While current feminists are calling for a theoretical psychology of women, the present paper suggests that its foundation can be found in the writings of certain nineteenth-century women. Their conclusions, drawn from a different era and assuming contrasting social science paradigms, parallel and anticipate modern discoveries. This paper examines the work of Kate Sanborn (1839–1917), who edited an anthology of women's humor and crusaded for 20 years to alter the stereotype of women's humorlessness. It is suggested that her work adds to our knowledge of feminist history, as well as presaging current theoretical developments in the psychology of women.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
BergerP. L.LuckmannT. (1966). The social construction of reality.New York: Doubleday/Anchor
2.
BlairW. (1942). Horse sense in American humor.Chicago: University of Chicago Press
3.
BruèreM.BeardM. (Eds.). (1934). Laughing their way: Women's humor in America.New York: Macmillan
4.
CollierD.BeckettK. (1980). Spare ribs: Women in the humor biz.New York: St. Martin's
5.
CurryJ. A. (1976). Women as subjects and writers of nineteenth-century American humor.Dissertation Abstracts International, 36, 6681A. (University Microfilms No. 76–9379)
6.
CurryJ. A. (Ed.). (1983). Samantha rastles the woman question.Urbana, IL: University of Illinois Press
7.
DaskamJ. (1904). The memoirs of a baby.New York: Harper's
8.
DouglasA. (1977). The feminization of American culture.New York: Knopf
9.
DresnerZ. Z. (1982). Twentieth century American women humorists.Dissertation Abstracts International, 43, 1970A. (University Microfilms No. 82–26451)
10.
EliotG. (1967). Daniel Deronda.New York: Penguin. (Original work published 1876)
11.
FrankfortR. (1977). Collegiate women: Domesticity and career in turn-of-the-century women.New York: New York University Press
12.
GilderJ. (1912, May). Women writers as humorists. Woman's Home Companion, p. 22
13.
GilliganC. (1982). In a different voice.Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press
14.
GrochA. (1974). Generality of response to humor and wit in cartoons, jokes, stories, and photographs.Psychological Reports, 35, 835–838
15.
GutmannD. (1970). Female ego styles, and generational conflict. In BardwickJ. M.DouvanE.HornerM. S.GutmannD., Feminine personality and conflict (pp. 77–96). Belmont, CA: Brooks/Cole
16.
HabeggerA. (1982). Gender, fantasy and realism in American literature.New York: Columbia University Press
17.
HaleB. F. (1914). What women want: An interpretation of the feminist movement.New York: Stokes
18.
HanscomE. D. (1935). Sanborn, Katherine Abbott. In MaloneD. (Ed.), Dictionary of American biography (Vol. 16, pp. 327–328). New York: Scribner's
19.
HolleyM. (1885). Sweet Cicely, or Josiah Allen as a politician.New York: Funk & Wagnalls
20.
JelinekE. C. (1980). Introduction: Women's autobiography, and the male tradition. In JelinekE. C. (Ed.), Women's autobiography (pp. 1–20). Bloomington, IN: Indiana University Press
21.
JohnsonB. (1902). The new humor, Critic, 40, 331–338
22.
KaufmanG.BlakelyM. K. (Eds.). (1980). Pulling our own strings.Bloomington, IN: Indiana University Press
23.
The Lounger. (1884). Critic, 4, 138
24.
The Lounger. (1905). Critic, 46, 6
25.
LukensH. C. (1890, April). American literary comedians. Harper's, pp. 783–797
26.
MauriceA. (1910, January). Feminine humorists. Good Housekeeping, pp. 34–39
27.
McGheeP. E. (1979). The role of laughter, and humor in growing up female. In KoppC. B. (Ed.), Becoming female (pp. 183–206). New York: Plenum
28.
McGheeP. E.GoldsteinJ. H. (Eds.). (1983). Handbook of humor research (Vols. 1–2). New York: Springer-Verlag
29.
MillerJ. B. (1976). Toward a new psychology of women.Boston: Beacon Press
30.
MorrisL. A. F. (1979). Women vernacular humorists in nineteenth-century America: Ann Stephens, Frances Whitcher, and Marietta Holley.Dissertation Abstracts International, 40, 258A. (University Microfilms No. 79–14705)
31.
MottF. (1938). A history of American magazines (Vol. 3). Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press
32.
MottF. (1947). Golden multitudes: The story of best sellers in the United States.New York: Macmillan
33.
NealA. B. (1856). Introductory. In WhitcherF. M., The Widow Bedott papers (pp. ix–xix). New York: Derby
34.
NeitzM. J. (1980). Humor, hierarchy, and the changing status of women.Psychiatry, 43, 211–223
35.
RatherL. (1971). Were women funny? Some 19th century humorists.American Book Collector, 21, 5–10
36.
Review of The wit of women. (1886, January 23). Saturday Review of Literature, Science, and Art, 61, p. 126
37.
Review of Samantha at Saratoga. (1887, September 25). New York Times, p. 14
38.
RollinsA. W. (1884a). Woman's sense of humor.Critic, 4, 145–146
39.
RollinsA. W. (1884b). The humor of women.Critic, 4, 301–302
40.
SanbornE. W. (1918). Kate Sanborn.Boston: McGrath Sherrill
41.
SanbornK. (1885). The wit of women.New York: Funk & Wagnalls
42.
SanbornK. (1891). Adopting an abandoned farm.New York: Appleton
43.
SanbornK. (1894). Abandoning an adopted farm.New York: Appleton
44.
SanbornK. (1898). Are women witty? In SanbornK.My favorite lectures of long ago for friends who remember (pp. 309–338). Boston: Case, Lockwood, & Brainard
45.
SanbornK. (1900, January 27). Kate Sanborn, one of them, makes a defense. [Letter to the editor]. New York Times Saturday Review, p. 52
46.
SanbornK. (1915). Memories and anecdotes.New York: Putnam
47.
SchachtelE. G. (1959). Metamorphosis: On the development of affect, perception, attention and memory.New York: Basic Books
48.
SheppardA. (1984). There were ladies present! American women cartoonists and comic artists in the early twentieth century.Journal of American Culture, 7, 38–48
49.
SheppardA. (1985). Funny women: Social change and audience response to female comedians.Empirical Studies in the Arts, 3, 179–195
50.
StearnsB. M. (1936). Whitcher, Frances Mirium Berry. In MaloneD. (Ed.), Dictionary of American biography (Vol. 20, p. 82). New York: Scribner's
51.
StillmanD.BeattsA. (Eds.). (1976). Titters: The first collection of humor by women.New York: Collier
52.
WagnallsM. (1903, November). A glimpse of Marietta Holley. Ladies Home Journal, p. 61
53.
WalkerN. (1981). Wit, sentimentality, and the image of women in the nineteenth century.American Studies, 22, 5–22
54.
WalkerN. (1984). The tradition of women's humor in America.Huntington Beach, CA: American Studies Publishing Co
55.
WeissteinN. (1973). Introduction. In LevineE.All she needs (pp. 1–10). New York: Quadrangle
56.
WhitcherF. M. B. (1856). The Widow Bedott papers.New York: Derby
57.
WilderM. P. (Ed.). (1907). The wit and humor of America, (vols. 1–10). New York: Funk & Wagnalls
58.
WillardF. E.LivermoreM. A. (1893). Holley, Miss Marietta. In WillardF. E.LivermoreM. A. (Eds.), A woman of the century (p. 386). New York: Moulton
59.
Women among humorists. (1900, January 20). New York Times Saturday Review, p. 40
60.
ZivA. (1984). Personality and sense of humor.New York: Springer
