Abstract
In combination with other parameters, the real, n(
Keywords
Introduction
Both the real, n(
Due to its importance in atmospheric science and agriculture, there have been several attempts to assess the n/k values for ammonium sulfate. In 1976, Toon et al. 9 grew single crystals of this important solid that were large enough for transmission and reflectance measurements, yielding n/k data. The authors used the reflectance/transmittance method to derive the values for (NH4)2SO4, but also literature data to derive values for NaCl and Al2O3. The n/k optical constant measurements represented a significant achievement since (i) the high-quality (NH4)2SO4 crystal took more than a year to grow, (ii) they provided estimates for their systematic measurement errors, and (iii) they made quantitative comparisons with previously published results. While the seminal (NH4)2SO4 measurements were an achievement, the data were recorded at coarse spectral resolution (57 digital points between 250 and 5000 cm−1) and discrepancies were observed when the optical constants were used to fit experimental extinction spectra.10,11 Our previous work has similarly demonstrated8,12 how simply increasing the spectral resolution can change the derived k values by as much as 28%. In 2006, Earle et al. 10 reported better-resolved (2 cm−1) optical constants for crystalline ammonium sulfate at 298 K, as well as at 213, 223, and 243 K. Using an aerosol flow tube, they derived optical constants from transmission measurements of dry (NH4)2SO4 aerosols. While their optical constants are in only modest agreement with Toon et al.'s results, 9 Earle et al.'s higher resolution measurements have been found to better reproduce transmission spectra, especially of atmospheric aerosols.
For most materials, however, it is impractical or impossible to obtain uniform crystals that are large enough (centimeter sized) for reflectance measurements8,13; most solids can only be acquired as powders or amorphous materials, often presenting as solid mixtures (e.g., minerals). Growing crystals from such powders is difficult and time-consuming, and in most cases impossible.12,13 Due to the lack of such crystals for most substances, alternative methods for extracting n/k from materials other than single crystals include in situ evaporation techniques 14 as well as pressing the powder form into a uniform pellet or disk for reflectance measurements. The salt (NH4)2SO4 was selected not only due to its importance in atmospheric chemistry, but because its n and k values have been previously reported, and the powder flows relatively easily to form pellets with measured densities close to its literature value. The broader goals of our studies are thus to determine (i) if pellets of pure material powders formed at high pressures can yield reliable optical constants n and k as determined using single-angle reflectance spectroscopy 15 comparable to its crystalline analog16–20 and (ii) how the methods can be optimized to produce optical-quality pellets. Specifically, using the values from Toon et al. 9 and Earle et al. 10 as literature benchmarks, the quality of pressed (NH4)2SO4 pellets and their associated optical constants are assessed by comparing the literature n/k values to those derived using near-normal angle specular reflectance using a Fourier transform infrared (FT-IR) spectrometer followed by KKT.
The single-angle reflectance technique quantitatively measures the change in amplitude of light reflected from the material of interest on an absolute scale as a function of wavelength over a wide spectral range.8,12 Using the broadest λ range possible (e.g., including the far- and near-infrared) allows for more accurate application of the Kramers–Kronig relationship, 13 which is employed numerically to obtain the optical constants. Another method, infrared spectroscopic ellipsometry (IRSE), based on the measurement of the changes in amplitude, tan Ψ, and phase, Δ, of polarized light reflected from the sample can also be used,21,22 and will be discussed in a companion paper. 23 The intercomparison of four data sets of optical constants for ammonium sulfate (vide infra) shows significant variability but very good agreement between single-angle reflectance spectroscopy and IRSE, indicating promise for measuring the optical constants of other materials by the pellet pressing method.
Experimental
Single-Angle Infrared Reflectance Spectroscopy: Kramers–Kronig transform
The single-angle reflectance method to determine n and k has been used for decades.8,13,19,24 The method measures a sole experimental parameter to determine n(
Obviously, evaluating the integral from 0 to ∞ cm−1 as per Eq. 1 is not possible and requires certain approximations, making the data analysis more challenging. The optical constants n/k are derived from the measured reflectance and phase angle via the following relations
7
Single-Angle Infrared Reflectance: Instrumental
Experimentally, the reflectance R(
This earlier study also demonstrated that sample positioning, sample masks, and optical alignment are crucial in the single-angle experiment; the R( Far-IR reflectance obtained with (a) a 6 mm mask and (b) an 8 mm sample mask using different interferometer aperture sizes. For these data, the aperture setting for the reference (mirror) and sample (z-cut quartz) were the same for each background–spectrum pair, but the aperture size was stepped up in succession. As the focal spot size becomes too large, inaccurate values start to result for (a) the ∼4 to 5 mm aperture (6 mm mask) or (b) the ∼6 to 8 mm aperture (8 mm mask).
Materials, Sample Sieving and Drying, Particle Size Distribution
Ammonium sulfate was purchased from Sigma-Aldrich (A5132, ReagentPlus, ≥99.0%). Prior to sieving, powder was taken directly from the bottle and ground using a mortar and pestle to obtain more of the smaller diameter particles: Without grinding, there were almost no particles smaller than 150 µm. Sieving was then performed using an Advantech Sonic Sifter to separate the ground samples into various size fractions using the following sieve diameters: 53, 90, 150, 212, 355, and 500 µm. In some cases, a single sieve was used to obtain all particle sizes below a specific diameter.
For the original powder, as well as the ground and sieved fractions, a digital microscope (Keyence VHX-1000) with 16-bit resolution was utilized to obtain photomicrographs (see Fig. 2) of different (NH4)2SO4 sieve fractions and to measure the diameters of individual particles.
17
Good separation was ensured by spreading the particles over a glass slide. The microscope software differentiates the brightness in the image and extracts the bright portions to produce a binary image by joining the contiguous bright portions. Using an assumption that all adjacent bright points are part of the same object, the software calculates the perimeter and area of each object.
17
The equation d = Photomicrographs of the various size fractions generated by the grinding and sieving procedures. Red scale bar at lower right corner is 200 µm for all images. Particle size fractions and mean particle sizes of the original powder and of ground and sieved ammonium sulfate as measured by optical microscopy.
Due to its hygroscopic behavior, (NH4)2SO4 powders were also dried in a vacuum oven with a slow ramp rate up to 110 ℃ to remove any water adsorbed during the grinding and sieving processes. After drying, the oven temperature was cooled to room temperature under a nitrogen purge to bring the oven back to atmospheric pressure at zero humidity. The slow heating profile is used to avoid discoloration of the powder.
Pellet Preparation
Pellets of ammonium sulfate were pressed at two different diameters: 13 and 20 mm. Approximately 2.0 g of powder was used to press each 20 mm pellet, whereas 0.15 g to 0.8 g was used for the 13 mm pellets. As described above, prior to sieving, the powder was first ground using a mortar and pestle. For the 13 mm pellets, a second grinding was also performed using a Wig-L-Bug ball mill. This supplementary ball-mill grinding was not implemented for the 20 mm pellets (except for one 20 mm pellet in the grinding study, see Table S2) since the canister has a relatively small volume and cannot efficiently grind masses >0.15 g. The ball mill grinding was performed in two rounds of 25 s each, with intermittent mixing of the powder with a spatula.
Two different dies and two different presses were used to press ammonium sulfate powders: An evacuable pellet die set from Pike Technologies along with a two-post, 10 ton manual press (Carver 3851-0) was used for the 13 mm pellets, and a 20 mm die set (International Crystal Laboratories #0012-5223) 15 along with a four-post, 20 ton manual hydraulic press (Carver #4128) were used for the 20 mm pellets. The stainless-steel dies were at room temperature (between 21 and 23 ℃) during the pressing and were actively pumped by a diaphragm pump to avoid entrapping any water vapor. The various time–pressure conditions used to press pellets are summarized in Table S1. Pellets were stored in a dry box when not in use.
Pellet Characterization
The surfaces of two 20 mm pellets were characterized using the same Keyence digital microscope (see the Materials, Sample Sieving and Drying, Particle Size Distribution section) but also a scanning electron microscope (SEM). For the SEM analysis, samples were mounted on carbon tape-covered aluminum SEM stubs (Ted Pella, Redding, CA), and sputter-coated with carbon. They were imaged with a high-resolution Helios 600 Nanolab Dual Beam SEM (FEI, Hillsboro, OR) at 5 keV. Figure 3a depicts photomicrographs of the surfaces; pellet 130 was chosen because it gave a high reflectance value, whereas the reflectance for pellet 66 was significantly lower (see Tables S2 and S3 for pressing conditions). As discussed below, the quality of the surface has a significant effect on the specular reflectance.
(a) Photomicrographs of the surfaces obtained from a high- (#130) and low-reflective (#66) 20 mm pellet. Red scale bar at lower right corner is 1000 µm for both images. (b) SEM images of the same pellet surfaces at 1000×, 5000×, and 12 000 × magnification, respectively. Due to slight translations of the SEM at different magnifications (to obtain a “true” representation of the pellet surface), the same pellet spot is not necessarily shown in each picture. The diamond shape at top right is an approximately 12 µm long particle and the trapezoidal shape at bottom right is an approximately 8 µm void.
In addition to the optical measurements, other methods were considered to assess the quality of the pellet, namely its density. Using the measured mass and volume (assuming a cylinder of volume V = πr2t, where t is the pellet thickness), an experimental density ρpellet was calculated and compared to the literature value 32 for ammonium sulfate, ρlit = 1.769 ± 0.003 g/cm3. From these values, the pellet void space was calculated as [1–(ρpellet/ρlit)] × 100. For each pellet, thickness t and diameter d were measured using a caliper to 0.01 mm and the mass was measured to ±0.0001 g on a four-position balance. Table S2 summarizes the parameters for 43 pellets and how they were investigated in a systematic fashion. Typical masses of (NH4)2SO4 used to press 13 mm and 20 mm pellets were 0.15 g and 2.0 g, respectively. However, for the diameter study (13 versus 20 mm), 13 mm pellets were pressed using a mass of ∼0.8 g to match the thickness of the 20 mm pellet.
Results
Assessing the Results: Maximizing Reflectance
One goal of this study is to try to understand which parameters can be controlled so as to ultimately deliver the most reliable single-angle n/k values for (NH4)2SO4. A second goal is to develop general experimental protocols for those substances which do not easily form single crystals and must be studied as a pellet to get the n/k vectors. In order to optimize parameters for the single-angle pellet pressing method, rather than using, e.g., median or mean %R values, only those methods were retained that resulted in maximizing the %R values, particularly for strongly reflecting bands such as the first-surface-scattering reststrahlen bands,
17
e.g., the ν3(
Powder Particle Size and Grinding
The powder particle sizes that go into forming the pellets turned out to be a key parameter in yielding specimens suited for reflectance spectroscopy. To investigate this parameter, different combinations of particle fractions were studied to determine optimal conditions for obtaining the most reflective (NH4)2SO4 pellet. The list is extensive and includes various particle sizes ranging from very small (<53 µm) to very large (>500 µm), along with mixtures of various fraction ratios, as shown in Table S3.
Two conditions were found to be particularly important in producing high reflectance values including: (i) the mixing of particle fractions and (ii) the use of small particles with diameters <90 µm. The first is supported by the theory that larger particles fill up a certain amount of space, while smaller particles fill the voids produced by the larger particles. 36 Moreover, ground particles become less spherical and can nest better, aiding in filling the voids. 36 The best reflectance was obtained by using greater fractions of smaller particles: In particular, by using two different sieving fractions, namely <53 µm and 53–90 µm in a 40/60 mass ratio, respectively, and then grinding this mixture further still with a Wig-L-Bug ball mill.
The grinding effects were studied for both 13 mm and 20 mm pellets. Two sets of 13 mm pellets were prepared: one set included three pellets composed of fresh powder taken directly from the bottle, and the other set of three pellets was composed of particles (after sieving) with diameters <250 µm. Each of the sets included a pellet prepared from (i) unground powder, (ii) powder ground with a mortar and pestle, and (iii) powder ground using a mortar and pestle followed by the ball mill.
Generally, the ball mill was not used for the 20 mm pellets because the canister is relatively small and consequently it can efficiently grind only small quantities (∼0.15 g). However, to reveal the influence of grinding with a Wig-L-Bug ball mill on the obtained reflectance values, two 20 mm pellets with a mixture of <53 µm and 53–90 µm in a ratio of 40/60 were also prepared: one with ground powder from the mortar and pestle prior to sieving (pellet #91) and one with an additional grinding using the ball mill prior to pressing (pellet #130). To prepare this 2 g sample, several 0.15 g fractions were ground and combined before pressing.
Reflectance of 13 and 20 mm pellets with different particle formulations and different grinding procedures.
Note: Additional grinding with the ball mill led to greater fractions of the smallest particles.
Packing Density, Void Space
Comparison of (NH4)2SO4 pellet specular reflectance at 1106 cm–1 and density (void space).
Note: The void space was calculated as [1–(ρpellet/ρlit)] × 100.
When there exist more defects at the surface, (diffuse) scattering effects become more apparent, and the overall specular reflectance is in turn reduced. That is, a rough or porous surface with irregularities leads to greater diffuse reflectance and less specular component. But the specular response is crucial as it is the sole signal for single-angle reflectance. During the pressing process, it is hypothesized that smaller particles or a microcrystalline continuum are incorporated to formulate the surface. This generates a “smooth” and more specular surface (independent of the bulk density), leading to higher band reflectance (and thus higher k) values.
The degree of diffuse scattering of light from a surface depends on several parameters, including (i) the wavelength and (ii) the angle of incidence of the light wave. The Rayleigh criterion
38
can provide an estimate of surface roughness by estimating the value at which a surface irregularity or particle of height h becomes too large for light to reflect in a specular manner, i.e., results in diffuse scattering. The dimension of the surface irregularity h is calculated via Eq. 5, where λ is the wavelength of the incident/reflected light and θ the angle of incidence
When this relation holds, the surface is considered smooth, and primarily specular reflectance is observed. Using parameters from the present experiment (θ = 11°), and assuming λ = 10 µm, h is found to be 1.27 µm, with h = 12.7 µm for λ = 100 µm, etc. As seen in Eq. 5, the value is wavelength specific, but suggests that for IR studies, the surface needs to be planar to the order of a few µm or better. Any surface defects must be (approximately) less than such values in order to obtain specular reflectance, with specular behavior more difficult to achieve at shorter λ. For the present experiment, Rayleigh height h was found to be 2.04 µm, 1.15 µm, and 0.89 µm at the wavelengths of key ammonium sulfate bands, namely λ = 16 µm (615 cm−1), 9 µm (1106 cm−1), and 7 µm (1415 cm−1), respectively.
Figure 3a depicts photomicrographs obtained by optical microscopy for a smooth (#130, R = 53.2% at 1106 cm−1) and a rough (#66, R = 44.2% at 1106 cm−1) 20 mm pellet surface. Only qualitative estimates of the surface texture can be gleaned from these photos, since no quantitative data can be obtained of the surface in terms of defects and irregularities. However, SEM pictures of the same two surfaces are presented in Fig. 3b at three different magnifications (1000×, 5000×, and 12 000×). At 1000 × magnification, it is possible to observe larger surface defects for pellet 66 (in the form of voids) compared to pellet 130. At higher magnification (12 000×), defects can be measured and, for pellet 66, voids on the order of 5 to 8 µm (bottom right frame) were observed compared to ≤1 µm for pellet 130. Based on the calculated Rayleigh criterion, the lack of several micron-sized defects in pellet 130 most likely plays a role in its higher degree of specular reflectance, since h in this spectral region is 1 to 2 µm. Conversely, since many surface defects of pellet 66 are approximately ≥ 2 µm, the surface roughness is higher, yielding a higher scattering contribution and consequently reducing the specular reflectance. Even if all defects on the surface are not <2 µm, in general, the micromorphological conditions of the surface of pellet 130 favor specular reflectance obeying the Fresnel equations.
Pellet Formation: Application of Drying
Effects of drying on the measured infrared reflectance of ammonium sulfate at 1106 cm–1 as measured by fixed-angle reflectance.
Pellet Diameter and Pellet Formation Pressure
As discussed above, pellets of 13 and 20 mm diameter were prepared using different dies and different presses. The applied pressure (force/surface area) was calculated for both pellet sizes/presses: For 9 100 kg (20 000 lb; 13 mm dies) and 18 200 kg (40 000 lb; 20 mm dies), these forces correspond to 9.7 × 104 lb/in2 and 8.2 × 104 lb/in2, respectively. Moreover, for this specific study, the mass of powder used to make some of the 13 mm pellets was adjusted to match the thickness of the resultant 20 mm pellets. Reflectance values for (blends of) three different sieve sizes (≤250 µm, 50:50 mix of ≤ 53 and 53–90 µm, and a 40:60 mix of ≤53 and 53–90 µm) yielded very similar results between the 13 and 20 mm pellets, demonstrating that the pellet size had minimal effect. However, for 13 mm pellets with lower masses, the use of a Wig-L-Bug ball mill to further powder the salt before pressing (a method often used for KBr transmission pellets) 39 was shown to significantly improve the reflectance.
Pellet Formation–Duration of Press
Another parameter known to affect the optical quality of the pellet is the duration and magnitude of the press, i.e., at what pressures for what time intervals? Many of these procedures have, e.g., been optimized for KBr pellets39,40 as used in IR transmission spectroscopy, but KBr is softer than salts such as ammonium sulfate. It is known that incrementally increasing the weight (pressure) generally leads to better pellets. To test this hypothesis, Method 1 directly ramped the weight to 18 143.695 kg (40 000 lb) for the 20 mm pellets, while several other methods (e.g., Method 3a, Table SI) ramped up the weight over the course of the first 15 min and then held it at a constant weight of 18 200 kg (40 000 lb) for differing durations ranging from 2 min to 12 h, as seen in Fig. 4a. In this analysis, the pellet mixing conditions were constant (6%, 90–150 µm; 48%, 150–212 µm, 46% > 500 µm) and only the pressing time was varied. It is seen that for pellets with pressing times between 2 and 60 min, their reflectance values are lower, but, at least for the 20 mm die, after approximately 90 min, there appears to be a threshold time beyond which the reflectance no longer increases. A similar trend was observed for the 13 mm pellet die (Fig. 4b), although the overall reflectance values were more consistent, even for relatively short pressing times (30 min). The reflectance of the 20 mm pellets does not surpass ∼50% despite the long pressing times, whereas all the 13 mm pellets demonstrate reflectance values above 52%. As discussed in Section 3.2, this is likely due to pellet composition: The 13 mm pellets consisted of a mixture of 40% < 53 µm and 60% 53–90 µm diameter particles that were ball-milled prior to pressing, whereas the 20 mm pellets were prepared only with powder ground with a mortar and pestle. The 13 mm pellets thus have generally higher reflectance values due to the greater fractions of small particles. Typically, values of reflectance in the 1106 cm−1 band are approximately R = 0.54 for 13 mm and R = 0.49 for 20 mm, respectively.
Measured specular reflectance (spectral peak in inset) of ammonium sulfate pellets at 1106 cm−1 as function of pressing time. The same powder formulation was used in all cases. Pressing time methods were described in Table S2. (a) 20 mm pellets and (b) 13 mm pellets.
Homogeneity and Spectral Quality of the Reflecting Surface
To confirm that a smooth surface is a key parameter for high reflectance values, the effects of surface homogeneity on the reflectivity of (NH4)2SO4 pellets were also studied. By rotating the pellet in the sample holder ∼72° each turn, the specular R were measured at five independent spots on the surface of both a nominally smooth (planar) pellet (#100) and a less-smooth pellet (#37) – these pellets were chosen because small (#100) and large (#37) changes in %R were initially observed when attempting to maximize the signal. In theory, because the focal spot of illumination is constant, this rotation should measure the same spot on the pellet surface, yielding identical reflectance values. However, due to simple apparati (no goniometer, only manual sample rotation), slight translations and tilts emerge with rotation, resulting in measurement of different spots, albeit with some overlap of the original illumination spots. Myriad factors can cause such variations including small cavities or voids, impurities on the surface, and powder inhomogeneity, to name but a few. Some examples of cavities and voids can be observed in Fig. 3. Another point to consider is the crystal structure of ammonium sulfate, which is orthorhombic at room temperature and thus has an (s- versus p-) polarization effect to which the reflectance value is linked. 37
A pressed pellet of powder (compared to a single crystal) is, at best, an average of microcrystals with various polarization directions, some spots preferentially polarizing/reflecting more light than others.37,41 Although polarization effects are not expected at small incidence angles, we have considered the possibility of slight polarization effects from microcrystalline domains in the pressed powders. As seen in Fig. 5, the calculated ss- and pp-reflectance (using the optical constants from Myers et al.
23
) for this angle of incidence (11°) are compared with single-angle reflectance results. The calculated spectra vary by only 1.5%R at the ν3( Comparison of calculated R
ss
and R
pp
polarized reflectance spectra at an 11° angle of incidence with results obtained from single-angle reflectance measurements.
Figure 6a displays the result for three different IR reflectance bands, namely at 1415, 1106, and 615 cm−1 for ν4( Effects of surface roughness/homogeneity on the specular reflectance of (NH4)2SO4 pellets studied by rotating pellet in holder. The reflectance of a (a) nominally rough pellet (#37) and (b) smooth pellet (#100) is measured at five independent surface spots.
Reproducibility Using Optimal Parameters
Finally, using only the optimal parameters and preparation methods as outlined above, a series of 10 pellets were prepared and measured separately to estimate the variability (analytical precision) in the measurements. The results are seen in Fig. 7a. The inset of the spectral region that manifests the largest %R variation is shown, and the pellets are listed in order of highest to lowest reflectance (the single-angle reflectance spectra of the 10 optimized pellets from 1500 to 450 cm−1 is presented in Figure S1, Supplemental Material). The reflectance at 1106 cm−1 varies from 55.0% to 52.8% over the 10 pellets yielding a relatively small fractional variation of 4.0%.
(a) Optical constants n and k for the series of 10 optimized pellets. (b) Decadic log scale of k, emphasizing subtle differences in weak features and baseline variability. Numbers at right indicate pellet number.
The small sinusoidal waves visible across the peak maxima in the inset of Fig. 7a are ascribed to spectral fringing, i.e., an étalon formed between the pellet's front and back surfaces. This effect is commonly observed in thin films or pellets composed of IR transmitting materials. 42 However, spectral fringing was observed here especially for those pellets pressed with optimal parameters because (i) these pellets are extremely thin (∼0.6 mm) and (ii) the pellet surfaces are smooth and parallel with fewer voids, causing the pellets to become more transparent.
Using the R(
Relative standard deviation and relative spread of the reflectance values, n(
Discussion
This study has shown, at least for moderately soft materials, that powdered forms of neat chemicals can be pressed at an appropriate pressure into pellets of sufficient planarity and homogeneity to yield specular behavior. We note that the specularity is essentially the complement of the diffuseness spectrum, D, which is defined as D = ρd/ρ, where ρd is the diffuse reflectance and ρ is the total reflectance. 15 The diffuseness, D, is a reflectance analogue to the “haze factor”, b, used for visible transmission measurements; that is, for a window, b gauges the fraction of light transmitted diffusely.15,43,44 Key elements to forming specularly reflecting pellets include use of sufficiently small and dried particles in the right sieve fractions, pressing for sufficient duration (ramped, for approximately 30 min total) at pressures of approximately 9 × 104 lb/in2 (final pressure). Such methods result in pellets that yield reliable optical constants. Future studies will investigate if such methods can be applied to harder materials.
In similar work, Volz 37 studied the near-normal reflectance of inorganics, though no attempt was made to derive the optical constants. He noted that crystalline substances may exhibit certain vibrational bands whose reflected intensity depends on beam polarization. He compared near-normal reflectance from reststrahlen bands of several inorganic species, both neat and mixed, as crystals but also as pressed pellets, including for ammonium sulfate. The near-normal reflectance of the pellets was recorded and Volz also found that, similar to the present work, only relatively small variations in R were observed once the particle sizes were small enough, mostly crystals and microcrystals ground with mortar and pestle to sizes of ∼10 µm and smaller, and most samples prepared with very fine particles. To press the pellets, Volz used higher pressures than in the present studies, namely 30 s at 160 000 lb/in2 vis-a-vis the ∼97 000 lb/in2 values used in this work. He noted that such high pressures only brought marginal gain; using only 40 000 lb/in2 for 30 s, the calcite reflectance dropped only 10% from its maximal value. Using a beam condenser, his IR spot size was also much smaller with an effective sample area <1 mm2, and with the incidence angle ranging from 2 to 15° and polarized 0–10° perpendicular to that plane. As expected, no polarization effects were observed for the pressed powders; presumably due to random microcrystal orientation and also the near-normal angles of incidence (similar to the only small changes observed in the present work, Fig. 5). For the pellets, including mixtures, Volz was also able to obtain specular reflectance comparable to those of pure crystals for softer substances such as KBr or (NH4)2SO4 (Mohs hardness 1.5 and 2.3, respectively), but rightly pointed out the potential lack of applicability of the method to harder specimens such as quartz (Mohs hardness = 7) which do not readily flow nor compress. For the 20 or so species measured, the reflectance of the pressed powders ranged from approximately 40 to 100% of the values obtained from the corresponding crystals, the pellets of the harder materials (limestone, basalt, quartz) having the lower R values relative to crystalline species.
For the present work, (NH4)2SO4 was chosen because it is compressible and also because its optical constants have been reported. Ammonium sulfate is in fact biaxial, but it was assumed that the three sets of optical constants are identical. Toon et al. 9 found from their optical constant measurements of a macroscopic crystal of the material that indeed the three sets of optical constants were very close in value over much of the IR wavelength range. In that 1976 paper, Toon et al. first reported 9 the optical constants of (NH4)2SO4 obtained from a single crystal using reflectance–transmittance measurements on a dispersive IR system. Thirty years on, Earle et al. 10 reported better-resolved optical constants for crystalline ammonium sulfate at 298 K, along with the n and k values at 213, 223, and 243 K. They derived n/k from extinction measurements of dry (NH4)2SO4 aerosols using an aerosol flow tube coupled to a Fourier transform spectrometer. Besides these two literature data sets, in a separate effort, Pacific Northwest National Laboratory (PNNL) and Defence Research and Development Canada have generated values of n/k (NH4)2SO4 using IRSE. 23 While derived differently, all three methods provide n/k data which can be used (either n/k directly or generating reflectance spectra via Fresnel equations) as benchmarks to which the present single-angle data can be compared.
A comparison for the four sets of k vector data is seen in Fig. 8 which displays the n( (a) Optical k values representing four sets of optical data. The blue trace represents the k values derived from single-angle reflectance spectroscopy from the best pellet (max %R). The red trace represents the k values derived from the spectroscopic ellipsometric method, whereas the green and black traces represent the spectra obtained from the n/k data sets of Toon et al.
9
and Earle et al.,
10
respectively. (b) Comparison of optical constants n and k between four different measurement techniques. Those shown with a solid line were measured at PNNL, while the dashed lines were data acquired by other laboratories.
Percent differences ((kA–kB)/kA) × 100 and ((∫kA–∫kB)/∫kA) × 100 for each of the five bands ν4(
The differences between PNNL results (both using single angle and ellipsometry) and the Toon et al.
9
(crystal) and Earle et al.
10
(aerosol) results, however, are significantly larger, in some cases with PNNL peak height for k 28–30% stronger than the Earle et al. data for the one peak of ν3(
As seen in Fig. 8, the agreement of Toon et al. with the present single-angle and ellipsometry data is limited in part by spectroscopic resolution of the Toon et al. 9 instrument; the lower spectral resolution of 1970s instrumentation likely plays a large role in the lack of agreement. The limited number of data points (just 57 between 250 and 5000 cm−1) has a strong effect not only on resolution and digital spacing of the abscissa as seen in Fig. 8 but also affects the n/k amplitudes. If higher resolution instrumentation had been available at the time, the Toon et al. crystal data would likely agree well with the present results. Moreover, the low-spectral resolution of the Toon et al. 9 data likely explains the significant differences between values obtained from the peak maxima and the integrated areas (see Table VI). In fact, as shown in Fig. 8, peak maxima of the Toon et al. 9 spectrum are not as high at PNNL values; this is expected due to the lack of data points, but the integrated peak areas are similar to those of the PNNL spectral bands.
Earle et al. 10 derived their n/k vectors by making FT-IR extinction measurements of dried ammonium sulfate powder in an aerosol flow tube. The data are at higher spectroscopic resolution and match the peak profiles of the two PNNL data sets well, but while the digital spacing is more consistent, there appears to be slight shifts in frequency calibration (peak position) and especially amplitude. Specifically, the Earle et al. data appear to have significantly lower k values, approximately 19 to 30% lower than either PNNL data set as compared across the three bands at 1417, 1089, and 614 cm−1 (using kmax). The Earle et al. k values were also noted in Fig. 4 of their own paper 10 as being significantly lower than the Toon et al. 9 data. The methods in which the data are derived are very different, and the reasons for the disagreement are not immediately clear but one possibility is the analysis method to obtain n/k may not be fully applicable to such fine, non-spherical particles: Their SEM data indicated that not all the particles were perfectly spherical, and some may have agglomerated. As pointed out by both Weis and Ewing 35 and Clapp and Miller, 45 a limitation of Mie scattering theory is that it is not fully applicable to non-spherical particles.
For the ν3(
In another approach, Pecharromán and Iglesias reported
49
an alternate method to determine the optical constants for isotropic materials such as ammonium sulfate using a variant effective-medium theory that is calculated based on measurement of an isotropic material's reflectance from a powdered sample. It employs an expression for the average dielectric constant of a heterogeneous system which shows percolation features. Finally, we note still another method to approximate the n/k values for ammonium sulfate was developed by Downing et al.
50
using molar fractional amounts of aqueous ammonium sulfate solutions at progressively higher concentrations (1.6, 2.4, and 3.2 M) and then extrapolating the derived k(
Conclusion
Laboratory, industrial, and standoff IR spectroscopies continue their exponential growth.52,53 It has already been demonstrated 54 that laboratory reference data can readily be used for field detection of both solids and liquids, as well as gases 55 but increasingly the n/k vectors are used for modeling5,56 the target signal both for liquids 4 and solids. 54 Obtaining n/k for solids is more challenging, and one goal of this study was thus to (determine how to) prepare pellets with high surface smoothness, since the single-angle method measures only specular reflectance. We have recorded single-angle reflectance data of pelletized ammonium sulfate powder. (NH4)2SO4 is an easy material with which to work; it flows well producing homogeneous pellets with void space typically on the order of 5% or less. To simplify the study, we did not consider using binders such as polyethylene glycol which are often used to bind particles and act as a lubricant during the pressing process. 57
The spectrum of each pellet was recorded in two spectral segments, including the mid- and far-IR. The two spectral segments for each pellet were trimmed (50 to 600 cm−1 for the far-IR and 400–5000 cm−1 for the mid-IR), concatenated into a single R(
Because most methods to determine the optical constants require (near-) crystalline materials, the pressed pellet/single-angle method offers a viable alternative to determine n/k. So long as optical quality pellets (highly specular faces) can be obtained, the method is reliable, faster, and significantly more economical than, e.g., spectroscopic ellipsometry. The results suggest that for some materials it may be possible to press a pellet of the powder form of the material and make optical constant measurements on the pellet rather than a single bulk crystal. It does suffer the drawback that, as demonstrated here, it can be challenging to prepare specular surfaces from powders.
In a companion paper,
23
we have also investigated the use of pressed pellets of (NH4)2SO4 with the spectroscopic ellipsometry method to obtain the n(
Supplemental Material
sj-pdf-1-asp-10.1177_0003702820930009 - Supplemental material for Infrared Optical Constants from Pressed Pellets of Powders: I. Improved n and k Values of (NH4)2SO4 from Single-Angle Reflectance
Supplemental material, sj-pdf-1-asp-10.1177_0003702820930009 for Infrared Optical Constants from Pressed Pellets of Powders: I. Improved n and k Values of (NH4)2SO4 from Single-Angle Reflectance by Timothy J. Johnson, Emmanuela Diaz, Kendall D. Hughey, Tanya L. Myers, Thomas A. Blake, Alice C. Dohnalkova and Sarah D. Burton in Applied Spectroscopy
Footnotes
Acknowledgments
We thank Carolyn S. Brauer, Brent M. DeVetter, and Molly Kelly-Gorham for assistance in the earlier phases of this project.
Declaration of Conflicting Interests
The author(s) declared no potential conflicts of interest with respect to the research, authorship, and/or publication of this article.
Funding
The research is based upon work supported in part by the Office of the Director on National Intelligence (ODNI), Intelligence Advanced Research Projects Activity (IARPA), via DOE contract DE-AC05-76RL01830. The views and conclusions contained herein are those of the authors and should not be interpreted as necessarily representing the official policies or endorsements, either expressed or implied, of the ODNI, IARPA, or the U.S. Government. The U.S. Government is authorized to reproduce and distribute reprints for Governmental purposes notwithstanding any copyright annotation thereon. We thank our sponsor Dr. Kristin Dewitt for program support. PNNL is operated by Battelle for the U.S. Department of Energy under contract DE-AC05-76RLO1830.
Supplemental material
The supplemental material mentioned in the text, which includes Tables S1–S3, Figure S1, the data set for reflectance obtained with single-angle reflectance spectroscopy, and the associated n and k for our best pellet from 5000 to 0 cm−1, is available in the online version of the journal.
References
Supplementary Material
Please find the following supplemental material available below.
For Open Access articles published under a Creative Commons License, all supplemental material carries the same license as the article it is associated with.
For non-Open Access articles published, all supplemental material carries a non-exclusive license, and permission requests for re-use of supplemental material or any part of supplemental material shall be sent directly to the copyright owner as specified in the copyright notice associated with the article.
