The Similarity of Brain Activity Associated with True and False Recognition Memory Depends On Test Format

Abstract

Event-related potentials (ERPs) were compared for correct recognitions of previously presented words and false recognitions of associatively related, nonpresented words (lures) When the test items were presented blocked by test type (old, new, lure), waveforms for old and lure items were different, especially at frontal and left parietal electrode sites, consistent with previous positron emission tomography (PET) data (Schacter, Reiman, et al, 1996) When the test format randomly intermixed the types of items, waveforms for old and lure items were more similar We suggest that test format affects the type of processing subjects engage in, consistent with expectations from the source-monitoring framework (Johnson, Hashtroudi, & Lindsay, 1993) These results also indicate that brain activity as assessed by neuroimaging designs requiring blocked presentation of trials (e.g., PET) do not necessarily reflect the brain activity that occurs in cognitive-behavioral paradigms, in which types of test trials are typically intermixed

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Baddeley

A.D.

Wilson

(1986). Amnesia, autobiographical memory and confabulation. In Rubin

, (Ed.), Autobiographical memory, (pp. 225–252), New York, Cambridge University Press.

Belli

Loftus

(1994). Recovered memories of childhood abuse: A source monitoring perspective. In Lynn

S.J.

Rhue

J.W.

, (Eds.), Dissociation Clinical and theoretical perspectives, (pp. 415–433), New York, Guilford Press.

Buckner

R.L.

Tulving

(1995). Neuroimaging studies of memory: Theory and recent PET results. In Boller

Grafman

, (Eds.), Handbook of neuropsychology, (Vol. 10, pp. 439–466), New York, Elsevier.

Deese

(1959). On the prediction of occurrence of particular verbal intrusions in immediate recall. Journal of Experimental Psychology, 58, 17–22.

Dodson

C.S.

Johnson

M.K.

(1993). Rate of false source attributions depends on how questions are asked American Journal of Psychology, 106, 541–557.

Dywan

Segalowitz

S.J.

(1996). Source memory and aging ERP evidence for changes in attentional control, Manuscript submitted for publication.

Gardiner

J.M.

Java

R.I.

(1993). Recognizing and remembering: In Collins

A.E.

Gathercole

S.E.

Conway

M.A.

Morns

P.E.M.

, (Eds.), Theories of memory (pp. 163–188), Hillsdale, NJ Erlbaum.

Jasper

H.A.

(1958). The ten-twenty system of the international federation: Electroencephalography and Clinical Neurophysiology, 10, 371–375.

Johnson

M.K.

(1985). The origin of memories. In Kendall

P.C.

, (Ed.), Advances in cognitive behavioral research and therapy (pp. 1–27), New York, Academic Press.

10.

Johnson

M.K.

(1988). Discriminating the origin of information. In Oltmanns

T.F.

Maher

B.A.

, (Eds.), Delusional beliefs (pp. 34–65), New York, Wiley.

11.

Johnson

M.K.

(1991). Reality monitoring Evidence from confabulation in organic brain disease patients. In Prigatano

G.P.

Schacter

D.L.

, (Eds.), Awareness of deficit after brain injury Clinical and theoretical issues (pp. 176–197), New York, Oxford University Press.

12.

Johnson

M.K.

(1997). Identifying the origin of mental experience. In Myslobodsky

M.S.

, (Ed.), The Mythomanias, The nature of deception and self deception (pp. 133–180), Mahwah, NJ Erlbaum.

13.

Johnson

M.K.

Hashtroudi

Lindsay

D.S.

(1993). Source monitoring Psychological Bulletin, 114(1), 3–28.

14.

Johnson

M.K.

Kounios

Nolde

S.F.

(1996). Electrophysiological brain activity and memory source monitoring. NeuroReport, 7, 2929–2932.

15.

Johnson

M.K.

Raye

C.L.

(1981). Reality monitoring Psychological Review, 88, 67–85.

16.

Keselman

H.J.

Rogan

J.C.

(1980). Repealed measures F tests and psychophysiological research. Controlling the number of false positives Psychophysiology, 17, 499–503.

17.

Lindsay

D.S.

Johnson

M.K.

(1989). The eyewitness suggestibility effect and memory for source. Memory & Cognition, 17, 349–358.

18.

Lindsay

D.S.

Read

J.D.

(1994). Psychotherapy and memories for childhood sexual abuse: A cognitive perspective Journal of Experimental Child Psychology, 52, 297–318.

19.

Mather

Henkel

L.A.

Johnson

M.K.

(in press). Evaluating characteristics of false memories. Remember/know judgments and memory characteristics questionnaire compared. Memory & Cognition..

20.

McCarthy

Wood

C.C.

(1985). Scalp distributions of event-related potentials: An ambiguity associated with analysis of variance models. Electroencephalography and Clinical Neurophysiology, 62, 203–208.

21.

Milner

Petrides

Smith

M.L.

(1985). Frontal lobes and the temporal organization of memory. Human Neurobiology, 4, 137–142.

22.

Moscovitch

(1995). Confabulation. In Schacter

D.L.

Coyle

J.T.

Mesulam

G.D. Fischbach M.M.

Sullivan

L.E.

, (Eds.), Memory distortion. How minds brains and societies reconstruct the past (pp. 226–251), Cambridge, MA Harvard University Press.

23.

Multhaup

K.S.

(1995). Aging source and decision criteria. When false fame errors do and do not occur Psychology and Aging, 10, 492–497.

24.

Norman

K.A.

Schacter

D.L.

(in press). False recognition in younger and older adults. Exploring the characteristics of illusory memories. Memory & Cognition..

25.

Raye

C.L.

Johnson

M.K.

Taylor

T.H.

(1980). Is there something special about memory for internally generated information?Memory and Cognition, 8, 141–148.

26.

Roediger

H.L.

III , (1996). Memory illusions Journal of Memory and Language, 35, 76–100.

27.

Roediger

H.L.

III McDermott

K.B.

(1995). Creating false memories Remembering words not presented in lists. Journal of Experimental Psychology Learning, Memory, and Cognition, 21, 803–814.

28.

Schacter

D.L.

(1995). Memory distortion. History and current status. In Schacter

D.L.

Coyle

J.T.

Fischbach

G.D.

Mesulam

M.-M.

Sullivan

L.E.

, (Eds.), Memory distortion. How minds, brains and societies reconstruct the past (pp. 1–43), Cambridge, MA Harvard University Press.

29.

Schacter

D.L.

Curran

Galluccio

Milberg

W.P.

Bales

J.F.

(1996). False recognition and the right frontal lobe: A case study, Neuropsychologia, 34, 793–808.

30.

Schacter

D.L.

Harbluk

J. L.

McLachlan

D.R.

(1984). Retrieval without recollection. An experimental analysis of source amnesia, Journal of Verbal Learning and Verbal Behavior, 23, 593–611.

31.

Schacter

D.L.

Retman

Curran

Yun

L.S.

Bandy

McDermott

K.B.

Roediger

H.L.

III , (1996). Neuroanatomical correlates of veridical and illusory recognition memory. Evidence from positron emission tomography. Neuron, 17, 267–274.

32.

Stuss

D.T.

Alexander

M.P.

Lieberman

Levine

(1978). An extraordinary form of confabulation. Neurology, 28, 1166–1172.

33.

Wilding

E.L.

Rugg

M.D.

(1996). An event related potential study of recognition memory with and without retrieval of source. Brain, 119, 889–905.

34.

Zaragoza

M.S.

Lane

S.M.

(1994). Source misattributions and the suggestibility of eyewitness memory. Journal of Experimental Psychology, Learning, Memory, and Cognition, 20, 934–945.