Maximum Likelihood Estimates for the Lifetime of Bonded Dental Prostheses

Abstract

Clinical studies measuring the lifetime of dental prostheses produce censored data when not all specimens have failed during the course of the study. Such clinical data can be analyzed by the Weibull probability distribution function. Algorithms are presented that provide the maximum likelihood estimates of the distribution's parameters. These parameters are the characteristic lifetime (time to failure for 63% of the specimens of the total sample) and the Weibull or shape parameter. Two iterative methods for solving the maximum likelihood equations are given. These mathematical methods have been applied to the results from a retrospective clinical investigation into the lifetime assessment of resin-bonded prostheses. This study evaluated 164 resin-bonded prostheses (for 146 patients) placed between January, 1980, and May, 1985. To date (April, 1995), 47 prostheses (29%) have failed with a median time in service of 74 months (6.2 yr). For the surviving prostheses, the median time in service is 123 months (10.3 yr) and still increasing. The maximum likelihood estimate of the characteristic lifetime for these restorations is 255 months (21.3 yr). Differences in the characteristic lifetime were observed between prostheses placed anteriorly, 338 months (28 yr), and posteriorly, 207 months (17 yr). Since there are no rigorous confidence intervals for deeply censored samples, only provisional confidence bounds could be determined, which substantiated the observed differences. The Weibull modulus value of 1.5 indicates that the probability of failure for resin-bonded prostheses begins to decrease after 10 years in service.

Keywords

survival analysis bridges (resin-bonded)clinical trials statistics.

References

Barrack G. , Bretz WA (1993). A long-term prospective study of the etched-cast restoration. Int J Prosthodont 6:428-434.

Boyer DB , Williams VD , Thayer KE , Denehy GE , Diaz-Arnold AM (1993). Analysis of debond rates of resin-bonded prostheses . J Dent Res 72:1244-1248.

Cohen AC (1965). Maximum likelihood estimation in the Weibull distribution based on complete and on censored samples. Technometrics 7:579-588.

Creugers NHJ , Kayser AF , van 't Hof MA (1992). A seven-and-a-half-year survival study of resin-bonded bridges. J Dent Res 71:1822-1825.

Creugers NHJ , Kayser AF , van 't Hof MA (1994). A meta-analysis of durability data on conventional fixed bridges. Commitnity Dent Oral Epidemiol 22:448-452.

Hansson O. , Moberg L-E. (1992). Clinical evaluation of resin-bonded prostheses . Int J Prosthodont 5:533-541.

Kaplan EL , Meier P. (1958). Nonparametric estimation from incomplete observations . J Am Stat Soc 53:457-481.

Lawless JF (1982). Statistical models and methods for lifetime data . New York: John Wiley and Sons .

Mann NR , Shafer RE , Singpurwalla ND (1974). Methods for statistical analysis of reliability and life data. New York: John Wiley and Sons.

10.

Natrella MG (1969). The relation between confidence intervals and test significance. In: Precision measurement and calibration, statistical concepts and procedures. Ku HH , editor. NBS Special Pub 300. Vol. 1, No. 003-003-00072-8 . Washington, DC: US Government Printing Office.

11.

Rammelsberg P. , Pospiech P. , Gernet W. (1993). Clinical factors affecting adhesive fixed partial dentures: a 6 year study. J Prosthet Dent 70:300-307.

12.

Rust SW , Rice RC ( 1985). Statistical distributions. In: Metals handbook®. Vol. 8. Mechanical testing. Metals Park, OH : ASTM Handbook Committee, American Society for Testing and Materials.

13.

Saunders SC , Mann NR ( 1985). Weibull parameter estimates for failure data. Conference on the statistical treatment of data. NBS, Oct 11-13, 1985.

14.

Smales RJ , Berekally TL , Webster DA (1993). Predictions of resin-bonded bridge survivals, comparing two statistical models. J Dent 21:147-149.

15.

Thoman DR , Bain LJ , Antle CE (1969). Inferences on the parameters of the Weibull distribution . Technometrics 11:445-460.

16.

Thompson VP , de Rijk WG (1989). Clinical evaluation and lifetime predictions for resin-bonded prostheses. In: Quality evaluation of dental restorations. Criteria for placement and replacement. Anusavice KJ , editor. Chicago: Quintessence Publishing Co.