This paper reports a series of three experiments that tested the “spatial-mapping” and “working-memory” theories of hippocampal function. The experimental designs incorporate separate reference- and working-memory procedures of a water-escape task, using both spatial and non-spatial learning. In Experiment 1 (Reference memory), rats with hippocampal (HC) or cortical (CC) lesions and unoperated (UNOP) rats learned to swim to a rigid visible escape platform while avoiding contact with a floating one. In the nonspatial task, the platforms each occupied any of 8 possible positions in the pool over successive trials but differed in appearance. In the spatial task, the platforms were of identical appearance but the safe one always occupied a single fixed location. The HC rats showed a highly specific spatial learning impairment but did learn to perform consistently above chance towards the end of training. In Experiment 2 (working memory), new groups of rats were trained on similar spatial and nonspatial tasks, but the platform designated correct-in terms of its visual appearance or its spatial location-was randomly changed each day. No animal learned the nonspatial task despite extensive training. Performance on the spatial version unexpectedly revealed an impairment in the CC as well as the HC group relative to the UNOP rats. However, the HCs again performed at above chance levels and demonstrated rapid (I-trial) spatial learning towards the end training. Experiment 3 used a place navigation matching-to-sample task examine spatial working memory further. Each day, an underwater platform was hidden at any of 4 possible locations, and the rats were given 2 trials to search for it. Both UNOP and CC rats located the platform faster on Trial 2 than on Trial 1, even when the inter-trial interval was long as 30min. HC rats were no faster on Trial 2 than on Trial 1. We conclude that hippocampal lesions (1) severely but partially impair spatial but not visual reference memory and (2) give rise to different patterns impairment in different working-mermory tasks. The results are a challenge to both the spatial-mapping and working-memory theories.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
AggletonJ. P. (1985). One-trial object recognition by rats.Quarterly Journal of Experimental Psychology37B, 279–294.
2.
AggletonJ. P.HuntP. R.RawlinsJ. N. P. (1986). The effects of hippocampal lesions upon spatial and nonspatial tests of working memory.Behavioural Brain Research.
3.
BeckerJ. T.OltonD. S.AndersonC. A.BreitingerE. R. P. (1981). Cognitive mapping in rats: The role of the hippocampal and frontal systems in retention and reversal.Behavioural Brain Research3, 1–22.
4.
BergerT. W.OrrW. B. (1983). Hippocampectomy selectively disrupts discimination reversal conditioning of the rabbit nictitating membrane response.Behavioural Brain Research8, 49–68.
5.
BoitanoJ. P.DoklaC. J. P.MulinskiP.MisikonisS.KaluzynskiT. (1980). Effects of hippocampectomy in an incremental step DRL paradigm.Physiology and Behavior25, 273–278.
6.
Diez-ChamizoV.SterioD.MackintoshN. J. (1985). Blocking and overshadowing between intra-maze and extra-maze cues: A test of the independence of locate and guidance learning.Quarterly Journal of Experimental Psychology37B, 235–254.
7.
DiMattiaR. V.KesnerR. P. (1984). Posterior parietal cortex: A part of the cognitive map?.Society for Neuroscience Abstracts10, 3912.
8.
DouglasR. J. (1967). The hippocampus and behaviour.Psychological Bulletin67, 416–442.
9.
GaffanD. (1985). Hippocampus: Memory, habit and voluntary movement.Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society (London), Series B308, 87–99.
10.
GaffanD.HarrisonS.GaffanE. A. (1986). Visual identification following inferotemporal ablation in the monkey.Quarterly Journal of Experimental Psychology38B, 5–30.
11.
GaffanD.SaundersR. C.GaffanE. A.HarrisonS.ShieldsC.OwenM. J. (1984). Effects of fornix transection upon associative memory in monkeys: Role of the hippocampus in learned action.Quarterly Journal of Experimental Psychology36B, 173–221.
12.
GrayJ. A. (1982). The neuropsychology of anxiety: An enquiry into the functions of the septo-hippocampal systemOxford: Oxford University Press.
13.
JarrardL. E. (1983). Selective hippocampal lesions and behaviour: Effects of kainic acid lesions on performance of place and cue tasks.Behavioural Neuroscience97, 873–889.
14.
JarrardL. E.OkaichiH.GoldschmidtR.StewardO. (1984). On the role of the hippocampal connections in the performance of place and cue tasks: Comparisons with damage to hippocampus.Behavioural Neuroscience98, 946–954.
15.
KimbleD. P. (1968). Hippocampus and internal inhibition.Psychological Bulletin70, 285–295.
16.
KolbB.SutherlandR. J.WhishawI. Q. (1983). A comparison of the contributions of the frontal and parietal association cortex to spatial localisation in rats.Behavioural Neuroscience97, 13–27.
17.
KriegW. J. S. (1946). Connections of the cerebral cortex: I. The albino rat. B. Structure of the cortical areas.Journal of Comparative Neurology84, 277–323.
18.
KubieJ. L.RanckJ. B.Jr. (1983). Sensory behavioural correlates in individual hippocampus neurons in three situations: Space and context.The neurobiology of the hippocampus.SiefertW.London: Academic Press.
19.
LynchG. S. (1986). Synapses, circuits and the beginnings of memoryCambridge, Mass.: MIT Press.
20.
MackintoshN. J. (1974). The psychology of animal learningLondon: Academic Press.
21.
MishkinM.DelacourJ. (1975). An analysis of short-term visual memory in the monkey.Journal of Experimental Psychology: Animal Behavior Processes1, 326–334.
22.
MorrisR. G. M. (1981). Spatial localisation does not depend on the presence of local cues.Learning and Motivation12, 239–260.
23.
MorrisR. G. M. (1983). An attempt to dissociate spatial-mapping and working-memory theories of hippocampal function.The neurobiology of the hippocampus.SiefertW.London: Academic Press.
24.
MorrisR. G. M. (1984). Developments of a water-maze procedure for studying spatial learning in the rat.Journal of Neuroscience Methods11, 47–60.
25.
MorrisR. G. M.DoyleJ. (1985). Successive incompatible tasks: Evidence for separate systems for storage of spatial knowledge.Electrical activity of the archicortex.BuszakiG.VanderwolfC. H.Budapest: Akademial Kiadó.
26.
MorrisR. G. M.GarrudP.RawlinsJ. N. P.O'KeefeJ. (1982). Place-navigation impaired in rats with hippocampal lesions.Nature297, 681–683.
27.
NadelL.MacdonaldL. (1980). Hippocampus: Cognitive map or working memory?.Behavioral and Neural Biology29, 405–409.
28.
O'KeefeJ. (1976). Place-units in the hippocampus of the freely moving rat.Experimental Neurology51, 78–109.
29.
O'KeefeJ. (1983). Spatial memory within and without the hippocampal system.The neurobiology of the hippocampus.SieferM. W.London: Academic Press.
30.
O'KeefeJ.NadelL. (1978). The hippocampus as a cognitive mapOxford: Oxford University Press.
31.
O'KeefeJ.NadelL.KeightlyS.KillD. (1975). Fornix lesions selectively abolish place-learning in the rat.Experimental Neurology48, 152–166.
32.
O'KeefeJ.SpeakmanA. (in press). Evidence that activation of one part of a cognitive map activates all of it.Neuroscience Letters.
33.
OltonD. S. (1978). Characteristics of spatial memory.Cognitive processes in animal behaviour.HulseS. H.FowlerH.HonigW. K.Hillsdale, N.J.: Lawrence Erlbaum Associates.
34.
OltonD. S.BeckerJ. T.HandelmanG. E. (1979). Hippocampus, space and memory.Behavioral and Brain Sciences2, 313–365.
35.
OltonD. S.FeustleW. A. (1981). Hippocampal function required for nonspatial working-memory.Experimental Brain Research41, 380–389.
36.
OltonD. S.PapasB. C. (1980). Spatial memory and hippocampal system function.Neuropsychologia17, 669–681.
37.
OltonD. S.SamuelsonR. J. (1976). Remembrance of places passed: Spatial memory in rats.Journal of Experimental Psychology: Animal Behavior Processes2, 97–116.
38.
ParkinsonJ. K.MishkinM. (1982). A selective mnemonic role for the hippocampus in monkeys: Memory for the location of objects.Society for Neuroscience Abstracts12, 117.
39.
PaxinosG.WatsonC. (1982). The rat brain in stereotaxic coordinatesSydney: Academic Press.
40.
PicoR. M.GerbrandtL. K.PondelM.IvyG. (1985). During stepwise cue deletion, rat place behaviours correlate with place unit responses.Brain Research330, 369–372.
41.
PohlW. (1973). Dissociation of spatial discrimination deficits following frontal and parietal lesions in monkeys.Journal of Comparative and Physiological Psychology82, 227–239.
42.
RawlinsJ. N. P. (1985). Associations across time: The hippocampus as a temporary memory store.Behavioral and Brain Sciences8, 479–528.
43.
RawlinsJ. N. P.BennettR. C. (1980). A headholder for visually guided surgery in rats.Physiology and Behavior24, 415–416.
44.
RawlinsJ. N. P.FeldonJ.GrayJ. A. (1980). The effects of hippocampectomy and of fimbria section upon the partial reinforcement extinction effect in rats.Experimental Brain Research38, 273–283.
45.
RawlinsJ. N. P.OltonD. S. (1982). The septo-hippocampal system and cognitive mapping.Behavioural Brain Research5, 331–358.
46.
SchapiroS.SalasM.VukovichK. (1970). Hormonal effects on ontogeny of swimming ability in the rat: Assessment of central nervous system development.Science168, 147–151.
47.
SchenkF.MorrisR. G. M. (1985). Dissociation between components of spatial memory in rats after recovery from the effects of retrohippocampal lesions.Experimental Brain Research58, 11–28.
48.
SmithM. L.MilnerB. (1981). The role of the right hippocampus in the recall of spatial location.Neuropsychologia19, 781–793.
49.
StevensR. (1973). Effects of amount of training on reversal learning in hippocampectomised rats.Physiological Psychology1, 377–399.
50.
SutherlandR. J.DyckR. H. (1984). Place-navigation by rats in a swimming-pool.Canadian Journal of Psychology38, 322–347.
51.
SutherlandR. J.WhishawI. Q.KolbB. (1983). A behavioural analysis of spatial localisation following electrolytic, kainate or colchicine induced damage to the hippocampal formation in the rat.Behavioural Brain Research7, 133–153.
52.
SutherlandR. J.WishawI. Q.RegehrJ. C. (1982). Cholinergic receptor blockade impairs spatial localisation using distal cues in the rat.Journal of Comparative and Physiological Psychology96, 563–573.
53.
SuzukiS.AugerinosG.BlackA. H. (1980). Stimulus control of spatial behaviour on the 8-arm maze in rats.Learning and Motivation11, 1–18.
54.
WebsterD. B.VoneidaT. J. (1964). Learning deficits following hippocampal lesions in split-brain cats.Experimental Neurology10, 170–182.
55.
WyssJ. M. (1981). Autoradiographic study of the efferent connections of entorhinal cortex in the rat.Journal of Comparative Neurology199, 495–512.
56.
ZillesK. (1985). The cortex of the ratBerlin: Springer-Verlag.
57.
Zola-MorganS.SquireL. R. (1986). Memory impairment in monkeys following lesions limited to the hippocampus.Behavioural Neuroscience100, 155–160.
