Limit of Resolution of Flow Cytometry for the Detection of Selected Bacterial Species

Abstract

The enumeration of bacteria in dental plaque samples is a vital but time-consuming procedure that uses standard cultural methods. Flow cytometry has proven to be a useful tool for the analysis of eukaryotic cells. In the present investigation, the utility of this technology for the enumeration of bacteria in mixtures was explored. Rabbit antisera were produced against the putative periodontal pathogens A. actinomycetemcomitans, B. intermedius, B. gingivalis, E. corrodens, W. recta, B. forsythus, as well as the frequently isolated supragingival species S. sanguis. Cross-reactive antibodies were removed by absorption, and the specificity of each antiserum was confirmed by being tested against a panel of 235 oral microbial strains (79 genera; 94 species) by means of ELISA. Conditions were established for the indirect immunofluorescent labeling of cells without agglutination with use of a goat anti-rabbit Ig-FITC second antibody. When an internal bead standard was used, it was found that unstained bacteria were enumerated by light-scattering parameters with poor efficiency (<3%). However, cells exposed to FITC either in the presence of specific or nonspecific first antibody were enumerated with high efficiency (102.6±29.3%), indicating that a small amount of non-specific binding of fluorochrome facilitates bacterial detection. Clear discrimination between specifically- and non-specifically-stained bacteria was achieved with all six rabbit antisera. Mixtures of known composition were made (1) with pure cultures or (2) with a known species and supragingival plaque devoid of that species by culture. The results from both approaches with various species combinations revealed that the limit of resolution for accurate quantitation of a selected species was approximately 5%, although specific organisms could be detected qualitatively when present at approximately 1%.

References

Alexander, M.K. ; Khan, M.S. ; and Dow, C.S. (1981): Rapid Screening for Bacteriuria Using a Particle Counter, Pulse Height Analyzer, and Computer, J Clin Pathol 34:194-198.

Arndt-Jovin, D.J. and Jovin, T.M. (1978): Automated Cell Sorting with Flow Systems, Ann Rev Biophys Bioeng 7:527-558.

Bailey, J.E. ; Fazel-Madjlessi, D.N. ; McQuitty, D.N. ; Lee, L.Y. ; Alred, J.C. ; and Oro, J.A. (1977): Characterization of Bacterial Growth by Means of Microfluorometry, Science 198 :1175-1176.

Baker, J.S. ; Ederer, G.M. ; and Mundschenk, D. (1983): Particle Size Distribution Analysis as a Rapid Detection of Significant Bacteruria, Med Tech 49:727-732.

Barnett, J.M. ; Cuchens, M.A. ; and Buchanan, W. (1984): Automated Immunofluorescent Speciation of Oral Bacteria Using Flow Cytometry, J Dent Res 63:1040-1042.

Dow, C.S. ; France, C.S. ; Khan, M.S. ; and Johnson, T. (1979): Particle Size Distribution for the Rapid Detection of Microbial Infection of Urine, J Clin Pathol 32:386-390.

Dzink, J.L. ; Smith, C. ; and Socransky, S.S. (1984): Semi-automated Technique for the Identification of Subgingival Isolates, J Clin Microbiol 19:599-605.

Dzink, J.L. ; Socransky, S.S. ; and Haffajee, A.D. (1988): The Predominant Cultivable Microbiota of Active and Inactive Lesions of Destructive Periodontal Disease, J Clin Periodontol 15:161-168.

Ebersole, J.L. ; Frey, D.E. ; Taubman, M.A. ; Smith, D.J. ; Socransky, S.S. ; and Tanner, A.C.R. (1984): Serological Identification of Bacteroides spp. by Enzyme-Linked Immunosorbent Assay, J Clin Microbiol 19:639-644.

10.

Herzenberg, L.A. ; Sweet, R.G. ; and Herzenberg, L.A. (1976): Fluorescence-Activated Cell Sorting, Scientific American 234:108-117.

11.

Kornman, K.S. ; Patters, M. ; Kiel, R. ; and Marucha, P. (1984): Detection and Quantitation of Bacteroides gingivalis in Bacterial Mixtures by Means of Flow Cytometry, J Periodont Res 19:570-573.

12.

Lambe, D.W. and Moroz, D. (1976): Serogrouping of Bacteroides fragilis subsp. fragilis by the Agglutination Test, J Clin Microbiol 3:586-592.

13.

Malamed, M. ; Mullaney, P. ; and Mendelsohn, M. (1979): Flow Cytometry and Cell Sorting, New York: John Wiley & Sons, Inc., pp. 1-17.

14.

Moore, W.E.C. ; Holdeman, L.V. ; Cato, E.P. ; Smibert, R.M. ; Burmeister, J.A. ; Palcanis, K.G. ; and Ranney, R.R. (1982a): Bacteriology of Moderate (Chronic) Periodontitis in Mature Adult Humans, Infect Immun 42:510-515.

15.

Moore, W.E.C. ; Holdeman, L.V. ; Cato, E.P. ; Smibert, R.M. ; Burmeister, J.A. ; and Ranney, R.R. (1982b): Bacteriology of Severe Gingivitis in Young Adult Humans, Infect Immun 38:1137-1148.

16.

Mouton, C. ; Reynolds, H. ; and Genco, R.J. (1978): Combined Micromanipulation, Culture, and Immunofluorescent Techniques of the Coccal Organisms Comprising the "Corn Cob" Configuration of Human Dental Plaque, J Biol Buccale 5 :321-332.

17.

Muldrow, L.L. ; Tyndall, R.L. ; and Filersmans, C.B. (1982): Application of Flow Cytometry to Studies of Pathogenic Free-living Amoeba, Appl Environ Microbiol 44:1258-1269.

18.

Paau, A.S. ; Cowles, J.R. ; and Oro, J.A. (1977): Flow Microfluorometric Analysis of Escherichia coli, Rhizobium meliloti, and Rhizobium japonicum at Different Stages in the Growth Cycle, Can J Microbiol 23:1165-1169.

19.

Phillips, A.P. and Martin, K.L. (1983): Immunofluorescence Analysis of Bacillus Spores and Vegetable Cells by Flow Cytometry, Cytometry 4:123-131.

20.

Phillips, A.P. and Martin, K.L. (1988): Limitations of Flow Cytometry for the Specific Detection of Bacteria in Mixed Populations, J Immunol Methods 106:109-117.

21.

Salanitro, J.P. and Muirhead, P.A. (1975): Quantitative Method for the Gas Chromatographic Analysis of Short-chain Monocarboxylic and Dicarboxylic Acids in Fermentation Media, Appl Microbiol 29:374-381.

22.

Slots, J. (1982): Importance of Black-pigmented Bacteroides in Human Periodontal Disease. In: Host-parasite Interactions in Periodontal Diseases, R.J. Genco and S.E. Mergenhagen , Eds., Washington, D.C. : American Society for Microbiology, pp. 27-45.

23.

Smither, R. (1977): Rapid Screening for Significant Bacteriuria Using a Coulter Counter, J Clin Pathol 30:1158-1162.

24.

Socransky, S.S. ; Dzink, J.L. ; and Smith, C.L. (1985): Chemically-defined Medium for Oral Organisms, J Clin Microbiol 22:303-305.

25.

Socransky, S.S. ; Tanner, A.C.R. ; Goodson, J.M. ; Haffajee, A.D. ; Walker, C.B. ; Ebersole, J.L. ; and Sorn-Berger, G.C. (1982): An Approach to the Definition of Periodontal Disease Syndromes by Cluster Analysis, J Clin Periodontol 9:460-471.

26.

Steen, H.B. and Boye, E. (1980): Bacterial Growth Studied by Flow Cytometry, Cytometry 1:32-36.

27.

Steen, H.G. ; Boye, E. ; Skarstad, K. ; Bloom, B. ; Godal, T. ; and Mustafa, S. (1982): Applications of Flow Cytometry on Bacteria: Cell Kinetics, Drug Effects, and Quantitation of Antibody Binding, Cytometry 2:249-257.

28.

Tanner, A.C.R. ; Listgarten, M.A. ; Ebersole, J.L. ; and Strzempko, M.N. (1986): Bacteroides forsythus sp. nov., A Slow Growing, Fusiform Bacteroides sp. from the Human Oral Cavity, Int J System Bacteriol 36:213-221.