This article explores the processes involved in the construction and contestation of community in New York City following the disaster of September 11, 2001. By employing insights from the literatures on disaster and cultural meaning making, we examine how New Yorkers created and negotiated the meanings of the cultural, symbolic, and moral problems that followed the attacks. Though this postdisaster period has come to be heralded as one that witnessed a spontaneous and uniform rise in patriotism, helping behaviors, and memorial practices, we demonstrate that New Yorkers actively contested and negotiated these terrains. We argue that the tension inherent in this contestation was rooted in uncertainty about identity, interaction, and the boundaries of community in the wake of the attacks, and that its negotiation resulted in a structure of feeling that was fraught with lingering inconsistencies. This was ultimately taken for granted and incorporated into the cultural framework of the “new normal,” marking the collapse of the acute liminality of the New York community's postdisaster experience.
References
1.
AbbottA.1992. “From Causes to Events: Notes on Narrative Positivism,” Sociological Methods and Research20(4),429–455.
2.
AhearneJ.1995. Michel de Certeau: Interpretation and its Other. Oxford : Polity .
3.
AlthusserL.1971. Lenin and Philosophy. New York : Monthly Review Press.
4.
AminzadeR.1992. “Historical Sociology and Time,” Sociological Methods and Research20,462–467.
5.
AndersonB.1993. Imagined Communities. London : Verso .
6.
AndersonE.1990. Streetwise: Race, Class, and Change in an Urban Community. Chicago , IL : University of Chicago Press.
7.
AndersonE.2000. Code of the Street: Decency, Violence, and the Moral Life of the Inner City. New York : W.W. Norton & Company.
8.
Associated Press.2001. “White House Staffers Shifting into ‘New Normal’ Life at Work,”Houston ChronicleSeptember 19.
9.
BartonA. H.1969. Communities in Disaster. Garden City , NY : Doubleday.
10.
BeamerL.2002. Let's Roll: Ordinary People, Extraordinary Courage. Wheaton , IL : Tyndale House Publishing.
11.
BeauregardR. A.1993. Voices of Decline: The Postwar Fate of U.S. Cities. Cambridge , MA : Blackwell.
12.
BerelsonB.SteinerG. A.1964. Human Behavior: An Inventory of Scientific Findings. New York : Harcourt, Brace and World.
13.
BielS.2001. “ Introduction: On the Titanic Research and Recovery Expedition and the Production of Disasters,”in S. Biel (ed.), American Disasters, pp.1–8. New York / London : New York University Press.
14.
BonnellV. E.HuntL.1999. Beyond the Cultural Turn: New Directions in the Study of Society and Culture. Berkeley , CA : University of California Press.
15.
CBS News.2002. What We Saw: The Events of September 11th, 2001, in Words, Pictures, and Video. New York : Simon & Schuster.
16.
CurranJ.1996. “ The New Revisionism in Mass Communication Research,”in J. Curran , D. Morley , and V. Walkerdine (eds.), Cultural Studies and Communication. London : Arnold .
17.
DeutscherI.NewP. K.‐M .1961. “A Functional Analysis of Collective Behavior in a Disaster,” Sociological Quarterly2(1),21–36.
18.
DrabekT. E.1986. Human Systems Responses to Disaster: An Inventory of Sociological Findings. New York : Springer.
19.
DrabekT. E.KeyW. H.1983. Conquering Disaster: Family Recovery and Long‐Term Consequences. New York : Irvington.
20.
DubinS. C.2000. Displays of Power. New York : New York University Press.
21.
DurkheimE.1984. Division of Labor in Society, W. D. Halls (trans.). New York : Free Press.
22.
DworkinR.2002. “ The Threat to Patriotism,”in C. Calhoun , P. Price , and A. Timmer (eds.), Understanding September 11. New York : New Press.
23.
DynesR. R.BillingsD.MaggardS.1978. “ Two Views of an Award Winning Book (in Book Reviews) Review of Everything in Its Path: Destruction of Community in the Buffalo Creek Flood, by Kai T. Erikson ,”Social Forces 57(2),721–723.
24.
DynesR. R.QuarantelliE. L.1994. “Foreword,” in G. A. Kreps and S. L. Bosworth (eds.), Organizing, Role Enactment, and Disaster. Newark , DE : University of Delaware Press .
25.
EarnshawA.2003. “Easy Street Learns to Live with the ‘New Normal,’” Portland Business JournalMay 5.
26.
EntmanR. M.1993. “Framing: Toward Clarification of a Fractured Paradigm,” Journal of Communication43,51–58.
27.
EriksonK. T.1976. Everything in its Path: Destruction of Community in the Buffalo Creek Flood. New York : Simon and Schuster.
28.
EriksonK. T.1994. A New Species of Trouble. New York : W.W. Norton and Co.
29.
FiskeJ.1987. Television Culture. London : Routledge.
30.
FiskeJ.1991. Understanding Popular Culture. London : Routledge.
31.
FiskeJ.HartleyJ.1978. Reading Television. London : Methuen.
32.
ForrestT. R.1988. “ Review of Sociology of Disasters: Contributions of Sociology to Disaster Research, ed. by R. Dynes, B. De Marchi , and C. Pelanda ,”Contemporary Sociology 17(3),317–319.
33.
FoucaultM.1980. Power/Knowledge: Selected Interviews and Other Writings, 1972–1977, C. Gordon (ed.). New York : Pantheon Books.
34.
FritzC. E.1961. “ Disasters,”in R. K. Merton and R. Nisbet (eds.), Social Problems, pp.651–694. New York : Harcourt, Brace, and World.
35.
FuY.‐C .1985. “The ‘Decline of Community’ Thesis and its Critiques,” National Taiwan University Journal of Sociology17,137–154.
36.
GamsonW. A.1992. Talking Politics. New York : Cambridge University Press.
37.
GamsonW. A.CroteauD.HoynesW.SassonT.1992. “Media Images and the Social Construction of Reality,” Annual Review of Sociology18,373–393.
38.
GamsonW. A.ModiglianiA.1989. “Media Discourse and Public Opinion on Nuclear Power,” American Journal of Sociology95,1–37.
39.
GansH. J.1962. The Urban Villagers: Group and Class in the Life of Italian‐Americans. New York : Free Press.
40.
GarfinkelH.1967. Studies in Ethnomethodology. Englewood Cliffs , NJ : Prentice‐Hall.
41.
GarnhamN.1997. “ Political Economy and the Practice of Cultural Studies,”in M. Ferguson and P. Golding (eds.), Cultural Studies in Question. London : Sage.
42.
GeertzC.1973. The Interpretation of Cultures. New York : Basic Books.
43.
GertzB.2002. Breakdown: How America's Intelligence Failures Led to September 11. Washington , DC : Regnery Publishing .
44.
GillisJ. R.1994. Commemorations: The Politics of National Identity. Princeton , NJ : Princeton University Press.
45.
GitlinT.1980. The Whole World is Watching. Berkeley , CA : University of California Press.
46.
GiulianiR.2001. “ Remarks by Rudolph Giuliani Following the Attack at the World Trade Center,” City of New York HomepageSeptember 12. Available at〈http://www.ci.nyc.ny.us/message.html.
47.
GoffmanE.1974. Frame Analysis. New York : Harper & Row.
48.
GoldbergJ.2002. “ Reverse Engineering,” New York Times Book ReviewOctober 20, 9.
49.
GoldmannL.1977. Cultural Creation in Modern Society, Translated by B. Grahl (trans.). Oxford : B. Blackwell.
50.
GramsciA.1971. Selections from the Prison Notebooks of Antonio Gramsci, Q. Hoare and G. N. Smith (eds. and trans.). New York : International Publishers.
51.
GriffinL. J.1992. “Temporality, Events, and Explanation in Historical Sociology,” Sociological Methods and Research20(4),403–427.
52.
GurevitchM.LevyM. R.1985. Mass Communication Review Yearbook 5. Beverly Hills , CA : Sage.
53.
HallS.1980. “ Encoding/Decoding,”in S. Hall (ed.), Culture, Media, Language. London : Hutchinson .
54.
HallS.1982. “ The Rediscovery of ‘Ideology’: Return of the Repressed in Media Studies,”in M. Gurevitch , T. Bennett , J. Curran , and J. Woollacott (eds.), Culture, Society, and the Media. London : Methuen.
55.
HartR. P.JarvisS. E.LimE. T.2002. “The American People in Crisis: A Content Analysis,” Political Psychology23,417–437.
56.
HarveyD.1989. The Condition of Postmodernity: An Enquiry into the Origins of Cultural Change. Oxford : Blackwell.
57.
HorkheimerM.AdornoT. W. [1944]1997. The Dialectic of Enlightenment. London : Verso .
58.
HovlandC. I.1957. The Order of Presentation in Persuasion. New Haven, CT : Yale University Press.
59.
HovlandC. I.JanisI. L.KelleyH. H.1953. Communication and Persuasion: Psychological Studies of Opinion Change. New Haven , CT : Yale University Press.
60.
JacobsJ.1961. The Death and Life of Great American Cities. New York : Random House.
61.
KatzE.LazarsfeldP. F.1955. Personal Influence. Glencoe , IL : Free Press.
62.
KendraJ. M.WachtendorfT.2003. “ Reconsidering Convergence and Converger Legitimacy in Response to the World Trade Center Disaster,”in L. Clarke (ed.), Terrorism and Disaster: New Threats, New Ideas. New York : Elsevier.
63.
KlapperJ. T.1960. The Effects of Mass Communication. Glencoe , IL : Free Press.
64.
KlinenbergE.1999. “Denaturalizing Disaster: A Social Autopsy of the 1995 Chicago Heat Wave,” Theory and Society28,239–295.
65.
KlinenbergE.2002. Heat Wave: A Social Autopsy of Disaster in Chicago. Chicago , IL : University of Chicago Press.
66.
KrepsG.1984. “Sociological Inquiry and Disaster Research,” Annual Review of Sociology10,309–330.
67.
KrepsG.BosworthS. L.1994. Organizing, Role Enactment, and Disaster. Newark , DE : University of Delaware Press.
68.
LaBarreP .2003. “The New Normal,”Fast Company70,74.
69.
LangewiescheW.2002. American Ground: Unbuilding the World Trade Center. New York : North Point .
70.
LaskaS.1989. “ Book Review: Sociology of Disasters: Contributions of Sociology to Disaster Research,”Social Forces 68(1),338–339.
71.
Lawyers Committee for Human Rights.2003. Assessing the New Normal. New York : Lawyers Committee for Human Rights Press.
72.
LeeN.SchleinL.LevitasM.2002. A Nation Challenged: A Visual History of 9/11 and Its Aftermath. New York : Times Books.
73.
LinenthalE. T.2001. The Unfinished Bombing: Oklahoma City in American Memory. New York : Oxford University Press.
74.
LipsitzG.2002. “ The Possessive Investment in Whiteness,”in P. S. Rothberg (ed.), White Privilege, pp.61–84. New York : Worth Publishers.
75.
LongmanJ.2002. Among the Heroes: United Flight 93 and the Passengers and Crew Who Fought Back. New York : HarperCollins.
76.
MarcuseH.1964. One‐Dimensional Man: Studies in the Ideology of Advanced Industrialized Society. Boston , MA : Beacon Press.
77.
MarshallB. K.PicouJ. S.GillD. A.2003. “ Terrorism as Disaster: Selected Commonalities and Long‐Term Recovery for 9/11 Survivors,”in L. Clarke (ed.), Terrorism and Disaster: New Threats, New Ideas. New York : Elsevier.
78.
MasseyD. S.DentonN. A.1998. American Apartheid. Cambridge , MA : Harvard University Press.
79.
MaynardD. W.1996. “On ‘Realization’ in Everyday Life: The Forecasting of Bad News as a Social Relation,” American Sociological Review61,109–131.
80.
McFaddenR. D.2001. “In a Stadium of Heroes, Prayers for the Fallen and Solace for Those Left Behind,” New York TimesSeptember 24,B7.
81.
Merton, R. K. , and Nisbet, R. A. (eds.).1961. Contemporary Social Problems: An Introduction to the Sociology of Deviant Behavior and Social Disorganization. New York : Harcourt, Brace and World.
82.
MillerJ.StoneM.2002. The Cell: Inside the 9/11 Plot, And Why the FBI and CIA Failed to Stop It. New York : Hyperion.
83.
MillsC. W.1956. The Power Elite. New York : Oxford University Press.
84.
MurphyD. E.HalbfingerD. M.2002. “9/11 Bridged the Racial Divide, New Yorkers Say, Gingerly,” New York TimesJune 16,25A.
85.
NoahT.2002. “ Lay off Langewiesche,” SlateOctober 17. Available at〈http://slate.msn.com/?id=2072721.
86.
OrrJ.1999. “Panic Diaries: Cybernetics, Psychiatry, and the Technoscientific Control of Disease,”Ph.D. dissertation, University of California at Berkeley . Berkeley , CA .
87.
OrtnerS.1984. “Theory in Anthropology Since the Sixties,” Comparative Studies in Society and History26,126–166.
88.
PowersR.1991. Far from Home: Life and Loss in Two American Towns. New York : Random House.
89.
PutnamR. D.2000. Bowling Alone: The Collapse and Revival of American Community. New York : Simon & Schuster.
90.
PutnamR. D.2002. “Bowling Together,” American Prospect13(3),20–22.
91.
QuarantelliE. L.DynesR. R.1977. “Response to Social Crisis and Disaster,” Annual Review of Sociology3,23–49.
92.
RichardsonH. J.1993. “The Gulf Crisis and African‐American Interests Under International Law,” American Journal of International Law87,42–82.
93.
RiederJ.1985. Canarsie: The Jews and Italians of Brooklyn Against Liberalism. Cambridge , MA : Harvard University Press.
94.
SahlinsM.1985. Islands of History. Chicago , IL : University of Chicago Press.
95.
SchildkrautD. J.2002. “The More Things Change … American Identity and Mass and Elite Responses to 9/11,” Political Psychology23,511–535.
96.
SchubertJ. N.StewartP. A.CurranM. A.2002. “A Defining Presidential Moment: 9/11 and the Rally Effect,” Political Psychology23,559–583.
97.
SchutzA.1967. The Phenomenology of the Social World, G. Walsh and F. Lehnert (trans.). Evanston , IL : Northwestern University Press.
98.
ScottJ. C.1990. Domination and the Arts of Resistance. New Haven , CT : Yale University Press.
99.
ScottJ. C.1999. Seeing Like a State. New Haven , CT : Yale University Press.
100.
SennettR.1998. Corrosion of Character. New York : Norton .
101.
SennettR.CobbJ.1972. The Hidden Injuries of Class. New York : Vintage .
102.
SewellW. H .1996. “Political Events as Structural Transformations: Inventing Revolution at the Bastille,” Theory and Society25,841–881.
103.
SewellW. H.1999. “ The Concept(s) of Culture,”in V. E. Bonnell and L. Hunt (eds.), Beyond the Cultural Turn: New Directions in the Study of Society and Culture, pp.35–61. Berkeley , CA : University of California Press.
104.
SherifM.HovlandC. I.1961. Social Judgment: Assimilation and Contrast Effects in Communication and Attitude Change. New Haven , CT : Yale University Press.
105.
SidaniusJ.FeshbachS.LevinS.PrattoF.1997. “The Interface Between Ethnic and National Attachment: Ethnic Pluralism or Ethnic DominancePublic Opinion Quarterly61,102–133.
106.
SimmelG. [1903]1971. On Individuality and Social Forms: Selected Writings. Chicago , IL : University of Chicago Press.
107.
SimmelG. [1903]1995. “ The Metropolis and Mental Life,” P. Kasinitz (ed.), Metropolis: Center and Symbol of Our Times. New York : New York University Press.
108.
SnowD.BenfordR. D.1988. “ Ideology, Frame Resonance, and Participant Mobilization,”in B. Klandermans, H. Kriesi , and S. Tarrow (eds.), International Social Movements: From Structure to Action: Comparing Social Movement Research Across Cultures. Greenwich , CT : JAI.
109.
SnowD.RochfordE. B.WardenS. K.BenfordR. D.1986. “Frame Alignment Processes, Micromobilization, and Movement Participation,” American Sociological Review51,464–481.
110.
StewartJ. B.2002. Heart of a Soldier: A Story of Love, Heroism, and September 11th. New York : Simon & Schuster.
111.
SturkenM.2002. “ Memorializing Absence,”in C. Calhoun , P. Price , and A. Timmer (eds.), Understanding September 11. New York : New Press.
112.
SugrueT. J.1996. The Origins of the Urban Crisis: Race and Inequality in Postwar Detroit. Princeton , NJ : Princeton University Press.
113.
ThabitW.2003. How East New York Became a Ghetto. New York : NYU Press.
114.
TierneyK. J.2002. “ Strength of a City: A Disaster Research Perspective on the World Trade Center Attack,” Social Science Research Council Website. Available at <http://www.ssrc.org/sept11/essays/sturken_text_only.htm.
115.
WacquantL.1998. “‘A Black City Within the White’: Revisiting America's Dark Ghetto,” Black Renaissance—Renaissance Noire2(1),141–151.
116.
Wagner‐PacificiR .1987. The Moro Morality Play: Terrorism as Social Drama. Chicago , IL : University of Chicago Press.
117.
Wagner‐PacificiR.2000. Theorizing the Standoff: Contingency in Action. Cambridge : Cambridge University Press.
118.
WallaceA. F. C .1956a. Human Behavior in Extreme Situations: A Survey of the Literature and Suggestions for Further Research. Washington , DC : Committee on Disaster Studies, National Academy of Sciences—National Research Council .
119.
WallaceA. F. C .1956b. Tornado in Worcester: An Exploratory Study of Individual and Community Behavior in an Extreme Situation. Washington , DC : Committee on Disaster Studies, National Academy of Sciences—National Research Council.
120.
WeberM.1949. Max Weber on the Methodology of the Social Sciences. Glencoe , IL : Free Press.
121.
WeickK. E.1993. “The Collapse of Sensemaking in Organizations: The Mann Gulch Disaster,” Administrative Science Quarterly38(4),628–652.
122.
WellmanB.1979. “The Community Question: The Intimate Networks of East Yorkers,” American Journal of Sociology84,1201–1231.
123.
WellmanB.LeightonB.1979. “Networks, Neighborhoods, and Communities: Approaches to the Study of the Community Question,” Urban Affairs Quarterly14,363–390.
124.
WellmanB.WetherellC.1996. “Social Network Analysis of Historical Communities: Some Questions from the Present for the Past,” History of the Family1,97–121.
125.
WilliamsR.1963. Culture and Society 1780–1950. London : Penguin.
126.
WilliamsR.1977. Marxism and Literature. Oxford : Oxford University Press.
127.
WilsonW. J.1980. The Declining Significance of Race: Blacks and Changing American Institutions. Chicago , IL : University of Chicago Press.
128.
WilsonW. J.1987. The Truly Disadvantaged: The Inner City, The Underclass, and Public Policy. Chicago , IL : University of Chicago Press.
