Comparative Study of the Clinical Effectiveness of a Pyrethrin-Based Pediculicide with Combing Versus a Permethrin-Based Pediculicide with Combing

Abstract

In a randomized, evaluator-blinded clinical trial, 190 patients were treated for Pediculus humanus capitis infestations with a pyrethrin-piperonyl-butoxide pediculicide (RID®; Py-PB) and a permethrin pediculicide (NIX®; PM). A total of 160 patients were evaluable for nit-combing speed, 156 patients were evaluable for efficacy at day 7, and 150 patients were evaluable for efficacy at day 14. Both Py-PB and PM showed 100% efficacy at day 7. At day 14, one patient in the PM group had an apparent reinfestation. The Py-PB group had significantly lower mean combing times (P=0.04), but because the PM group had more nits, the two groups were not significantly different in combing speed expressed as seconds per nit. Multiple regression and covariance analyses suggested that the greater speed of the Py-PB comb might have been masked by this baseline difference. Three patients had mild adverse experiences (Py-PB: erythema, PM: erythema and tingling sensation). No patients were removed from the study because of adverse events. In conclusion, this controlled clinical study demonstrated that both Py-PB and PM provided 100% efficacy following a single application. Differences attributable to comb design favored the Py-PB “rake” comb, but this requires additional evaluation and confirmation.

References

1. Rasmussen JE . Pediculosis and the pediatrician. Pediatr Dermatol. 1985; 133:741-742.

2. Stier Carson D , Tribble PW , Weart CW . Pyrethrins combined with piperonyl butoxide (RID) vs. 1% permethrin (NIX) in the treatment of head lice. Am J Dis Child. 1988;142: 768-769.

3. Sokoloff F . Identification and management of pediculosis. Nurse Practitioner. 1994;62-64.

4. Taplin D , Meinking TL , Castillero PM , et al. Permethrin 1% cream rinse for the treatment of Pediculus humanusvar capitis infestation. Pediatr Dermatol. 1986;3:344-348.

5. DeFeliceJ , RumsfieldJ , Bernstein JE , Roshal J . Clinical evaluation of an after-pediculide nit removal system. Int J Dermatol. 1989;28:468-470.

6. Vander Stichele RH , Dezeure EM , Bogaert M . Systematic review of clinical efficacy of topical treatments for head lice. Br Medj 1995;311:604-608.

7. Chunge RN , Scott FE , Underwood JE , Zavarella KJ . A review of the epidemiology, public health importance, treatment and control of head lice. Can J Public Health. 1991;82:196-200.

8. Mathias RG , Wallace JF . Control of head lice: using parent volunteers. Can J Public Health. 1989;80:461-463.

9. Clinical Investigator Network. A randomized parallel comparative study of the clinical effectiveness of two nit combs after treatment with a pyrethrin-based pediculicide, Pfizer, Inc. Final Report, Protocol Number 360-6, September 15, 1992.