Recent attempts to grant private concessions to water in Bolivia raise questions regarding the effects of the state's neoliberal restructuring on environmental governance. Like other Latin American states, Bolivia has enacted sweeping neoliberal reforms during the past two decades, including privatization of public sector industries, reduction of state services, and administrative decentralization. These reforms have been accompanied by constitutional reforms that recognized certain resource and political rights on the part of Bolivia's indigenous and campesino peoples. This paper examines the reregulation and rescaling of rural water management in Bolivia, and associated processes of mobilization on the part of peasant irrigators aimed at countering state reforms. Although traditional resource rights of peasant irrigators are strengthened by cultural aspects of constitutional reforms, rural livelihoods are undermined by economic liberalization. The paper examines the implications and contradictions of neoliberal reforms for rural water management in highland Bolivia. These processes are illustrated through a brief analysis of current organizational efforts on the part of peasant irrigators.
References
1.
AlbóX, 1994, “And from Kataristas to MNRistas? The surprising and bold alliance between Aymaras and neoliberals in Bolivia”, in Indigenous Peoples and Democracy in Latin America Ed. Van CottD L (St Martin's Press, New York) pp 55–81.
2.
AlbóX, 1999Ojotas en el Poder Local: Cuatro Años Después [Peasants’ sandals in local power: four years later] (CIPCA, La Paz).
3.
AlbóX, 2002Pueblos Indios en la Política [Indian peoples in politics] (Plural Editores, La Paz).
4.
ArdayaRThévozL, 2001, “Promoting popular participation: Lessons to be learned from the Bolivian decentralization process”Mountain Research and Development21(3) 215–220.
5.
AssiesW, 2000, “Indigenous people and reform of the state in Latin America”, in The Challenge of Diversity: Indigenous People and Reform of the State in Latin America Eds AssiesWvan der HaarGHoekemaA (Thela Thesis, Amsterdam) pp 3–21.
6.
BakkerK, 2000, “Privatizing water, producing scarcity: The Yorkshire drought of 1995”Economic Geography76(1) 4–27.
7.
BakkerK, 2002, “From state to market?: Water mercantilización in Spain”Environment and Planning A34767–790.
BeccarL, 1999, “Aguas para riego y competencias municipales” [Irrigation water and municipal abilities], in Aguas y Municipios [Water and municipalities] Ed. HoogendamP (PEIRAV/Plural Editores, Cochabamba) pp 37–50.
10.
Bolivia Bulletin1989, “The informal economy”4(4) 1.
11.
BonifazC R, 2001, “Comentarios a la propuesta de modificatión de la Ley INRA presentada por la comunal al poder ejecutivo” [Commentaries on the proposal to modify the INRA law presented by the COMUNAL to the executive] Artículo Primero5(9) 7–36.
12.
BrennerN, 1998, “Between fixity and motion: Accumulation, territorial organization and the historical geography of spatial scales”Environment and Planning D: Society and Space16459–481.
13.
BrennerN, 1999, “Beyond state-centrism? Space, territoriality, and geographical scale in globalization studies”Theory and Society2839–78.
14.
BridgeG, 2000, “The social regulation of resource access and environmental impact: Production, nature and contradiction in the US copper industry”Geoforum31237–256.
15.
BridgeGJonasAEG, 2002, “Governing nature: The reregulation of resource access, production, and consumption”Environment and Planning A34759–766.
16.
BridgeGMcManusP, 2000, “Sticks and stones: Environmental narratives and discursive regulation in the forestry and mining sectors”Antipode3210–47.
17.
BustamanteR, 2002, “Legislatión del agua en Bolivia” [Water legislation in Bolivia], in Indigenous Water Rights, Local Water Management, and National Legislation Ed. BoelensR, unpublished report prepared for Water Law and Indigenous Rights (Wageningen University/IWE and United Nations/CEPAL, Wageningen, The Netherlands).
18.
BustamanteRGutiérrezZ, 1999, “Usos y costumbres en la gestión de riego: Caos uorden en la gestión de agua para riego” [Customary uses in the management of irrigation: Chaos or order in the management of water for irrigation] in Aguasy Municipios [Water and municipalities] Ed. HoogendamP (PEIRAV/Plural Editores, Cochabamba) pp 163–188.
19.
CallaR, 2000a, “Los sindicalismos bolivianos contemporáneos: Crisis y secundarización de un movimiento social desarticulado” [Contemporary Bolivian sindicalisms: Crisis and loss of influence of a disarticulated social movement], in Los Movimientos Sociales en las Democracias Andinas [Social movements in the Andean democracies] Eds MassalJBonillaM (FLACSO Ecuador–IFEA, Quito) pp 215–227.
20.
CallaR, 2000b, “Indigenous people, the law of popular participation and changes in government: Bolivia, 1994–1998”, in The Challenge of Diversity: Indigenous People and Reform of the State in Latin America Eds AssiesWvan der HaarGHoekemaA (Thela Thesis, Amsterdam) pp 77–94.
21.
CernyP, 1995, “Globalization and the changing logic of collective action”International Organization46595–625.
22.
ChávezW, 2002, “Quiere vender el agua de Potosí a Chile” [They want to sell Potosí's water to Chile] El Jugete Rabioso 17 November, page 1.
23.
ChávezW, 2003, “Peter McFarren isiste en su proyecto: El agua de Potosí para los chilenos” [Peter McFarren insists on his project: Postosí's water for the Chileans]El Juguete Rabioso 7 December, page 11.
24.
ConaghanC MMalloyJ MAbugattasL A, 1990, “Business and the ‘boys’: The politics of neoliberalism in the Central Andes”Latin American Research Review25(2) 3–30.
25.
CoxK R (Ed.), 1997Spaces of Globalization: Reasserting the Power of the Local (Guilford Press, New York).
26.
DemmersJFernãndez JilbertoA EHogenboomB, 2001, “The transformation of Latin American populism: Regional and global dimensions”, in Miraculous Metamorphoses: The Neoliberalization of Latin American Populism Eds DemmersJFernandez JilbertoA EHogenboomB (Zed Books, London) pp 1–21.
27.
EscobarA, 2001, “Culture sits in places: Reflections on globalism and subaltern strategies of localization”Political Geography20139–174.
28.
FarthingL, 1991, “The new underground”NACLA Report on the Americas25(1) 18–23.
29.
FarthingLKohlB, 2001, “Bolivia's new wave of protest”NACLA Report on the Americas34(5) 8–11.
30.
FinneganW, 2002, “Leasing the rain”The New Yorker78(7), 8 April, pp 43–53.
FlynnAMarsdenT K, 1995, “Rural change, regulation and sustainability”Environment and Planning A271180–1192.
33.
GarcíaAGarcíaFQuitonL, 2003La ‘Guerra del Agua’ Abril de 2000: La Crisis de la Política en Bolivia [The ‘water war’ April 2000: political crisis in Bolivia] (PIEB, La Paz).
34.
GlassmanJ, 1999, “State power beyond the ‘territorial trap’: The internationalization of the state”Political Geography18669–696.
35.
HaleC R, 2002, “Does multiculturalism menace? Governance, cultural rights and the politics of identity in Guatemala”Journal of Latin American Studies34485–524.
36.
HarperC L, 2001Environment and Society: Human Perspectives on Environmental Issues (Prentice-Hall, Upper Saddle River, NJ).
37.
HarveyD, 1974, “Population, resources and the ideology of science”Economic Geography50(3) 256–277.
38.
HaughtonG, 1998, “Private profits—public drought: The creation of a crisis in water management for West Yorkshire”Transaction of the Institute of British Geographers, New Series23419–433.
39.
HaughtonG, 2002, “Market making: Internationalization and global water markets”Environment and Planning A34791–807.
40.
HealyK, 2001Llamas, Weavings, and Organic Chocolate: Multicultural Grassroots Development in the Andes and Amazon of Bolivia (University of Notre Dame Press, South Bend, IN).
41.
HealyKPaulsonP, 2000, “Political economies of identity in Bolivia 1952–1998”The Journal of Latin American Anthropology5(2) 2–29.
42.
HershbergE, 2003, “Latin America at a crossroads”NACLA Report on the Americas37(3) 20–23.
43.
HoogendamPVargasG, 1999a, “Continuidades y discontinuidades en la gestión de agua después de la implementatión del nuevo marco legal” [Continuities and discontinuities in the management of water after the implementation of the new legal framework], in Aguas y Municipios [Water and municipalities] Ed. HoogendamP (PEIRAV/Plural Editores, Cochabamba) pp 151–161.
44.
HoogendamPVargasG, 1999b, “La compleja relatión entre municipalizatión, gobernabilidad y la gestión de agua” [The complex relationship between municipalization, governance, and water management], in Aguas y Municipios [Water and municipalities] Ed. HoogendamP (PEIRAV/Plural Editores, Cochabamba) pp 21–35.
45.
JessopB, 1990State Theory: Putting the Capitalist State in its Place (Polity Press, Cambridge).
46.
KaimowitzDThieleGPachecoP, 1999, “The effects of structural adjustment on deforestation and forest degradation in lowland Bolivia”World Development27505–520.
47.
KleinH S, 1992Bolivia: The Evolution of a Multi-ethnic Society2nd edition (Oxford University Press, New York).
48.
KohlB H, 1999, “Economic and political restructuring in Bolivia: tools for a neoliberal agenda?” PhD dissertation, Cornell University, Ithaca, NY.
49.
KohlB, 2002, “Stabilizing neoliberalism in Bolivia: Popular participation and privatization”Political Geography21449–472.
50.
MacLeodGGoodwinM, 1999, “Space, scale and state strategy: Rethinking urban and regional governance”Progress in Human Geography23503–527.
51.
MarvinSLaurieN, 1999, “An emerging logic of urban water management, Cochabamba, Bolivia”Urban Studies36341–357.
52.
MNR-MRTKL, 1993Plan de Todos (Government of Bolivia, La Paz).
53.
MohanG, 1996, “Adjustment and decentralization in Ghana: A Case of diminished sovereignty”Political Geography15(1) 75–94.
54.
Muñoz ElsnerD, 2000Políticas Publicas y Agricultura Campesina: Encuentros y Desencuentros [Public policies and peasant agriculture: encounters and disencounters] (Plural Editores, La Paz).
55.
NicksonAVargasC, 2002, “The limitations of water regulation: The failure of the Cochabamba concession in Bolivia”Bulletin of Latin American Research21(1) 99–120.
56.
OrellanaR, 1999, “Re-pensando proposiciones y conceptos sobre el derecho consuetudinario” [Rethinking proposals and concepts of customary law]Artículo Primero3(7) 41–54.
57.
OrellanaR, 2000, “Municipalization and indigenous peoples in Bolivia: Impacts and perspectives”, in The Challenge of Diversity: Indigenous People and Reform of the State in Latin America Eds AssiesWvan der HaarGHoekemaA (Thela Thesis, Amsterdam) pp 181–194.
58.
OrellanaR, 2001, “Propuesta de modificatión de Ley INRA” [Proposal for the modification of the INRA law]Artículo Primero5(9) 37–67.
59.
PerreaultT, 2003, “Changing places: Transnational networks, ethnic politics, and community development in the Ecuadorian Amazon”Political Geography22(1) 61–88.
60.
PolanyiK, 1944The Great Transformation (Farrar and Rinehart, New York).
61.
RondinelliD AMcCulloughJ SJohnsonR W, 1989, “Analysing decentralization policies in developing countries: A Political-economy framework”Development and Change2057–87.
62.
SachsJ, 1987, “The Bolivian hyperinflation and stabilization”American Economic Review77(2) 279–283.
63.
SachsJLarrainF, 1993Macroeconomics in a Global Economy (Prentice-Hall, Englewood Cliffs, NJ).
64.
SanabriaH, 1999, “Consolidating states, restructuring economies, and confronting workers and peasants: The antinomies of Bolivian neoliberalism”Comparative Studies in Society and History41535–562.
65.
SanabriaH, 2000, “Resistance and the arts of domination: Miners and the Bolivian state”Latin American Perspectives27(1) 56–81.
66.
Sánchez de LozadaG, 1985, “La nueva política económica” [The new political economy]Foro Económico56.
67.
SchultzJ, 2003, “Bolivia: The water war widens”NACLA Report on the Americas36(4) 34–37.
68.
SlaterD, 1989, “Territorial power and the peripheral state: The issue of decentralization”Development and Change20501–531.
69.
SmithN, 1992, “Geography, difference, and the politics of scale”, in Postmodernism and the Social Sciences Eds DohertyJGrahamEMalekM (St Martin's Press, New York) pp 57–79.
70.
SmithN, 1996, “Spaces of vulnerability: The spaces of flows and the politics of scale”Critique of Anthropology16(1) 63–77.
71.
SNPP-DNFC, 1997Diagnóstico de la Situación de Organizaciones Territoriales de Base, Comités de Vigilancia, Asociaciones Comunitarias y Listado de Organizaciones Funcionales [Diagnostic of the condition of territorial base organizations, oversight committees, communal associations and listed functional organizations] (SNPP, La Paz).
72.
SwyngedouwE, 1997a, “Neither global nor local: ‘glocalization’ and the politics of scale”, in Spaces of Globalization: Reasserting the Power of the Local Ed. CoxK R (Guilford Press, New York) pp 137–166.
73.
SwyngedouwE, 1997b, “Power, nature, and the city: The conquest of water and the political ecology of urbanization in Guayaquil, Ecuador, 1880–1990”Environment and Planning A29311–332.
74.
SwyngedouwE, 2000, “Authoritarian governance, power, and the politics of rescaling”Environment and Planning D: Society and Space1863–76.
75.
The Economist2002, “Troubled waters”, 14 December, pp 32–33.
76.
TickellAPeckJ A, 1995, “Social regulation after Fordism: regulation theory, neo-liberalism and the global–local nexus”Economy and Society24357–386.
77.
UriosteM, 2003, “Reorientar la reforma agraria” [Redirect the agrarian reform]Le Monde Diplomatique (Bolivian edition) 1(11) (August) 4–5.
78.
Van CottD L, 2000The Friendly Liquidation of the Past: The Politics of Diversity in Latin America’ (University of Pittsburgh Press, Pittsburgh, PA).
79.
Van DammeP, 2002, “Disponibilidad, uso y calidad de los recursos hídricos en Bolivia” (availability, use, and quality of water resources in Bolivia), unpublished report for the Comisión para la Gestión Integral del Agua en Bolivia, http://www.aguabolivia.org/.
YasharD J, 1999, “Democracy, indigenous movements, and the postliberal challenge in Latin America”World Politics5276–104.
82.
Zeballos HurtadoHQuiroga CrespoE, 2003Política y Economía de los Recursos Naturales Renovables en Bolivia [Politics and economics of renewable natural resources in Bolivia] (Plural, La Paz).
83.
ZimmererK, 1996, “Discourses on soil loss in Bolivia: Sustainability and the search for socioenvironmental ‘middle ground’”, in Liberation Ecologies Eds PeetRWattsM (Routledge, New York) pp 110–124.
84.
ZimmererK, 2000a, “Rescaling irrigation in Latin America: The cultural images and political ecology of water resources”Ecumene7(2) 150–175.
85.
ZimmererK, 2000b, “Commentary: Social science intellectuals, sustainable development and the political economies of Bolivia”Journal of Latin American Anthropology5(2) 179–189.
