This article examines the hypothesis that citizens' perceptions of injustice are based on normative factors (i.e., perceptions of equity and fairness) rather than instrumental factors (i.e., the outcomes received) by examining citizens'perceptions of injustice after traffic stops by police. The factors that predict citizens'perceptions of injustice are assessed using data collected for the Bureau of Justice Statistics (BJS)–sponsored Police-Public Contact Survey, a national survey of citizens regarding their contacts with police, collected in 1999. Using multinomial logistic regression, the influences of the normative and instrumental perspectives are examined while controlling for citizens' characteristics and race-interaction terms, along with legal, situational, and other control variables. The findings support Tyler's proposition that citizens are concerned with issues of fairness in addition to the actual outcomes they receive from criminal-justice officials. The findings also show significant differences in citizens' perceptions of distributive and procedural injustice by race. The implications for policy and future research are explored.
Albrecht, Stan L. and Miles Green. 1977. “Attitudes toward the Police and the Larger Attitude Complex. Implications for Police-Community Relationships.”Criminology15 (1): 67-86.
2.
Aristotle. [ca. 322 B.C.] 2000. “TheVariousTypes of Justice.” Nicomachean Ethics. Pp. 35-44 in What Is Justice? Classic and Contemporary Readings, 2d ed, edited by Robert C. Soloman and Mark C. Murphy. Reprint, New York: Oxford University Press.
3.
Bayley, David H. and Harold Mendelsohn. 1969. Minorities and the Police. New York: Free Press.
4.
Bentham, Jeremy. [1789] 2000. “A Utilitarian Theory of Punishment.” Introduction to the Principles of Morals and Legislation. Pp. 215-220 in What Is Justice? Classic and Contemporary Readings, 2d ed., edited by Robert C. Soloman and Mark C. Murphy. Reprint, New York: Oxford University Press.
5.
Bernard, Thomas J. and Robin S. Engel. 2001. “Conceptualizing Criminal Justice Theory.”Justice Quarterly18:1-30.
6.
Biderman, Albert, James P. Lynch, and James Petersen. 1991. Understanding Crime Incidence Statistics: Why the UCR Diverges from the NCS. New York: Springer Verlag.
7.
Bordua, David J. and Larry L. Tifft. 1971. “Citizen Interviews, Organizational Feedback, and Police-Community Relations Decisions.”Law and Society Review6:155-182.
8.
Brandl, Steven G., James Frank, Robert E. Worden, and Timothy S. Bynum. 1994. “Global and Specific Attitudes toward the Police: Disentangling the Relationship.”Justice Quarterly11:119-134.
9.
Brewer, Kenneth R. W. and RobertW. Mellor. 1973. “The Effect of Sample Structure on Analytical Surveys.”Austrian Journal of Statistics15:145-152.
10.
Browning, Sandra L., Francis T. Cullen, Liqun Cao, Renee Kopache, and Thomas J. Stevenson. 1994. “Race and Getting Hassled by the Police: AResearch Note.”Police Studies17:1-11.
11.
Carter, David L.1983. “Hispanic Interaction with the Criminal Justice System in Texas: Experiences, Attitudes, and Perceptions.”Journal of Criminal Justice11:213-227.
12.
Decker, Scott. 1981. “Citizen Attitudes toward the Police: A Review of Past Findings and Suggestions for Future Research.”Journal of Police Science and Administration9:80-87.
13.
DuMouchel, William H. and Greg J. Duncan. 1983. “Using Sample SurveyWeights in Multiple Regression Analyses of Stratified Samples.”Journal of the American Statistical Association78:535-543.
14.
Dunham, Roger G. and Geoffrey P. Alpert. 1988. “Neighborhood Differences in Attitudes toward Policing: Evidence for a Mixed-Strategy Model of Policing in a Multi-Ethnic Setting.”The Journal of Criminal Law & Criminology79:504-523.
15.
Eisenstein, James H. and Herbert Jacob. 1977. Felony Justice: An Organizational Analysis of Criminal Courts. Boston: Little, Brown.
16.
Engel, Robin S.2001. “Examining the Influence of Citizens'Race during Traffic Stops: Results from a National Survey.”Presentation at ICPSR summerworkshop, Quantitative Analysis of Crime and Criminal Justice, July, Ann Arbor, MI.
17.
Engel, Robin S.2003. “Explaining Suspects' Resistance and Demeanor toward Police.”Journal of Criminal Justice31:475-492.
18.
Engel, Robin S. and Jennifer M. Calnon. 2004. “Examining the Influence of Drivers' Characteristics duringTraffic Stops with Police: Results from a National Survey.”Justice Quarterly21 (1): 49-90.
19.
Engel, Robin S., Jennifer M. Calnon, and Thomas J. Bernard. 2002. “Theory and Racial Profiling: Shortcomings and Future Directions in Research.”Justice Quarterly9 (2): 249-273.
20.
Engel, R. S., J. M. Calnon, L. Liu, and R. R. Johnson. 2004. Project on Police-Citizen Contacts, Year 1 Final Report. Report submitted to the Pennsylvania State Police, Harrisburg, PA.
21.
Engels, Friedrich. [1878] 2000. “Against Arm-Chair Justice.” Anti-Duhring.P. 175-175 in What Is Justice? Classic and Contemporary Readings, 2d ed., edited by Robert C. Soloman and Mark C. Murphy. Reprint, New York: Oxford University Press.
22.
Feeley, Malcolm M.1973. “Two Models of the Criminal Justice System: An Organizational Perspective.”Law & Society Review7:407-425.
23.
Frank, James, Steven G. Brandl, Francis T. Cullen, and Amy Stichman. 1994. “Reassessing the Impact of Race on Citizens' Attitudes toward the Police: A Research Note.”Justice Quarterly13:321-334.
24.
Fridell, Lorie. 2004. By the Numbers: A Guide for Analyzing Race Data from Vehicle Stops. Washington, DC: Police Executive Research Forum.
25.
Furstenberg, Frank F., Jr. and Charles F. Wellford. 1973. “Calling the Police: The Evaluation of Police Service.”Law and Society Review7:393-406.
26.
Gottfredson, Michael R. and Don M. Gottfredson. 1988. Decision Making in Criminal Justice, toward the Rational Exercise of Discretion, 2d ed.New York: Plenum.
27.
Harris, David A.1999. “The Stories, the Statistics, and the Law: Why ‘Driving While Black' Matters.”Minnesota Law Review84:265-326.
28.
Hersey, Paul and Kenneth Blanchard. 1988. Management of Organizational Behavior, 5th ed.Englewood Cliffs, NJ: Prentice Hall.
29.
Hobbes, Thomas. [1651] 2000. “The State of Nature and the Laws of Nature.” Leviathan. Pp. 63-73 in What Is Justice? Classic and Contemporary Readings, 2d ed., edited Robert C. Soloman and Mark C. Murphy. Reprint, New York: Oxford University Press.
30.
Homer. [ca. 800 B.C.] 2000. “Agamemnon's Plea for Justice.” Iliad. Pp. 13-14 in What Is Justice? Classic and Contemporary Readings, 2d ed., edited Robert C. Soloman and Mark C. Murphy. Reprint, New York: Oxford University Press.
31.
Hurst, Yolander G. and James Frank. 2000. “How Kids View Cops. The Nature of Juvenile Attitudes toward the Police.”Journal of Criminal Justice28:189-202.
32.
Jacob, Herbert. 1971. “Black and White Perceptions of Justice in the City.”Law & Society Review6:69-89.
33.
Jesilow, Paul, J'ona Meyer, and Nazi Namazzi. 1995. “Public Attitudes toward the Police.”American Journal of Police14:67-88.
34.
Kennedy, Randall. 1997. Race, Crime, and the Law. New York: Pantheon Books.
35.
Langan, Patrick A., Lawrence A. Greenfeld, StevenK. Smith, Matthew R. Dunrose and David J. Levin. 2001. Contacts between Police and the Public, Findings form the 1999 National Survey. Washington, DC: Department of Justice, Office of Justice Programs, Bureau of Justice Statistics.
36.
Lasley, James R.1994. “The Impact of the Rodney King Incident on Citizen Attitudes toward Police.”Policing and Society3:245-255.
37.
Liao, T. F.1994. Interpreting Probability Models: Logit, Probit, and other Generalized Linear Models. Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage.
38.
Locke, John. [1690] 2000. “The State of Nature and the Social Contract. SecondTreatise of Government.” Pp. 74-80, 133-136 in What Is Justice? Classic and Contemporary Readings, 2d ed., edited Robert C. Soloman and Mark C. Murphy. Reprint, New York: Oxford University Press.
39.
Lohr, Sharon L.1999. Sampling: Design and Analysis. Pacific Grove, CA: Duxbury Press, International Thomson Publishing.
40.
Lundman, Richard J.2004. “Driver Race, Ethnicity, and Gender and Citizen Reports of Vehicle Searches by Police and Vehicle Search Hits: Toward a Triangulated Scholarly Understanding.”Journal of Criminal Law & Criminology94 (2): 309-349.
41.
Lundman, Richard J. and Robert L. Kaufman2003. “Driving While Black: Effects of Race, Ethnicity, and Gender on Citizen Self-Reports ofTraffic Stops and Police Actions.”Criminology41:195-220.
42.
Lynch, James P.2002. “Using Citizen Surveys to Produce Information on the Police: The Present and Potential Uses of the National CrimeVictimization Survey.”Justice Research andPolicy4:62-69.
43.
MacIntyre, Alasdair. 1984. After Virtue: A Study in Moral Theory, 2d ed.South Bend, IN: University of Notre Dame Press.
44.
Marongiu, Pietro and GraemeNewman. 1987. Vengeance. Lanham, MD: Rowman& Littlefield.
45.
Marx, Karl. [1875] 2000. “From Each According to His Needs.” Critique of the Gotha Programme. Pp. 176-180 in What Is Justice? Classic and Contemporary Readings, 2d ed., edited Robert C. Soloman and Mark C. Murphy. Reprint, New York: Oxford University Press.
46.
Mastrofski, Stephen D., Jeffrey B. Snipes, and Anne E. Supina. 1996. “Compliance on Demand: The Public's Response to Specific Police Requests.”Journal of Research on Crime and Delinquency33:269-305.
47.
Nagel, Thomas. 1973. “Rawls on Justice.”Philosophical Review82:220-234.
48.
Nozick, Robert. 1974. Anarchy, State, and Utopia. New York: Basic Books.
49.
Okin, Susan M.1989. Justice, Gender, and the Family. New York: Basic Books.
50.
Packer, Herbert L.1968. Limits of the Criminal Process. Stanford, CA: Stanford University Press.
51.
Plato. [ca. 380 B.C.] 2000. “Justice in the State and in the Soul.” Republic. Pp. 21-34 in What Is Justice? Classic and Contemporary Readings, 2d ed., edited Robert C. Soloman and Mark C. Murphy. Reprint, New York: Oxford University Press.
52.
Police Foundation. 2001. Racial Profiling: The State of the Law!Washington, DC: Author.
53.
Ramirez, D., McDevitt, J., and Farrell, A.2000. A Resource Guide on Racial Profiling Data Collection Systems: Promising Practices and Lessons Learned. Washington, DC: Department of Justice.
54.
Rawls, John. 1971. A Theory of Justice. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.
55.
Rawls, John. 1999. A Theory of Justice, Rev. ed.Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.
56.
Reisig, Michael D. and Roger B. Parks. 2000. “Experience, Quality of Life, and Neighborhood Context: AHierarchical Analysis of Satisfaction with Police.”Justice Quarterly17:607-630.
57.
Rousseau, Jean-Jacques. [1754] 2000. “From the State of Nature to Citizenship.” A Discourse on the Origins of Inequality. Pp. 81-89What Is Justice? Classic and Contemporary Readings, 2d ed., edited Robert C. Soloman and Mark C. Murphy. Reprint, New York: Oxford University Press.
58.
Rousseau, Jean-Jacques. [1762] 2000. Onthe Social Contract. Pp. 89-94 in What Is Justice? Classic and Contemporary Readings, 2d ed., edited Robert C. Soloman and Mark C. Murphy. Reprint, NewYork: Oxford University Press.
59.
Sandel, Michael J.1982. Liberalism and the Limits of Justice. New York: Cambridge University Press.
60.
Sampson, Robert J. and Dawn J. Bartusch. 1998. “Legal Cynicism and (Subcultural?) Tolerance of Deviance: The Neighborhood Context of Racial Differences.”Law & Society Review32:777-804.
61.
Scaglion, Richard and Richard G. Condon. 1980a. “Determinants of Attitudes toward City Police.”Criminology17:485-494.
62.
Scaglion, Richard and Richard G. Condon. 1980b. “The Structure of Black and White Attitudes toward Police.”Human Organization39:280-283.
63.
Scheingold, Stuart A.1991. The Politics of Street Crime, Criminal Process and Cultural Obsession. Philadelphia: Temple University Press.
64.
Smith, Adam. [1759] 2000. “Justice As a Moral Sentiment.” A Theory of the Moral Sentiments. Pp. 143-147What Is Justice? Classic and Contemporary Readings, 2d ed., edited Robert C. Soloman and Mark C. Murphy. Reprint, New York: Oxford University Press.
65.
Smith, Adam. [1776] 2000. “TheVirtues of the Free Market.” TheWealth of Nations. Pp. 148-151What Is Justice? Classic and Contemporary Readings, 2d ed., edited Robert C. Soloman and Mark C. Murphy. Reprint, New York: Oxford University Press.
66.
Smith, Paul E. and Richard O. Hawkins. 1973.“Victimization, Types of Citizen-Police Contacts, and Attitudes toward the Police.”Law and Society Review8:135-152.
67.
Smith, William R., Don Tomaskovic-Devey, Marcy Mason, Matthew T. Zingraff, Cheryl Chambers, Patricia Warren, and Cynthia Wright. 2000. “Driving While Black: Establishing a Baseline of Driver Behavior by Measuring Driving Speed and Demographic Characteristics.” Unpublished manuscript, North Carolina State University.
68.
Soloman, Robert C. and Mark C. Murphy, eds. 2000. What Is Justice? Classic and Contemporary Readings, 2d ed.New York: Oxford University Press.
69.
Strom, K. J., Brien, P., and Smith, S.2001. Traffic Stop Data Collection Policies for State Police, 2001(NCJ 191158). Washington, DC: Bureau of Justice Statistics, Department of Justice.
70.
Sullivan, Peggy S., Roger G. Dunham, and Geoffrey P. Alpert. 1987. “Attitude Structures of Different Ethnic and Age Groups Concerning Police.”The Journal of Criminal Law & Criminology78:177-196.
71.
Sykes, Richard E. and John P. Clark. 1975. “A Theory of Deference Exchange in Police-Citizen Encounters.”American Journal of Sociology81:584-600.
72.
Taylor, Terrance J., K. B. Turner, Finn-Aage Esbensen, and L. Thomas Winfree, Jr.2001. “Coppin' an Attitude. Attitudinal Differences among Juveniles toward Police.”Journal of Criminal Justice29:295-305.
73.
Tedeschi, James T. and Richard B. Felson. 1994. Violence, Aggression, & Coercive Actions. Washington, DC: American Psychological Association.
74.
Tuch, Steven A. and RonaldWeitzer. 1997. “The Polls? Trends, Racial Differences in Attitudes toward the Police.”Public Opinion Quarterly61:642-663.
75.
Tyler, Tom R.1990. Why People Obey the Law. New Haven, CT: Yale University Press.
76.
Tyler, Tom R.2001. “Public Trust and Confidence in Legal Authorities: What do Majority and Minority Group MembersWant from the Lawand Legal Institutions?”Behavioral Sciences and the Law19:215-235.
77.
Tyler, TomR., Robert J. Boeckmann, Heather J. Smith, and Yuen J. Huo. 1997. Social Justice in a Diverse Society. Boulder, CO: Westview.
78.
Tyler, Tom R. and Robert Folger. 1980. “Distributional and Procedural Aspects of Satisfaction with Citizen-Police Encounters.”Basic and Applied Social Psychology1:281-292.
79.
U.S. Department of Justice. 2001. Police-Public Contact Survey, 1999: [United States]. Ann Arbor, MI: Inter-university Consortium for Political and Social Research, United States Department of Justice, and the Bureau of Justice Statistics.
80.
van den Haag, E.1969. “Deterrence and the Death Penalty.”Journal of Criminal Law, Criminology, and Police Science60 (2): 141-147.
81.
Walker, Samuel. 2001. “Searching for the Denominator: Problems with Police Traffic Stop Data and an Early Warning System Solution.”Justice Research and Policy3:63-95.
82.
Walton, Anthony. 1989. “Willie Horton and Me.”New York Times Magazine, August 20, 6 (1): 52-52.
83.
Webb, Vincent J. and Chris E. Marshall. 1995. “The Relative Importance ofRace and the Ethnicity on Citizen Attitudes toward the Police.”American Journal of Police14:45-66.
84.
Weitzer, Ronald. 1999. “Citizens' Perceptions of Police Misconduct: Race and Neighborhood Context.”Justice Quarterly16:819-846.
85.
Weitzer, Ronald. 2000. “Racialized Policing: Residents' Perceptions in Three Neighborhoods.”Law & Society Review34:129-155.
86.
Weitzer, Ronald and Steven A. Tuch. 1999. “Race, Class, and Perceptions of Discrimination by the Police.”Crime & Delinquency45:494-507.
87.
Williams, Hubert and Patrick V. Murphy. 1990. “The Evolving Strategies of Police: A Minority View.”Perspectives on Policing 13(Monograph). Washington, DC: National Institute of Justice.
