It has been claimed that American employers' experiments in private welfare capitalism collapsed during the Great Depression, giving place to the welfare state and industrial unionism. Recent studies, however, reveal considerable differences in experience across firms. The author of this study, who characterizes private welfare capitalism as a set of human resource management practices constituting an implicit contract equilibrium, tests the implications of implicit contract theory using data from fourteen leading manufacturing firms. The repudiation of implicit contracts, she finds, was positively correlated with the severity of the depression's impact experienced by firms and negatively correlated with the effectiveness of “internal enforcement mechanisms” instituted by firms. Furthermore, she finds that greater breaches of implicit contracts were associated with greater employee support for industrial unions and more explicit employment contracts concluded under the New Deal. A comparative case study complements the quantitative analysis by exploring internal dynamics.
References
1.
AlexanderMagnus. 1914. “Waste in Hiring and Discharging Men.”Iron Age, Vol. 94, pp. 1032–33.
2.
AllenHugh. 1943. The House of Goodyear: A Story of Rubber and Modern Business. Cleveland: Corday & Gross.
3.
BaronJames1986. “War and Peace: The Evolution of Modern Personnel Administration in U.S. Industry.”American Journal of Sociology, Vol. 92, No. 2 (September), pp. 350–83.
4.
BerkowitzEdwardMcQaidKim. 1980. Creating the Welfare State. New York: Praeger.
5.
BernsteinIrving. 1960. The Lean Years: A History of the American Worker, 1920–1933. Boston: Houghton Mifflin.
6.
BerridgeWilliam. 1929. “Labor Turnover in American Factories.”Monthly Labor Review, Vol. 29 (July), pp. 62–65.
7.
BertrandMarianne. 1990. “From the Invisible Handshake to the Invisible Hand? How Import Competition Changes the Employment Relationship.” NBER Working Paper No. 6900.
8.
BordoMichael1998. The Defining Moment: The Great Depression and the American Economy in the Twentieth Century. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
9.
BrandesStuart. 1970. American Welfare Capitalism, 1880–1940. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
10.
BrandtFloyd. 1960. “Independent and National Unionism in the Oil Refining Industry.” D.B.A. thesis, Graduate School of Business Administration, Harvard University.
11.
BrodyDavid. 1960. Steelworkers in America: The Nonunion Era. Cambridge, Mass.: Harvard University Press.
12.
BrodyDavid. 1980. Workers in Industrial America. New York: Oxford University Press.
13.
BrownClairReichMichael. 1989. “When Does Union-Management Cooperation Work? A Look at NUMMI and GM Van-Nuys.”California Management Review, Vol. 31 (Summer), pp. 26–44.
14.
BullClive. 1987. “The Existence of Self-Enforcing Implicit Contracts.”Quarterly Journal of Economics, Vol. 102, No. 1 (February), pp. 147–59.
15.
ChandlerAlfred. 1962. Strategy and Structure. Cambridge, Mass.: MIT Press.
16.
CohenLisabeth. 1990. Making a New Deal: Industrial Workers in Chicago, 1919–1939. New York: Cambridge University Press.
17.
CommonsJohn R.1935. History of Labor in the United States, 1896–1932. New York: MacMillan.
18.
CornwellChristopherDorseyStuartMehrzadNasser. 1991. “Opportunistic Behavior by Firms in Implicit Pension Contracts.”Journal of Human Resources, Vol. 26, No. 4 (Fall), pp. 704–25.
19.
DobbinFrank. 1992. “The Origins of Private Social Insurance: Public Policy and Fringe Benefits in America, 1920–1950.”American Journal of Sociology, Vol. 97, No. 5 (March), pp. 1416–50.
20.
DuncanMargaret. 1932. “Personnel Practices of Two Electrical Equipment Companies with Reference to Employee Training and Welfare.” Ph.D. thesis, University of Pittsburgh.
21.
EngelbourgSaul. 1976. International Business Machines: A Business History. New York: Arno.
22.
FairrisDavid. 1997. Shop floor Matters: Labor-Management Relations in Twentieth-Century American Manufacturing. New York: Routledge.
23.
FeisHerbert. 1928. Labor Relations: A Study Made in the Procter and Gamble Company. New York: Adelphi.
24.
FineSidney. 1969. Sit-Down: The General Motors Strike of 1936–1937. Ann Arbor: University of Michigan Press.
25.
GibbGeorgeKnowltonEvelyn. 1956. History of Standard Oil Company (New Jersey), Vol. 2: The Resurgent Years, 1911–1927. New York: Harper & Brothers.
GrayEdmundGullettRay. 1973. “Employee Representation at Standard Oil Company of New Jersey: A Case Study.” Occasional Paper Number 11, College of Business Administration, Louisiana State University.
28.
GreifAvner. 1993. “Contract Enforceability and Economic Institutions in Early Trade: The Maghribi Traders' Coalition.”American Economic Review, Vol. 83, No. 3 (June), pp. 525–48.
29.
GreifAvner1994. “Coordination, Commitment, and Enforcement: The Case of the Merchant Guild.”Journal of Political Economy, Vol. 102, No. 3, pp. 745–76.
30.
GulickCharles. 1924. Labor Policy of the United States Steel Corporation. New York: Columbia University Press.
31.
HarrisHowell. 1982. The Right to Manage: Industrial Relations Policies of American Business in the 1940s. Madison: University of Wisconsin Press.
32.
HiraoT.1998. Amerika Daikigyo to Rodosha (Big Business and Workers in the United States in the 1920s). Sapporo: Hokkaido Daigaku Tosho Kankokai.
33.
HouserJ. David. 1927. What the Employer Thinks: Executives' Attitudes toward Employees. Cambridge, Mass.: Harvard University Press.
34.
IchniowskiCaseyShawKathrynPrennushiGiovanna. 1997. “The Effects of Human Resource Management Practices on Productivity: A Study of Steel Finishing Lines.”American Economic Review, Vol. 87, No. 3 (June), pp. 291–313.
35.
IdsonToddVallettaRobert. 1996. “Seniority, Sectoral Decline, and Employee Retention: An Analysis of Layoff Unemployment Spells.”Journal of Labor Economics, Vol. 14, No. 4 (October), pp. 654–76.
36.
JacobySanford. 1985. Employing Bureaucracy: Managers, Unions, and the Transformation of Work in American Industry, 1900–1945. New York: Columbia University Press.
37.
JacobySanford. 1997. Modern Manors: Welfare Capitalism Since the New Deal. Princeton: Princeton University Press.
38.
JacobySanford. 2000. “A Road Not Taken: Independent Local Unions in the United States Since 1935.” In TarasD., ed., Nonunion Employee Representation. Armonk, N.Y.: M. E. Sharpe.
39.
JonesDerekKatoTakao. 1995. “The Productivity Effects of Employee Stock-Ownership Plans and Bonuses: Evidence from Japanese Panel Data.”American Economic Review, Vol. 85, No. 3 (June), pp. 391–414.
40.
KanemotoYoshitsuguMacLeodBentley. 1989. “Optimal Labor Contract with Non-Contractible Human Capital.”Journal of the Japanese and International Economies, Vol. 3, pp. 385–402.
41.
KatoTakaoMorishimaMotohiro. 2002. “The Productivity Effects of Participatory Employment Practices: Evidence from New Japanese Panel Data.”Industrial Relations, Vol. 41, No. 4 (October), pp. 487–520.
42.
KletzerLori G.1998. “Job Displacement.”Journal of Economic Perspectives, Vol. 12, No. 1 (Winter), pp. 115–36.
43.
KnezMarcSimesterDuncan. 2001. “Firm-Wide Incentives and Mutual Monitoring at Continental Airlines.”Journal of Labor Economics, Vol. 19, No. 4 (October), pp. 743–72.
44.
LarsonHenrietta1971. History of Standard Oil Company (New Jersey), Vol. 3: New Horizons, 1927–1950. New York: Harper & Row.
45.
LazearEdward. 2000. “Performance Pay and Productivity.”American Economic Review, Vol. 90, No. 5 (December), pp. 1346–61.
46.
LiefAlfred. 1958. “It Floats”: The Story of Procter & Gamble. New York: Rinehard.
47.
MacLeodBentleyMalcomsonJames. 1989. “Implicit Contracts, Incentive Compatibility, and Involuntary Unemployment.”Econometrica, Vol. 57, No. 2 (March), pp. 447–80.
48.
MarshallRay. 1961. “The Union in the Gulf Coast Petroleum Refining Industry.”Labor Law Journal, Vol. 12, pp. 823–40.
49.
MatlesJamesHigginsJames. 1974. Them and Us: Struggles of a Rank-and-File Union. Englewood Cliffs, N.J.: Prentice-Hall.
50.
McDuffieJohn Paul. 1995. “Human Resource Bundles and Manufacturing Performance: Organizational Logic and Flexible Production Systems in the World Auto Industry.”Industrial and Labor Relations Review, Vol. 48, No. 2 (January), pp. 197–221.
51.
McQaidKim. 1977. “Young, Swope and General Electric's ‘New Capitalism’: A Study in Corporate Liberalism, 1920–33.”American Journal of Economics and Sociology, Vol. 36, No. 3 (July), pp. 323–34.
52.
MeyerStephen. 1981. The Five Dollar Day: Labor, Management, and Social Control in the Ford Motor Company. Albany: State University of New York Press.
53.
MillisHarry. 1942. How Collective Bargaining Works: A Survey of Experience in Leading American Industries. New York: Twentieth Century Fund.
54.
MillisHarryMontgomeryRoyal. 1945. Organized Labor. New York: McGraw-Hill.
55.
MoriguchiChiaki. 2000. “The Evolution of Employment Relations in U.S. and Japanese Manufacturing Firms, 1900–1960: A Comparative Historical and Institutional Analysis.” NBER Working Paper No. 7939.
56.
MoriguchiChiaki. 2001. “Implicit Contracts, the Great Depression, and Institutional Change: A Comparative Study of U.S. and Japanese Manufacturing Firms, 1910–1940.” Unpublished Manuscript.
57.
MoriguchiChiaki. 2003. “Implicit Contracts, the Great Depression, and Institutional Change: A Comparative Analysis of U.S. and Japanese Employment Relations, 1920–1940.”Journal of Economic History, Vol. 63, No. 3 (September), pp. 625–65.
58.
MorrowEllis. 1921. The Lynn Plan of Representation. M.B.A. thesis, Harvard University.
59.
NelsonDaniel. 1975. Managers and Workers: Origins of the Twentieth-Century Factory System in the U.S., 1880–1920. Madison: University of Wisconsin Press.
60.
NelsonDaniel. 1982. “The Company Union Movement, 1900–1937: A Reexamination.”Business History Review, Vol. 56, No. 3, pp. 335–357.
61.
NelsonDaniel. 1988. American Rubber Workers and Organized Labor, 1900–1941. Princeton: Princeton University Press.
62.
NelsonDaniel. 1989. “Managers and Nonunion Workers in the Rubber Industry: Union Avoidance Strategies in the 1930s.”Industrial and Labor Relations Review, Vol. 43, No. 1 (October), pp. 41–52.
63.
Nelson-RoweShan. 1991. “Corporation Schooling and the Labor Market at General Electric.”History of Education Quarterly, Vol. 31, No. 1, pp. 27–46.
64.
NeumarkDavid2000. On the Job: Is Long-Term Employment a Thing of the Past?New York: Russell Sage Foundation.
65.
NevinsAllanHillFrank. 1957. Ford: Expansion and Challenge, 1915–1933. New York: Scribner's Sons.
66.
NICB. 1928. The Economic Status of the Wage Earners in New York and Other States. New York: National Industrial Conference Board.
67.
NICB. 1929. Industrial Relations Programs in Small Plants. New York: National Industrial Conference Board.
68.
NICB. 1931a. Industrial Relations: Policies and Programs. New York: National Industrial Conference Board.
69.
NICB. 1931b. Unemployment Benefits and Insurance. New York: National Industrial Conference Board.
70.
NICB. 1934. Effect of the Depression on Industrial Relations Programs. New York: National Industrial Conference Board.
71.
NICB. 1936. What Employers Are Doing for Employees: A Survey of Voluntary Activities for Improvement of Working Conditions in American Business Concerns. New York: National Industrial Conference Board.
72.
OstermanPaul. 1994. “How Common Is Workplace Transformation and Who Adopts It?”Industrial and Labor Relations Review, Vol. 53, No. 2 (January), pp. 173–87.
73.
OttenA.1973. “Note on the Spearman Rank Correlation Coefficient.”Journal of the American Statistical Association, Vol. 68, pp. 585.
74.
OwenLaura. 1995. “Worker Turnover in the 1920s: What Labor-Supply Arguments Don't Tell Us.”Journal of Economic History, Vol. 55, No. 4, pp. 822–41.
75.
OzanneRobert. 1967. A Century of Labor-Management Relations at McCormick and International Harvester. Madison: University of Wisconsin Press.
76.
OzanneRobert. 1968. Wages in Practice and Theory: McCormick and International Harvester, 1860–1960. Madison: University of Wisconsin Press.
77.
RetzlerJulius. 1963. “Labor Organization at Du Pont: A Study in Independent Local Unionism.”Labor History, Vol. 4, pp. 178–95.
78.
RobertsJohnVan den SteenEric. 2000. “Shareholder Interests, Human Capital Investment, and Corporate Governance.” Stanford GSB Research Paper No. 1631.
79.
RogersGregoryBeerMichael. 1995. “Human Resources at Hewlett-Packard.” Harvard Business School Cases 5-495-051 and 5-494-052.
80.
RummJohn. 1989. “Mutual Interests: Managers and Workers at the Du Pont Company, 1802–1915.” Ph.D. thesis, University of Delaware.
81.
SchachtJohn. 1975. “Toward Industrial Unionism: Bell Telephone Workers and Company Unions, 1919–1937.”Labor History, Vol. 16, No. 1 (Winter), pp. 5–36.
82.
SchatzRonald. 1979. “Union Pioneers: The Founders of Local Unions at General Electric and Westinghouse, 1933–1937.”Journal of American History, Vol. 66, pp. 586–602.
83.
SchatzRonald. 1983. The Electrical Workers: A History of Labor at General Electric and Westinghouse, 1923–1960. Urbana: University of Illinois Press.
84.
ShleiferAndreiSummersLawrence. 1988. “Breach of Trust in Hostile Takeovers.” In AuerbachAlan J., ed., Corporate Takeovers: Causes and Consequences. Chicago: University of Chicago Press, pp. 33–56.
85.
SlichterSumner. 1929. “The Current Labor Policies of American Industries.”Quarterly Journal of Economics, Vol. 43, No. 2 (May), pp. 393–435.
86.
ToneAndrea. 1997. The Business of Benevolence: Industrial Paternalism in Progressive America. Ithaca, N.Y.: Cornell University Press.
87.
U.S. Department of Labor, Bureau of Labor Statistics. 1919. Bulletin No. 250: Welfare Work for Employees in Industrial Establishments in the United States. Washington, D.C.: Government Printing Office.
88.
U.S. Department of Labor, Bureau of Labor Statistics. 1928. Bulletin No. 458: Health and Recreation Activities in Industrial Establishments, 1926. Washington, D.C.: Government Printing Office.
89.
U.S. Senate, Committee on Education and Labor. 1937. Industrial Espionage. Report No. 46, Part 3, 75th Congress, 2nd Session. Washington, D.C.: Government Printing Office.
90.
VallasSteven P.1993. Power in the Workplace: The Politics of Production at AT&T. Albany: State University of New York.
91.
VallettaRobert. 1999. “Declining Job Security.”Journal of Labor Economics, Vol. 17, No. 4, Part 2, pp. S170–S197.
92.
WeberArnold. 1959. “Competitive Unionism in the Chemical Industry.”Industrial and Labor Relations Review, Vol. 13, No. 1 (October), pp. 16–37.
93.
WiseGeorge. Undated. “General Electric's Century: A History of the General Electric Company from Its Origins to 1986.” Unpublished manuscript.
94.
YoungClarenceTuttleRobert. 1969. The Years 1919–1969: A History of General Motors Institute. Flint, Mich.: General Motors Institute.
95.
ZahaviGerald. 1988. Workers, Managers, and Welfare Capitalism: The Shoeworkers and Tanners of Endicott Johnson, 1890–1950. Urbana: University of Illinois Press.
