What Does the Term Whole Language Mean? Constructing a Definition from the Literature

Abstract

The present study analyzed 64 articles pertaining to whole-language instruction in elementary classrooms in order to compile a definition for this term. Five questions are presented and explored: (a) How is whole langauge defined in the educational literature? (b) What types of instructional techniques/strategies are used in describing whole-language programs? (c) What trends can be drawn from comparisons made between publication dates of journal articles as well as between author categorizations? (d) What definition for whole language can be compiled as a result of an extensive review, analysis, and synthesis of the literature? and (e) What implications does the knowledge gained from the literature analysis have for elementary reading instruction? Review analysis found that definitions and descriptions of whole language vary widely throughout the literature and that differences exist between school- and university-based authors' perceptions of this concept.

References

Altwerger

Edelsky

Flores

B. M.

(1987). Whole language: What's new? The Reading Teacher, 41, 144–154.

Asher

J. W.

(1976). Educational research and evaluation methods. Boston, MA: Little, Brown.

Brand

(1989). Learning through meaning. Academic Therapy, 24, 305–314.

Bergeron

B. S.

(1990). Definitions of whole language: Exploring a professional schism. Unpublished Master's thesis, Purdue University, West Lafayette, IN.

Bond

G. L.

Dykstra

(1967). The cooperative research program in first-grade reading instruction. Reading Research Quarterly, 2, 5–142.

Brountas

(1987). Whole language really works. Teaching K-8. 18, 57–60.

Clarke

M. A.

(1987). Don't blame the system: Constraints on “whole language” reform. Language Arts, 64, 384–396.

Edelsky

Draper

Smith

(1983). Hookin' em in at the start of school in a ‘whole language’ classroom. Anthropology and Education Quarterly, 14, 257–281.

Edlesky

Smith

(1984). Is that writing—or are those marks just a figment of your curriculum? Language Arts, 61, 24–32.

10.

Farr

(1988). Trends: A place for basal readers under the whole language umbrella. Educational Leadership, 46, 86.

11.

Farris

P. J.

Kaczmarski

(1988). Whole language, a closer look. Contemporary Education, 59, 77–81.

12.

Ferguson

(1988). Whole language: A global approach to learning. Instructor, 97, 25–27.

13.

Fields

M. V.

(1988). Talking and writing: Explaining the whole language approach to parents. The Reading Teacher, 41, 898–903.

14.

Fountas

I. C.

Hannigan

I. L.

(1989). Making sense of whole language: The pursuit of informed teaching. Childhood Education, 65, 133–137.

15.

Forester

A. D.

(1977). What teachers can learn from “natural readers”. The Reading Teacher, 31, 160–166.

16.

Glaser

B. G.

Strauss

A. L.

(1967). The discovery of grounded theory: Strategies for qualitative research. New York: Aldine De Gruyter.

17.

Goodman

K. S.

(1965). A linguistic study of cues and miscues in reading. Elementary English, 42, 639–643.

18.

Goodman

K. S.

(1967). Reading: A psycholinguistic guessing game. Journal of the Reading Specialist, 6, 126–135.

19.

Goodman

K. S.

(1971). Reading: The key is in children's language. The Reading Teacher, 25, 505–508.

20.

Goodman

K. S.

(1977). Acquiring literacy is natural: Who skilled Cock Robin? Theory Into Practice, 16, 309–314.

21.

Goodman

K. S.

(1979). The know-more and the know-nothing movements in reading: A personal response. Language Arts, 56, 657–663.

22.

Goodman

K. S.

(1987). Beyond basal readers: Taking charge of your own teaching. Learning 87, 16, 63–65.

23.

Goodman

K. S.

(1989a). Whole language is whole: A response to Heymsfeld. Educational Leadership, 46, 69–70.

24.

Goodman

K. S.

(1989b). Whole language research: Foundations and development. The Elementary School Journal, 90, 207–221.

25.

Goodman

(1989). Roots of the whole-language movement. The Elementary School Journal, 90, 113–127.

26.

Gunderson

Shapiro

(1988). Whole language instruction: Writing in 1st grade. The Reading Teacher, 41, 430–437.

27.

Hajek

(1984). Whole language: Sensible answers to the old problems. Momentum, 15, 39–40.

28.

Hall

B. W.

Ward

A. W.

Comer

C. B.

(1988). Published educational research: An empirical study of its quality. Journal of Educational Research, 81, 182–189.

29.

Harste

J. C.

(1989). The future of whole language. The Elementary School Journal, 90, 243–249.

30.

Hayward

R. A.

(1988). Inside the whole language classroom. Instructor, 98, 34–40.

31.

Heymsfeld

C. R.

(1989). Filling the hole in whole language. Educational Leadership, 46, 65–68.

32.

Hildreth

G. H.

(1965). Experience-related reading for school beginners. Elementary English, 42, 280–297.

33.

Hoffman

J. V.

(1989). Introduction. The Elementary School Journal, 90, 111–112.

34.

Holdaway

(1982). Shared book experience: Teaching reading using favorite books. Theory Into Practice, 21, 293–300.

35.

Huey

E. B.

(1908/1977). The psychology and pedagogy of reading. Institute of Technology, Cambridge, MA: The MIT Press.

36.

Jacobs

L. B.

(1989). What is whole language? Teaching K-8, 19, 34–36.

37.

Lamme

L. L.

(1989). Authorship: A key facet of whole language. The Reading Teacher, 42, 704–710.

38.

Maguire

M. H.

(1989). Understanding and implementing a whole-language program in Quebec. The Elementary School Journal, 90, 143–159.

39.

McCaslin

M. M.

(1989). Whole language: Theory, instruction, and future implementation. The Elementary School Journal, 90, 223–229.

40.

McConaghy

(1988). Canada: A leader in whole language instruction. Phi Delta Kappan, 70, 336–337.

41.

Mersereau

Glover

Cherland

(1989). Dancing on the edge. Language Arts, 66, 109–117.

42.

Mosenthal

P. B.

(1989). The whole language approach: Teachers between a rock and a hard place. The Reading Teacher, 42, 628–629.

43.

Paulet

R. O.

(1984). The whole language approach: Will it be used in Quebec and Manitoba? English Quarterly, 17, 30–36.

44.

Pienaar

P. T.

(1977). Breakthrough in beginning reading: Language experience approach. The Reading Teacher, 30, 489–496.

45.

Ramig

C. J.

Hall

M. A.

(1980). Reading strategies of first grade children taught by a language experience approach and a basal approach. Reading World, 19, 280–289.

46.

Reutzel

D. R.

Hollingsworth

P. M.

(1988). Whole language and the practitioner. Academic Therapy, 23, 405–416.

47.

Rich

S. J.

(1985). Restoring power to teachers: The impact of “whole language”. Language Arts, 62, 717–724.

48.

Richards

J. C.

Gipe

J. P.

Thompson

(1987). Teachers' beliefs about good reading instruction. Reading Psychology, 8, 1–6.

49.

Shanklin

N. L.

Rhodes

L. K.

(1989). Transforming literacy instruction. Educational Leadership, 46, 59–63.

50.

Shapiro

Gunderson

(1988). Comparison of vocabulary generated by grade 1 students in whole language classrooms and basal reader vocabulary. Reading Research and Instruction, 27, 40–46.

51.

Slaughter

(1988). Indirect and direct teaching in a whole language program. The Reading Teacher, 42, 30–34.

52.

Smith

(1976). Learning to read by reading. Language Arts, 53, 297–299.

53.

Stahl

S. A.

Miller

P. D.

(1989). Whole language and language experience approaches for beginning reading: A quantitative research synthesis. Review of Educational Research, 59, 87–116.

54.

Suhor

(1987). ERIC/RCS report: Orthodoxies in language arts instruction. Language Arts, 64, 416–420.

55.

Tunnell

M. O.

Jacobs

J. S.

(1989). Using “real” books: Research findings on literature based reading instruction. The Reading Teacher, 43, 470–477.

56.

Watson

D. J.

(1989). Defining and describing whole language. The Elementary School Journal, 90, 129–141.

57.

Wrightstone

J. W.

(1951). Research related to experience records and basal readers. The Reading Teacher, 5, 5–6, 17.

58.

Zirbes

(1951). The experience approach in reading. The Reading Teacher, 5, 1–2, 15–16.