In recent years, regulationist research has increasingly focused on questions of subnational governance and regulation. Whilst there has been a shift towards new forms of local governance across the United Kingdom, in this paper I contend that the interaction between new mechanisms of (national) regulation and preexisting local conditions has produced considerable spatial variation in the precise forms of governance that have emerged at the local level. Following Peck, I suggest that this can be seen in terms of the interaction of distinct institutional ‘layers’. This insight is developed by adapting Offe's notion of ‘institutional filters’ to emphasise the role of regional agencies in mediating and ‘filtering’ the effects of wider (national) regulatory mechanisms. In the second half of the paper, I apply these ideas to a particular regional case study, assessing how the national-level shift towards neoliberalism has shaped the practice of economic governance in the Scottish Highlands in the 1990s. As mid-level metaphors, ideas of institutional ‘layers’ and ‘filters’ help to open up a space for the consideration of agency and strategy at regional level, thereby addressing what has been termed the ‘regulationist enigma’, defined in terms of the need to avoid ‘reading off’ regional transformations from the posited logic of broader macrostructural shifts.
References
1.
AgliettaM, 1979A Theory of Capitalist Regulation: The US Experience (New Left Books, London).
2.
AllenJMasseyDCochraneA, 1998Rethinking the Region (Routledge, London).
3.
BennettR JWicksPMcCoshanA, 1994Local Empowerment and Business Services: Britain's Experiment with TECs and LECs (UCL Press, London).
4.
BoyerR, 1990The Regulation School: A Critical Introduction (Columbia University Press, New York).
5.
BrennerN, 1998, “Between fixity and motion: Accumulation, territorial organization and the historical geography of spatial scales” Environment and Planning D: Society and Space16459–481.
6.
BrennerN, 1999, “Regulation theory and the regionalization debate: Recent German contributions” Environment and Planning D: Society and Space17645–650.
7.
CollingeC, 1999, “Self-organisation of society by scale: A Spatial reworking of regulation theory” Environment and Planning D: Society and Space17557–574.
8.
CookePMorganK, 1998The Associational Economy: Firms, Regions, and Innovation (Oxford University Press, Oxford).
9.
DansonMFairleyJLloydM GNewlandsD, 1990, “Scottish Enterprise: An integrated approach to training and economic development in Scotland”, in The Scottish Government Yearbook 1990 Eds BrownAParryR (Edinburgh University Press, Edinburgh) pp 168–194.
10.
DansonMLloydM GNewlandsD, 1993, “The role of development agencies in regional economic regeneration”, in Spatial Policy in a Divided Nation Eds HarrisonR LHartM (Jessica Kingsley, London) pp 162–175.
11.
DevineT M, 1999The Scottish Nation, 1700–2000 (Penguin Books, Harmondsworth, Middx).
12.
DuncanS SGoodwinM, 1988The Local State and Uneven Development (Polity, Cambridge).
13.
DunfordM, 1990, “Theories of regulation” Environment and Planning D: Society and Space8297–321.
14.
FriedmanA L, 2000, “Microregulation and post-Fordism: Critique and development of regulation theory” New Political Economy559–76.
15.
GeddesM, 1984The Political Economy of Regional Development: The Highlands and the Highlands and Islands Development Boardunpublished D Phil thesis, University of Sussex, Brighton, Sussex.
16.
GiddensA, 1984The Constitution of Society (Polity, Cambridge).
17.
GoodwinM, 1992, “The changing local state”, in Policy and Change in Thatcher's Britain Ed. ClokeP (Pergamon, Oxford) pp 77–96.
18.
GoodwinMPainterJ, 1996, “Local governance, the crises of Fordism and the changing geographies of regulation” Transactions of the Institute of British Geographers, New Series21635–648.
19.
GoodwinMDuncanSHalfordS, 1993, “Regulation theory, the local state, and the transition of urban politics” Environment and Planning D: Society and Space1167–88.
20.
GoodwinMClokePMilbourneP, 1995, “Regulation theory and rural research: Theorising contemporary rural change” Environment and Planning A271245–1260.
21.
GramsciA, 1971Selections from the Prison Notebooks (Lawrence and Wishart, London).
22.
GrassieJ, 1983Highland Experiment: The Story of the Highlands and Islands Development Board (Aberdeen University Press, Aberdeen).
23.
Hansard, 26th July 1989 (London: HMSO).
24.
HarveyD, 1985The Urbanisation of Capital: Studies in the History of Capitalist Industrialisation (Basil Blackwell, Oxford).
25.
HayC, 1995, “Re-stating the problem of regulation and re-regulating the local state” Economy and Society24387–404.
26.
HayC, 1996Re-stating Social and Political Change (Open University Press, Buckingham).
27.
HayCJessopB, 1995, “Introduction: Local political economy: Regulation and governance” Economy and Society24303–306.
28.
HIDB, Highlands and Islands Development Board, Inverness.
29.
Annual Reports 1966–90.
30.
1989, “Response of the HIDB to the Government's Proposals for Scottish Enterprise: A New Approach to Training and Enterprise Creation”.
1991A Strategy for Enterprise Development in the Highlands and Islands of Scotland.
34.
1996Strategy for Enterprise Development.
35.
1999Strategy for Enterprise Development.
36.
2000Network Plan 2000–2001.
37.
Highland Regional Council, 1989, “Minutes of Meeting”, 9 May (Highland Regional Council, Inverness).
38.
HirstPZeitlinJ, 1991, “Flexible specialisation versus post-Fordism: Theory, evidence and policy implications” Economy and Society201–50.
39.
HunterJ, 1991The Claim of Crofting (Mainstream, Edinburgh) IDS, 1988 Scottish Enterprise: A New Approach to Training and Enterprise Creation Cm 534, Industry Department for Scotland (HMSO, Edinburgh).
40.
IDS, 1989Towards Highlands and Islands Enterprise—An Invitation to Play a Vital Part in Stimulating Enterprise and Training in Your Locality Industry Department for Scotland (Scottish Office, Edinburgh).
41.
ImrieRRacoM, 1999, “How new is the new local governance? Lessons from the United Kingdom” Transactions of the Institute of British Geographers, New Series2445–63.
42.
JensonJ, 1990, “Representations in crisis: The roots of Canada's permeable Fordism” Canadian Journal of Political Science23653–682.
43.
JensonJ, 1991, “All the world's a stage: Ideas, spaces and times in Canadian political economy” Studies in Political Economy3643–71.
44.
JessopB, 1990a, “Regulation theories in retrospect and prospect” Economy and Society19153–216.
45.
JessopB, 1990bState Theory: Putting Capitalist States in their Place (Blackwell, Oxford).
46.
JessopB, 1995, “Towards a Schumpeterian workforce regime in Britain? Reflections on regulation, governance and the welfare state” Environment and Planning A271613–1627.
47.
JessopB, 1997a, “A neo-Gramscian approach to the regulation of urban regimes: Accumulation strategies, hegemonic projects and governance”, in Reconstructing Urban Regime Theory: Regulating Urban Politics in a Global Economy Ed. LaurieM (Sage, Thousand Oaks, CA) pp 51–73.
48.
JessopB, 1997b, “The entrepreneurial city: Re-imaging localities, redesigning economic governance, or restructuring capital”, in Transforming Cities: Contested Governance and New Spatial Divisions Eds JewsonNMcGregorS (Routledge, London) pp 28–41.
49.
JessopB, 1997c, “Survey article: The regulation approach” Journal of Political Philosophy5287–326.
50.
JessopBBonnettKBromleySLingT, 1988Thatcherism: A Tale of Two Nations (Polity, Cambridge).
51.
JonesM, 1997, “Spatial selectivity of the state? The regulationist enigma and local struggles over economic governance” Environment and Planning A29831–864.
52.
JonesM, 1998, “Restructuring the local state: Economic governance or social regulation?” Political Geography17959–988.
53.
JonesM, 1999New Institutional Spaces: TECs and the Re-making of Economic Governance (Jessica Kingsley, London).
54.
KearnsA, 1995, “Active citizenship and local governance: Political and geographical dimensions” Political Geography14155–177.
55.
LevittI, 1999, “The creation of the Highlands and Islands Development Board, 1935–65” Northern Scotland1985–105.
56.
LipietzA, 1986, “New tendencies in international development: Regimes of accumulation and modes of regulation”, in Production, Work, Territory: the Geographical Anatomy of Industrial Capitalism Eds ScottAStorperM (Unwin Hyman, London) pp 16–40.
57.
LipietzA, 1994, “The national and the regional: Their autonomy vis-à-vis the capitalist world crisis”, in Transcending the State – Global Divide: a Neo-structuralist Agenda in International Relations Eds PalanRGillsB (Lynne Reinner, Boulder, CO) pp 23–43.
58.
LoveringJ, 1999, “Theory led by policy: The inadequacies of the ‘new regionalism’ (illustrated from the case of Wales)” International Journal of Urban and Regional Research23379–395.
59.
MacKinnonD, 1998Local Governance and Economic Development: Refiguring State Regulation in the Scottish Highlandsunpublished PhD thesis, Department of Geography, University of Edinburgh, Edinburgh.
60.
MacKinnonD, 2000, “Managerialism, governmentality and the state: A Neo-Foucauldian approach to local economic governance” Political Geography19293–314.
61.
MacKinnonD, 2001, “Rural governance and local involvement: assessing state – community relations in the Scottish Highlands”, mimeograph, available from the author.
62.
MacKinnonDPhelpsN A, 2001, “Regional governance and foreign direct investment: The dynamics of institutional change in Wales and North East England” Geoforum32255–269.
63.
MacLeodG, 1997, “Globalising Parisian thought-waves: Recent advances in the study of social regulation, discourse and space” Progress In Human Geography24530–553.
64.
MacLeodG, 1998, “In what sense a region? Place hybridity, symbolic shape and institutional formation in (post) modern Scotland” Political Geography17833–863.
65.
MacLeodG, 1999, “Entrepreneurial spaces, hegemony and state strategy: The political shaping of privatism in lowland Scotland” Environment and Planning A31345–375.
66.
MacLeodG, forthcoming, “The new regionalism reconsidered: Globalisation, regulation and the rescaling of political space” International Journal of Urban and Regional Research.
67.
MacLeodGGoodwinM, 1999a, “Reconstructing an urban and regional political economy: On the state, politics, scale and explanation” Political Geography18697–730.
68.
MacLeodGGoodwinM, 1999b, “Space, scale and state strategy: Towards a re-interpretation of the new urban and regional governance” Progress In Human Geography23503–527.
69.
MacLeodGJonesM, 1999, “Reregulating a regional rustbelt: Institutional fixes, entrepreneurial discourse and the ‘politics of representation’” Environment and Planning D: Society and Space17575–605.
70.
MasseyD, 1984Spatial Divisions of Labour: Social Structures and the Geography of Production (Macmillan, London).
71.
MasseyD, 1995, “Reflections on debates over a decade”, in Spatial Divisions of Labour: Social Structures and the Geography of Production2nd edition (Macmillan, London) pp 296–354.
72.
MidwinterAKeatingMMitchellJ, 1991Politics and Public Policy in Scotland (Macmillan, Basingstoke, Hants).
73.
MooreC, 1989, “The Hughes Initiative: The blueprint for enterprise?” Local Economy4237–244.
74.
MooreCBoothS, 1989Managing Competition: Meso-corporatism, Pluralism and the Negotiated Order in Scotland (Clarendon, Oxford).
75.
MorganKReesGGarmiseS, 1999, “Networking for local economic development”, in The New Management of British Local Governance (Macmillan, Basingstoke, Hants) pp 181–196.
76.
MurdochJ, 1995, “Actor-networks and the evolution of economic forms: Combining description and explanation in theories of regulation, flexible specialization and networks” Environment and Planning A27731–757.
77.
NairnT, 1981The Break-up of Britain: Crisis and Neo-nationalism (Verso, London).
78.
OffeC, 1974, “Structural problems of the capitalist state”, in German Political Studies, Volume 1 (Sage, London) pp 31–57.
79.
OffeC, 1996Modernity and the State: East, West (Polity Press, Cambridge).
80.
PainterJGoodwinM, 1995, “Local governance and concrete research: Investigating the uneven development of regulation” Economy and Society24334–356.
81.
ParsonsD W, 1988The Political Economy of British Regional Policy (Routledge, London).
82.
PatersonL, 1994The Autonomy of Modern Scotland (Edinburgh University Press, Edinburgh).
83.
PeckJ, 1995, “Moving and shaking: Business elites, state localism and urban privatism” Progress In Human Geography1916–46.
84.
PeckJ, 1998, “Geographies of governance: TECs and the neo-liberalisation of local interests” Space and Polity25–31.
85.
PeckJJonesM, 1995, “Training and Enterprise Councils: Schumpeterian workfare state, or what?” Environment and Planning A271361–1396.
86.
PeckJMiyamachiY, 1994, “Regulating Japan? Regulation theory versus the Japanese experience” Environment and Planning D: Society and Space12639–674.
87.
PeckJTickellA, 1992, “Local modes of social regulation? Regulation theory, Thatcherism and uneven development” Geoforum23347–363.
88.
PeckJTickellA, 1995, “The social regulation of uneven development: ‘regulatory deficit’, England's South East and the collapse of Thatcherism” Environment and Planning A2715–40.
89.
PoulantzasN, 1978States, Power, Socialism (New Left Books, London).
90.
RhodesR A W, 1996, “The new governance: Governing without government” Political Studies44652–667.
91.
RichardsonRGillespieA, 1996, “Advanced communications and employment creation in rural and peripheral regions: A Case study of the Highlands and Islands of Scotland” Annals of Regional Science3091–110.
92.
RoseN, 1996, “The death of the social: Refiguring the territory of government” Economy and Society25327–356.
93.
ScottA, 1988, “Flexible production systems and regional development: The rise of new industrial spaces in North America and Western Europe” International Journal of Urban and Regional Research12171–185.
94.
ScottK, 2001, “Scotland creates a new North-South divide” The Guardian 27 January.
95.
Scottish Executive, 2000aThe Way Forward: Framework for Economic Development in Scotland (The Scottish Executive, Edinburgh).
96.
Scottish Executive, 2000bModernising the Enterprise Networks: The Interim Conclusions of the Enterprise Networks Review (The Scottish Executive, Edinburgh).
97.
Scottish Executive, 2000cStaying Ahead of the Game: Wendy Alexander Streamlines Local Economic Delivery Press Release, 6 December, Enterprise and Lifelong Learning Department (The Scottish Executive, Edinburgh).
98.
Scottish Executive, 2000dLocal Economic Forums Draft National Guidelines—Consultation (The Scottish Executive, Edinburgh).
99.
Scottish Executive, 2001A Smart, Successful Scotland. Ambitions for the Enterprise Networks (The Scottish Executive, Edinburgh).
100.
StokerG, 1998, “Governance as theory: Five propositions” International Social Science Journal15515–28.
101.
StorperM, 1997The Regional World: Territorial Development in a Global Economy (Guilford Press, London).
102.
SwyngedouwE, 1997, “Neither global nor local: ‘glocalisation’ and the politics of scale”, in Spaces of Globalisation—Reasserting the Power of the Local Ed. CoxK (Guilford Press, New York) pp 137–166.
103.
TickellAPeckJ, 1992, “Accumulation, regulation and the geographies of post-Fordism: Missing links in regulationist research” Progress In Human Geography16190–218.
