Soviet legacies and uneven economic distress make post-Soviet Russia an especially interesting case in which to assess the effects of economic performance on regional net migration rates. Random effects models of net regional migration in 77 Russian regions from 1993 to 2002 indicate that mean wages and unemployment levels have substantial and predictable effects. These effects have several dynamic aspects: changes in mean wages (but not changes in unemployment) exert effects independently of wage and unemployment levels, the effect of unemployment decreases over time, and the effect of wage levels appears to increase. Overall, the results suggest a tendency toward regional equilibrium with respect to employment following the initial shock of Soviet collapse and market reforms, but continuing disequilibrium with respect to wages.
References
1.
AndrienkoY., and GurievS.2005“Understanding Migration in Russia.” Policy note prepared for the World Bank. Moscow, Russia: Center for Economic and Financial Research.
2.
AndrienkoY., and GurievS.2004“Determinants of Interregional Mobility in Russia: Evidence From Panel Data.”Economics of Transition12: 1–27.
3.
BahlR., and WallichC. I.1995“Intergovernmental Fiscal Relations in the Russian Federation.” In Decentralization of the Socialist State: Intergovernmental Finance in Transition Economies. Ed. BirdRichard M., EbelRobert D., and WallichChristine I.Washington, DC: The World Bank. Pp. 321–379
4.
BondA.1994“Outmigration, Economic Dislocation, and Reassessment of the Labor Resource in the Russian Far North.”Post-Soviet Geography5: 299–308.
5.
BradshawM. J., and HansonP.1998“Understanding Regional Patterns of Economic Change in Russia: An Introduction.”Communist Economies and Economic Transformation10: 285–304.
6.
BrownA.1997“The Economic Determinants of Internal Migration Flows in Russia during the Transition.” Working paper series, number 89. Ann Arbor, MI: The Davidson Institute.
7.
BuckleyC.1995“The Myth of Managed Migration: Migration Control and Market in the Soviet Period.”Slavic Review54: 896–916.
8.
CaoY., and NeeV. G.2000“Comment: Controversies and Evidence in the Market Transition Debate.”American Journal of Sociology105: 1175–1188.
9.
ClarkeS.1998“Structural Adjustment without Mass Unemployment? Lessons from Russia.” In Structural Adjustment without Mass Unemployment? Lessons from Russia. Ed. ClarkeSimon. Cheltenham: Edward Elgar. Pp. 9–86
10.
ConnorW. D.2000“New World of Work: Employment, Unemployment, and Adaptation.” In Russia's Torn Safety Nets: Health and Social Welfare During the Transition. Ed. FieldMark G., and TwiggJudyth L.New York: St. Martin's Press. Pp. 191–212
11.
DaVanzoJ., and GrammichC.2001Dire Demographics: Population Trends in the Russian Federation.Santa Monica, CA: Rand Corporation.
12.
DaviesP. S., GreenwoodM. J., and LiH.2001“A Conditional Logit Approach to U.S. State-to-State Migration.”Journal of Regional Science41: 337–360.
13.
DmitrievM., and MalevaT.1997“Russian Labor Market in Transition: Trends, Specific Features, and State Policy.”Social Research64: 1499–1529.
14.
EarleJ. S., and SabirianovaK. Z.2002“How Late to Pay? Understanding Wage Arrears in Russia.”Journal of Labor Economics20: 661–707.
15.
GerberT. P.2002“Structural Change and Post-Socialist Stratification: Labor Market Transitions in Contemporary Russia.”American Sociological Review67: 629–659.
16.
GerberT. P., and HoutM.1998“More Shock Than Therapy: Market Transition, Employment, and Income in Russia, 1991–1995.”American Journal of Sociology104: 1–50.
17.
Goskomstat Rossii2002Regiony Rossii, 2002. [The Regions of Russia, 2002.] Moskva: Goskomstat. CD-ROM version.
18.
Goskomstat Rossii1998Regiony Rossii, 1998. [The Regions of Russia, 1998.] Moskva: Goskomstat.
19.
Goskomstat SSSR1990Sotsial'noe Razvitie SSSR. [The Social Development of the USSR.] Moskva: “Finansy i statistika.”
20.
GrandstaffP. J.1980Interregional Migration in the U.S.S.R.: Economic Aspects, 1959–1970.Durham, NC: Duke University Press.
21.
GreenwoodM. J.1997“Internal Migration in Developed Countries.” In Handbook of Population and Family Economics. Vol. 2. Ed. RozenzweigMark R., and StarkOded. New York: Elsevier. Pp. 648–720.
22.
GreenwoodM. J.1981Migration and Economic Growth in the United States: National, Regional, and Metropolitan Perspectives.New York: Academic Press.
23.
GreenwoodM. J.1975“Research on Internal Migration in the United States: A Survey.”Journal of Economic Literature13: 397–433.
24.
GruskyD. B., HertingJ. R., and Van RompaeyS. E.1998“Reply: The Simple Virtues of Descriptive Modeling.”American Sociological Review63: 907–913.
25.
HansonP.1995“Regions, Local Power and Economic Change in Russia.” In Challenges for Russian Economic Reform. Ed. SmithAlan. Washington, DC: The Brookings Institution. Pp. 21–78
26.
HeleniakT.1999“Out-Migration and De-Population of the Russian North during the 1990s.”Post-Soviet Geography and Economics40: 155–205.
27.
HeleniakT.1997“Internal Migration in Russia during the Economic Transition.”Post-Soviet Geography and Economics38: 81–104.
28.
HertingJ. R., GruskyD. B., and Van RompaeyS. E.1997“The Social Geography of Interstate Mobility and Persistence.”American Sociological Review62: 267–287.
29.
JuarezJ. P.2000“Analysis of Inter-regional Labor Migration in Spain Using Gross Flows.”Journal of Regional Science40: 377–399.
30.
JudgeG. G.1985The Theory and Practice of Econometrics.2nd edn.New York: John Wiley and Sons.
31.
KorelL., and KorelI.1999“Migrations and Macroeconomic Processes in Postsocialist Russia: Regional Aspect.” Unpublished working paper. Project Reference Number 98-0891. Moscow: Economic Education and Research Consortium.
32.
KornaiJ.1981The Economics of Shortage.Amsterdam: North Holland.
33.
KritzM. M., and NogleJ. M.1994“Nativity Concentration and Internal Migration among the Foreign-Born.”Demography31: 509–524.
34.
LeeL., and StruykR.1996“Residential Mobility in Moscow during the Transition.”International Journal of Urban and Regional Research20: 656–570.
35.
LinG., and XieY.1998“Comment: The Loglinear Modeling of Interstate Migration: Some Additional Considerations.”American Sociological Review63: 900–906.
36.
LiuB.1975“Differential Net Migration Rates and the Quality of Life.”Journal of Economics and Statistics57: 329–337.
37.
LongL.1992“Changing Residence: Comparative Perspectives on its Relationship to Age, Sex, and Marital Status.”Population Studies46: 141–158.
38.
MasseyD. S.1998Worlds in Motion: Understanding International Migration at the End of the Millennium.Oxford: Clarendon Press.
39.
MasseyD. S., and EspinosaK. E.1997“What's Driving Mexico-U.S. Migration? A Theoretical, Empirical, and Policy Analysis.”American Journal of Sociology102: 939–999.
40.
MauV., and StupinV.1997“The Political Economy of Russian Regionalism.”Communist Economies and Economic Transformation9: 5–25.
41.
MikheevaN.1999“Differentiation of Social and Economic Situation in the Russian Regions and Problems of Regional Policy.” Working paper 99/09. Moscow: Economic Education and Research Consortium.
42.
MitchneckB.1991“Geographic and Economic Determinants of Interregional Migration in the USSR, 1968–1985.”Soviet Geography32: 168–189.
43.
MitchneckB., and PlaneD. A.1995a “Migration Patterns During a Period of Political and Economic Shocks in the Former Soviet Union: A Case Study of Yaroslavl' Oblast.”Professional Geographer47: 17–30.
44.
MitchneckB., and PlaneD. A.1995b “Migration and the Quasi-labor Market in Russia.”International Regional Science Review18: 267–288.
45.
NeeV., and CaoY.1999“Path Dependent Societal Transformation: Stratification in Mixed Hybrid Economies.”Theory and Society28: 799–834.
46.
PlaneD. A.1989“Population Migration and Economic Restructuring in the United States.”International Regional Science Review12: 263–280.
47.
PopovV.1999“Reform Strategies and Economic Performance of Russia's Regions.”World Development29: 865–886.
48.
RitcheyP. N.1976“Explanations of Migration.”Annual Review of Sociology2: 363–404.
49.
SandefurG. D., and ScottW. J.1981“A Dynamic Analysis of Migration: An Assessment of the Effects of Age, Family and Career Variables.”Demography18: 355–368.
50.
ShawD.1999Russia in the Modern World: A New Geography.Oxford: Blackwell.
51.
SjastaadL. A.1962“The Costs and Returns of Human Migration.”Journal of Political Economy70: S80–S89.
52.
StataCorp2005Stata Release 9: Longitudinal/Panel Data.College Station, TX: Stata Press.
53.
StimsonJ. A.1985“Regression in Space and Time: A Statistical Essay.”American Journal of Political Science29: 914–947.
54.
SutherlandD., and HansonP.1996“Structural Change in the Economies of Russia's Regions.”Europe-Asia Studies48: 367–392.
55.
TiendaM., and WilsonF. D.1992“Migration and the Earnings of Hispanic Men.”American Sociological Review57: 661–678.
56.
TodaroM. P.1969“A Model of Labor Migration and Urban Unemployment in Less Developed Countries.”American Economic Review59: 138–148.
57.
TreyzG. I., RickmanD. S., HuntG. L., and GreenwoodM. J.1993“The Dynamics of U.S. Internal Migration.”Review of Economics and Statistics75: 209–214.
58.
Van SelmB.1998“Economic Performance in Russia's Regions.”Europe-Asia Studies50: 603–618.
59.
ZayonchkovskayaZ.1999“Recent Migration Trends in Russia.” In Population under Duress: The Geodemography of Post-Soviet Russia. Ed. DemkoGeorge J., IoffeGrigory, and ZayonchkovskayaZhanna. Boulder: Westview. Pp. 107–130
