Recurring Cost Minimization of Composite Laminated Structures – Optimum Part Size as a Function of Learning Curve Effects and Assembly

Abstract

The cost of a laminated composite plate is examined in detail. The fabrication process is broken out into individual steps and simple equations to estimate the cost on the basis of part size and complexity are developed. The option to divide the plate into modulesisals o included in the approach. The effectsof learning curve and assembly are also incorporated. The cost equations developed are implemented in a simple optimization algorithm that minimizes the fabrication cost as a function of module size, overall plate size, thickness, learning curve, and fastener type and spacing. It isfound that there isa range of valuesfor these parametersfor which the total cost of the plate is lower if it is made by assembling smaller identical modules instead of making it in a single piece. There is a module size that minimizes the total fabrication and assembly cost and results in cost values significantly lower than the cost of the plate if it were fabricated in one piece. The modular approach is also compared to an approach where the plate is made of pieces optimized locally for minimum weight based on local applied loads. The cost of the plate made by identical modules (at the optimum size found by the analysis) is found to be lower than that for a plate assembled with pieces each of which is optimized for weight. On the other hand, the weight of the plate made by identical modulesishigher than the weight of the plate made by assembling pieces locally optimized for weight.

References

1. McGettrick, M. and Abbott, R. (1993). To MRB or not to be: intrinsic manufacturing variabilitiesand effectson load carrying capacity. In: Proceedings of 10th DoD/NASA/FAA Conference on Fibrous Composites in Structural Design. Vol. 1. Hilton Head, SC. 1–4 Nov. pp. 5–39.

2. Phillips, E.H. (1996). Robotics key to curbing premier 1 production costs. Aviation Week & Space Technology. July. pp. 54-54.

3. Mabson, G.E. , Flynn, B.W. , Ilcewicz, L.B. and Graesser, D.L. (1994). The use of COSTADE in developing composite commercial aircraft fuselage structures. In: Proceedings of 35th AIAA/ ASME/ASCE/AHS/ASC Structures, Structural Dynamics and Materials Conference. Hilton Head, SC. AIAA Paper 94-1492.

4. Olson, J.T. , Smith, P.J. and Ilcewicz, L.B. (1991). Advanced composite fuselage technology. In: Proceedings of 8th DoD/NASA/FAA Conference on Fibrous Composites in Structural Design. Lake Tahoe, NV.

5. Kassapoglou, C. (1997). Simultaneous cost and weight minimization of composite stiffened panels under compression and shear. Composites Part A, 419–435.

6. Kassapoglou, C. (1999). Minimum cost and weight design of fuselage frames, Part A: design constraints and manufacturing process characteristics. Composites Part A, 887–894.

7. Kassapoglou, C. (1999). Minimum cost and weight design of fuselage frames, Part B: cost considerations, optimization and results. Composites Part A, 895–904.

8. Kassapoglou, C. and Dobyns, A. (2001). Simultaneous cost and weight minimization of postbuckled composite panels under combined compression and shear. Journal of Structural and Multidisciplinary Optimization, 372–382.

9. Gutowski, T. , Hoult, D. , Dillon, G. , Muter, S. , Kim, E. , Tse, M. and Neoh, E.-T. (1993). Development of a theoretical cost model for advanced composite fabrication. 4th Advanced Composites Technology Conference. Salt Lake City, UT.

10.

10. Structural Composites Fabrication Guide DoD/NASA, 2nd Edn. 1979.

11.

11. Apostolopoulos, P. (2000). Cost minimization for aircraft using composite materials. Master’s Thesis, Department of Physics, Aristotle University of Thessaloniki.

12.

12. Sarh, B. (1985). Robotic applicationsto automated composite aircraft component manufacturing. SAMPE Symposium, Paper MF 85-506.

13.

13. Ostwald, P.F. (1992). Engineering Cost Estimating, 3d Fd, Prentice Hall.

14.

14. Whitney, J.M. (1987). Structural analysis of laminated anisotropic plates. Technomic Publishing Co. pp. 117-117.

15.

15. Willden, K.S. , Gessel, M. , Davies, T. , Mabson, G.E. , Grant, C.G. , and Brown, T.S. (1993). Fuselage Crown Manufacturing Technology Verification, Fourth NASA Advanced Composites Technology Conference, Salt Lake City, UT.

16.

16. Gutowski, T. , Haffner, S. and Martin, T. (2001). Cost Elements of Autoclave Tooling, NSF, DMII Grantees Conference, Tampa, FL.