Abstract
In this article I examine the role that the concept of human nature plays within the conservative philosophy of Roger Scruton. I argue that it is of fundamental importance for his approach to conservatism, as well as showing the influence on his views of Hegel and Wittgenstein. However, such an approach can cause many problems for the conservative, and I argue that Scruton's use of a theory of human nature to justify particular social arrangements makes his approach resemble the methods of e.g socialism and liberalism, precisely those theories he wishes to attack for being based on abstract theories of human nature.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
Casey
J.
(1991 ) Pagan Virtue , Oxford : Clarendon Press .
2.
Hegel
G.W.F.
(1977 ) Phenomenology of Spirit , trans.
Miller
A.V.
, New York : Oxford University Press .
3.
Hegel
G.W.F.
(1991 ) Elements of the Philosophy of Right , trans.
Nisbet
H.B.
, ed.
Wood
A.W.
, Cambridge : Cambridge University Press .
4.
Kant
I.
(1991 ) Political Writings , Second Ed. , trans.
Nisbet
H.B.
, ed.
Reiss
H.
, Cambridge : Cambridge University Press .
5.
Plant
R.
(1973 ) Hegel , London : Allen and Unwin .
6.
Plant
R.
(1991 ) Modern Political Thought , Oxford : Blackwell .
7.
Quinton
A.
(1978 ) The Politics of Imperfection , London : Faber and Faber .
8.
Scruton
R.
(1975 ) ‘Reason and Happiness’ , in Nature and Conduct ,
Peters
R.S.
(ed.), London : Macmillan .
9.
Scruton
R.
(1978 ) ‘The Politics of Culture’ , in Conservative Essays ,
Cowling
M.
(ed.), London : Cassell .
10.
Scruton
R.
(1979 ) ‘The Significance of Common Culture’ , Philosophy , Vol. 54 .
11.
Scruton
R.
(1982 ) A Dictionary of Political Thought , London : Macmillan .
12.
Scruton
R.
(1983 ) Kant , Oxford : Oxford University Press .
13.
Scruton
R.
(1984a ) A Short History of Modern Philosophy , London : Ark Paperbacks .
14.
Scruton
R.
(1984b ) The Meaning of Conservatism , Second Ed. , London : Macmillan .
15.
Scruton
R.
(1986 ) Sexual Desire , London : Weidenfeld and Nicolson .
16.
Scruton
R.
(1987 ) A Land Held Hostage , London : The Claridge Press .
17.
Scruton
R.
(1990 ) The Philosopher on Dover Beach , Manchester : Carcanet .
18.
Scruton
R.
(1991 ) Conservative Texts , Basingstoke : Macmillan .
19.
Scruton
R.
(1994 ) Modern Philosophy London : Sinclair-Stevenson .
20.
Smith
S.B.
(1989 ) Hegel's Critique of Liberalism , Chicago : University of Chicago Press , 1989.
21.
Wittgenstein
L.
(1967 ) Philosophical Investigations Third Ed. , trans.
Anscombe
G.E.M.
, Oxford : Blackwell .
22.
Wittgenstein
L.
(1974 ) On Certainty , trans.
Paul
D.
Anscombe
G.E.M.
, Oxford : Blackwell .