This article looks at the impact of citizenship acquisition on the labour market position of immigrants in Belgium. Citizenship is open to all immigrants with a sufficient period of legal residence, without any language or integration requirements. In that respect, this study is an important complement to existing studies which have mostly focused on countries with strict acquisition rules. Based on Labour Force Survey data for 2008, this study uses probit regression to estimate the static and dynamic employment probabilities and unemployment risks. We find that citizenship acquisition is associated with better labour market outcomes for non-Western immigrants in general. This effect remains after controlling for years of residence since migration, indicating the existence of a citizenship premium in Belgium.
BevelanderPPendakurR (2009) Citizenship, co-ethnic populations and employment probabilities of immigrants in Sweden. IZA Discussion Paper Series 4495, IZA, Bonn.
2.
BevelanderPVeenmanJ (2006) Naturalization and employment integration of Turkish and Moroccan immigrants in the Netherlands. Journal of International Migration and Integration7(3): 327–349.
3.
BorjasG (1995) The economic benefits of immigration. Journal of Economic Perspectives9(2): 3–22.
4.
BratsbergBRaganJFNasirZM (2002) The effect of naturalization on wage growth: A panel study of young male immigrants. Journal of Labour Economics20: 568–597.
5.
CECFR (2008) Toegang tot het grondgebied en internationale bescherming. Jaarrapport 2008, CECFR, Brussels, 18–37.
6.
ChiswickB (1978) The effect of Americanization on the earnings of foreign-born men. The Journal of Political Economy86: 897–921.
7.
CorluyVVerbistG (2010) Inkomens- en arbeidsmarktpositie van migranten in België. Over.Werk4: 85–90.
8.
DeVoretzD (2006) The economics of citizenship: A common intellectual ground for social scientists?IZA Discussion Paper Series 2392, IZA, Bonn.
9.
DevoretzDJPivnenkoS (2008) The economic determinants and consequences of Canadian citizenship ascension. In: BevelanderPDevoretzDJ (eds) The Economics of Citizenship. Malmö: Holmbergs, 21–62.
10.
DuguetELeandriNL’HortyY. (2007) Discriminations à l’embauche: Un testing sur les jeunes des banlieues d’Île-de-France. Rapports et documents, Centre d’analyse stratégique, Paris.
11.
DustmannCGlitzAVogelT (2009) Employment, wages, and the economic cycle: Differences between immigrants and natives. IZA Discussion Paper Series 4432, IZA, Bonn.
12.
EuwalsRDagevosJGijsbertsM. (2010) Citizenship and labour market position: Turkish immigrants in Germany and the Netherlands. International Migration Review44(3): 513–538.
13.
FleischmannFDronkersJ (2007) The effects of social and labour market policies of EU-countries on the socio-economic integration of first and second generation immigrants from different countries of origin. EUI Working Papers 19, Robert Schuman Centre for Advanced Studies, Florence.
14.
FougèreDSafiM (2009) Naturalization and employment of immigrants in France (1968–1999). International Journal of Manpower30(1/2): 83–96.
15.
GeddesANiessenJ (2007) European Civic Citizenship and Inclusion Index. Brussels: British Council.
16.
HuddlestonT (2010) Promoting citizenship: The choices for immigrants, advocates, and European cooperation. In: Zapata-BarreroR (ed.) Citizenship Policies in the Age of Diversity. Europe at the Crossroads. Barcelona: CIDOB Foundation, 157–172.
17.
JuradoE (2008) Citizenship: Tool or reward? The role of citizenship policy in the process of integration. Policy network paper, Policy network, London.
18.
KelejianH (1973) Two-stage least squares and econometric systems linear in parameters but nonlinear in the endogenous variable. Journal of the American Statistical Association66: 373–374.
19.
KoganI (2003) Ex-Jugoslavs in the Austrian and Swedish labour markets: The significance of period of migration and the effect of citizenship acquisition. Journal of Ethnic and Migration Studies29: 595–622.
20.
KoganI (2006) Labour markets and economic incorporation among recent immigrants in Europe.Social Forces85(2): 697–721.
21.
MazzolariF (2009) Dual citizenship rights: Do they make more and richer citizens?Demography46: 169–191.
22.
MincerJPolachekS (1974) Family investments in human capital: Earnings of women. Journal of Political Economy84: 76–108.
23.
MünzR (2008) Migration, labour markets and integration of immigrants: An overview for Europe. Economic Department Working Papers 284, OECD, Paris.
24.
MusscheNCorluyVMarxI (2010) Satisfying Labour Demand through Migration in Belgium.Brussels: Belgian Contactpoint for European Migration Network.
25.
NeelsK (2000) Education and the transition to employment: Young Turkish and Moroccan adults in Belgium. In: LesthaegeR (ed.) Communities and Generations. Brussels: VUB, 279–320.
26.
OECD (2010) Naturalization and the labour market integration of immigrants. In: Migration Outlook 2010. Paris: OECD, 158–187.
27.
ReyneriEFullinG (2008) New immigration and labour markets in Western Europe: A trade-off between employment and job quality?Transfer14(4): 573–588.
28.
ScottK (2008) The economics of citizenship: Is there a naturalization effect? In: BevelanderPDevoretzDJ (eds) The Economics of Citizenship. Malmö: Holmbergs, 105–126.
29.
SteinhardtMF (2008) Does citizenship matter? The economic impact of naturalizations in Germany. HWWI research paper 3-13, HWWI, Hamburg.
30.
VDAB (2004) Fatima of Sil, een wereld van verschil. Een vergelijkend onderzoek naar de slaagkansen op de arbeidsmarkt tussen etnisch E.U. en allochtone schoolverlaters. ArbeidsmarktTopic 2, VDAB, Brussels.
31.
YangQP (1994) Explaining immigrant naturalization. International Migration Review28(3): 449–477.
