A Note on the Validity of Self-Reports of Absenteeism

Abstract

The general unavailability of and difficulty associated with obtaining records-based data on absenteeism suggests the potential value of self-report data for those conducting research on absenteeism. This should not be recommended, however, until the validity of these self-report measures is assessed. In this paper, we compare records-based and self-report measures of absenteeism for the same employees for the same period of time. We find that although the univariate descriptive data for the two measures are similar, the correlation between the two is .299. Although this is in the expected direction, its magnitude is small enough for us to question the validity of self- report measures of absenteeism. Several suggestions are offered for additional study of this.

References

AKERS, R. K. , MASSEY, J. , CLARKE, W. , & LAUER, B. Are self-report questionnaire responses valid? Biochemical measures, randomized response, and the bogus pipeline in smoking behavior . Social Forces, 1983, 62, 234-251 .

GOODMAN, P. S. , ATKIN, R. S. , et al. Absenteeism. San Francisco: Jossey-Bass , 1984.

GUPTA, N. , & JENKINS, G. D. Tardiness as a manifestation of employee withdrawal . Journal of Business Research, 1983, 11, 61-75 .

HAMMER, T. H. , & LANDAU, J. Methodological issues in the use of absence data . Journal of Applied Psychology, 1981, 66, 574-581 .

HARDT, R. H. , & PETERSON-HARDT, S. On determining the quality of the delinquency self-report method . Journal of Research in Crime and Delinquency, 1977, 2, 247-261 .

HEDGES, J. N. Absence from work—a look at some national data . Monthly Labor Review, 1973, 96, 24-30 .

HEDGES, J. N. Unscheduled absence from work—an update . Monthly Labor Review, 1975, 98, 36-39 .

HEDGES, J. N. Absence from work—measuring the hours lost . Monthly Labor Review, 1977, 100, 16-23 .

LEON, C. B. Employed but not at work: A review of unpaid absences . Monthly Labor Review, 1981, 104, 18-22 .

10.

NEWMAN, J. E. Predicting absenteeism and turnover: A field comparison of Fishbein's model and traditional job attitude measures . Journal of Applied Psychology, 1974, 59, 610-615 .

11.

NICHOLSON, N. , WALL, T. , & LISCHERON, J. The predictability of absence and propensity to leave from employee's job satisfaction and attitudes toward influence in decision making . Human Relations, 1977, 30, 499-514 .

12.

PRICE, J. P. , & MUELLER, C. W. Absenteeism and turnover among hospital employees. New York: JAI Press , 1986. (a)

13.

PRICE, J. P. , & MUELLER, C. W. Handbook of organizational measurement. Marshfield, Massachusetts: Pitman , 1986. (b)

14.

SEKSCENSKI, E. S. The health services industry: A decade of expansion . Monthly Labor Review, 1981, 104, 9-16 .

15.

TAYLOR, D. E. Absent workers and lost work hours, May 1978 . Monthly Labor Review, 1979, 102, 49-53 .

16.

TAYLOR, D. E. Absence from work among full-time employees . Monthly Labor Review, 1981, 104, 68-70 .

17.

VAN DER MERWE, R. , & MILLER, S. Measuring absenteeism and labor turnover. Johannesburg: McGraw-Hill , 1976.

18.

WOLPIN, J. , & BURKE, R. J.

Relationships between absenteeism and turnover: A function of the measures?

Personnel Psychology, 1985, 38, 57-74 .