The role of the American Red Cross in the U.S. response to the 1918–1919 influenza pandemic holds important lessons for current-day pandemic response. This article, which examines local ARC responses in Boston, Pittsburgh, St. Louis, and Richmond, Virginia, demonstrates how the ARC coordinated nursing for military and civilian cases; produced and procured medical supplies and food; transported patients, health workers, and bodies; and aided influenza victims' families. But the organization's effectiveness varied widely among localities. These findings illustrate the persistently local character of pandemic response, and demonstrate the importance of close, timely, and sustained coordination among local and state public health authorities and voluntary organizations before and during public health emergencies. They further illustrate the persistently local character of these emergencies, while underscoring the centrality and limits of voluntarism in American public health.
References
1.
Red Cross National Committee on Influenza Chairman. Inter-office memo to all division managers. 1918 Oct 5. Folder 803, Epidemics, Box 687, Group 2, RG 200, National Archives and Records Administration, College Park, MD.
2.
CrosbyAW. America's forgotten pandemic: The influenza of 1918. Cambridge (MA): Cambridge University Press; 1989.
3.
Red Cross War Council. The work of the American Red Cross during the war: A statement of finances and accomplishments for the period Jul. 1, 1917 to Feb. 28, 1919. Washington: American Red Cross; 1919.
4.
PersonsWF. Night letter to Atlantic division manager, New York City. 1918 Oct 3. Folder 803, Epidemics influenza 1918 divisions, Box 688, Group 2, RG 200, National Archives and Records Administration, College Park, MD.
5.
American Red Cross. The mobilisation of the American National Red Cross during the influenza epidemic, 1918–1919. Geneva: Printing Office of the Tribune de Geneve; 1920.
6.
Precautions against epidemic. Important items. American Red Cross Southwestern division (bulletin) 1918 Oct 14; p. 2. Box 520, Group 2, RG 200, National Archives and Records Administration, College Park, MD.
7.
DockLLPickettSENoyesCDClementFFFoxEGVan MeterAR. History of American Red Cross nursing. New York: MacMillan Co.; 1922.
WayneBKlaimanTDearingerAWilfertRMartiCMaysG. Session 3050.1: Variation in local public health response to the 2009 H1N1 outbreak: Comparative analyses from across the U.S. American Public Health Association Annual Meeting; 2009 Nov 9; Philadelphia [cited 2009 Nov 20]. Abstracts available from: URL: http://apha.confex.com/apha/137am/webprogram/Session28438.html
10.
MarkelHLipmanHBNavarroJASloanAMichalsenJSternA. Nonpharmaceutical interventions implemented by U.S. cities during the 1918–1919 influenza pandemic. JAMA2007;298;644–54.
11.
BremnerRH. American philanthropy. Chicago: University of Chicago Press; 1988.
12.
BremnerRH. The public good: Philanthropy and welfare in the Civil War era. New York: Knopf; 1980.
13.
BartonC. The Red Cross of the Geneva Convention: What it is. Washington: Rufus H. Darby; 1878.
14.
KosarK. The congressional charter of the American National Red Cross: Overview, history, and analysis. CRS Report No. RL33314. Washington: Congressional Research Service; 2006.
15.
GaeddertG. The Boardman influence, 1905–1917. The history of the American National Red Cross [unpublished monograph by American Red Cross History division]. Washington: American Red Cross; 1950. Box 765, Group 2, RG 200, National Archives and Records Administration, College Park, MD.
16.
DullesFR. The American Red Cross: A history. New York: Harper; 1950.
17.
ClementsKA. The presidency of Woodrow Wilson. Lawrence (KS): University Press of Kansas; 1992.
18.
American Red Cross. The American Red Cross organization and activities. Washington Bureau of Publicants; 1917. Folder 800.08, Statistics, Box 675, Group 2, RG 200, National Archives and Records Administration, College Park, MD.
19.
The business side of the Red Cross. Red Cross Magazine1918 Dec:21–3.
20.
CutlipSM. Fund raising in the United States: Its role in America's philanthropy. New Brunswick (NJ): Transaction Publishers; 1990.
21.
OfficerLHWilliamsonSH. Measuring worth. Chicago: University of Illinois at Chicago; 2006 (updated 2009 Apr 2) [cited 2009 Nov 18]. Available from: URL: http://www.measuringworth.com
22.
CottNF. The bonds of womanhood: Woman's sphere in New England, 1780–1835. New Haven (CT): Yale University Press; 1977.
23.
WelterB. The cult of true womanhood: 1820–1860. American Quarterly1966;2:151–74.
24.
GinzburgLD. Women and the work of benevolence: Morality, politics and class in the nineteenth-century United States. New Haven (CT): Yale University Press; 1990.
25.
ScottAF. Natural allies: Women's associations in American history. Urbana (IL): University of Illinois Press; 1991.
26.
CapolozzaC. Uncle Sam wants you: World War I and the making of the modern American citizen. New York: Oxford University Press; 2008.
27.
CashFB. African American women and social action: The clubwomen and volunteerism from Jim Crow to the New Deal, 1806–1936. Westport (CT): Greenwood Press; 2001.
28.
ElmoreJA. Nurses in American history: Black nurses: Their service and their struggle. J Am Nurs1976;76:435–7.
29.
BoyleST. Paul Robeson: The years of promise and achievement. Amherst (MA): University of Massachusetts Press; 2001. p. 87.
30.
What the Boston Metropolitan chapter of the Red Cross accomplished during the epidemic. 1918 Nov 18. Folder 803.11, Epidemics influenza Massachusetts, Box 689, Group 2, RG 200, National Archives and Records Administration, College Park, MD.
31.
JacksonJ. Telegram to SM Greer, American Red Cross, Washington, 1918 Sep 23. Folder 803.11, Epidemics influenza Massachusetts, Box 689, Group 2, RG 200, National Archives and Records Administration, College Park, MD.
32.
JacksonJ. Letter to W. Frank Persons, Washington, 1918 Oct 4. Folder 803, Epidemics influenza 1918 divisions, Box 689, Group 2, RG 200, National Archives and Records Administration, College Park, MD.
33.
Director of Civilian Relief, New England division, American Red Cross. Letter to Miss Marjorie Perry, Burlington, Vermont. 1918 Oct 17. Folder 803, Epidemics influenza 1918 divisions, Box 688, Group 2, RG 200, National Archives and Records Administration, College Park, MD.
34.
Director of Civilian Relief, New England division, American Red Cross. Letter to J. Byron Deacon, national headquarters. 1918 Oct 16. Folder 803, Epidemics influenza 1918 divisions, Box 688, Group 2, RG 200, National Archives and Records Administration, College Park, MD.
35.
American Red Cross organized for action. Red Cross Bulletin1917 Jul 28:1–3.
36.
GreelyD. Beyond benevolence: Gender, class and the development of scientific charity in New York City, 1882–1935 [dissertation]. Stony Brook (NY): State University of New York at Stony Brook; 1995.
37.
PersonsWF. Letter to division directors of civilian relief. 1918 Oct 25. Folder 803, Epidemics influenza 1918 divisions, Box 688, Group 2, RG 200, National Archives and Records Administration, College Park, MD.
38.
MonroeFC. Letter to Red Cross division managers. 1919 Mar 1. Folder 803, Epidemics influenza 1918 divisions, Box 688, Group 2, RG 200, National Archives and Records Administration, College Park, MD.
39.
Again—the grip! Pittsburgh Gazette-Times1918 Oct 1:6.
40.
11 more deaths from influenza. Philadelphia Enquirer1918 Oct 1:17.
41.
WoodsEA. Supplemental report memoranda as to some of the methods employed in the influenza campaign by the Pittsburgh chapter of the American Red Cross. 1919 Jan 14. Folder 803.11, Epidemics, influenza Pennsylvania, Box 689, Group 2, RG 200, National Archives and Records Administration, College Park, MD.
42.
PaulinDC. Report of sub-committee on relief and rehabilitation of the influenza committee of the Pittsburgh chapter, American Red Cross. 1918 Dec 18. Folder 803.11, Epidemics, influenza Pennsylvania, Box 689, Group 2, RG 200, National Archives and Records Administration, College Park, MD.
PetersonER. Unfinished monograph on Pittsburgh chapter's work in influenza. 1920 Jan 28. Folder 803.11, Epidemics, influenza Pennsylvania, Box 689, Group 2, RG 200, National Archives and Records Administration, College Park, MD.
45.
Real vaccine for influenza will be made. Pittsburgh Gazette-Times1918 Oct 25:1,7.
46.
Rules governing the distribution of supplies by the influenza committee of the Pittsburgh chapter, American Red Cross. Undated. Folder 803.11, Epidemics, influenza Pennsylvania, Box 689, Group 2, RG 200, National Archives and Records Administration, College Park, MD.
47.
American Red Cross, Pittsburgh chapter. A history of the activities of the chapter from its organization to January 1, 1921. Pittsburgh: Pittsburgh Printing Co.; 1922.
48.
Lists of grip victims show big increase. Pittsburgh Gazette-Times1918 Oct 8:1.
49.
Officials plan hospitals for grip patients. Pittsburgh Gazette-Times1918 Oct 9:1.
50.
PetersonER. Letter to John H. McCandless, director, Bureau of Disaster Preparedness and Organization, Dept. of Civilian Relief., American Red Cross. 1920 Jan 28. Folder 803.11, Epidemics, influenza Pennsylvania, Box 689, Group 2, RG 200, National Archives and Records Administration, College Park, MD.
51.
HammarVC. Letter from Chairman of St. Louis chapter to Mrs. W. K. Draper, Chairman, Woman's National Advisory Committee American Red Cross, Washington. 1918 Nov 16. Folder 803.11, Epidemics, influenza Missouri, Box 689, Group 2, RG 200, National Archives and Records Administration, College Park, MD.
52.
Doctors here must report influenza. St. Louis Globe-Democrat1918 Sep 20:2.
53.
Pneumonia cases 10 per cent of winter deaths; how to avoid it. St. Louis Post-Dispatch1918 Sep 21:11.
54.
No quarantine here against influenza, says Dr. Starkloff. St. Louis Globe-Democrat1918 Oct 6:8.
55.
To close schools and theaters to check influenza. St. Louis Globe-Democrat1918 Oct 14:1.
56.
Influenza quarantine placed on city and schools, theaters, churches are to be closed. St. Louis Globe-Democrat1918 Oct 8:1.
57.
Sixteen city hospital attaches fall victim to Spanish influenza. St. Louis Globe-Democrat1918 Oct 15:1.
58.
424 new influenza cases in St. Louis. St. Louis Globe-Democrat1918 Oct 14:4.
59.
“Spanish Influenza,” “Three-Day Fever” “The Flu.” Supplement No. 34 to the Public Health Reports. Washington: United States Public Health Service 1918 Sep 28. Reprinted by the American Red Cross Southwestern division. Folder 803.7, Epidemics, influenza publicity and publications, Box 688, Group 2, RG 200, National Archives and Records Administration, College Park, MD.
60.
Letter from associate director, bureau of chapter organization to W. Frank Persons, chairman, committee to conduct campaign against Spanish influenza. 1918 Oct 3. Folder 803.7, Epidemics, influenza publicity and publications, Box 688, Group 2, RG 200, National Archives and Records Administration, College Park, MD.
61.
Simple precautions to prevent influenza. Bulletin of the Northwestern division. Seattle American Red Cross 1918 Oct 12;1:1. Box 520, Group 2, RG 200, National Archives and Records Administration, College Park, MD.
62.
How to protect yourself from influenza [pamphlet]. Folder 803.7, Epidemics, influenza publicity and publications, Box 688, Group 2, RG 200, National Archives and Records Administration, College Park, MD.
63.
BillingsJS. The registration and sanitary supervision of tuberculosis in New York City. Department of Health of the City of New York Monograph Series 1. New York: Department of Health; 1912.
64.
City fights grippe with severe steps. The Washington Post1918 Oct 3:1.
65.
New gains in grip here. The New York Times1918 Oct 4:24.
66.
“Flu” cases down in city and state. The Atlanta Constitution1918 Oct 24:7.
67.
Influenza epidemic spreads to Richmond. Richmond Times-Dispatch1918 Oct 1:1.
90 die of influenza. The Washington Post1918 Sep 15:8.
70.
Influenza in three camps. Richmond Times-Dispatch1918 Sep 18:5.
71.
Pneumonia causes six deaths at Camp Lee. Richmond Times-Dispatch1918 Sep 22:3.
72.
Denies Virginia quarantine. The Washington Post1918 Sep 17:3.
73.
Richmond may bar troops. The Washington Post1918 Oct 1:4.
74.
Influenza safeguards taken by Dr. Flannagan. Richmond Times-Dispatch1918 Oct 2:14.
75.
Report of Potomac division for July–December 1918. 1919 Jan 23. Folder 149.18, Potomac division civilian relief reports 1918, Box 233, Group 2, RG 200, National Archives and Records Administration, College Park, MD.
76.
Good work of Red Cross recognized at Camp Lee. Richmond Times-Dispatch1918 Oct 9:4.
77.
More nurses needed. Richmond Times-Dispatch1918 Oct 3:3.
78.
Epidemic forces drastic action. Richmond Times-Dispatch1918 Oct 5:1.
79.
Close all fairs during epidemic. Richmond Times-Dispatch1918 Oct 9:1.
80.
Flu besieges city; 10,000 cases here. Richmond Times-Dispatch1918 Oct 8:1.
81.
Grippe still rages in city. Richmond Times-Dispatch1918 Oct 12:1.
82.
Colored soup kitchen. Richmond Times-Dispatch1918 Oct 22:6.
83.
Supplying 100 gallons of soup a day to sick. Richmond Times-Dispatch1918 Oct 14:10.
84.
Grippe crisis is reached, should ebb from now on. Richmond Times-Dispatch1918 Oct 15:10.
85.
Graduate nurses teach services in new hospital. Richmond Times-Dispatch1918 Oct 16:12.
86.
All helping sufferers in emergency hospital. Richmond Times-Dispatch1918 Oct 13:4.
87.
Catholics render help at emergency hospital. Richmond Times-Dispatch1918 Oct 17:4.
88.
J. S. Williams' nephew dead. The Washington Post1918 Oct 18:7.
89.
314 new flu cases reported in city. Richmond Times-Dispatch1918 Oct 13:1.
90.
Grippe situation thought better. Richmond Times-Dispatch1918 Oct 16:1.
91.
Red Cross workrooms issue appeal for help. Richmond Times-Dispatch1918 Nov 9:2.
92.
Plague continues to ravage state. Richmond Times-Dispatch1918 Oct 10:1.
93.
Many women will join Red Cross motor corps. Richmond Times-Dispatch1918 Oct 25:4.
94.
PryorEB. Clara Barton professional angel. Philadelphia: University of Pennsylvania Press; 1988. p. 234.
95.
Department of Health and Human Services (US). HHS pandemic influenza plan. Part 2. Public health guidance on pandemic influenza for state and local partners. November 2005 (updated 2006 Jun 26) [cited 2009 Jun 16]. Available from: URL: http://www.hhs.gov/pandemicflu/plan/part2.html
