Integrating Environmental Justice and the Precautionary Principle in Research and Policy Making: The Case of Ambient Air Toxics Exposures and Health Risks among Schoolchildren in Los Angeles
Available accessResearch articleFirst published online November, 2002
Integrating Environmental Justice and the Precautionary Principle in Research and Policy Making: The Case of Ambient Air Toxics Exposures and Health Risks among Schoolchildren in Los Angeles
Two policy frameworks, environmental justice and the precautionary principle, have begun to transform traditional approaches to environmental policy making and community organizing related to public health. Despite having several important overlapping policy goals, little effort has been made to purposefully integrate these two frameworks. This article discusses preliminary research on environmental inequality in ambient air toxics exposures and associated health risks among schoolchildren in the Los Angeles Unified School District. Results indicate that children of color, namely, Latinos and African Americans, bear the highest burden of estimated cancer and noncancer health risks associated with ambient air toxics exposures while they are in school. The implications of these study results for controversial policy decisions related to school siting and construction in urban districts are discussed within the context of environmental justice and the precautionary principle.
References
1.
Anderson, S.2000. The school that was-n't: Politics and pollution in LA . Nation, p. 32.
2.
Beck, Ulrich.1992. From industrial society to the risk society: Questions of survival, social structure and ecological enlightment. Theory, Culture and Society9 (1): 97-123.
3.
Bener, A., Y.M. Abdulrazzaq, P. Debuse, and A.H. Abdin.1994. Asthma and wheezing as the cause of school absence. Journal of Asthma31 (2): 93-98.
4.
Bickel, R., and C. Howley.2000. The influence of scale on school performance: A multi-level extension of the Matthew principle. Education Policy Analysis Archives8 (22). Retrieved from http://epaa.asu.edu/epaa/v8n22/ .
5.
Blume, H.2000. No vacancy: The school district's space crunch is much worse than you know. And no one has a plan that will fix it. LA Weekly, 9-15 June. Retrieved from http://www.laweekly.com/ink/00/29/features-blume.php.
6.
Boer, T.J., M. Pastor, J.L. Sadd, and L.D. Snyder.1997. Is there environmental racism? The demographics of hazardous waste in Los Angeles County. Social Science Quarterly78 (4): 793-810.
7.
Bowen, W.M., M.J. Salling, K.E. Haynes, and E.J. Cyran.1995. Toward environmentaljustice: Spatial equity in Ohio and Cleveland. Annals of the Association of American Geographers85 (4): 641-63.
8.
Brown, P., and E.J. Mikkelsen.1997. No safe place: Toxic waste, leukemia, and community action. Berkeley: University of California Press.
9.
Bullard, Robert.1983. Solid waste sites and the black community. Sociological Inquiry53:273-88.
10.
Bullard, R.D.1994. Overcoming racism in environmental decision-making. Environment36 (4): 10-44.
11.
—. 1996. Environmental justice: It's more than waste facility siting . Social Science Quarterly77 (3): 493-99.
12.
Burg, J., and G. Gist.1998. The National Exposure Registry: Analysis of health outcomes from the Benzene subregistry. Toxicology and Industrial Health14 (3): 367-87.
13.
Burke, L.M.1993. Race and environmental equity: A geographic analysis in Los Angeles. Geo-Info Systems October: 44-50.
14.
Caldwell, J.C., T.J. Woodruff, R. Morello-Frosch, and D.A. Axelrad.1998. Application of health information to hazardous air pollutants modeled in EPA's Cumulative Exposure Project. Toxicology and Industrial Health14 (3): 429-54.
15.
Calver, M.C.2000. Lessons from preventive medicine for the precautionary principle and ecosystem health. EcosystemHealth6 (2): 339-47.
16.
Clark, N.M., R.W. Brown, E. Parker, T.G. Robins, D.G. Remick, M.A. Philbert, G. Keeler, and B. Israel.1999. Childhood asthma. Environmental Health Perspectives107 (Suppl. 3): 421-29.
17.
Clean Air Act Amendments. § 112(f), Standard to Protect Health and the Environment (1990).
18.
Commission for Racial Justice, United Church of Christ.1987. Toxic wastes and race in the U.S.: A national report on the racial and socio-economic characteristics of communities with hazardous waste sites. New York: United Church of Christ.
19.
Crom, W.R.1994. Pharmacokinetics in the child. Environmental Health Perspectives102 (Suppl. 11): 111-17.
20.
Diette, G.B., L. Markson, E.A. Skinner, T.T. Nguyen, P. Algatt-Bergstrom, and A.W. Wu.2000. Nocturnal asthma in children affects school attendance, school performance, and parents' work attendance. Archives of Pediatrics and Adolescent Medicine154 (9): 923-29.
21.
Dourson, M.L., and J.F. Stara.1983. Regulatory history and experimental support of uncertainty (safety) factors. Regulatory Toxicology and Pharmacology3 (3): 224-38.
22.
Ecob, R., and G. Davey Smith.1999. Income and health: What is the nature of the relationship?Social Science & Medicine48:693-705.
23.
Foster, K.R., P. Vecchia, and M.H. Repacholi.2000. Science and the precautionary principle . Science288 (5468): 979-81.
24.
Fowler, M.G., M.G. Davenport, and R. Garg.1992. School functioning of US children with asthma. Pediatrics90 (6): 939-44.
25.
Fowler, W.J., Jr., and J.W. Herbert .1991. School size, characteristics, and outcomes. Educational Evaluation and Policy Analysis13 (2): 189-202.
26.
Gelobter, M.1992. Toward a model of environmental discrimination. In Race and the incidence of environmental hazards: A time for discourse , edited by B. Bryant and P. Mohai.Boulder, CO: Westview.
27.
Gilliland, F.D., R. McConnell, J. Peters, and H. Gong.1999. A theoretical basis for investigating ambient air pollution and children's respiratory health. Environmental Health Perspectives107 (Suppl. 3): 403-7.
28.
Ginns, S.E., and A.C. Gatrell.1996. Respiratory health effects of industrial air pollution: A study in east Lancashire, UK. Journal of Epidemiology and Community Health50 (6): 631-35.
29.
Gold, D.R., A. Rotnitzky, A.I. Damokosh, J.H. Ware, F.E. Speizer, B.G. Ferris, and D.W. Dockery.1993. Race and gender differences in respiratory illness prevalence and their relationship to environmental exposures in children 7 to 14 years of age. American Review of Respiratory Disease148:10-18.
30.
Gomzi, M., and M. Saric.1997. Respiratory impairment among children living in the vicinity of a fertilizer plant. International Archives of Occupational and Environmental Health70 (5): 314-20.
31.
Guo, Y.L., Y.C. Lin, F.C. Sung, S.L. Huang, Y.C. Ko, J.S. Lai, H.J. Su, C.K. Shaw, R.S. Lin, and D.W. Dockery.1999. Climate, traffic-related air pollutants, and asthma prevalence in middle-school children in Taiwan. Environmental Health Perspectiues107 (12): 1001-6.
32.
Guzelian, P., C. Henry, and S. Olin.1992. Similarities and differences between children and adults: Implications for risk assessment. Washington, DC: ILSI Press.
33.
Haan, M., G. Kaplan, and T. Camacho.1987. Poverty and health: Prospective evidence from the Alameda County study. American Journal of Epidemiology125:989-98.
34.
Haan, M.N.1985. Socio-economic position and health: A review. Berkeley: California State Department of Public Health.
35.
Hahn, R., E. Eaker, N. Barker, S. Teutsch, W. Sosniak, and N. Krieger.1996. Poverty and death in the United States . International Journal of Health Services26 (4): 673-90.
36.
Hernandez, J.1999. Is Belmont High School's legacy racist environmental standards? Planning Report 13(3). Available from www.ablinc.net/trp.
37.
Hersh, R.1995. Race and industrial hazards: An historical geography of the Pittsburgh region, 1900-1990. Washington, DC: Resources for the Future.
38.
Institute of Medicine.1999. Toward environmental justice: Research, education, and health policy needs . Washington, DC: Committee on Environmental Justice, Health Sciences Policy Program, Health Sciences Section, Institute of Medicine.
39.
Jedrychowski, W., and E. Flak.1998. Separate and combined effects of the outdoor and indoor air quality on chronic respiratory symptoms adjusted for allergy among preadolescent children. International Journal of Occupational Medicine and Environmental Health11 (1): 19-35.
40.
Kaplan, S., and J. Morris.2000. Kids at risk: Chemicals in the environment come under scrutiny as the number of childhood learning problems soars. U.S. News & World Report, p. 1.
41.
Kawachi, I., and M.G. Marmot.1998. Commentary: What can we learn from studies of occupational class and cardiovascular disease? American Journal of Epidemiology148 (2): 160-63.
42.
Koretz, Daniel.1998. Indicators of educational achievement. In Indicators of children's well-being, edited by R. M. Hauser, B. V. Brown, and W. R. Prosser, 208-34. New York: Russell Sage.
43.
Kraft, M.E., and D. Scheberle.1995. Environmental justice and the allocation of risk—The case of lead and public health. Policy Studies Journal23 (1): 113-22.
44.
Kreibel, D., and J. Tickner.2001. Reenergizing public health through precaution. AmericanJournal of Public Health91 (9): 1351-54.
45.
Kriebel, D., J. Tickner, P. Epstein, J. Lemons, R. Levins, E.L. Loechler, M. Quinn, R. Rudel, T. Schettler, and M. Stoto.2001. The precautionary principle in environmental health science. Environmental Health Perspectives109 (9): 871-76.
46.
Krieger, N., D.L. Rowley, A.A. Herman, B. Avery, and M.T. Phillips.1993. Racism, sexism, and social class: Implications for studies of health, disease, and well-being. American Journal of Preventive Medicine9 (6): 82-122.
47.
Krueger, A.B.1999. Experimental estimates of educational production functions . Quarterly Journal of Economics114 (2): 497-532.
48.
Kubzansky, L.D., L.F. Berkman, T.A. Glass, and T.E. Seeman.1998. Is educational attainment associated with shared determinants of health in the elderly? Findings from the MacArthur Studies of Successful Aging. Psychosomatic Medicine60 (5): 578-85.
49.
Kuehn, R.R.1996. The environmental justice implications of quantitative risk assessment. University of Illinois Law Review13 (1): 103-72.
50.
Landrigan, P.J., L. Claudio, S.B. Markowitz, G.S. Berkowitz, B.L. Brenner, H. Romero, J.G. Wetmur, T.D. Matte, A.C. Gore, J.H. Godbold, and M.S. Wolff.1999. Pesticides and inner-city children: Exposures, risks and prevention. Environmental Health Perspectives107 (Suppl. 3): 431-37.
51.
Latin, H.1988. Good science, bad regulation, and toxic risk assessment . Yale Journal of Regulation5 (1): 89-148.
52.
Lavelle, M., and M. Coyle.1992. Unequal protection. National Law Journal21: S2.
53.
Lazarus, R.J.1993. Pursuing "environmental justice": The distributional effects of environmental protection. Northwest UniuersityLaw Review87 (3): 787-845.
54.
Lee, C.2002. Environmentaljustice: Building a unified vision of health and environment. Environmental Health Perspectives110 (Suppl. 2): 141-44.
55.
Leikauf, G.D., S. Line, R.E. Albert, C.S. Baxter, D.I. Bernstein, and C.R. Buncher.1995. Evaluation of a possible association of urban air toxics and asthma. Environmental Health Perspectives103 (Suppl. 6): 253-71.
56.
Mannino, D., D. Homa, and C. Pertowski.1998. Surveillance for asthma— United States, 1960-1995. Morbidity and Mortality Weekly Report 47 (SS-1): 1-28.
57.
Metropolitan Forum Project.1999. What if? New schools, better neighborhoods, more livable communitiesLos Angeles: Metropolitan Forum Project.
58.
Mohai, P., and B. Bryant.1992. Environmental racism: Reviewing the evidence. In Race and the incidence of environmental hazards: A time for discourse, edited by B. Bryant and P. Mohai.Boulder, CO: Westview.
59.
Morello-Frosch, R.2002. The political economy of environmental discrimination . Environment and Planning C: Government and Policy20 (4): 477-96.
60.
Morello-Frosch, R.A., M. Pastor, and J.L. Sadd.2001. Environmental justice and Southern California's "riskscape": The distribution of air toxics exposures and health risks among diverse communities. Urban Affairs Review36 (4): 551-78.
61.
Morello-Frosch, R.A., T.J. Woodruff, D.A. Axelrad, and J.C. Caldwell.2000. Air toxics and health risks in California: The public health implications of outdoor concentrations. Risk Analysis20 (2): 273-91.
62.
National Research Council.1993. Pesticides in the diets of infants and children. Washington, DC: National Research Council.
63.
Navarro, V.1990. Race or class versus race and class: Mortality differentials in the United States. Lancet226:1238-40.
64.
Northwest Coalition for Alternatives to Pesticides.2000. Unthinkable risk: How children are exposed and harmed when pesticides are used at school. Eugene, OR: Northwest Coalition for Alternatives to Pesticides.
65.
Orfield, M.1997. Metropolitics: A regional agenda for community and stability . Washington, DC: Brookings Institution .
66.
Parkinson, A.1996. Casarett and Doull's toxicology, the basic science of poisons, edited by C. Klaassen.New York: McGraw-Hill.
67.
Pastor, M., J. Sadd, and J. Hipp.2001. Which came first? Toxic facilities, minority move-in, and environmental justice. Journal of Urban Affairs23 (1): 1-21.
68.
Pastor, M., J. Sadd, and R.A. Morello-Frosch .2002. Reading, writing and toxics: Children's health, academic performance and environmental justice in Los Angeles. Working Paper, Center for Justice, Tolerance, and Community, University of California, Santa Cruz.
69.
Pastor, M., J.L. Sadd, and R. Morello-Frosch .2002. Who's minding the kids? Pollution, public schools, and environmental justice in Los Angeles. Social Science Quarterly83 (1): 263-80.
70.
Perera, F.P., W. Jedrychowski, V. Rauh, and R.M. Whyatt.1999. Molecular epidemiological research on the effects of environmental pollutants on the fetus. Environmental Health Perspectives107 (Suppl. 3): 451-60.
71.
Pollock, P.H., and M.E. Vittas.1995. Who bears the burden of environmental pollution? Race, ethnicity, and environmental equity in Florida. Social Science Quarterly76 (2): 294-310.
72.
Prussel, D., and J. Tepperman.2001. Tackling health hazards at school action alliance for children, 2001. Retrieved 26 May 2002 from http://www.4children.org/news/901toxic.htm.
73.
Pulido, L., S. Sidawi, and R.O. Vos.1996. An archeology of environmental racism in Los Angeles. Urban Geography17 (5): 419-39.
74.
Raffensperger, C., and J. Tickner, eds. 1999. Protecting public health and the environment: Implementing the precautionary principle. Washington, DC: Island Press.
75.
Ritz, B., F. Yu, S. Fruin, G. Chapa, G.M. Shaw, and J.A. Harris.2002. Ambient air pollution and risk of birth defects in Southern California. American Journal of Epidemiology155 (1): 17-25.
76.
Robinson, J.C.1984. Racial inequality and the probability of occupational-related injury or illness. Milbank Quarterly62 (4): 567-90.
77.
—. 1987. Trends in racial inequality and exposure to work-related hazards. Milbank Quarterly65 (2): 404-19.
78.
Rosenbaum, A., D.A. Axelrad, T.J. Woodruff, Y. Wei, M.P. Ligocki, and J.P. Co-hen.1999. National estimates of outdoor air toxics concentrations. Journal of theAir & Waste Management Association49:1138-52.
79.
Rosenbaum, A., M. Ligocki, and Y. Wei.1999. Modeling cumulative outdoor concentrations of hazardous air pollutants: Revised final report Systems Applications International, Inc. Retrieved May 2000 from http://www.epa.gov/CumulativeExposure/resource/resource.htm.
80.
Sadd, J.L., M. Pastor, T. Boer, and L.D. Snyder.1999. "Every breath you take ...": The demographics of toxic air releases in Southern California. Economic Development Quarterly13 (2): 107-23.
81.
Schettler, T., G. Solomon, M. Valenit, and A. Huddle.1999. Generations at risk: Reproductive health and the environment. Cambridge, MA: MIT Press.
82.
Schettler, T., J. Stein, F. Reich, and M. Valenti.2001. In harm's way: Toxic threats to child development. Boston: Greater Boston Physicians for Social Responsibility. Available from http://www.igc.org/psr.
83.
Schwartz, J., D. Gold, D.W. Dockery, S.T. Weiss, and F.E. Speizer.1990. Predictors of asthma and persistent wheeze in a national sample of children in the United States: Association with social class, perinatal events and race.American Review of Repiratory Disease142:555-62.
84.
Sexton, K., and J.L. Adgate.1999. Looking at environmental justice from an environmental health perspective. Journal of Exposure Analysis and EnvironmentalEpidemiology9 (1): 3-8.
85.
Steingraber, S.2000. The social production of cancer: A walk upstream. In Rethinking the environmental debate: The politics of health in a toxic culture, edited by R. Hofrichter.Cambridge, MA: MIT Press.
86.
Syme, S., and L. Berkman.1976. Social class, susceptibility and sickness . American Journal of Epidemiology104 (1): 1-8.
87.
Tickner, J.A., and P. Hoppin.2000. Children's environmental health: A case study in implementing the precautionary principle. International Journal of Environmental Health6 (4): 281-88.
88.
Trotter, A.2002. Los Angeles revives beleaguered Belmont project. Education Week on the Web21 (27): 5). Retrieved 21 May from http://www.edweek.org/ew/newstory.cfm?slug=27belmont.h21.
89.
U.S. Department of Health and Human Services.1990. Age-adjusted death rates for selected causes of death, according to sex and race: United States, selected years, 1950-87. Washington, DC: U.S. Department of Health and Human Services.
90.
U.S. Environmental Protection Agency.1986 . Guidelines for carcinogenic risk assessment. Washington, DC: U.S. Environmental Protection Agency , Federal Register.
91.
—. 1992. Environmental equity: Reducing risk for all communitiesWashington, DC: U.S. Environmental Protection Agency
92.
—. 1998. Cumulative Exposure Project. Retrieved from www.epa.gov/CumulativeExposure.
93.
U.S. General Accounting Office.1999. Pesticides: Uses effects and alternatives to pesticides in schools. Washington, DC: U.S. General Accounting Office.
94.
Van Vliet, P., M. Knape, J. de Hartog, N. Janseen, H. Harssema, and B. Brunekreef.1997. Motor vehicle exhaust and chronic respiratory symptoms in children living near freeways. Environmental Research74 (2): 122-32.
95.
Ware, J.H., J.D. Spengler, L.M. Neas, J.M. Samet, G.R. Wagner, D. Coultas, H. Ozkaynak, and M. Schwab.1993. Respiratory and irritant health effects of ambient volatile organic compounds: The Kanawha County Health Study. American Journal of Epidemiology137 (12): 1287-1301.
96.
Wernette, D.R., and L.A. Nieves.1991. Minorities and air quality non-attainment areas: A preliminary geo-demographic analysis. Paper presented at the Socioeconomic Energy and Research Conference, Baltimore.
97.
White House.1997. Protection of children from environmental health risks and safety risks. Executive order 13045. Washington, DC: White House .
98.
World Health Organization.2002. Precautionary policies and health protection: Principles and applications: Report on a WHO workshop. Rome: World Health Organization.
99.
Zimmerman, Rae.1993. Social equity and environmental risk. Risk Analysis13 (6): 649-66.
