Dialectic Tensions in the Financial Markets: A Longitudinal Study of pre- and Post-Crisis Regulatory Technology

Abstract

This article presents the findings from a longitudinal research study on regulatory technology in the UK financial services industry. The financial crisis with serious corporate and mutual fund scandals raised the profile of compliance as governmental bodies, institutional and private investors introduced a ‘tsunami’ of financial regulations. Adopting a multi-level analysis, this study examines how regulatory technology was used by financial firms to meet their compliance obligations, pre- and post-crisis. Empirical data collected over 12 years examine the deployment of an investment management system in eight financial firms. Interviews with public regulatory bodies, financial institutions and technology providers reveal a culture of compliance with increased transparency, surveillance and accountability. Findings show that dialectic tensions arise as the pursuit of transparency, surveillance and accountability in compliance mandates is simultaneously rationalized, facilitated and obscured by regulatory technology. Responding to these challenges, regulatory bodies continue to impose revised compliance mandates on financial firms to force them to adapt their financial technologies in an ever-changing multi-jurisdictional regulatory landscape.

Keywords

regulatory technology compliance systems financial technology financial crisis surveillance ethics accountability fintech regtech

References

Aloui

, Aïssa

M.S.B.

and Nguyen

D.K.

(2011). Global Financial Crisis, Extreme Interdependences, and Contagion Effects: The Role of Economic Structure? Journal of Banking & Finance 35(1): 130–141.

Alvesson

and Deetz

(2000). Doing Critical Management Research. London: Sage Publications Ltd.

Arnold

(2009). Global Financial Crisis: The Challenge to Accounting Research, Accounting, Organizations and Society 34(6): 803–809.

Ashby

and Waite

(2009). The Turner Review on the Global Banking Crisis: A Response from the Financial Services Research Forum. Retrieved 8th June, 2012, from http://www.nottingham.ac.uk/business/forum/documents/researchreports/paper61.pdf.

Avgerou

(2013). Social Mechanisms for Causal Explanation in Social Theory Based IS Research, Journal of the Association for Information Systems 14(8): 399–419.

Awrey

, Blair

and Kershaw

(2012). Between Law and Markets: Is There a Role for Culture and Ethics in Financial Regulation?, LSE Legal Studies Working Paper No. 14/2012.

Bamberger

K.A.

(2010). Technologies of Compliance: Risk and Regulation in a Digital Age, Texas Law Review 8(4): 669–739.

Barratt

(2008). The Later Foucault in Organization and Management Studies, Human Relations 61(4): 515–537.

Barth

M.E.

and Landsman

W.R.

(2010). How Did Financial Reporting Contribute to the Financial Crisis? European Accounting Review 19: 399–423.

10.

Becker

H.S.

(1958). Problems of Inference and Proof n Partcipant Observation, American Sociological Review 23(6): 652–660.

11.

Benston

G.J.

(2006). Fair-Value Accounting: A Cautionary Tale from Enron, Journal of Accounting and Public Policy 25(4): 465–484.

12.

Bernauer

J.W.

and Mahon

(1994). 6 the Ethics of Michel Foucault. In Gutting

(Ed.), The Cambridge Companion to Foucault (pp. 141–151). Cambridge: Cambride University Press.

13.

Black

(2008). Forms and Paradoxes of Principles-Based Regulation, Capital Markets Law Journal 3(4): 425–457.

14.

Black

, Hoper

and Band

(2007). Making a Success of Principles-Based Regulation, Law & Fiancial. Markets Review 1(3): 191–206.

15.

Blyth

(2003). The Political Power of Financial Ideas: Transparency, Risk and Distribution in Global Finance. In Kirshner

(Ed.), Monetary Orders, Ambiguous Economics, Ubiquitous Politics (pp. 239–259). Ithaca: Cornell University Press.

16.

Bossewitch

and Sinnreich

(2013). The End of Forgetting: Strategic Agency Beyond the Panopticon, New Media & Society 15(2): 224–242.

17.

Burawoy

(2003). Revisits: An Outline of a Thoery of Reflexive Ethnography, American Sociological Review 68 645–679.

18.

Butler

(2005). Giving an Account of Oneself. New York: Fordham University Press.

19.

Callon

(2007). What does it Mean to Say that Economics is Performative? In Mackenzie

, Muniesa

, & Siu

(Eds.), Do Economists Make Markets? On the Performativity of Economics. Princeton: Princeton University Press.

20.

Callon

and Muniesa

(2005). Economic Markets as Calculative Collective Devices, Organization Studies 26(8): 1229–1250.

21.

Claessens

and Kodres

(2014). The Regulatory Responses to the Global Financial Crisis: Some Uncomfortable Questions. IMF Working Paper, WP/14/46.

22.

Cliff

and Northrop

(2010). “The Global Financial Markets: An Ultra-Large Scale Systems Perspective”, Foresight: The Future of Computer Trading in Financial Markets driver review – DR4, Report for the Government Office for Science.

23.

Collinson

D.L.

(1999). Surviving the Rigs’: Safety and Surveillance on North Sea Oil Installations, Organization Studies 20(4): 579–600.

24.

Currie

W.L.

(2008). Institutionalization of IT compliance: A Longitudinal Study, International Conference on Information Systems, Paris, France, December.

25.

De Haas

and Van Horen

(2012). International Shock Transmission after the Lehman Brothers Collapse: Evidence from Syndicated Lending, American Economic Review Papers & Proceedings 102(3): 231–237.

26.

DeWalt

K.M.

and DeWalt

B.R.

(2011). Participant Observation: A Guide for Fieldworkers. Rowman Altamira.

27.

Drury

and Scott

(2001). Bias as a Research Strategy in Participant Observation: The Case of Intergroup Conflict, Field Methods 13(1):47–67.

28.

Eaton

, Hedman

and Medaglia

R.J.

(2017). Three Different Ways to Skin a Cat: Financialization in the Emergence of National e-ID Solutions, Journal of Information Technology. doi:10.1057/s41265-017-0036-8.

29.

Eisenhardt

K.M.

(1989). Building Theories from Case Study Research, The Academy of Management Review 14(4): 532–550.

30.

Eisenhardt

K.M.

and Graebner

M.E.

(2007). Theory Building from Cases: Opportunities and Challenges, Academy of Management Journal 50(1): 25–32.

31.

Fayard

A.-L.

and Weeks

(2007). Photocopiers and Water-Coolers: The Affordances of Informal Interaction, Organization studies 28(5): 605–634.

32.

Fields

, Sami

and Sumners

(1986). Quantification of the Auditor's Evaluation of Internal Control in Data Base Systems, The Journal of Information Systems 1(1): 24–77.

33.

Flick

(1998). An Introduction to Qualitative Research. London: Sage.

34.

Fligstein

and Habinek

(2014). Sucker Punched by the Invisible Hand: The World Financial Markets and the Globalization of the US Mortgage, Crisis. doi:10.1093/ser/mwu004.

35.

Ford

C.L.

(2010). Principles-Based Securities Regulation in the Wake of the Global Financial Crisis, McGill Law Journal 55(2): 257–307.

36.

Franks

, Mayer

and Rossi

(2009). Ownership: Evolution and Regulation, Review of Financial Studies 22(10): 4009–4056.

37.

FSA (2007). Principles-Based Regulation Focusing on the Outcomes that Matter. Retrived April 5th 2009.

38.

Funk

R.J.

and Hirschman

(2014). Derivatives and Deregulation: Financial Innovation and the Demise of Glass-Steagall, Administrative Science Quarterly 59(4): 669–704.

39.

Geertz

(1973). The Interpretation of Cultures: Selected Essays. New York: Basic Books.

40.

Gibson

J.J.

(1986). The Ecological Approach to Visual Perception. Hillsdale, NJ: Lawrence Erlbaum Associates.

41.

Gillespie

, Hurley

, Dietz

, and Bachmann

(2012). Restoring Institutional Trust after the Global Financial Crisis. In Kramer

& Pittinsky

(Eds.), Resotoring Trust in Organizations and Leaders: Enduring Challanges and Emerging Answers. New York: Oxford University Press.

42.

Glaser

and Risius

(2017). Effects of Transparency: Analyzing Social Biases on Trader Performance in Social Trading, Journal of Information Technology. doi:10.1057/s41265-016-0028-0.

43.

Golden

B.R.

(1992). Research Notes. The Past is the Past—or is it? The Use of Retrospective Accounts as Indicators of Past Strategy, Academy of Management Journal 35(4): 848–860.

44.

Gozman

and Currie

(2014). The Role of Investment Management Systems in Regulatory Compliance: A Post-Financial Crisis Study of Displacement Mechanisms, Journal of Information Technology 29: 44–58.

45.

Gray

(2002). The Social Accounting Project and Accounting Organizations and Society. Privileging Engagement, Imaginings, New Accountings and Pragmatism over Ritique? Accounting, Organizations and Society 27(7): 687–708.

46.

Greenspan

(2008). Transcript of testimony to House Oversight Committee, Retrived April 12th 2012, from http://oversight.house.gov/documents/20081024163819.pdf.

47.

Greenwald

B.C.

and Stiglitz

J.E.

(1990). Asymmetric Information and the New Theory of the Firm: Financial Constraints and Risk Behaviour, The American Economic Review 80(2): 160–165.

48.

Guest

, MacQueen

K.M.

and Namey

E.N.

(2012). Applied Thematic Anlaysis. Thousand Oaks: Sage.

49.

Hansen

H.K.

and Flyverbom

(2015). The Politics of Transparency and the Calibration of Knowledge in the Digital Age, Organization 22(6): 872–889.

50.

Heidegger

(1954). The Question Concerning Technology. In Hank

(Ed.), Technology and Values: Essential Readings (pp. 99–113). Oxford: Blackwell Publishing.

51.

Humphrey

, Loft

and Woods

(2009). The Global Audit Profession and the International Financial Architecture: Understanding Regulatory Relationships at a Time of Financial Crisis, Accounting, Organizations and Society 34: 810–825.

52.

Iedema

and Rhodes

(2010). The Undecided Space of Ethics in Organizational Surveillance, Organization Studies 31(2): 199–217.

53.

Itami

and Numagami

(1992). Dynamic Interaction between Strategy and Technology, Strategic Management Journal 13(S2): 119–135.

54.

Kane

(1981). Accelerating Inflation, Technological Innovation, and the Decreasing Effectiveness of Bank Regulation. Journal of Finance 36(2): 355–367.

55.

Kauffman

R.J.

, Liu

and Ma

(2014). Innovations in Financial IS and Technology Ecosystems: High-Frequency Trading in the Equity Market, Technological Forecasting and Social Change 99: 339–354.

56.

Krawiec

K.D.

(2000). Accounting for Greed: Unraveling the “Rogue Trader” Mystery, Oregon Law Review 79: 301–338.

57.

Kvale

and Brinkmann

(2009), Interviews Learning the Craft of Qualitative Research Interviewing, Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage.

58.

Lenglet

(2011). Conflicting Codes and Codings: How Algorithmic Trading is Reshaping Financial Regulation, Culture & Society 28(6): 44–66.

59.

Leonard-Barton

(1990). A Dual Methodology for Case Studies: Synergistic Use of a Longitudinal Single Site with Replicated Multiple Sites, Organization Science 1(3): 248–266.

60.

Leonardi

P.M.

(2011). When Flexible Routines Meet Flexible Technologies: Affordance, Constraint, and the Imbrication of Human and Material Agencies, MIS Quarterly 35(1): 147–167.

61.

Majchrzak

and Markus

(2013). Technology Affordances and Constraints Theory (of MIS). Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage Publications.

62.

Messner

(2009). The Limits of Accountability, Accounting, Organizations and Society 34: 918–938.

63.

Mikes

(2009). Risk Management and Calculative Cultures, Management Accounting Research 20: 18–40.

64.

Mikes

(2011). From Counting Risk to Making Risk Count: Boundary-Work in Risk Management, Accounting, Organizations and Society 36: 226–245.

65.

Miles

M.B.

and Huberman

(1994). Qualitative Data Analysis: An Expanded Sourcebook (2nd ed.). Thousand Oaks CA: Sage.

66.

Miller

, Kurunmaki

and O'Leary

(2008). Accounting, Hybrids and the Management of Risk, Accounting, Organizations and Society 33: 942–967.

67.

Muniesa

, Millo

and Callon

(2007). An Introduction to Market Devices, The Sociological Review 55(s2): 1–12.

68.

Orlikowski

W.J.

and Iacono

C.S.

(2001). Research Commentary: Desperately Seeking the” It” in It Research—A Call to Theorizing the IT Artifact, Information Systems Research 12(2): 121–134.

69.

Patton

(1990), Qualitative Evaluation and Research Methods. Beverley Hills, CA: Sage.

70.

Perrow

(1985). Review Essay: Overboard with Myth and Symbols, American Journal of Sociology 91: 151–155.

71.

Pettigrew

A.M.

(1985). Contextualist Research: A Natural Way to Link Theory and Practice. In Lawler

E. E.

, Mohrman

A. M.

, Mohrman

S. A.

, Ledford

, & Cummings

T. G.

(Eds.), Doing Research that is Useful in Theory and Practice. Oxford: Lexington Books.

72.

Pettigrew

A.M.

(1990). Longitudinal Field Research on Change: Theory and Practice, Organization Science 1(3): 267–292.

73.

Power

(2000). The Audit Society – Second Thoughts, International Journal of Auditing 4: 111–119.

74.

Power

(2004). Counting, Control and Calculation: Reflections on Measuring and Management, Humans Relations 57(6): 765–783.

75.

Power

(2007), Organized Uncertainty Designing a World of Risk Management, Oxford: Oxford University Press.

76.

Preda

(2006). Socio-Technical Agency in Financial Markets the Case of the Stock Ticker, Social Studies of Science 36(5): 753–782.

77.

Punch

K.F.

(2005), Introduction to Social Research: Qualitative and Quantitative Approaches (2nd ed.). London: Sage.

78.

Radcliffe

V.S.

, Cooper

D.J.

and Robson

(1993). The Management of Professional Enterprises and Regulatory Change: British Accountancy and the Financial Services Act, 1986 http://papers.ssrn.com/so13/papers.cfm?abstract_id=2269384.

79.

Roberts

(1991). The Possibilities of Accountability, Accounting, Organizations and Society 16(4): 355–368.

80.

Roberts

(2001). Trust and Control in Anglo-American Systems of Corporate Governance: The Individualizing and Socializing Effects of Processes of Accountability’, Human Relations 54(12): 1547–1572.

81.

Roberts

(2009). No One is Perfect: The Limits of Transparency and an Ethic for ‘Intelligent’ Accountability, Accounting, Organizations and Society 34(8): 957–970.

82.

Roberts

and Jones

(2009). Accounting for Self Interest in the Credit Crisis, Accounting, Organizations and Society 34(6–7): 856–867.

83.

Saldana

(2009), The Coding Manual for Qualitative Researchers, Thousand Oaks: Sage.

84.

Sants

(2009). Delivering Intensive Supervision and Credible Deterrence, Retrieved 23rd March, 2009, from http://www.fsa.gov.uk/pages/Library/Communication/Speeches/2009/0312_hs.shtml.

85.

Sants

(2010). UK Financial Regulation: After the Crisis. Retrieved 17th March, 2010, from http://www.fsa.gov.uk/pages/Library/Communication/Speeches/2010/0312_hs.shtml.

86.

Schinckus

(2017). An Essay on Financial Information in the Era of Computerization, Journal of Information Technology. doi: 10.1057/s41265-016-0027-1.

87.

Schwartz

S.M.

and Schwartz

C.G.

(1955). Problems in Participant Observation, American Journal of Sociology 60(4): 343–353.

88.

Seale

(1999). Quality in Qualitative Research, Qualitative Inquiry 1999(5): 465–478.

89.

Sewell

and Barker

J.R.

(2001). Neither Good, nor Bad, but Dangerous: Surveillance as an Ethical Paradox, Ethics and Information Technology 3(3): 181–194.

90.

Shearer

(2002). Ethics and Accountability: From the For-Itself to the Fort-the-Other, Accounting, Organizations and Society 27: 541–573.

91.

Siereing

, Clapham

, Engel

, and Gomber

(2017). A Taxonomy of Financial Market Manipulations: Establishing Trust and Market Integrity in the Financialized Economy Through Automated Fraud Detection, Journal of Information Technology. doi: 10.1057/s41265-016-0029-z.

92.

Siggelkow

(2007). Persuasion with Case Studies, Academy of Management Journal 50(1): 20–24.

93.

Silverman

(2001), Interpreting Qualitative Data: Methods for Analyzing Talk, Text and Interaction (2nd ed.), London: Sage.

94.

Soin

and Huber

(2013). Financial Scandal!! Regulation? Carr Research: Risk and Regulation: 16–17.

95.

Solomon

(2013), Corporate Governance and Accountability (4th ed.), Chicester: Wiley.

96.

Somerville

, Cliff

, Calinescu

, Keen

, Kelly

, Kwiatkowska

, (2012). Large-Scale Complex IT Systems, Communications of the ACM 55(7): 71–77.

97.

Strathern

(2000). The Tyranny of Transparency, British Educational Research Journal 26(3): 309–321.

98.

Symon

and Cassell

(2012), Qualitative Organizational Research: Core Methods and Current Challenges. London: Sage.

99.

Tan

(2014). The Construction of Calculative Expertise: The Integration of Corporate Governance into Investment analyses by Sell-Side Financial Analysts, Accounting, Organizations and Society 39: 362–364.

100.

Tiejun

and McGroaty

(2017). Social Machines: How Recent Technological Advances have Aided Financialisation, Journal of Information Technology. doi: 10.1057/s41265-017-0037-7.

101.

Tsatsou

, Elaluf-Calderwood

and Liebenau

(2009). Towards a Taxonomy for Regulatory Issues in a Digital Business Ecosystem in the Eu, Journal of Information Technology 25(3): 288–307.

102.

Turner

(2009). The Turner Review a Regulatory Response to the Global Banking Crisis, Retrieved 17th March, 2010, from http://www.fsa.gov.uk/pubs/other/turner_review.pdf.

103.

Turner

(2012a). Banking at the Cross-Roads: Where do We Go from Here? Retrieved 2012, 22nd December, from http://www.fsa.gov.uk/library/communication/speeches/2012/0724-at.shtml.

104.

Turner

(2012b). ‘Mansion House Speech.’ Retrieved 20th October, 2012, from http://www.fsa.gov.uk/library/communication/speeches/2012/1011-at.shtml.

105.

Van de Ven

A.H.

and Poole

M.S.

(1995). Explaining Development and Change in Organizations, Academy of Management Review 20(3): 510–540.

106.

Van den Brink

, Benschop

and Jansen

(2010). Transparency in academic recruitment: A problematic tool for gender equality? Organization Studies 31(11): 1459–1483.

107.

van Li

, Dalen

and van Rees

(2017). More than Just Noise? Examining the Information Content of Stock Microblogs on Financial Markets, Journal of Information Technology doi:10.1057/s41265-.

108.

Williams

J.W.

(2012), Policing the Markets. Oxon: Routledge.

109.

Williams

J.W.

(2013). Regulatory Technologies, Risky Subjects, and Financial Boundaries: Governing ‘Fraud’ in the Financial Markets’, Accounting, Organizations and Society 38(6): 544–558.

110.

, Nord

J.H.

, Brown

and Nord

G.D.

(2002). Data Quality Issues in Implementing an ERP, Industrial Management & Data Systems 102(1): 47–58.

111.

Yin

(2009), Case Study Research: Design and Methods (4th ed.). Los Angeles: Sage.

112.

Zammuto

R.F.

, Griffith

T.L.

, Majchrzak

, Dougherty

D.J.

and Faraj

(2007). Information Technology and the Changing Fabric of Organization, Organization Science 18(5): 749–762.

113.

Zhang

X.M.

and Zhang

(2015). How does the Internet Affect the Financial Market? An Equilibrium-Model of Internet-Facilitated Feedback Training, Management Information Systems Quarterly, 39.