The United Nations Conference on Sustainable Development, held in June 2012 in Rio de Janeiro, was probably the largest event in a long series of megasummits on environmental protection and sustainable development. Roughly 44 000 participants descended on Rio de Janeiro to take part in ten days of preparatory committee meetings, informal consultations, side events, and the actual conference. Yet despite this unprecedented high attendance by participants from governments and civil society, the outcome of the conference is less than many had hoped for. In this paper I review the outcomes of the 2012 Rio conference in detail, with a special focus on its contributions towards the reform of the institutional framework for sustainable development. Following this review, I discuss the way ahead and options for structural reform to restrengthen earth system governance.
AbbottK WSnidalD, 2010, “International regulation without international government: Improving IO performance through orchestration”Review of International Organization5315–344
2.
AndresenSRosendalK, 2009, “The role of the United Nations Environment Programme in the coordination of multilateral environmental agreements”, in International Organizations in Global Environmental Governance Eds BiermannFSiebenhünerBSchreyöggA (Routledge, Abingdon, Oxon) pp 133–150
3.
AndresenSUnderdalA, 2012, “We do not need more global sustainability conferences”, open letter in the Internet forum on international environmental governance hosted by the Earth System Governance Project, http://www.ieg.earthsystemgovernance.org
4.
BarnettMColemanL, 2005, “Designing police: Interpol and the study of change in international organizations”International Studies Quarterly49593–619
BauerS, 2009, “The secretariat of the United Nations Environment Programme: Tangled up in blue”, in Managers of Global Change: The Influence of International Environmental Bureaucracies Eds BiermannFSiebenhünerB (MIT Press, Cambridge, MA), pp 169–201
7.
BauerS, 2013, “Strengthening the United Nations”, in The Handbook of Global Climate and Environment Policy Ed. FalknerR (John Wiley, Chichester, Sussex) forthcoming
8.
BauerSAndresenSBiermannF, 2012, “International bureaucracies”, in Global Environmental Governance Reconsidered Eds BiermannFPattbergP (MIT Press, Cambridge, MA), pp 27–44
9.
BernsteinSBrunnéeJ, 2011, “Consultants' report on options for broader reform of the Institutional Framework for Sustainable Development (IFSD): Structural, legal, and financial aspects”, UN Department of Economic and Social Affairs, New York, http://www.uncsd2012.org/rio20/index.php?page=view&type=400&nr=211&menu=45
10.
BiermannF, 2000, “The case for a world environment organization”Environment42(9) 22–31
11.
BiermannF, 2012a, “Greening the United Nations Charter: World politics in the Anthropocene”Environment54(3) 6–17
12.
BiermannF, 2012b, “Planetary boundaries and earth system governance: Exploring the links”Ecological Economics811–9
13.
BiermannFBauerS (Eds), 2005A World Environment Organization: Solution or Threat for Effective International Environmental Governance? (Ashgate, Aldershot, Hants)
14.
BiermannFGuptaA, 2011, “Accountability and legitimacy in earth system governance: A research framework”Ecological Economics701856–1864
BiermannFSiebenhünerB, 2009Managers of Global Change: The Influence of International Environmental Bureaucracies (MIT Press, Cambridge, MA)
17.
BiermannFAbbottKAndresenSBäckstrandKBernsteinSBetsillM MBulkeleyHCashoreBClappJFolkeCGuptaAGuptaJHaasP MJordanAKanieNKluvánková-OravskáTLebelLLivermanDMeadowcroftJMitchellRBNewellPOberthürSOlssonLPattbergPSánchez-RodríguezRSchroederHUnderdalAVieiraS CVogelCYoungO RBrockAZondervanR, 2012, “Navigating the Anthropocene: Improving earth system governance”Science335(6074) 1306–1307
18.
BinaO, 2013, “The green economy and sustainable development: An uneasy balance?”Environment and Planning C: Government and Policy311023–1047
19.
BulkeleyHJordanA, 2012, “Transnational environmental governance: New findings and emerging research agendas”Environment and Planning C: Government and Policy30556–570
20.
BulkeleyHAndonovaLBäckstrandKBetsillM MCompagnonDDuffyRKolkAHoffmannMLevyDNewellPMilledgeTPatersonMPattbergPVanDeveerS, 2012, “Governing climate change transnationally: Assessing the evidence from a database of sixty initiatives”Environment and Planning C: Government and Policy30591–612
21.
ChasekP S, 2000, “The UN Commission on Sustainable Development: The first five years”, in The Global Environment in the Twenty-first Century: Prospects for International Cooperation Ed. ChasekP S (UN University, New York) pp 378–398
22.
Colombia and Guatemala, 2011, “Rio + 20: Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs). A proposal from the governments of Colombia and Guatemala”, available from author
23.
Commission on Global Governance, 1995Our Global Neighbourhood: The Report of the Commission on Global Governance (Oxford University Press, Oxford)
24.
Consultative Group of Ministers or High-level Representatives on International Environmental Governance, 2010, “Nairobi-Helsinki Outcome”, agreed at the group's second meeting in Espoo, Finland, 21–23 November
25.
CrutzenP J, 2002, “The Anthropocene: Geology of mankind”Nature41523
26.
CrutzenP JStoermerE F, 2000, “The ‘Anthropocene’”IGBP Newsletter4117–18
27.
ElliottL, 2005, “The United Nations record on environmental governance: An assessment”, in A World Environment Organization: Solution or Threat for Effective International Environmental Governance? Eds BiermannFBauerS (Ashgate, Aldershot, Hants) pp 27–56
28.
ElyASmithAStirlingALeachMScoonesI, 2013, “Innovation politics post-Rio+20: Hybrid pathways to sustainability?”Environment and Planning C: Government and Policy311063–1081
29.
ENB, 2012Report of the 2012 United Nations Conference on Sustainable DevelopmentEarth Negotiations Bulletin, http://www.iisd.ca
FalkRStraussA, 2001, “Toward global parliament”Foreign Affairs80212–220
32.
GuptaJ, 2005, “Global environmental governance: Challenges for the South from a theoretical perspective”, in A World Environment Organization: Solution or Threat for Effective International Environmental Governance? Eds BiermannFBauerS (Ashgate, Aldershot, Hants) pp 57–83
33.
HaasP, 2012, “The road from Rio: Why environmentalism needs to come down from the summit”Foreign Affairs 16 August
34.
HajerM, 2011De energieke samenleving. Op zoek naar een sturingsfilosofie voor een schone economiePlanbureau voor de Leefomgeving, Den Haag
35.
HalleM, 2012Life after Rio: IISD CommentaryInternational Institute for Sustainable Development, Winnipeg
36.
HawkinsD GLakeD ANielsonD LTierneyM J (Eds), 2006a, Delegation and Agency in International Organizations (Cambridge University Press, Cambridge)
37.
HawkinsD GLakeD ANielsonD LTierneyM J, 2006b, “Delegation under anarchy: States, international organizations, and principal-agent theory”, in Delegation and Agency in International Organizations, Eds. HawkinsD GLakeD ANielsonD LTierneyM J (Cambridge University Press, Cambridge) pp 3–38
38.
High Level Dialogue on Institutional Framework for Sustainable Development, 2011, “High Level Dialogue on Institutional Framework for Sustainable Development”, Chair's Summary, 19–21 July, Solo, Indonesia; available from author
39.
High-Level Panel on Global Sustainability, 2012, “Resilient people, resilient planet: A future worth choosing”, http://www.un.org/gsp
40.
HobsonK, 2013, “‘Weak’ or ‘strong’ sustainable consumption? Efficiency, degrowth, and the 10 year framework of programmes”Environment and Planning C: Government and Policy311082–1098
41.
IvanovaM, 2010, “UNEP in global environmental governance: Design, leadership, location”Global Environmental Politics1030–59
42.
JasanoffS S, 1987, “Contested boundaries in policy-relevant science”Social Studies of Science17195–230
43.
JasanoffS S, 1996, “Science and norms in global environmental regimes”, in Earthly Goods: Environmental Change and Social Justice Eds HampsonF OReppyJ (Cornell University Press, Ithaca, NY) pp 173–197
44.
JasanoffS SMartelloLong M (Eds), 2004Earthly Politics: Local and Global in Environmental Governance (MIT Press, Cambridge, MA)
45.
JerneckAOlssonL, 2010, “Shaping future adaptation governance: Perspectives from the poorest of the poor”, in Global Climate Governance Beyond 2012: Architecture, Agency, and Adaptation Eds BiermannFPattbergPZelliF (Cambridge University Press, Cambridge) pp 286–305
46.
JordanA J, 2008, “The governance of sustainable development: Taking stock and looking forwards”Environment and Planning C: Government and Policy2617–33
47.
KaasaS M, 2007, “The UN Commission on Sustainable Development: Which mechanisms explain its accomplishments?”Global Environmental Politics7107–129
48.
KanieNBetsillM MZondervanRBiermannFYoungO R, 2012, “A charter moment: Restructuring governance for sustainability”Public Administration and Development32292–304
49.
LinnérB-OSelinH, 2013, “The United Nations Conference on Sustainable Development: Forty years in the making”Environment and Planning C: Government and Policy31971–987
50.
MeadowcroftJ, 2013, “Reaching the limits? Developed country engagement with sustainable development in a challenging conjuncture”Environment and Planning C: Government and Policy31988–1002
51.
MertA, 2009, “Partnerships for sustainable development as discursive practice: Shifts in discourses of environment and democracy”Forest Policy and Economics11326–339
52.
MertA, 2013Environmental Governance through Transnational Partnerships: A Discourse Theoretical Study (Cheltenham, Edward Elgar, Glos)
53.
PattbergForthcoming P, 2006, “Private governance and the South: Lessons from global forest politics”Third World Quarterly27579–593
54.
PattbergPBiermannFChanSMertA (Eds), 2012Public—Private Partnerships for Sustainable Development: Emergence, Influence, and Legitimacy (Edward Elgar, Cheltenham, Glos)
55.
RockströmJSteffenWNooneKPerssonÅChapinStuart FLambinE FLentonT MSchefferMFolkeCSchellnhuberH-JNykvistBde WitC AHughesTvan der LeeuwSRodheHSörlinSSnyderP KCostanzaRSvedinUFalkenmarkMKarlbergLCorellR WFabryV JHansenJWalkerBLivermanDRichardsonKCrutzenPFoleyJ A, 2009, “A safe operating space for humanity”Nature461472–475
56.
SchoutenGGlasbergenP, 2011, “Creating legitimacy in global private governance: The case of the Roundtable on Sustainable Palm Oil”Ecological Economics701891–1899
57.
SchwartzbergJ E, 2009, “Universal weighted regional representation as a basis for security council reform”, presentation at the opening panel on ‘Reform of the Security Council’ at the International Law Weekend Conference of the American Branch of the International Law Association, New York, 22 October
58.
State of the Planet Declaration, 2012, “Planet under pressure: New knowledge towards solutions”, Co-chairs of the Planet under Pressure conference, London, 26–29 March, supported by the conference Scientific Organizing Committee, http://www.planetunderpressure2012.net
59.
UNGA, 2012The Future We WantUnited Nations General Assembly, New York
60.
UN Joint Inspection Unit, 2008, “Management review of environmental governance within the United Nations system”, UN Doc. JIU/REP/2008/3, prepared by T Inomata
61.
Van VuurenDKokMvan der EschSJeukenMLucasPPrinsA GAlkemadeRvan den BergMBiermannFvan der GrijpNHilderinkHKramTMelamedCPattbergPScottAStehfestEde VriesBde VeldeD WWigginsS, 2012Roads from Rio+20: Pathways to Achieve Global Sustainability Goals by 2050PBL Netherlands Environmental Assessment Agency, The Hague
62.
VieiraS C, 2012, “From sustainable development to earth system governance: A view from the South”Anuário Brasileiro de Direito Internacional [Brazilian Yearbook of International Law]2167–176
63.
VijgeM J, 2013, “The promise of new institutionalism: Explaining the absence of a World or United Nations Environment Organization”International Environmental Agreements: Politics, Law and Economics in press
