This article analyzes functionalist and normative assumptions about marriage, divorce, family, and gender in developmental models of family life cycle. An interdisciplinary review of the literature in family development, family sociology, and family therapy reveals how a deficit comparison model implicitly informs the discourse in the study of single-parent families, women who are alone, and the adjustment of women and children to divorce. A feminist critique of family life cycle as the prevailing conceptual model in family development and therapy is presented, and postmodern definitions that deconstruct the concept of family are discussed. Future perspectives for research on family life and form are considered in terms of new action theory that considers divorce as a mode of resistance and change for women and families.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
AhronsC. (1980). Redefining the divorced family: A conceptual framework.Social Work,25, 437–441
2.
AldousJ. (1990). Family development and the life course: Two perspectives on family change.Journal of Marriage and the Family,52, 571–583
3.
AlexanderJ. C. (1988). The new theoretical movement. In SmelserN. J. (Ed.), Handbook of sociology (pp. 77–102). Newbury Park, CA: Sage
4.
AmatoP. R. (1991). The “child of divorce” as a person prototype: Bias in the recall of information about children in divorced families.Journal of Marriage and the Family,53, 59–69
5.
AmatoP. R.BoothA. (1991). The consequences of divorce for attitudes toward divorce and gender roles.Journal of Family Issues,12, 306–322
6.
AmatoP. A.KeithB. (1991a). Parental divorce and adult well-being: A meta-analysis.Journal of Marriage and the Family,53, 43–58
7.
AmatoP. A.KeithB. (1991b). Parental divorce and child well-being: A meta-analysis.Psychological Bulletin,110, 26–46
AtwoodJ. D. (1993, Fall). The competent divorce. The Family Psychologist, 15–19
10.
Ault-RicheM. (1986). A feminist critique of five schools of family therapy. In Ault-RicheM. (Ed.), Women and family therapy (pp. 1–15). Rockville, MD: Aspen
11.
AvisT. (1985). The politics of functional family therapy: A feminist critique.Journal of Marital and Family Therapy,11, 127–138
12.
Baca ZinnM. (1990). Family, feminism and race in America.Gender and Society,4, 68–82
13.
BagarozziD.GiddingsC. (1983). Conjugal violence: A critical review of current research and clinical practices.American Journal of Family Therapy,11, 3–15
14.
BatesonG. (1978). Mind and nature.New York: Dutton
15.
BequaertL. (1976). Single women: Alone and together.Boston: Beacon Press
16.
BernardesJ. (1993). Responsibilities in studying postmodern families.Journal of Family Issues,14, 35–49
17.
BianchiS. (1991). Family disruption and economic hardship: Survey of income and program participation. U.S. Bureau of the Census, Series P-70, no. 23
18.
BogradM. (1986). A feminist examination of family systems models of violence against women in the family. In Ault-RicheM. (Ed.), Women and family therapy (pp. 34–49). Rockville, MD: Aspen
19.
BossP.ThorneB. (1989). Family sociology and family therapy: A feminist linkage. In McGoldrickM.AndersonC. M.WalshF. (Eds.), Women in families: A framework for family therapy (pp. 78–96). New York: Norton
20.
BouldS. (1993). Familial caretaking: A middle-range definition of family in the context of social policy.Journal of Family Issues,14, 133–151
21.
BreunlinD. C.SchwartzR. C.Mac Kune-KarrerB. (1992). Meta-frameworks: Transcending the models of family therapy.San Francisco: Jossey-Bass
22.
BursikK. (1991). Correlates of women's adjustment during the separation and divorce process.Journal of Divorce and Remarriage,14, 137–162
23.
CandibL. M. (1989). Point and counterpoint. Family life cycle: A feminist critique.Family Systems Medicine,7, 473–487
24.
CarterE. A.McGoldrickM. (Eds.)., (1980). The family life cycle: A framework for family therapy.New York: Gardner
25.
CarterE. A.McGoldrickM. (Eds.)., (1989). The changing family life cycle: A framework for family therapy.Boston: Allyn and Bacon
26.
CashionB. G. (1982). Female-headed families: Effects on children and clinical implications.Journal of Marital & Family Therapy,8, 77–85
27.
CattonW. R. (1988). Family “divorce heritage” and its intergenerational transmission: Toward a system-level perspective.Sociological Perspectives,31, 398–419
28.
ChealD. (1993). Unity and difference in post modern families.Journal of Family Issues,14, 5–19
29.
CollierJ.RosaldoM. Z.YanaesakoS. (1982). Is there a family? In ThorneB.YalomM. (Eds.), Rethinking the family (pp. 25–39). New York: Longman
30.
CoontzS. (1992). The way we never were: American families and the nostalgia trap.New York: Basic Books
31.
CrowleyS. L. (1993). Grandparents to the rescue.National Retired Teachers Association Bulletin,34(1), 16–17
32.
DartB. (1991, January 17). Senate given bleak view of U.S. families. Washington, DC: Cox News Service
33.
DemosJ. (1986). Past, present, and personal: The family and the life course in American history.New York: Oxford University Press
34.
DiedrickP. (1991). Gender differences in divorce adjustment.Journal of Divorce & Remarriage,14, 33–45
35.
DizardJ. E.GadlinH. (1990). The minimal family.Amherst: The University of Massachusetts Press
36.
DuncanG. J.HoffmanS. D. (1985). A reconsideration of the economic consequences of marital dissolution.Demography,22, 485–497
37.
DuncanG. J.MorganJ. N. (Eds.)., (1976). Five thousand American families: Patterns of economic progress.Ann Arbor, MI: Institute for Social Research
38.
DuvallE. M. (1957 and revised editions, 1962, 1967, 1971, 1977). Family development.Philadelphia: Lippincott
39.
ElderG. H.Jr. (1985). Life course dynamics: Trajectories and transitions, 1968–1980.Ithaca: Cornell University Press
40.
FalicovC. J. (1988). Family sociology and family therapy contributions to family development framework: A comparative analysis and thoughts on future trends. In FalicovC. J. (Ed.), Family transitions, continuity, and change over the life cycle (pp. 3–53). New York: Guilford
41.
FaludiS. (1991). Backlash, the undeclared war against women.New York: Crown
42.
FerreeM. M. (1990). Beyond separate spheres: Feminism and family research.Journal of Marriage and the Family,52, 866–884
43.
ForehandR.ThomasN.BrodyG.FauberR. (1990). Role of maternal functioning and parental skills in adolescent functioning following parental divorce.Journal of Abnormal Psychology,99, 278–283
44.
GerginM. (1990). Finished at 40: Women's development within the patriarchy.Psychology of Women Quarterly,14, 471–493
45.
GlickP. C. (1984). Marriage, divorce and living arrangements.Journal of Social Issues,5, 7–26
46.
GoldnerV. (1985). Feminism and family therapy.Family Process,24, 31–47
47.
GoldnerV. (1989). Generation and gender: Normative and covert hierarchies. In McGoldrickM.AndersonC. M.WalshF. (Eds.), Women in families: A framework for family therapy (pp. 42–60). New York: Norton
48.
GordonD.BurgeD.HammenC.AdrianC.JaenickeC.HirotoD. (1989). Observations of interaction of depressed women with their children.American Journal of Psychiatry,146, 50–55
49.
GreensteinT. N. (1990). Marital disruption and the employment of married women.Journal of Marriage and the Family,52, 657–676
50.
Hare-MustinR. (1978). A feminist approach to family therapy.Family Process,17, 181–193
51.
Hare-MustinR. (1983). Psychology: A feminist perspective on family therapy. In HaberE. (Ed.), The Women's Annual: 1982-83 (pp. 177–204). Boston: G. K. Hall
52.
Hare-MustinR. (1986). The problem of gender in family therapy.Family Process,26, 15–27
53.
HaskinsR.RicheyT.WickerF. (1987). Paying and visiting: Child support enforcement and fathering from afar. Unpublished manuscript
54.
HicksS.AndersonC. M. (1989). Women on their own. In McGoldrickM.AndersonC. M.WalshF. (Eds.), Women in families: A framework for family therapy (pp. 308–335). New York: Norton
55.
HillR. (1970). Family development in three generations.Cambridge, MA: Schenkman
56.
HillR. (1986). Life cycle stages for types of single parent families: Of family development theory.Family Relations,35, 19–29
57.
HillR.RogersR. (1964). The developmental approach. In ChristensenH. (Ed.), Handbook of marriage and the family (pp. 171–172). Chicago: Rand-McNally
58.
HinesP. M. (1989). The family life cycle of poor black families. In CarterE. A.McGoldrickM. (Eds.), The changing family life cycle: A framework for family therapy (pp. 513–544). Boston: Allyn & Bacon
59.
HoffmanL. (1989). The family life cycle and discontinuous change. In CarterE. A.McGoldrickM. (Eds.), The changing family life cycle: A framework for family therapy (pp. 91–105). Boston: Allyn & Bacon
60.
HoffmanS. D. (1977). Marital instability and the economic status of women.Demography,14, 67–76
61.
HollandD. C.EisenhartM. A. (1990). Educated in romance: Women, achievement, and college culture.Chicago: University of Chicago Press
62.
HollowayS. C.MachidaS. (1991). Child-rearing strategies of divorced mothers: Relationship to coping strategies and social support.Journal of Divorce and Remarriage,14, 179–199
63.
HughesR.GoodE. S.CandellK. (1993). A longitudinal study of the effects of social support on the psychological adjustment of divorced mothers.Journal of Divorce and Remarriage,19, 37–56
64.
HurvitzN.StrausR. A. (1991). Marriage and family therapy: A sociocognitive approach.New York: Haworth Press
65.
Imber-BlackE. (1986). Women, families and larger systems. In Ault-RicheM. (Ed.), Women and family therapy (pp. 25–33). Rockville, MD: Aspen
66.
JewellK. S. (1988). Survival of the black family: The institutional impact of U.S. social policy.New York: Praeger
67.
KeithD.WhitakerC. (1988). The presence of the past: Continuity and change in the symbolic structure of families. In FalicovC. J. (Ed.), Family transitions, continuity, and change over the life cycle (pp. 431–447). New York: Guilford
68.
KnaubP. K. (1989). The stepfamily. In TextorM. (Ed.), The divorce and divorce therapy handbook (pp. 333–367). London: Jason Aaronson
69.
LevinI. (1993). Family as mapped realities.Journal of Family Issues,14, 82–91
70.
LewinE. (1984). Lesbianism and motherhood: Implications for child custody. In DartyT.PotterS. (Eds.), Women-identified women (pp. 163–183). Palo Alto, CA: Mayfield
71.
Lindblad-GoldbergM.DukesJ. L. (1985). Social support in black, low-income, single parent families.American Journal of Orthopsychiatry,55, 42–58
72.
LoweryC. R.SettleS. A. (1985). Effects of divorce on children: Differential impact of custody and visitation patterns.Family Relations,34, 455–463
73.
MartinT. C.BumpassL. L. (1989). Recent trends in marital disruption.Demography,26, 37–51
74.
MattessichP.HillR. (1987). Life-cycle and family development. In SussmanM. B.SteinmetzS. K. (Eds.), Handbook of marriage and the family (pp. 437–469). New York: Plenum Press
75.
McGoldrickM.AndersonC. M.WalshF. (Eds.)., (1989). Women in families: A framework for family therapy.New York: Norton
76.
McGoldrickM.CarterE. A. (1989). Forming a remarried family. In CarterE. A.McGoldrickM. (Eds.), The changing family life cycle: A framework for family therapy (pp. 399–429). Boston: Allyn & Bacon
77.
McGoldrickM.PearceJ. K.GiordanoJ. (Eds.)., (1982). Ethnicity and family therapy.New York: Guilford
78.
MinuchinS.NicholsM. P. (1993). Family healing: Tales of hope and renewal from family therapy.New York: Free Press
79.
MoenP.HoweryC. B. (1988). The significance of time in the study of families under stress. In KleinD. M.AldousJ. (Eds.), Social stress and family development (pp. 131–156). New York: Guilford
80.
MooreH. L. (1988). Feminism and anthropology.Minneapolis: University of Minnesota Press
81.
MurdockG. P. (1949). Social structure.New York: Free Press
82.
National Center for Health Statistics. (1989). Incidence of divorce: 1975–1988. Washington, DC: U.S. Government Printing Office
83.
NortonA. J. (1980). The influence of divorce on traditional life-cycle measures.Journal of Marriage and the Family,42, 63–69
84.
NortonA. J. (1983). Family life cycle: 1980.Journal of Marriage and the Family,45, 267–277
85.
NortonA. J.GlickP. C. (1986). One parent families: A social and economic profile.Family Relations,35, 9–17
86.
OlsonD. H. (1988). Family types, family stress, and family satisfaction: A family development perspective. In FalicovC. J. (Ed.), Family transitions, continuity, and change over the life cycles (pp. 55–79). New York: Guilford
87.
ParsonsT. (1951). The social system.New York: Free Press
88.
ParsonsT.BalesR. F. (1955). Family socialization, and interaction process.New York: Free Press
89.
PeckJ. S.ManocherianJ. R. (1989). Divorce in the changing family life cycle. In CarterE. A.McGoldrickM. (Eds.), The changing family life cycle: A framework for family therapy (pp. 335–369). Boston: Allyn & Bacon
90.
PharesV.CompasB. E. (1992). The role of fathers in child and adolescent psychopathology: Make room for Daddy.Psychological Bulletin,111, 387–412
91.
PollackS.VaughnJ. (1987). Politics of the heart: A lesbian parenting anthology.Ithaca: Firebrand Books
92.
RiceJ. K.RiceD. G. (1986). Living through divorce: A developmental approach to divorce therapy.New York: Guilford
93.
Rodgers-RoseL. (Ed.)., (1980). The black woman.New York: Sage
94.
RothS. (1989). Psychotherapy with lesbian couples: Individual issues, female socialization and the social context. In McGoldrickM.AndersonC. M.WalshE. (Eds.), Women in families: A framework for family therapy (pp. 297–307). New York: Norton
95.
RothS.MurphyB. C. (1986). Therapeutic work with lesbian clients: A systemic therapy view. In Ault-RicheM., (Ed.), Women and family therapy (pp. 78–89). Rockville, MD: Aspen
96.
ScanzoniJ.MarsiglioW. (1993). New action theory and contemporary families.Journal of Family Issues,14, 105–132
97.
SlaterS.MencherJ. (1991). The lesbian family life cycle: A contextual approach.American Journal of Orthopsychiatry,61, 372–382
98.
SmartC. (1984). The ties that bind: Law, marriage and the reproduction of patriarchal relations.London: Routledge & Kegan Paul
99.
SmithD. E. (1993). The standard North American family: SNAF as an ideological code.Journal of Family Issues,14, 50–65
100.
SobelS. B.RussoN. F. (1981). Sex roles, equality, and mental health.Professional Psychology,12, 1–5
101.
StaceyJ. (1990). Brave new families.New York: Basic Books
102.
StaplesR. (1985). Changes in black family structures: The conflict between family ideology and structural conditions.Journal of Marriage and the Family,47, 1005–1013
103.
StevensA. (1982). Archetype: A natural history of the self.London: Routledge & Kegan Paul
104.
TaggartM. (1985). The feminist critique in epistemological perspective: Questions of context in family therapy.Journal of Marital & Family Therapy,11, 113–126
105.
TrostJ. (1993). Family from a dyadic perspective.Journal of Family Issues,14, 92–104
106.
U.S. Bureau of the Census. (1987). Current population reports, P-60, No. 157. Washington, DC: U.S. Government Printing Office
107.
VincentJ. P.HarrisG. E.PlogA. (1991). Divorce and children's adjustment: The role of interparental conflict, maternal affect and parenting. In VincentJ. P. (Ed.), Advances in family intervention, assessment and theory (pp. 47–67). London: Jessica Kingsley
108.
WallersteinJ. S.BlakesleeS. (1989). Second chances: Men, women and children a decade after divorce.New York: Ticknor & Fields
109.
WallersteinJ. S.KellyJ. B. (1980). Surviving the breakup.New York: Basic Books
110.
WaltersM.CarterE.PappP.SilversteinO. (1988). The invisible web: Gender patterns in family relationships.New York: Guilford
111.
WarrenN. J.KonancJ. T. (1989). Single parent families. In TextorM. (Ed.), The divorce and divorce therapy handbook (pp. 303–331). London: Jason Aaronson
112.
WeitzmanL. (1985). The divorce revolution: The unexpected social and economic consequences for women and children in America.New York: Free Press
113.
WhiteheadB. D. (1993, April). Dan Quayle was right.Atlantic Monthly,271(4), 47–84
114.
WijnbergM. H.HolmesT. (1992, March). Adaptation to divorce: The impact of role orientation of family life-cycle perspectives. The Journal of Contemporary Human Services, 159–167
115.
WilsonE. O. (1978). On human nature.Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press
116.
WinchR. F. (1963). The modern family.New York: Holt, Rinehart & Winston
117.
WynneL. C. (1986). The epigenesis of relational systems: A model for understanding family development.Family Process,23, 297–318
118.
ZinnM. B.EitzenD. S. (1987). Diversity in families.New York: Harper & Row
