The aim of this paper is to explore the role of regional innovation systems and clusters in the economic recovery of old industrial regions. We draw a distinction between three types of cluster-based renewal: an innovation-oriented adjustment of mature clusters (incremental change); the emergence of new agglomerations in established industries (diversification); and the rise of knowledge-intensive and high-technology activities (radical change). In the empirical part of the paper we compare cluster-based recovery processes in the regions of Styria and the Saarland. It is shown that Styria rebuilt its regional innovation system more successfully, enabling the innovation-oriented adjustment of a mature cluster, the rise of a new cluster in an established industry, and the emergence of knowledge-intensive activities. In the Saarland, in contrast, the regional innovation system has been more specialised, which has resulted in weak performance with respect to incremental change and diversification and high performance regarding radical change.
References
1.
AdametzCFritzOHartmannC, 2000Cluster in der Steiermark: Lieferverflechtungen, Kooperationsbeziehungen und Entwicklungsdynamik (Joanneum Research, Graz)
2.
AsheimBGertlerM, 2005, “The geography of innovation”, in The Oxford Handbook of Innovation Eds FagerbergJMoweryDNelsonR (Oxford University Press, Oxford) pp 291–317
3.
AutioE, 1998, “Evaluation of RTD in regional systems of innovation”European Planning Studies6131–140
4.
BrücherW, 1989, “Struktur- und Standortveränderungen der saarländischen Eisen- und Stahlindustrie unter dem Druck der Krise”, in Das Saarland—Band 1 Eds BrücherWFliednerDLöfflerEMüllerPQuastenHRathjensCSoyezD (Selbstverlag des Geographischen Institutes der Universität des Saarlandes, Saarbrücken) pp 227–242
5.
ChapmanKMacKinnonDCumbersA, 2004, “Adjustment or renewal in regional clusters? A study of diversification amongst SMEs in the Aberdeen oil complex”Transactions of the Institute of British Geographers, New Series29382–396
6.
CookeP (Ed.), 1995The Rise of the Rustbelt (UCL Press, London)
7.
CookePMorganK, 1998The Associational Economy (Oxford University Press, Oxford)
8.
CookePBoekholtPTödtlingF, 2000The Governance of Innovation in Europe (Pinter, London)
GertlerMWolfeD, 2004, “Ontario's regional innovation system: The evolution of knowledge-based institutional assets”, in Regional Innovation Systems2nd edition, Eds CookePHeidenreichMBraczykH-J (Routledge, London) pp 91–124
14.
GierschV, 1989, “Saar-Wirtschaft im Wandel: Vom Montanstandort zu einer modernen Industrieregion”, in Das Saarland—Band 1 Ed. BrücherWFliednerDLöfflerEMüllerPQuastenHRathjensCSoyezD (Selbstverlag des Geographischen Institutes der Universität des Saarlandes, Saarbrücken) pp 257–268
15.
GrabherG, 1993, “The weakness of strong ties: The lock-in of regional development in the Ruhr-area”, in The Embedded Firm: On the Socioeconomics of Industrial Networks Ed. GrabherG (T J Press, London) pp 255–278
16.
HassinkR, 2008, “Geography locked in decline? On the role of regional lock-ins in old industrial areas”, in Handbook of Evolutionary Economic Geography Eds BoschmaRMartinR (Edward Elgar, Cheltenham, Glos) forthcoming
17.
HassinkRShinD-O, 2005, “The restructuring of old industrial areas in Europe and Asia”Environment and Planning A37571–580
18.
HilbertJNordhause-JanzJRehfeldDHeinzeR, 2004, “Industrial clusters and the governance of change: Lessons from North Rhine–Westphalia”, in Regional Innovation Systems2nd edition Eds CookePHeidenreichMBraczykH-J (Routledge, London) pp 234–258
19.
HudsonR, 2005, “Rethinking change in old industrial regions: Reflecting on the experiences of North East England”Environment and Planning A37581–596
KaufmannATödtlingF, 2000, “Systems of innovation in traditional industrial regions: The case of Styria in a comparative perspective”Regional Studies3429–40
22.
LerchW, 2007, “Strukturwandel und regionale Wirtschaftspolitik im Saarland von 1970 bis heute”, in 50 Jahre Saarland im Wandel Eds DörrenbächerPKúhneOWagnerJ M (Institut fúr Landeskunde im Saarland, Saarbrücken)
23.
LesterR, 2005, “Universities, innovation, and the competitiveness of local economies”, WP 05–010, Industrial Performance Center, Massachusetts Institute of Technology
24.
MartinRSunleyP, 2006, “Path dependence and regional economic evolution”Journal of Economic Geography6395–437
25.
Miehe-NordmeyerG, 2001Ökonomische Anpassung an Schocks: Das Beispiel der Regionen Saarland, Lothringen und Luxemburg (Peter Lang, Berlin)
26.
MorganK, 1997, “The learning region: Institutions, innovation and regional renewal”Regional Studies31491–503
27.
O'GormanCKautonenM, 2004, “Policies to promote new knowledge-intensive industrial agglomerations”Entrepreneur ship and Regional Development16459–479
28.
O'MalleyEO'GormanC, 2001, “Competitive advantage in the Irish indigenous software industry and the role of inward foreign direct investment”European Planning Studies9303–321
29.
OttoASchanneN, 2006, “Das Saarland—der ‘Sonderweg’ eines altindustrialisierten Agglomerationsraumes”Sozialer Fortschritt55291–294
30.
PorterM, 1998On Competition (Harvard Business School Press, Boston, MA)
31.
SadlerD, 2004, “Cluster evolution, the transformation of old industrial regions and the steel industry supply chain in North East England”Regional Studies3855–66
32.
StorperM, 2002, “Institutions of the learning economy”, in Innovation and Social Learning: Institutional Adaption in an Era of Technological Chance Eds GertlerMWolfeD (Palgrave Macmillan, Basingstoke, Hants) pp 135–158
33.
TödtlingFTripplM, 2004, “Like Phoenix from the ashes? The renewal of clusters in old industrial areas”Urban Studies411175–1195
34.
TödtlingFTripplM, 2005, “One size fits all? Towards a differentiated regional innovation policy approach”Research Policy341203–1219
35.
TripplM, 2004Innovative Cluster in alten Industriegebieten (LIT, Wien)
36.
TripplMTödtlingF, 2007, “Developing biotechnology clusters in non-high technology regions—the case of Austria”Industry and Innovation1447–67
37.
TripplMTödtlingF, 2008, “Cluster renewal in old industrial regions—continuity or radical change?” in Handbook of Research on Clusters Ed. KarlssonC (Edward Elgar, Cheltenham, Glos) forthcoming
