This article analyzes a Canadian immigration program that authorizes issuance of temporary work visas to ‘exotic dancers.’ In response to public criticism that the government was thereby implicated in the transnational trafficking of women into sexual exploitation, Citizenship and Immigration Canada retained the visa program de jure but eliminated it de facto. Using a legal and discursive analysis that focuses on the production of female labor migrants variously as workers, as criminals and as bearers of human rights, the article argues that the incoherence of Canadian policy can only be rendered intelligible when refracted through these different lenses. The article concludes by considering policy options available to the state in addressing the issue.
References
1.
Adult Entertainment Association of Canada1998“Portfolio of Members and Associates.” Unpublished. September.
2.
AlcivarC.2000Personal Communication. August 19.
3.
AppelbyT.1999“Toronto Police Bust Prostitution Ring,”The Globe and Mail. July 21. P. A5.
4.
AppelbyT.1998“Arrests Total 115 in Prostitution Related Raids,”The Globe and Mail. September 2.
5.
BellS., and JiminezM.2000a “Ottawa Helpless to Stop Global Sex Traffic,”The National Post. May 17.
6.
BellS., and JiminezM.2000b “Lax Immigration Rules Encourages Sex Trade,”The National Post. April 15.
7.
CaldwellG., GalsterS., and SteinzorN.1997Crime & Servitude: An Expose of the Traffic in Women for Prostitution from the Newly Independent States.Washington, DC: Global Survival Network.
8.
Canadian Adult Entertainment Association n.d. “Submission on Behalf of Exotic Dancers to the Ministry of Citizenship and Immigration and Human Resources Development Canada.” Unpublished, n.d.
9.
CarensJ.1992“Membership and Morality: Admission to Citizenship in Liberal Democratic States.” In Immigration and Politics of Citizenship in Europe and North America. Ed. BrubakerW. R.
10.
CarterV., and GiobbeE.1999“Duet: Prostitution, Racism and Feminist Discourse,”Hastings Women's Law Journal, 10: 37–68.
11.
CarusoB. J.2000“Why is There a Shortage of Dancers? Peeling Away at the Truth,”Immigration & Citizenship Bulletin, 11(10).
12.
ChaddockG. R.2000“Congress Takes Aim at Modern-Day Slavery – Traffickers in Human Cargo for Sex Trade or Sweatshops Will Face Tougher Penalties,”The Christian Science Monitor. October 18.
13.
Citizenship and Immigration Canada (CIC)2001“Temporary Foreign Worker Guidelines.” Chapter FW-2: Policy and Special Considerations. Immigration Manual. <http://www.cic.gc.ca/manuals-guides/english/FW-e/FWE02.pdf>. Accessed February 16, 2001.
14.
Citizenship and Immigration Canada (CIC)1998a “Pilot Project to Help Canadian Employers Attract Highly Skilled Temporary Workers,”News Release. September 30.
15.
Citizenship and Immigration Canada (CIC)1998b “Exotic Dancers,”Operations Memorandum, IP, IS. June 17.
16.
Citizenship and Immigration Canada (CIC)1998c “Exotic Dancers.”Operations Memorandum, IP 98, IS 98. July 15.
17.
Citizenship and Immigration Canada (CIC)1997“Exotic Dancers – VEC E99,”Operations Memorandum, OP 97–13, PE 97–09, IP 97–05. April 11.
DemleitnerN.1994“Forced Prostitution: Naming an International Offense,”Fordham International Law Journal, 18: 163.
20.
DerksA.2000“From White Slaves to Trafficking Survivors: Notes on the Trafficking Debate.” Working Paper Series, Working Paper No. 00–02m. Princeton, NJ: The Center for Migration and Development.
21.
DeVoretzD.1999“Temporary Canadian Migration: Quo Vadis?,” Third International Metropolis Conference. November 30-December 3.
22.
DoezemaJ.1999“Loose Women or Lost Women? The Re-emergence of the Myth of ‘White Slavery’ in Contemporary Discourses of ‘Trafficking in Women,’” <http://www.walnet.org/csis/papers/doezema-loose.html>. Accessed November 27.
23.
Exotic Dancers’ Alliance2000The Naked Truth: An Information Resource for the Exotic Dancers’ Community, 3: 1. April.
24.
FrischM.1986Gesammelte Werke in zeitlicher Folge. Volume 5. Surkump. 374.
25.
Globe and Mail1998“Strippers Chilled by Immigration Rules,”The Globe and Mail. July 31.
26.
GodfreyT.2000a “Canada Tries to Break the Habit – Foreign Strippers are Posing as Nuns, Officials Say,”The Toronto Sun. May 9. P. 5.
27.
GodfreyT.2000b “Brit ‘Nannies’ Turn to Stripping in T.O.,”The Toronto Sun. February 18.
28.
GodfreyT.2000c “Foreign Peelers Crucial, Say Clubs,”The Toronto Sun. May 10. P. 7.
29.
GodfreyT.2000d “Strippers Get the Boot,”The Toronto Sun. March 17.
30.
GreenhillD., and AceytunoJ.1999Managed Migration and the Seasonal Agricultural Worker Program.Washington, DC: Fourth International Metropolis Conference: Trade Agreements and Migration. December 8–11.
31.
HaugeC.1995“Prostitution of Women and International Human Rights Law: Transforming Exploitation into Equality,”New York International Law Review, 8: 23–50.
32.
HawaleshkaD.1997“Sex, Lies and Money,”Maclean's, 22: 24–26. September.
33.
International Organization for Migration1999“Irregular Migration in Canada,”Trafficking in Migrants. July 2.
34.
JacobsonD.1996Rights Across Borders.Baltimore: John Hopkins Press.
35.
JimenezM.2000“650 Charged in Canadian Sex Slave Trade,”The National Post. May 18.
36.
McDonaldL., MooreB., and TimoshkinaN.1996Migrant Sex Workers from Eastern Europe and the Former Soviet Union: The Canadian Case. Status of Women Canada. <http://www.cfc.gc.ca/pubs/062653351/index_e.html>.
37.
McLarenJ.2000“Recalculating the Wages of Sin,”Manitoba Law Journal, 23: 524–555.
38.
Note1998“The Trafficking of Women for Prostitution: A Growing Problem within the European Union,”Boston College International and Comparative Law Review, 21: 183–199.
39.
OziewiczE.2000a “Strip Club Raided, Owner Faces Prostitution-related Charges,”The Globe and Mail. February 25.
40.
OziewiczE.2000b “Canada Bare Essential,”The Globe and Mail. February 19.
41.
OziewiczE.1997“Ottawa Eyes Curb on Entry of Strippers,”The Globe and Mail. February 7. P. A1.
42.
PascoeB.2000Correspondence to Mendel Green. January 31.
43.
PickupF.1998“Deconstructing Trafficking in Women: The Example of Russia,”Millenium, 27(4): 995–1021.
44.
RazackS.1998“Race, Space and Prostitution: The Making of the Bourgeois Subject,”Canadian Journal of Women and the Law, 10: 338–376.
45.
Scott-DouglasR.1998Correspondence to Joan Atkinson, Director General, Selection Branch, Citizenship and Immigration Canada. May 29.
46.
SpectorM.1998“‘Traffickers’ New Cargo: Naïve Slavic Women,”The New York Times. January 11. P. 1.
47.
TaylorM.2000Exotic Dancers Alliance, Personal Communication. May 12.
48.
ThompsonA.1999“Promised Fresh Start Turns into Enslavement,”Toronto Star. February 20.
49.
ThompsonG.1999“Abused and Unshielded Wives,”The New York Times. April 18. P. 37.
50.
WalzerM.1983Spheres of Justice.New York: Basic Books.
51.
CASES
52.
1999 CRDD T98-06186. Bousfield and Milliner (diss.) November 2.
53.
1997 CRDD V95-02904. Nuenfeldt. November 26.
54.
1995 CRDD U94-04874. Smith and Haddad. November 7.
55.
Re Ontario Adult Entertainment Bar Association and Municipality of Metropolitan Toronto (1997), 35 O.R. (3d) 161.
56.
Silion v. Canada (Minister of Citizenship and Immigration) (1999), 173 F.T.R. 302 (T.D.).
57.
R. v. Mara [1997] 2 SCR 630.
58.
R. v. Pelletier [1999] 3 SCR 863.
59.
INTERNATIONAL LEGAL INSTRUMENTS
60.
International Agreement for the Suppression of the Slave Trade. 1904. I LNTS 83. May 18. International Convention for the Suppression of White Slave Traffic. 1910. III LNTS 278. May 4.
61.
Convention for the Suppression of the Traffic in Persons and of the Exploitation of the Prostitution of Others, opened for signature, March 21, 1950. 96 UNTS 271. International Convention on the Protection of the Rights of All Migrant Workers and Members of Their Families, G.A. Res 45/158, 55th Sess., Agenda Item 12, UN Doc. A/RES/45/158 (1991).
62.
Protocol to Prevent, Suppress and Punish Trafficking in Persons, Especially Women and Children, supplementing the United Nations Convention against Transnational Organized Crime. 2000. UNGA A/55/383, Annex II. November 2.
63.
CANADIAN LEGISLATION Criminal Code of Canada. RSC 1985, c.C-2.
64.
Immigration Act. RSC 1985, c. I-2.
65.
Immigration Regulations. SOR/78-172.
66.
Immigration and Refugee Protection Act. SC 2001, c. 27.
67.
Immigration and Refugee Protection Regulations. SOR/2002–227. June 11, 2002
68.
UNITED STATES LEGISLATION Victims of Trafficking and Violence Protection Act of 2000. H.R. 2344. 106th Congress. January 24.
