The Contribution of the EC Energy Certificate in Improving Sustainability of the Housing Stock

Abstract

In 2003 the European Commission introduced the EC Directive on the energy performance of buildings in recognition of the importance of energy savings in the urban housing stock. The Directive gives the member states freedom to design the different elements in practice. The energy certificate for existing buildings demanded by the EC Directive can be used as a communicative instrument, or combined with economic or regulatory principles. The authors discuss the anticipated efficiency and effectiveness of different policy approaches in the application of the EC energy certificate for the urban housing stock. They argue that, although energy certificates as a communication instrument for household appliances have appeared to be relatively successful, the different nature of the building sector may mean that their effectiveness here will be rather limited. The combination of energy certificates with tax schemes seems promising, but will have to be coupled with general income taxes or in housing-related taxes in order to prevent regressive social effects. Combination of the energy certificate with subsidies should be limited, because of the ‘free-rider effect’, and subsidies should only cover innovative products at the beginning of their ‘learning curve’. Effective results can probably be expected from the introduction of regulations combined with energy-certificate standards, but this requires a rather drastic approach and needs time to receive sufficient commitment, as has been the case for new buildings where there has been a gradual development of energy regulations over the last thirty years. However, an introduction of energy standards for the existing urban housing stock through the EC energy certificate offers great potential in the realisation of CO₂ reductions. The introduction of an energy standard, by means of the energy certificate in combination with progressive taxes or other economic measures to reward better and punish worse energy-performance levels, seems an interesting approach that needs further research.

References

Andersen

M S

, 1994 Governance by Green Taxes (Manchester University Press, Manchester)

Anker-Nilssen

, 2003, “Social obstacles in curbing residential energy demand”, in Proceedings of the ECEEE 2003 Summer Study, St-Raphaël, France, 2–7 June 2003 Eds Attali

Métreau

Prône

Tillerson

, European Council for Energy Efficient Economy, Sveavägen 98, 4tr, 11350, Stockholm

Beerepoot

, 2002a Energy Regulations for New Building—In Search of Harmonisation in the European Union (Delft University Press, Delft)

Beerepoot

, 2002b Task 1 Benchmark of Energy Performance Regulations and Incentives, with Regard to the Incorporation of Renewable Energy Sources, for New Housing and Extensions to Existing Housing Altener contract 4.1030/Z/01-122/2001, OTB Research Institute for Housing, Urban and Mobility Studies, Delft University of Technology, Delft

Beumer

Van der Giessen

E C

Olieman

Otten

G R

, 1993 Evaluate van de isolatieregeling (SES 1991) en de ketelregeling (SNEV) [Evaluation of the insulation regulations (SES 1991) and the boiler regulations (SNEV)] NEI, PO Box 4175, 3006 AD Rotterdam

Blaustein

, 2000, “Energy certification of existing buildings” SAVE contract No XVII/4.1031/Z/99-261 Intermediate Report International Conseil Energie, 46 rue de Provence, 75009, Paris

Bundesministerium für Wirtschaft, 2001 Verordnung über energiesparenden Wärmeschutz und energiesparende Anlagentechnik bei Gebäuden (Energieeinsparverordnung—EnEV) [Regulations for energy saving insulation and energy saving installations for buildings (Energy savings regulations—EnEV)] Bundesministerium für Wirtschaft, Bonn

Consult

C O W I

, 2001 Evaluation of the Energy Management Scheme (Rating for Large Buildings) The Danish Energy Authority, 44 Amaliegade, DK-1256 Copenhagen K

DTLR, 2001 Approved Document L1, Conservation of Fuel and Power in Dwellings Department of Transport, Local Government and the Regions, Eland House, Bressenden Place, London SW1E 5DU

10.

EC, 2001 Towards a European Strategy for the Security of Energy Supply Green Paper, European Commission, Brussels

11.

EC, 2003, Council Directive 2002/91/EC of 16 December 2002 on the energy performance of buildings Official Journal of the European Communities L 1 of 04/01/2003, 65–71, European Commission, Brussels

12.

Ekelenkamp

Hötte

Van der Vlies

, 2000 Nieuwe Instrumenten voor het milieubeleid [New instruments for environmental policies] TNO Strategie, Technologie en Beleid, Schoemakerstraat 97, 2628VK

13.

Gilijamse

Jablonska

, 2002 Verbetering energieprestatie bestaande woningen [Improving the energy performance of existing dwellings] ECN, PO Box 1, 1755 ZG Petten

14.

Hasegawa

, 2002, “Policies for environmentally sustainable buildings”, OECD report ENV/EPOC/WPNEP (2002)5 (OECD, Paris)

15.

Howlett

Ramesh

, 1993, “Pattern of policy instrument choice” Policy Studies Review 12, 3–24

16.

Jeeninga

Beeldman

Boonekamp

P G M

, 2001 EPA Woningen— Nadere invulling van de EPA doelstelling voor woningen [Energy performance advice for dwellings, elaboration of EPA goals for dwellings] ECN, PO Box 1, 1755 ZG Petten

17.

Jordan

Wurzel

Zito

Brückner

, 2000, “The innovation of ‘new’ environmental policy instruments (NEPIS): Patterns and pathways of convergence and divergence in the European Union”, paper for the international workshop on “Diffusion of Environmental Policy Innovations”, Berlin, 8–9 December; for copy contact R.K.Wurzel@polas.hull.ac.uk

18.

Kemp

, 1995 Environmental Policy and Technical Change: A Comparison of the Technological Impact of Policy Instruments (University of Limburg, Maastricht)

19.

Kemp

, 2000, “Technology and environmental policy: Innovation effects of past policies and suggestions for improvement”, presented to OECD workshop on Innovation and Environment, 19 June, Paris, http://meritbbs.unimaas.nl/rkemp/oecd.pdf

20.

Laustsen

J H

, 2001, “Mandatory labelling of buildings: The Danish experience” Sustainable Building 4, 12–14

21.

Murakami

Izumi

Yashiro

Ando

Hasegawa

, 2002 Sustainable Building and Policy Design (Institute of International Harmonisation for Building and Housing, Tokyo)

22.

Novem , 2002 Operating Space for European Sustainable Building Policies, Report of the Pan European Conference of the Ministers of Housing Addressing Sustainable Building, Genvalle, Belgium, 27–28 June 2002 Novem, Catharijnesingel 59, 3511 GG, Utrecht

23.

Schneider

Ingram

, 1990, “Behavioural assumptions of policy tools” Journal of Politics 52, 510–529

24.

Siebert

, 1995 Economics of the Environment, Theory and Policy (Springer, Berlin)

25.

Sunikka

, 2002 Policies and Regulations for Sustainable Building: A Comparative Study of Five European Countries (Delft University Press, Delft)

26.

Sunikka

, 2003a, “Fiscal instruments in sustainable housing policies in the EU and the accession countries” European Environment 13, 227–239

27.

Sunikka

, 2003b, “Sustainable housing policies for the existing housing stock in Europe” Open House International 28(1) 4–11

28.

Tweede Kamer der Staten Generaal, 1987 Evaluate WIR-milieutoeslag [Evaluation of the WIR investment subsidies] Dutch Parliamentary Study, Tweede Kamer, vergaderjaar 1986–1987, 19858, No. 4

29.

Tweede Kamer der Staten Generaal, 2002 Verslag van een algemeen overleg 14 mei 2002 [Minutes of a general meeting 14 May 2002] (Tweede Kamer der Staten Generaal, vergaderjaar 2001–2002, 26603 enz., no. 38)

30.

Van Cruchten

, 2003 Task 2 Benchmark of Energy Performance Regulations and Incentives, With Regard to the Incorporation of Renewable Energy Sources, for Existing Building Altener contract 4.1030/Z/01-122/2001 draft report, EBM consult, PO Box 694, NL-6800 AR, Arnhem

31.

Van der Waals

, 2001 CO2-Reduction in Housing: Experiences in Building and Urban Renewal Projects in the Netherlands (Rozenberg, Utrecht)

32.

Vekemans

, 2003, “Towards a common European approach for energy labelling and assessment of existing dwellings”, in Proceedings of the ECEEE 2003 Summer Study, St-Raphaël, France, 2–7 June 2003 Eds Attali

Métreau

Prône

Tillerson

, European Council for Energy Efficient Economy, Svearägen 98, 4tr, 11350, Stockholm

33.

Vermeulen

, 1992 De vervuiler betaald: Onderzoek naar de werking van subsidies op vier deelterreinen van het milieubeleid [The polluter gets paid] (Rijksuniversiteit Utrecht, Utrecht)