Mapreduce is Good Enough? If All You Have is a Hammer,Throw Away Everything That's Not a Nail!

Abstract

Hadoop is currently the large-scale data analysis “hammer” of choice, but there exist classes of algorithms that aren't “nails” in the sense that they are not particularly amenable to the MapReduce programming model. To address this, researchers have proposed MapReduce extensions or alternative programming models in which these algorithms can be elegantly expressed. This article espouses a very different position: that MapReduce is “good enough,” and that instead of trying to invent screwdrivers, we should simply get rid of everything that's not a nail. To be more specific, much discussion in the literature surrounds the fact that iterative algorithms are a poor fit for MapReduce. The simple solution is to find alternative, noniterative algorithms that solve the same problem. This article captures my personal experiences as an academic researcher as well as a software engineer in a “real-world” production analytics environment. From this combined perspective, I reflect on the current state and future of “big data” research.