This ‘afterword’ to the papers on dialectics situates the debate in the ground between Marxism and poststructuralism. Rather than a wholesale rejection of the dialectic, these authors attempt to think how poststructuralism might force an encounter with it, retaining yet transforming it. Drawing on Deleuze's characterization of abstract thought as dealing with concepts that “like baggy clothes, are much too big”, and Bergson's complaint that dialectics are “too large … not tailored to the measurements of the reality in which we live”, the paper moves to thinking about the relation of dialectics, measure, and world. It does so through an interrogation of a nondialectical materialism, that of Alain Badiou and his ex-student Quentin Meillassoux, particularly Meillassoux's critique of correlationism. One of the key issues raised is the return of mathematics, and its embrace within some aspects of human geography. Raising the question of how this may reverse some of the gains of poststructuralism and Marxism in combating the reduction of the quantitative revolution, the paper concludes by asking if geography is really willing to accept mathematical ordering, not merely in terms of a way of understanding the world, but as a suggestion that this is how the world actually is.
References
1.
AndersonBKellyTolia D (Eds), 2004, “Material geographies”Geoforum35669–754
2.
ArrighiG, 1994The Long Twentieth Century (Verso, London)
BadiouA, 2006d, “Préface”, in Après la finitude: Essai sur la nécessité de la contingence Ed. MeillassouxQ (Seuil, Paris) pp 9–11
12.
BadiouA, 2006e“Philosophy, sciences, mathematics: Interview with Alain Badiou”Collapse: Philosophical Research and Development111–26
13.
BadiouA, 2007The Century translated by ToscanoA (Polity Press, Cambridge)
14.
BarnesT JHannahM (Eds), 2001a, “The place of numbers: Histories, geographies, and theories of quantification, part 1”Environment and Planning D: Society and Space19(4) 379–459 (special issue)
15.
BarnesT JHannahM (Eds), 2001b, “The place of numbers: Histories, geographies, and theories of quantification, part 2”Environment and Planning D: Society and Space19(5) 505–572 (special issue)
16.
BergmannLSheppardEPlummerP, 2009, “Capitalism beyond harmonious equilibrium: Mathematics as if human agency mattered”Environment and Planning A41(2) forthcoming
17.
BergsonH, 1963, “La pensée et le mouvant”, in Oeuvres (Presses Universitaires de France, Paris)
18.
BhaskarR, 1993Dialectic: The Pulse of Freedom (Verso, London)
19.
BrassierR, 2007, “The enigma of realism: On Quentin Meillassoux's After Finitude”Collapse: Philosophical Research and DevelopmentII15–54
20.
BrassierRHamilton-GrantIHarmanGMeillassouxQ, 2007, “Speculative realism”Collapse: Philosophical Research and DevelopmentIII307–449
21.
CollingeC, 2008, “Positions without negations? Dialectical reason and the contingencies of space”Environment and Planning A402613–2622
22.
CramptonJEldenS (Eds), 2006, “Space, politics, calculation”Social and Cultural Geography7681–787
23.
DeleuzeG, 1991Bergsonism translated by TomlinsonHHabberjamB (Zone Books, New York)
24.
DewsburyJ-D, 2007, “Unthinking subjects: Alain Badiou and the event of thought in thinking politics”Transactions of the Institute of British Geographers, New Series32443–459
25.
DoelM, 2008, “Dialectics revisited. Reality discharged”Environment and Planning A402631–2640
26.
DoelM, 2009, “Miserly thinking/excessful geography: From Bataille to Badiou”Environment and Planning D: Society and Space (forthcoming)
27.
EldenS, 2004Understanding Henri Lefebvre: Theory and the Possible (Continuum, London)
28.
EldenS, 2006Speaking Against Number: Heidegger, Language and the Politics of Calculation (Edinburgh University Press, Edinburgh)
29.
EngelsF, 1940Dialectics of Nature translated and edited by DuttC (Lawrence and Wishart, London)
30.
GidwaniV, 2008, “The subaltern moment in Hegel's dialectic”Environment and Planning A402578–2587
31.
HarmanG, 2007, “Quentin Meillassoux: A new French philosopher”Philosophy Today51104–117
32.
HarveyD, 1982The Limits to Capital (Blackwell, Oxford)
33.
HarveyD, 2003The New Imperialism (Oxford University Press, Oxford)
34.
HarveyD, 2005A Brief History of Neoliberalism (Oxford University Press, Oxford)
35.
HegelG W F, 1977Hegel's Phenomenology of Spirit translated by MillerA V (Oxford University Press, Oxford); first published in 1807
36.
HeideggerM, 1962Being and Time translated by MacquarrieJRobinsonE (Blackwell, Oxford)
37.
HooperB, 2008, “Dialegesthai: Towards a posttranscendent politics—or, let's talk about bodies”Environment and Planning A402562–2577
38.
JonesM, 2009, “Phase space: Geography, relational thinking, and beyond”Progress in Human Geography (forthcoming)
39.
KerslakeC, 2008Immanence and the Vertigo of Philosophy: From Kant to Deleuze (Edinburgh University Press, Edinburgh)
40.
KleinJ, 1992Greek Mathematical Thought and the Origin of Algebra (Dover, New York)
41.
LefebvreH, 1960Problèmes actuels du marxisme2nd edition (Presses Universitaires de France, Paris)
42.
LeninV I, 1963, “Lenin's philosophical notebooks”, in Reader in Marxist Philosophy Eds SelsamHMartelH (International Publishers, New York) pp 325–364
43.
MachereyP, 1977Hegel ou Spinoza (Maspéro, Paris)
44.
MackayR, 2007, “Editorial introduction”, in Collapse: Philosophical Research and DevelopmentII3–13
45.
MarxKEngelsF, 1983Collected Worksvolume 40 (Laurence and Wishart, London)
46.
MeillassouxQ, 2004, “La contingence des lois de la nature”, unpublished conference paper, 9 December
47.
MeillassouxQ, 2006Après la finitude: Essai sur la nécessité de la contingence (Seuil, Paris)
48.
MilbankJ, 2007, “Only theology saves metaphysics: On the modalities of terror”, in Belief and Metaphysics Eds CunninghamCCandlerP MJr (SCM Press, London) pp 452–499
49.
PhiloC (Ed.), 1998, “Reconsidering quantitative geography”Environment and Planning A30191–332
50.
RoseG, 1984Dialectic of Nihilism: Post-structuralism and Law (Blackwell, Oxford)
51.
RuddickS, 2008, “Towards a dialectics of the positive”Environment and Planning A402588–2602
52.
SaldanhaA, 2007, “The LSD-event: Badiou not on acid”Theory and Event10, doi:10.1353/tae.2007.0091
53.
SecorA, 2008, “Žižek's dialectics of difference and the problem of space”Environment and Planning A402623–2630
54.
SheppardE, 2008, “Geographical dialectics?”Environment and Planning A402603–2612
55.
SimonsenK, 2004, “Networks, flows, and fluids—reimagining spatial analysis?”Environment and Planning A361333–1337
56.
SmithN, 1984Uneven Development: Nature, Capital and the Production of Space (Blackwell, Oxford)
57.
SmithN, 2003American Empire: Roosevelt's Geographer and the Prelude to Globalization (University of California Press, Berkeley, CA)
58.
SmithN, 2005The Endgame of Globalization (Routledge, London)
59.
VernesJ-R, 1982Critique de la raison aléatoire ou Descartes contre Kant (Aubier Montagne, Paris)
