonganant

(2012). Uncertainty, Fear and Liquidity, [www article] http://m.kdi.re.kr/data/download/attach/9598_3-4.pdf.

24.

Cooper

, Davis

, & Van Vliet

(2016). The Mysterious Ethics of High-Frequency Trading. Business Ethics Quarterly, 26(01), 1–22.

25.

Cooper

, & Van Vliet

(2015). Expected Return in High Frequency Trading. Journal of Trading, 10(2), 34–40.

26.

Davies

, and Richardson

(2010). Evolution of the UK banking system. Bank of England Quarterly Bulletin 4: 321–332, [www article] http://www.bankofengland.co.uk/publications/Documents/quarterlybulletin/qb100407.pdf.

27.

DeFrancesco

(2014). CAT Conundrum: SRO's, Vendors Vie to Build Consolidated Audit Trail, Oct 14, [www article] http://www.waterstechnology.com/waters/feature/2375167/cat-conundrum-sros-vendors-vie-to-build-consolidated-audit-trail.

28.

Dehning

, Richardson

, & Zmud

(2003). The Value Relevance of Announcements of Transformational Information Technology Investments. MIS Quarterly, 34(5), 717–737.

29.

Duhigg

(2009). Stock Traders find Speed Pays in Milliseconds. The New York Times, New York, p. 23.

30.

Easthope

, and Chermaine

(2009). Demystifying and Evaluating High Frequency Equities Trading. Fast Forward or Pause?, [www document] http://www.celent.com/reports/demystifying-and-evaluating-high-frequency-equities-trading-fast-forward-or-pause.

31.

Egginton

J. F.

, Van Ness

B. F.

, and Van Ness

R. A.

(2014). Quote Stuffing, [www document] https://www.business.msstate.edu/magnolia/pdf/quote-stuffing.pdf.

32.

Eisenhardt

(1989). Building Theories from Case Study Research. Academy of Management, 14(4), 532–549.

33.

Ellsberg

(1961). Risk, Ambiguity, and the Savage Axioms. Quarterly Journal of Economics, 75(4), 643–669. doi:10.2307/1884324.

34.

Eng

E. M.

, Fank

, & Lyn

E. O.

(2013). Finding Best Execution in the Dark: Market Fragmentation and the Rise of Dark Pools. Journal of International Business and Law, 12(1), 39–50.

35.

ESMA (European Securities and Markets Authority). (2014a). Consultation Paper: MiFID II/MiFIR, ESMA/2014/1570, [www article] https://www.esma.europa.eu/press-news/consultations/consultation-paper-mifid-iimifir.

36.

ESMA (European Securities and Markets Authority). (2014b). Economic Report High-frequency trading activity in EU equity markets, [www article] https://www.esma.europa.eu/sites/default/files/library/2015/11/esma20141_-_hft_activity_in_eu_equity_markets.pdf.

37.

European Commission. (2015). MEPs vote laws to regulate financial markets and curb high frequency trading, Committees Committee on Economic and Monetary Affairs, [www article] http://www.europarl.europa.eu/pdfs/news/expert/infopress/20140411IPR43438/201404111PR43438_en.pdf.

38.

Financial Conduct Authority. (2016). High frequency trading: MiFID. https://www.fca.org.uk/markets/mifid-ii/changes/high-frequency-trading.

39.

Foresight. (2012). The Future of Computer Trading in Financial Markets. The Government Office of Science, London: Final Project Report.

40.

Funk

R. J.

, & Hirschmann

(2014). Derivatives and Deregulation: Financial Innovation and the Demise of Glass-Steagall. Administrative Science Quarterly, 59(4), 669–704.

41.

Gioia

D. A.

, Corley

K. G.

, & Hamilton

A. L.

(2012). Seeking Qualitative Rigor in Inductive Research: Notes on the Gioia Methodology. Organizational Research Methods, 16(1), 15–31.

42.

Gioia

D. A.

, & Pitre

(1990). Multiparadigm Perspectives on Theory Building. The Academy of Management Review, 15(4), 584–602.

43.

Goldstein

M. A.

, Kumar

, & Graves

F. C.

(2014). Computerized and High-Frequency Trading. The Financial Review, 49, 177–202.

44.

Gomber

, Arndt

, Lutat

, and Uhle

(2011). High Frequency Trading. E-Finance Lab.Goethe University, Frankfurt, [www article] http://ssm.com/abstract+1858626.

45.

Graham

J. R.

, Harvey

C. R.

, & Huang

H. H.

(2009). Investor Competence, Trading Frequency, and Home Bias. Management Science, 55(7), 1094–1106.

46.

Guba

, & Lincoln

(1994). Competing Paradigms in Qualitative Research. In Denzin

, & Lincoln

(Eds.), Handbook of Qualitative Research (pp. 105–117). Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage.

47.

Hasbrouck

, & Saar

(2012). Low-latency Trading. Journal of Financial Markets, 16, 646–679.

48.

Hendershott

, Jones

C. M.

, & Menkveld

(2011). Does Algorithmic Trading Improve Liquidity? Journal of Finance, 66, 1–33.

49.

Hendershott

, and Riordan

(2011). High Frequency Trading and Price Discovery, [www document] https://financialreg.nd.edu/assets/153230/hendershott_hft.pdf.

50.

Henrikson

(2011). Characteristics of High Frequency Trading. Royal Institute of Technology Working Paper, [www document] http://www.math.kth.se/matstat/seminarier/reports/M-exjobb11/110630b.pdf.

51.

Iati

(2009). The Real Story of Trading Software Espionage, [www article] http://advancetrading.com/algorithms/showArticle.jhtml?.

52.

IOSCO. (2011). Regulatory Issues Raised by the Impact of Technological Changes on Market Integrity and Efficiency. Consultation Report, [www document] http://www.iosco.org/library/pubdocs/pdf/IOSCOPD354.pdf

53.

Jones

. (2013). What do we know about High Frequency Trading?, [www article] https://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=2236201.

54.

Kirilenko

A. A.

, Kyle

A. S.

, Mehrdad

, & Tugkan

(2016). The Flash Crash: High Frequency Trading in an Electronic Market. Journal of Finance, 1, 1–50.

55.

Kirilenko

A. A.

, & Lo

A. W.

(2013). Moore's Law versus Murphy's Law: Algorithmic Trading and its Discontents. Journal of Economic Perspectives, 27(2), 51–72.

56.

Kozhan

, & Tham

W. W.

(2012). Execution Risk in High Frequency Arbitrage. Management Science, 58(11), 2131–2149.

57.

Kumar

, Goldstein

, & Graves

(2011). Trading at the Speed of Light: The Impact of High Frequency Trading on Market Performance, Regulatory Oversight, and Securities Litigation. San Francisco: The Brattle Group.

58.

Linton

, and O'Hara

(2011). The Impact of Computer Trading on Liquidity, Price Efficiency/Discovery and Transaction Costs, Foresight, Government Office for Science, In: The Future of Computer Trading in Financial Markets, pp. 24–38, [www document] https://www.gov.uk/government/uploads/system/uploads/attachment_data/file/289058/11-1276-the-future-of-computer-trading-in-financial-markets.pdf.

59.

Locke

E. A.

(2007). The Case for Inductive Theory Building? Journal of Management, 33(6), 867–890.

60.

Loebbecke

, & Picot

(2015). Reflections on Societal and Business Model Transformation arising from Digitization and Big Data Analytics: A Research Agenda. Journal of Strategic Information Systems, 24(3), 149–157.

61.

Lucas

H. C.

Jr. , Agarwal

, Clemons

E. K.

, El Sawy

O. A.

, & Weber

B. W.

(2013). Impactful Research on Transformational Information Technology: An Opportunity to Inform New Audiences. MIS Quarterly, 37(2), 371–382.

62.

Lyytinen

, & Rose

(2003). The Disruptive Nature of Information Technology Innovations: The Case of Internet Computing in Systems Development Organizations. MIS Quarterly, 27(4), 557–596.

63.

MacKenzie

(2014). A Sociology of Algorithms: High-Frequency Trading and the Shaping of Markets, [www document] http://www.sps.ed.ac.uk/__data/assets/pdf_file/0004/156298/Algorithms25.pdf.

64.

MacKenzie

(2015). Dark Markets. London Review of Books, 37(11), 29–32.

65.

Markus

, Steinfield

C. W.

, Wigand

R. T.

, & Minton

(2006). Industry-wide IS Standardization as Collective Action: The Case of the US Residential Mortgage Industry. MIS Quarterly, 30, 439–465.

66.

Mayer-Schönberger

, & Cukier

(2013). Big Data: A Revolution that will Transform How we Live, Work, and Think. Boston: Houghton Mifflin Harcourt.

67.

McGowan

M.J.

(2011). The rise of computerized High Frequency Trading: Use and Controversy, [www article] http://scholarship.law.duke.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?article=1211&context=dltr.

68.

Menkveld

A. J.

(2014). High-Frequency Traders and Market Structure. The Financial Review, 49(2), 333–344.

69.

Menkveld

A.J.

, and Zoican

M.A.

(2014). Need for Speed? Exchange Latency and Liquidity. Discussion Paper Available at: TI 14–097/IV/DSF78, [www document] http://papers.tinbergen.nl/14097.pdf.

70.

Michaels

, and Baker

(2015). Stricter Dark Pool Rules Said to Be Under Consideration at SEC?, [www article] http://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2015-01-12/stricter-dark-pool-rules-said-to-be-under-consideration-at-sec.

71.

Millar

(2011). Lightning fast future traders working in nanoseconds, [www article] http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/business-15722530.

72.

Moshinsky

(2015). Regulators Outpace Physicists in Race to Catch Flash Boys, Bloomberg.com, [www article] http://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2015-03-18/regulators-outpace-physicists-in-race-to-catch-flash-boys.

73.

Muniesa

, Chabert

, & Scott

S. V.

(2011). Back Office Intricacy: The Description of Financial Objects in an Investment Bank. Industrial and Corporate Change, 10, 1093.

74.

NASDAQ, (2015). [www article] http://www.nasdaq.eom/investing/glossary/h/high-frequency-trading.

75.

Pagnotta

, and Philippon

(2012). Competing on speed, April 27. Working Paper, [www document] http://pages.stern.nyu.edu/~tphilipp/papers/Speed.pdf.

76.

Picketty

(2014). Capital in the 21^st Century. Cambridge, MA: Belknap Press.

77.

Prewitt

(2012). High Frequency Trading: Should Regulators Do More?. Mich Telecom and Tech. Law Review 19: p. 131, [www article] http://repository.law.umich.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?article=1015&context=mttlr.

78.

Prix

, Loistl

, & Huetl

(2007). Algorithmic Trading Patterns in Xetra Orders. European Journal of Finance, 13(8), 717–739.

79.

Reuters. (2012). Hold Brothers Hit with $5.9 mln in Fines for Trading Violations, [www article] http://in.reuters.com/article/holdbrothers-fine-idINLlE8KPE3H20120925.

80.

Rogow

(2009). Rise of the (Market) Machines. Wall Street Journal, 19, 118–128.

81.

SEC. (2005). Regulation NMS, [www document] https://www.sec.gov/rules/final/34-51808.pdf.

82.

SEC. (2010a). Concept Release on Equity Market Structure, 17 CFR Part 242, [www document] https://www.sec.gov/rules/concept/2010/34-61358.pdf.

83.

SEC. (2010b). SEC Approves Rules Expanding Stock-by-Stock Circuit Breakers and Clarifying Process for Breaking Erroneous Trades, Sept, [www article] http://www.sec.gov/news/press/2010/2010-167.htm.

84.

SEC. (2010c). Findings Regarding The Market Events Of May 6, 2010, September 30, [www document] https://www.sec.gov/news/studies/2010/marketevents-report.pdf.

85.

SEC. (2014). Equity Market Structure Literature Review. Part II: High Frequency Trading, March 18, [www document] https://www.sec.gov/marketstructure/research/hft_lit_review_march_2014.pdf.

86.

Seddon

J. J. M.

, & Currie

W. L.

(2016). A Model for Unpacking Big Data Analytics in High Frequency Trading. Journal of Business Research, 61(August), 1–8.

87.

Senior Supervisors Group (SSG). (2015). Algorithmic Trading Briefing Note, April, [www document] https://www.newyorkfed.org/medialibrary/media/newsevents/news/banking/2015/SSG-algorithmic-trading-2015.pdf.

88.

Sheppard

, and Spicer

(2011). HFT and the May 5 oil crash, [www article] http://www.reuters.com/article/2011/06/17/us-commodities-highfrequency-idUSTRE75G0MT20110617.

89.

Shorter

, and Miller

R.S.

(2014) High Frequency Trading: Background, Concerns, and Regulatory Developments. Congressional Research Service, 19: 7–5700, [www article] www.crs.gov.

90.

Silverman

(2011). Interpreting Qualitative Data” (4th ed.). Sage: London.

91.

Straub

, & Wetherbe

(1989). Information Technologies for the 1990s: An Organizational Impact Perspective. Communications of the ACM, 32(11), 1328–1339.

92.

Tabb

(2014). No, Michael Lewis, the US equities market is not rigged, [www article] http://tabbforum.com/opinions/no-michael-lewis-the-us-equities-market-is-not-rigged.

93.

Weber

(2006). Adoption of Electronic Trading at the International Securities Exchange. Decision Support Systems, 41, 728–746.

94.

Williams

J. W.

(2012). Policing the Markets - Inside the Blackbox of Securities Enforcement. London: Routledge Taylor and Francis Group.

95.

World Federation of Exchanges. (2016). Understanding HFT.

96.

Yan

(2010). Is Noise Trading Cancelled out by Aggregation? Management Science, 56(7), 1057–1059.

97.

Zhu

(2013). Do Dark Pools Harm Price Discovery?, Review of Financial Studies, [www article] http://rfs.oxfordjournals.org/content/early/2013/12/17/rfs.hht078.