Two Recently Confirmed False Confessions: Byron A. Halsey and Jeffrey M. Deskovic

Abstract

In the past decade “false confessions” have emerged as a major area of research and practice in forensic psychology and psychiatry. Most prominent among the factors for this emergence has been the media coverage of high profile false confession cases. Not long ago false confessions were viewed as an anomaly, but in the past decade DNA exonerations coupled with social science research, have focused attention on how false confessions can arise from common interrogation practice. This article explores two recent high profile cases where false confessions were obtained and explores the various factors involved. Modern psychological interrogation, criminal profiling literature, and polygraphy suggest to law enforcement that they can reliably identify “criminals” without adequate investigation. Thus reliance on these sources for evidence of guilt warrants careful review.

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Allison

Smith

Eastman

Rainbow

(2003). Toulmin's philosophy of argument and its relevance to offender profiling. Psychology, Crime, & Law, 9, 2, 173–183

Bedau

H. A.

Radelet

M. L.

(1987). Miscarriages of justice in potentially capital cases. Stanford Law Review, 40, 21–179

Borchard

E. M.

(1932). Convicting the innocent: Sixty-five actual errors of criminal justice. Garden City, NY: Doubleday

Brandon

Davies

(1973). Wrongful prisonment. London: Allen and Unwin

Braun

(2007). He's got a right to say the death penalty is wrong. The Star Ledger, November 19, 2007, p. 13

Castillo

(2007). Tankleff defense: Two more say another man killed parents. Newsday, November 2, 2007, see www.martytankleff.org

Citron

Johnson

M.B.

(2006). Expert psychological testimony regarding disputed confession evidence in Federal Courts: United States v. Vallejo. Journal of Forensic Psychology Practice, 6, 1, 1–27

Deskovic v. Mann (2000). 97-2946, United States Court of Appeals for the Second Circuit, 210 F.3d 354

Deskovic v. Mann (2001). 00-6829, Supreme Court of the United States. 531 U.S. 1088; 121 S. Ct. 806

10.

Drizin

S. A.

(2001). Coerced confessions shine light on Taping, Chicago Sun Times, p. 29

11.

Drizin

S. A.

Leo

R. A.

(2004). The problem of false confessions in the post-DNA world. North Carolina Law Review, 82, 891–1007

12.

Falkenberg

(2001). Man freed on DNA evidence, Fort Worth Star-Telegram, January 17, 2001, 1 and 13A

13.

Fitzgerald

(2007). Convict freed after 16 years sees real killer sentenced in murder. The Associated Press State & Local, May 3, 2007

14.

Fulero

S. M.

(2004). Expert psychological testimony on the psychology of interrogations and confessions. In Lassiter

G.D.

(Ed.) Interrogations, confessions, and entrapment (pp. 247–263). New York: Kluwer Academic

15.

Gudjonsson

(1992). The psychology of interrogations, confessions and testimony. Chichester, England: John Wiley & Sons

16.

Gudjonsson

(2003). The psychology of interrogations and confessions: A handbook. Chichester, England: John Wiley & Sons

17.

Halsey v. Hendricks (2004). No. 03-10385, Supreme Court of the United States, 543 U.S. 832; 125 S. Ct. 170

18.

Heilbrun

Marczyk

G. R.

DeMatteo

(2002). Forensic mental health assessment: A casebook. Oxford University Press, New York, NY

19.

Hovrath

Jayne

Buckley

(1994). Differentiation of truthful and deceptive criminal suspects in behavioral analysis interviews. Forensic Journal of Science, 39, 3, 793–806

20.

Huff

C. R.

Rattner

Sagarin

(1986). Guilty until proven innocent: Wrongful conviction and public policy. Crime & Delinquency, 32, 518–544

21.

Huff

C. R.

Rattner

Sagarin

(1996). Convicted but innocent: Wrongful convictions and public policy. London: Sage

22.

Inbau

F. E.

Reid

J. E.

(1962). Criminal interrogation and confessions. Baltimore, MD: Williams & Wilkens

23.

Inbau

F. E.

Reid

J. E.

Buckley

J. P.

Jayne

B. C.

(2001). Criminal interrogation and confessions (4th ed.). Gaithersberg, MD: Aspen

24.

Innocenceproject.org, (2007). After 19 years in prison for one of the most heinous crimes in NJ history, Byron Halsey is proven innocent through DNA. Retrieved May 16 from www.innocenceproject.org

25.

In the Matter of L.M. (1999). NO. 03-97-00334-CV Court of Appeals of Texas, Third District, Austin 993

26.

Johnson

M. B.

(2001). The emergence and significance of the “Mallott Rule”: The legal history. The Journal of Psychiatry and Law, 29, 2. 121–146

27.

Johnson

M. B.

(2003). The interrogation of Michael Crowe: A film review focused on education and training. American Journal of Forensic Psychology, 21, 3, 71–79

28.

Johnson

M. B.

(2005). The Central Park Jogger case: Police coercion and secrecy in interrogation—The 14th Annual Frantz Fanon, M.D. Memorial Lecture. Journal of Ethnicity in Criminal Justice, 3, 1–2, 131–143

29.

Kassin

Gudjonsson

(2004). The psychology of confessions: A review of the literature and issues. Psychological Science in the Public Interest, 5, 2, 33–67

30.

Kassin

Goldstein

Savitsky

(2003). Behavioral confirmation in the interrogation: On the dangers of presuming guilt. Law & Human Behavior, 27, 2, 187–203

31.

Kotlowitz

(1999). The unprotected. The New Yorker February 8, 42–53

32.

Lassiter

G. D.

(2004). Interrogations, confessions, and entrapment. New York, NY: Kluwer Academic/Plenum Publishers

33.

Leo

Ofshe

(1998). The consequences of false confessions: Deprivations of liberty and miscarriages of justice in the age of psychological interrogation. Journal of Criminal Law and Criminology, 88, 429–496

34.

McBreaty

(Director) (2002). The Interrogation of Michael Crowe. Produced by Court TV

35.

Melton

G. B.

Petrila

Poythress

N. G.

Slobogin

(2007). Psychological evaluations for the courts: A handbook for mental health professionals and lawyers. New York: Guilford Press

36.

Miranda v. Arizona (1966). U. S. 384, 436

37.

Moran

(2007). The Presence of Malice (Op-Ed). Retrieved August 2. 2007 from www.nytimes.com

38.

National Research Council (2003). The polygraph and lie detection. Washington, DC: National Academies Press

39.

New Jersey Supreme Court Special Committee (2005). Report on recordation of custodial interrogation. Retrueved at: http//www.judiciary.state.nj.us/notices/report/cookreport.pdf

40.

Ofshe

(1989). Coerced confessions: The logic of seemingly irrational action. Cultic Studies Journal, 6, 1, 1–15

41.

Peopleoftheheart.org (2004). Full transcript of the interrogation of Lacresha Murray, May 29, 1996. Retrieved March 20, 2004 from http://www.peopleoftheheart.org/transcript_interrogation.htm

42.

People v. Deskovic (1994). 91-01563, Supreme Court of New York, Appellate Division, Second Department, 201 A.D.2d 579; 607 N.Y.S.2d 957

43.

Perrotta

(2002). Convictions in Central Park Jogger case are overturned: Conclusions of Manhattan District Attorney are embraced by court. New York Law Journal, December 20, 1

44.

Radelet

M. L.

Bedau

H. A.

Putnam

C. E.

(1992). In spite of evidence: Erroneous convictions in capital cases. Boston, MA: Northeastern University Press

45.

Ryan

N. E.

(2002). Affirmation in response to motion to vacate judgment of conviction. Indictment no. 4762/89. Retrieved January 12, 2003 from www.ManhattanDA.org

46.

Salfati

C. G.

Kurcharski

(2005). The psychology of criminal conduct. In Trevino

Guarino

(Eds.) The common subject of crime: A multi-disciplinary approach. Cincinnati, OH: Anderson Publishing

47.

Scheck

Neufeld

Dwyer

(2000). Actual innocence. Garden City, NY: Doubleday

48.

Soto

O. R.

(2005). Interrogation machine's maker settles Crowe suit. The San Diego Union-Tribune, May 24, p. B-3

49.

Synder

L. C.

McQuillan

P. J.

Murphy

W. L.

Joselson

(2007). Report on the Conviction of Jeffrey Deskovic. Westchester County District Attorney's Office. White Plains, New York. Retrieved from www.da.westchester.ny.us

50.

State v. Byron A. Halsey (1988, March 7). Transcript of trial proceeding, testimony of Det. F. Pfieffer. Indictment Nos. 63-01-86 and 210-02-87

51.

State v. Halsey (2000). C-1379 September Term 1999, 49.669, Supreme Court of New Jersey, 165 N.J. 491

52.

Young

(1996). Unnecessary evil: Police lying in interrogations. Connecticut Law Review, 28, 425–477