It has frequently been suggested that the academic achievement of minority students may be hindered by low self-esteem in a white-dominated society. Some researchers and theorists, however, have questioned such assumptions. The self-esteem-academic achievement issue is further complicated by the relatively strong performance of children of immigrants in general, and of children of Asian immigrants in particular. A substantial literature suggests that these children face insecurities and difficulties that are inconsistent with high self-esteem. In examining data from the National Longitudinal Study of Adolescent Health, we find that Asians do show the lowest levels of reported self-esteem of the major racial/ethnic groups, but also the highest grade-point averages. Black adolescents, on the other hand, show the highest levels of reported self-esteem, but show relatively low grade-point averages. In further examination, we demonstrate that despite this apparent inconsistency between school performance and reported self-esteem, the two do have a positive relationship. Immigrant parental status, we suggest, has a complex relationship to school performance and psychological well-being that can help to explain the apparent paradox.
References
1.
Agbayani-SiewertP., and RevillaL.1995“Filipino Americans.” In Asian Americans: Contemporary Trends and Issues. Ed. MinP. G.Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage Publications. Pp. 134–168
2.
ArmorD. J.1995Forced Justice: School Desegregation and the Law.New York: Oxford University Press.
3.
BankstonC. L.III2000“Education and Asian Americans.” In Racial and Ethnic Relations in America. Ed. BankstonC. L.III. Pasadena, CA: Salem Press. Pp. 346–349
4.
BankstonC. L.III, and CaldasS. J.1998“Family Structure, Schoolmates, and the Racial Inequalities of Schools,”Journal of Marriage and the Family, 60: 715–723.
5.
BankstonC. L.III, and CaldasS. J.1996“Majority African American Schools and the Perpetuation of Social Injustice: The Influence of De Facto Segregation on Academic Achievement,”Social Forces, 75: 535–556.
6.
BankstonC. L.III, CaldasS. J., and ZhouM.1997“The Academic Achievement of Vietnamese American Students: Ethnicity as Social Capital,”Sociological Focus, 30: 1–16.
7.
BankstonC. L.III, and ZhouM.1995“Religious Participation, Ethnic Identification, and Adaptation of Vietnamese Adolescents in an Immigrant Community,”The Sociological Quarterly, 36: 523–535.
8.
BaumeisterR. F.1997“Inflated Self-Esteem Can Lead to Violence,”Learning25: 51. January/February.
9.
BerryW. D., and FeldmanS.1985Multiple Regression in Practice.Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage Publications.
10.
BlauP., and DuncanO. D.1967The American Occupational Structure.New York: John Wiley.
11.
BoatengF.1990“Combating Deculturalization of the African-American Child in the Public School System: A Multicultural Approach.” In Going to School: The African American Experience. Ed. LomoteyK.Albany, NY: State University of New York Press. Pp. 73–84
12.
BorjasG. J.1999Heaven's Door: Immigration Policy and the American Economy.Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press.
13.
BrooksR. L.1992Rethinking the American Race Problem.Berkeley, CA: University of California Press.
14.
ClarkE. E., and RamsayW.1990“The Importance of Family and Network of Other Relationships in Children's Success in School,”International Journal of Sociology of the Family, 20: 237–254.
15.
CloggC. C., PetrovkaE., and HaritouA.1995“Statistical Methods for Comparing Regression Coefficients Between Models,”American Journal of Sociology, 100: 1261–1293.
16.
Committee on the Health and Adjustment of Immigrant Children1998From Generation to Generation: The Health and Weil-Being of Children in Immigrant Families. Ed. HernandezD. J., and CharneyE.Washington, DC: National Academy Press.
17.
ColemanJ. S.1990Foundations of Social Theory.Cambridge, MA: The Belknap Press of Harvard University Press.
18.
EriksonE. H.1968Identity: Youth and Crisis.New York: W. W. Norton.
19.
EriksonE. H.1950Childhood and Society.New York: W. W. Norton.
20.
Fernandez-KellyM. P.1995“Social and Cultural Capital in the Urban Ghetto: Implications for the Economic Sociology of Immigration.” In The Economic Sociology of Immigration. Ed. PortesA.New York: Russell Sage Foundation. Pp. 213–247
21.
FilozofE. M., AlbertinH. K., and JonesC. R.1998“Relationship of Adolescent Self-Esteem to Selected Academic Variables,”The Journal of School Health, 68: 68–72.
22.
FriedmanL. J.1999Identity's Architect: A Biography of Erik H. Erikson.New York: Scribner.
23.
FuligniA. J.1997“The Academic Achievement of Adolescents from Immigrant Families: The Roles of Family Background, Attitudes, and Behavior,”Child Development, 68: 351–363.
24.
FurstenbergF., and HughesM. E.1995“Social Capital and Successful Development among At-Risk Youth,”Journal of Marriage and the Family, 57: 580–592.
25.
GerardH. B.1988“School Desegregation: The Social Science Role.” In Eliminating Racism. Ed. KatzP. A., and TaylorD. A.New York: Plenum Press. Pp. 225–236
26.
HackerA.1995Two Nations: Black, White, Separate, Hostile and Unequal.Second Edition. New York: Ballantine Books.
27.
Hale-BensonJ.1990“Visions for Children: Educating Black Children in the Context of their Culture.” In Going to School: The African American Experience. Ed. LomoteyK.Albany, NY: State University of New York Press. Pp. 209–222
28.
HaoL., and Bonstead-BrunsM.1998“Parent-Child Differences in Educational Expectations and the Academic Achievement of Immigrant and Native Students,”Sociology of Education, 71: 175–198.
29.
HareB. R.1977“Racial and Socioeconomic Variations in Preadolescent Area-Specific and General Self-Esteem.” Paper presented at “Toward the Competent Parent: An Interdisciplinary Conference on Parenting,” Atlanta, Georgia. February.
30.
HarrisK. M.1998“The Health Status and Risk Behavior of Adolescents in Immigrant Families.” In Children of Immigrants: Health, Adjustment, and Public Assistance. Ed. HernandezD. J.Washington, DC: National Academy Press.
31.
HarterS., WhitesellN. R., and JunkinL.1998“Similarities and Differences in Domain-Specific and Global Self-Evaluations of Learning-Disabled, Behaviorally Disordered, and Normally Achieving Adolescents,”American Educational Research Journal, 35: 653–680.
32.
HendrieC.1998“Failing but Feeling Fine,”Teacher Magazine, 9(6): 24. March.
33.
KahneJ.1996“The Politics of Self-Esteem,”American Educational Research Journal, 33: 3–22.
34.
KaoE. M., NagataD. K., and PetersonC.1997“Explanatory Style, Family Expressiveness, and Self-Esteem among Asian American and European American College Students,”Journal of Social Psychology, 137: 435–444.
35.
KaoG.1998“Psychological Well-Being and Educational Achievement among Immigrant Youth.” In Children of Immigrants: Health, Adjustment, and Public Assistance. Ed. HernandezD. J.Albany, NY: National Academy Press.
36.
LayR., and WaksteinJ.1984“Race, Academic Achievement, and Self-Concept of Ability.” Paper presented at the Annual Forum of the Association for Institutional Research, Fort Worth, Texas. May.
LongB.1968“The Self-Concept of Negro and White School Beginners.” Paper presented at the annual meeting of the American Educational Research Association, Chicago. February.
39.
Matute-BianchiM. E.1986“Ethnic Identities and Patterns of School Success and Failure among Mexican-Descent and Japanese-American Students in a California High School: An Ethnographic Analysis,”American Journal of Education, 95: 233–255.
40.
MauW.1997“Parental Influences on the High School Students' Academic Achievement: A Comparison of Asian Immigrants, Asian Americans, and White Americans,”Psychology in the Schools, 34: 267–277.
41.
MinP. G.1995“Major Issues Relating to Asian American Experiences.” In Asian Americans: Contemporary Themes and Issues. Ed. MinP. G.Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage Publications. Pp. 38–57
42.
National Center for Education Statistics2000a The Digest of Education Statistics, 1999.Washington, DC: U.S. Department of Education, Office of Educational Research and Improvement.
43.
National Center for Education Statistics2000b The Condition of Education, 2000.Washington, DC: U.S. Department of Education, Office of Educational Research and Improvement.
44.
OgbuJ. U.1991“Immigrant and Involuntary Minorities in Comparative Perspective.” In Minority Status and Schooling: A Comparative Study of Immigrant and Involuntary Minorities. Ed. GibsonM. A., and OgbuJ. U.New York: Garland Publishing.
45.
OgbuJ. U.1989Cultural Models and Educational Strategies of Non-Dominant Peoples.New York: The City College Workshop Center.
46.
OgbuJ. U.1983“Schooling the Inner City,”Society, 21: 75–79. November/December.
47.
OsborneJ. W.1995“Academics, Self-Esteem, and Race: A Look at the Underlying Assumptions of the Disidentification Hypothesis,”Personality and Social Psychology Bulletin, 21: 449–455.
48.
PhinneyJ. S., and ChaviraV.1992“Ethnic Identity and Self-Esteem: An Exploratory Longitudinal Study,”Journal of Adolescence, 15: 271–281.
QuadagnoJ.1994The Color of Welfare: How Racism Undermined the War On Poverty.New York: Oxford University Press.
51.
RosenbergM.1979Conceiving the Self.New York: Basic Books.
52.
RosenbergM.1965Society and the Adolescent Self-Image.Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press.
53.
RumbautR. G.1998“Transformations: The Post-Immigrant Generation in an Age of Diversity.” Paper presented at the Annual Meeting of the Eastern Sociological Society, Philadelphia, PA. March.
54.
RumbautR. G.1995“The New Californians: Research Findings on the Educational Progress of Immigrant Children.” In California's Immigrant Children: Theory, Research, and Implications for Educational Policy. Ed. RumbautR. G., and CorneliusW. A.San Diego: University of California, San Diego, Center for U.S.-Mexican Studies.
55.
RumbautR. G.1994“The Crucible Within: Ethnic Identity, Self-Esteem, and Segmented Assimilation among Children of Immigrants,”International Migration Review, 28(4): 748–794.
56.
SchroederK.1996“High on Self-Esteem?”The Education Digest, 62: 74.
57.
SchumpeterJ. A.1950Capitalism, Socialism, and Democracy.New York: Harper.
58.
SimmonsR.1978“Self-Esteem and Achievement of Black and White Adolescents,”Social Problems, 26: 86–96.
59.
SingelisT. M., BondM. H., SharkeyW. R., and KrissS. Y. L.1999“Unpackaging Culture's Influence on Self-Esteem and Embarrassability: The Role of Self-Construals.”Journal of Cross-Cultural Psychology, 30: 315–341.
60.
SteeleC. M., and AronsonJ.1998“Stereotype Threat and the Test Performance of Academically Successful African Americans.” In The Black-White Test Score Gap. Ed. JencksC., and PhillipsM.Washington, DC: Brookings Institution Press. Pp. 401–427
61.
SteinbergL.1996Beyond the Classroom.New York: Simon & Schuster.
62.
Suárez-OrozcoC., and Suárez-OrozcoM. M.1995Transformations: Migration, Family Life, and Achievement Motivation among Latino Adolescents.Stanford, CA: Stanford University Press.
63.
SueS., and OkazakiS.1990“Asian American Educational Achievement: A Phenomenon in Search of an Explanation,”American Psychologist, 45: 913–920.
64.
SunY.1998“The Academic Success of East-Asian American Students: An Investment Model,”Social Science Research, 27: 432–456.
65.
VegaW. A., and RumbautR. G.1991“Ethnic Minorities and Mental Health,”Annual Review of Sociology, 17: 351–383.
66.
Weiss Bar-YosefR.1968“Desocialization and Resocialization: The Adjustment Process of Immigrants,”International Migration Review, 2(3): 27–45.
67.
WiestD. J., WongE. H., KreilD. A.1998“Predictors of Global Self-Worth and Academic Performance among Regular Education, Learning Disabled, and Continuation High School Students,”Adolescence, 33: 601–618.
68.
WilgorenJ.1999“Report Calls for New Focus on Aid for Minority Students,”The New York Times, October 17, P. 30.
69.
ZhouM.1997“Growing Up American: The Challenge Confronting Immigrant Children and Children of Immigrants,”Annual Review of Sociology, 23: 63–95.
70.
ZhouM., and BankstonC. L.III2000Straddling Two Social Worlds: The Experience of Vietnamese Refugee Children in the United States.New York: ERIC Clearinghouse on Urban Education.
71.
ZhouM., and BankstonC. L.III1998Growing Up American: How Vietnamese Children Adapt to Life in the United States.New York: Russell Sage Foundation.
72.
ZhouM., and BankstonC. L.III1994“Effects of Minority-Language Literacy on the Academic Achievement of Vietnamese Youths in New Orleans.”Sociology of Education, 68: 1–17.
