The author examined whether nurses in an acute care setting use nursing diagnoses and correctly construct nursing diagnostic statements. Using a retrospective chart audit of a 237–bed acute care hospital, the author examined 150 diagnostic statements written by registered nurses. The Ziegler Criteria for Evaluating the Quality of the Nursing Process (ZCEQNP) was used to measure the components of the nursing diagnostic statements. The ZCEQNP is composed of 12 specific criteria that judge a diagnosis in general, and the response and etiology components individually. The findings revealed that only 4 of 150 diagnostic statements met all 12 criteria. The etiology component of the diagnostic statements was the least accurate: Only 16 out of 150 diagnostic statements met all of the etiology criteria. The findings indicate that nurses do not accurately compose nursing diagnostic statements. Implications and strategies for improvement are suggested.
BowmanS.McClendonP. (1994). Consistentcy of use of nursing diagnosis by staff nurses. In Carroll-JohnsonR.PaquetteM. (Eds.), Classification of nursing diagnoses: Proceedings of the tenth conference (pp. 393). Philadelphia: Lippincott.
4.
BriggsL. (1985). Nursing diagnoses generated from assessment data in a medical or nursing data baseUnpublished masters thesis, Texas Womans University, Denton, TX.
5.
CholowkiK.ChanL. (1992). Diagnostic reasoning among second year nursing students. Journal of Advanced Nursing, 17, 1171–1180.
6.
ColerM. (1993) An axial represetnation of community health nursing diagnoses of a country at war El Salvador. Nursing Diagnosis4, 63–69.
7.
DracupK. (1983). Nursing diagnosis: A rose by any other name. Heart and Lung, 12, 221.
8.
EtheridgeS.BosS.BosN. (1992). Staff nurse identification of nursing diagnosis from a written case study. Nursing Diagnosis, 3, 30–35.
9.
GebbieK. (1984). Nursing diagnosis: What is it and why does it existTopics in Clinical Nursing, 5, 1–9.
10.
GordonM. (1976). Nursing diagnoses and the diagnostic process. American Journal of Nursing, 76, 1298–1300.
11.
HamiltonL.CreasonN. (1992) Mental status and functional abilities: Change in institutionaled elderly women. Nursing Diagnosis3, 81–86.
12.
HermanJ. (1986). Nursing assessment and nursing diagnosis in patients with peripheral vascular disease. Nursing Clinics of North America, 21, 219–231.
13.
KimM.LarsonJ. (1987). Ineffective airway clearance and ineffective breathing patterns: Theoretical and research base for nursing diagnosis. Nursing Clinics of North America, 22, 125–134.
14.
LancourJ. (1991). Nursing diagnosis and the effectiveness initiative. Nursing Diagnosis, 2, 33–35.
15.
LashA. (1978). A re-examination of nursing diagnosis. Nursing Forum, 17, 332–343.
16.
LeeH.StrongK. (1985). Using nursing diagnosis to describe the clinical competence of baccalaureate and associate degree graduating students: A comparative study. Image, 17, 82–85.
17.
LeMoneP. (1993) Validation of the defining characteristics of alterd sexuality patterns. Nursing Diagnosis4, 56–62.
18.
LessowC. (1987) Nursing diangosis: Incidence and presieved value by nurses. In McLaneA. (Ed.), Classification of nursing diagnosis: Proceedings of the seventh conference (pp. 414–418). St Louis, MO: Mosby.
19.
LevinR.KrainovichB. (1987). A comparison of assessment and diagnostic competencies of B.S. and A.D. nurses.. In McLaneA. (Ed.), Classification of nursing diagnoses: Proceedings of the seventh conference (pp. 447–452). St. Louis, MO: Mosby.
LunneyM. (1992). Development of written case studies as simulations of diagnosis in nursing. Nursing Diagnosis, 3, 23–29.
22.
LunneyM. (1994). Measurement of accuracy of nursing diagnosis. In Carroll-JohnsonR.PaquetteM. (Eds.), Classification of nursing diagnosis: Proceedings of the tenth conference (pp. 281–282). Philadelphia: Lippincott.
23.
LunneyM.KrentzM. (1994). An instrument to measure attitudes towards nursing diagnosis. In Carroll-JohnsonR.PaquetteM. (Eds.), Classification of nursing diagnosis: Proceedings of the tenth conference. (pp. 389–390). Philadelphia: Lippincott.
24.
LutjensL. (1993). The nature and use of nursing diagnosis in hospitals, Nursing Diagnosis, 4, 107–113.
25.
MaasM.HardyM.CraftM. (1990). Some methodological considerations in nursing diagnosis research. Nursing Diagnosis, 1, 24–30.
26.
McKeighanR.MehmertP.DickelC. (1987). Nursing diagnosis: Assessment of use in acute-care settings in Iowa. In McLaneA. (Ed.), Classification of nursing diagnoses: Proceedings of the seventh conference (pp. 399–404). St Louis, MO: Mosby.
27.
MintonJ.CreasonN. (1991) Evaluation of admission nursing diagnosis. Nursing Diagnosis2, 119–125.
28.
MyersJ.PerryA.WesslerR.BeckerA.ReslerM.SpiesM.MethenyN. (1966). Staff nurses identification of nursing diagnoses from a simulated patient situation. In HurleyM. (Ed.), Classification of nursing diagnoses: Proceedings of the sixth conference (pp. 475–483). St Louis, MO Mosby.
29.
PriceM. (1980). Nursing diagnosis: Making a concept come alive. American Journal of Nursing, 80, 668–671.
30.
ShamanskyS.YanniC. (1963). In opposition to nursing diagnosis: A minority opinion. Image, 15, 47–50.
31.
SpiesM.MyersJ.PinnelN. (1989). The effects of a classroom learning experience on nurses ability to formulate nursing diagnosis. In Carroll-JohnsonR. (Ed.), Classification of nursing diagnosis: Proceedings of the eighth conference (pp. 241–245). Philadelphia: Lippincott.
32.
SummersS. (1992). Hypothermia: One diagnosis or threeNursing Diagnosis, 3, 2–11.
33.
TannerC.PadrickK.WestfallU.PutzierD. (1987). Diagnostic reasoning strategies of nurses and nursing students. Nursing Research, 36, 358–363.
34.
TophamD. (1983). Nursing and medical diagnosis: A comparisonUnpublished masters thesis, Texas Womans University, Denton, TX.
35.
WardC. (1987). Proportion of specific agreement as a measure of inter-rater reliability in the diagnostic process. In McLaneA. (Ed.), Classification of nursing diagnoses: Proceedings of the seventh conference (pp. 169–173). St. Louis, MO Mosby.
36.
ZieglerS. (1984). Nursing diagnosis–The state of the art as reflected in graduate students work. In KimM.McFarlandG.McLaneA. (Eds.), Classification of nursing diagnoses: Proceedings of the fifth national conference (pp. 199–208). St Louis: Mosby.
