Use of design thinking in the proposal of a multi-compound solar dryer applied to processes of traditional P'urhépecha Medicine

Abstract

The development of small-scale solar thermal technologies is useful to address specific energy needs; however, there is a gap between the technology that is developed and the one that is accepted and achieves its use in a sustained long-term manner. In this sense, the development of a double-inclination solar dryer for the dehydration of medicinal plants used in traditional P'urhépecha medicine is presented. From a participatory and consensual perspective of technological co-creation with the user that allows promoting its long-term use, the solar dryer was generated from the Design Thinking methodology and the conventional technological development process. The stages of the proposed process considered the identification of the energy need, the design, sizing and simulation, the prototyping, and the characterization and implementation of the technology in a group of traditional doctors for the drying of local medicinal plants. The result is a solar dryer with thermal efficiency of 23% and exergy efficiency of 3%, which achieves the dehydration of medicinal plants in 1 day with 4.7 kWh of average solar irradiance, and removes more than 80% of the humidity from a maximum load of 5 kilograms. The temperature of the drying chamber exceeds 50°C, and the energy distribution is homogeneous, being a natural convection device, easy to build and with affordable materials. This technology has been implemented in the home of a traditional doctor and it is expected that it can be replicated to satisfy the demand for drying products in indigenous community families in Mexico.

Keywords

Medicinal plants solar drying sustainability rural community

1. Introduction

In Mexico, the solar energy potential is useful for dehydration processes of products such as: fruits, vegetables, seeds, meat, wood, herbs, and medicinal plants (Valdes-Barrón et al., 2014). In the case of solar drying technologies, some used open systems exposed to direct radiation (UNESCO-UN-Celestina Pérez de Almada Foundation, 2016), an inefficient method, since the food is exposed and interacts with animals and insects, contaminating and reducing its feasibility of use, especially deteriorating the vitamins and more volatile elements of the products that are dehydrated (Ding et al., 2012). There are now indirect drying systems using hybrid forced convection processes, and some that use phase change materials and thermochemical processes (Kabeel et al., 2017; Khallaf and El-Sebaii, 2022; Ramezanizadeh et al., 2018), which is equipment that is expensive and requires considerable amounts of supplemental fuel, or electricity to operate (Sharma et al., 2009).

Currently, solar drying systems have greater efficiency and energy quality, as well as lower operating costs than mechanized dehydrators (Gilago and Chandramohan, 2022; Mugi and Chandramohan, 2021). Solar dehydrators are a viable and economical option that contributes to the reduction of harmful emissions to the environment (Sharma et al., 2009), which also as eco-technologies represent a technological milestone for the satisfaction of needs and are possible to adapt to the user requirements in a multi-scalar way (Ortíz-Moreno et al., 2014). It is also highlighted that solar drying technologies can in some cases be adaptive, participatory, and respond to sustainability criteria, as has been demonstrated in previous research for the drying of various products in an optimized way (López-Sosa et al., 2019). However, despite various efforts, some designs of solar dehydrators have been proposed and discussed in the literature, but users often do not adapt to them, and the technology stops being used because it is not developed together with the user to meet the particular needs. It is also important that they have local materials for their maintenance and that they are possible to replicate, which is why there are areas of opportunity in the co-development of these technologies (EL-Mesery et al., 2022; Kumar Jangde et al., 2022).

On the other hand, in the specific case of drying medicinal plants, these have been discovered and used in traditional medicine practice since prehistoric times. Medicinal plants should be dried as soon as possible after harvesting. Its humidity at harvest time is around 70–80%. Furthermore, the chemical components of medicinal plants are not affected by different drying methods (Khallaf and El-Sebaii, 2022), so it is a technique for preserving these natural resources by preserving their functional properties (El-Sebaii and Shalaby, 2012; Sharma et al., 2009). However, researchers on traditional medicine have privileged a wide variety of social approaches to determine the relationships that traditional doctors have with their health practice, in addition to their multiple and varied implications on the problems of somatization of the diseases.

Traditional medicine for its daily practice refers to and requires the extraction of plants, minerals, and materials that the nature of its own space provides; otherwise, it would lose the definition of being traditional due to the imposed use of modern medicine. Apparently, it is itself the bearer of the sustainability of its own conceptualization and the architect of preservation for all time. From an endless number of plants that in each region and in various parts of the world contain characteristic elements known and used for health/disease in the cases of treatment by traditional doctors. Therefore, it is necessary to address issues related to traditional medicine as a sustainability issue for indigenous communities (León, Olivé; Lazos, 2014), where the use of herbalism becomes daily as part of the task that must safeguard its uses and customs for the preservation of health. Within the multidisciplinarity in which research and systematization of knowledge can be poured, as well as the dialogue of knowledge (Bermúdez et al., 2005), is subject to the privilege of still having the presence of traditional doctors with knowledge of the use of plants and that this can be shared with new generations as a sustainable foundation of the relationships between the survival customs of individuals. Therefore, in this safeguarding approach, the contemporary articulation between traditional knowledge and technological co-development can coexist, to generate improvements in medicinal plant processing practice through efficient and sustainable drying mechanisms, with community available materials, and responding from ecotechniques that satisfy needs and adapt to local ways of life, as has happened with some experiences reported in the literature (L.B. López-Sosa, A. Ortíz-Carrión, D. Espinoza-Gómez, J. Zárate-Medina, 2021; López-Sosa et al., 2019, 2022; Morales-Máximo et al., 2022; Morales et al., 2020; Sosa et al., 2014).

Therefore, this research incorporates the Design Thinking (DT) methodology (Brown, 2009; Jeanne Liedtka, 2011), to propose a multicompound solar drying system that satisfies the dehydration needs of medicinal plants used in indigenous P'úrhépecha medicine by traditional doctors, incorporating sustainability indicators in the development of this technology, combining a co-creation process focused on the needs of the target population, which takes into account a technical analysis, the functionality of the device, the materials, the dimensions and efficiency appropriate to the case study, showing an experience of eco-technological generation from a participatory, inclusive and knowledge systematization perspective, which is articulated with the dialogue of knowledge, the result of which is a device that responds to specific needs, prioritizing that the technology adapts to the user and not vice versa.

2. Materials and methods

2.1. Context of the case study

The present proposal is developed territorially as a case study on the P'urhépecha plateau and the shores of Pátzcuaro lake, in the state of Michoacán, west of central Mexico, focusing mainly on 11 indigenous traditional doctors (Gabriela Orozco-Gutiérrez, Hipólito Jesús Muñoz Flores, Ignacio Vidales Fernández, 2014; Medina Huerta, 2021). These doctors include 10 women and one man, who live in five municipalities of Michoacán: Pátzcuaro, Uruapan, Tzintzuntzan, Tingambato and Cherán (Figure 1). Whose traditional community medicine practice focus, among many other activities, on the treatment and prevention of diseases, midwifery and community rituals that are part of the P'urhépecha worldview and their daily way of life. Traditional doctors represent the first service to address health problems in the populations where they live, using local medicinal plants and community resources, which due to the characteristics of their practice, are services with natural and low-cost products, which represents the more affordable medical care for the indigenous population of these regions.

2.2. Methodology

The methodology focuses on two main aspects:

The identification from DT of the needs of the target population. That is, the drying requirements of the medicinal plants with the greatest use and need for preservation. Traditional doctors grow and harvest medicinal plants, dry them outdoors, and then store and/or process them for use in their medical practice. However, the scarcity of some plants and climatic variability have required that the drying processes be different. Needing to preserve medicinal plants for a longer time and to optimize the extraction of these natural resources. An exploratory diagnosis was carried out on their medical practice, the use of medicinal plants, their extraction, processing, and daily use.

The technological development process, which, together, aims to establish an alternative for the drying of medicinal plants. Due to the above, new technologies are necessary that adhere to their needs and practices, so the development of new technologies is necessary but in a participatory manner as established in the DT methodology (Brown, 2009; Jeanne Liedtka, 2011), which is designed for the user, and incorporates various stages that include its definition, the ideation of possible solutions, its prototypes and iteration cycles: Empathy, Definition, Ideation, Prototyping and Testing (Figure 2). This is the motivation of the present study.

Following the DT methodology, the “Person” tool was used to establish empathy, using an archetype of a fictitious but realistic person (Bosque et al., 2021), whose analysis focused on “Tata,” a generic name to refer to a single person of the 11 doctors analyzed, but in addition, the results compile the collective interest of the 11 mentioned doctors, with whom dialogic workshops and participatory interviews were held to learn their way of life, their traditional medicine practice, and the use and processing of medicinal plants. To understand their thoughts and beliefs, an empathy map and the Journey Map tool were used (Bosque et al., 2021), with which the needs were identified in a consensual, participatory and inclusive manner, which also defines the need and the conception of a technology proposal for this need. Furthermore, considering the scenario of drying needs from its perception, a cause-effect map was built, through the Ishikawa diagram, where the characteristics required in the dehydration processes are observed, which together allowed us to articulate the methodology of DT with the technological development process and technology validation.

2.3. Technical-energy analysis

After considering the theoretical-conceptual tools of the DT, the technological development process together with the user, took up an initial version of a solar dryer that was manufactured from the appropriate technology approach (Hernán Thomas & Guillermo Santos, 2016), and which was implemented in the community of Pichátaro (Michoacán), for the drying of wood used in the manufacture of handmade furniture (López-Sosa et al., 2019). The design and simulation of the device for drying medicinal plants was carried out using the SolidWorks® design program (Bucio-Sistos et al., 2022). The simulation considered solar radiation of 1000 W/m², with an ambient temperature of 25°C; the interior convection temperature was also estimated considering the increase in temperature in a closed system. The device conforms to locally available materials incorporating polycarbonate or rubber for the walls and metal roof with glass cover, aluminum frame, and plastic mesh drying trays. The characterization was carried out by estimating the thermal drying efficiency (Chavan, BR; Yakupitiyage, A.; Kumar, 2011):

η = \frac{W L}{I A}

(1)

Where W is the mass loss of the material being dehydrated [Kg], L is the latent heat of vaporization of water [kJ/kg], “I” is the solar energy during the process [kWh/m²], and A is the area of the collector [m²]. The exergy efficiency of the dryer was also calculated. Being the exergy inflow and outflow of the drying chamber estimated with the following equations (2) and (3), respectively (Hepbasli, 2007; Mugi and Chandramohan, 2021):

\dot{E} x_{i n} = {\dot{m}}_{a} c_{p a} [(T_{d c i} - T_{0}) - T_{0} \ln (\frac{T_{d c i}}{T_{0}})]

(2)

\dot{E} x_{o u t} = {\dot{m}}_{a} c_{p a} [(T_{d c o} - T_{0}) - T_{0} \ln (\frac{T_{d c o}}{T_{0}})]

(3)

Where

T_{d c i}

and

T_{d c o}

are the inlet and outlet temperatures of the drying chamber, respectively;

T_{0}

the ambient temperature,

m_{a}

is the air flow (kg/s), and

c_{p a}

is the specific heat of the air (kJ/kg K). And the exergetic efficiency is estimated as (Akpinar, 2010):

η_{e x} = \frac{E x_{o u t}}{E x_{i n}}

(4)

For thermal characterization, a thermometer with 4 type K thermocouples, GAIN EXPRESS model, a Fluke 922 Airflow Micromanometer, also a Fluke-TiS10 thermal imaging camera, an LP02 pyranometer. A Bonvoisin B08DHTCS4 T analytical balance was used for the drying tests.

3. Results and discussion

A comprehensive analysis was carried out from the DT methodology starting with the results of the “Person” tool (Figure 3). Identifying some of the motivations that are based on a P'urhépecha value called “Maroani,” the vocation to serve their community and the use of natural resources as a practice of contact with nature that allows, on the one hand, to serve their community with the resources that nature provides them and, on the other hand, to be a sustainable practice with low environmental impact, low cost, and functional use for their medical practice.

The empathy map showed the different actions and procedures that are related to his/her daily practice in traditional medicine (Figure 4). What he/she does, what he/she thinks and how he/she lives. Demonstrating his/her concern to improve his/her traditional medicine practice, transmit them to subsequent generations and ensure that traditional medicine is valued by present and future members of their community. The importance of the use of medicinal plants as one of the most important elements in their medical practice, and the need to optimize their use, was also highlighted.

On the other hand, in a complementary way, the key parameters in the processing process of medicinal plants were defined using the Journey Map (Figure 5(a)), and the benefits in general terms that could be obtained with a technology for drying medicinal plants. The diagnostic experience of traditional doctors showed that there have been attempts to use technologies for drying, using metal plates, transparent rubber and even metal meshes to dry medicinal plants, but until the moment of writing this article, the development and implementation of technologies that satisfy their drying needs have not been achieved. Regarding the workshop on the co-design of drying technologies, the Ishikawa diagram allowed us to know four important aspects that the drying technology that adapts to its needs for medicinal plants must consider (Figure 5(b)): manufacturing, design, characteristics of the materials and aspects that technology transfer and appropriation must consider.

In short, the DT tools allowed us to know the ways of thinking, being and carrying out their medical practice of traditional doctors, their needs in this area linked to the use of natural resources, and the characteristics that a technology for drying their medicinal plants should contain that allow them to be used in ointments, infusions, and lotions. These results simultaneously allowed progress in each of the stages of the technological development process: sizing, design, simulation, construction, validation of functionality, and implementation.

The sizing estimated a design of 1 to 5 kilograms of load capacity, derived from the results of the drying processes of the 11 doctors analyzed, and from the exploratory diagnoses in each of them on their medical practice with medicinal plants. With the sizing, a design was obtained with a 0.3 m² collector that operates with natural convection, which represents an easy-to-use technology for traditional doctors (Figure 6(a)–(f)). A design of three input trays was included, to store up to 5 kg of organic matter. The plants with the greatest demand for drying are valerian leaves (Valeriana spp.), lemon balm root (Agastache mexicana) and cactus leaves (Opuntia spp.). The double-inclination design for drying systems was reported by the team of this work in past research, where the appropriate combination used in this design showed better hot air flow distribution conditions to achieve homogeneous drying (López-Sosa et al., 2019); the dual-tilt composite geometry has been shown in past research to be functional for drying processes because it provides better flow recirculation throughout the cavity (López-Sosa et al., 2019). After the design, a simulation was carried out to determine the thermal behavior of the drying chamber (Figure 6(g)).

The design and simulation validate acceptable operation for the drying process. The construction incorporated locally available materials, which make it possible for the repair of this technology to be achieved without difficulties (Figure 7). It has an aluminum structure, polycarbonate walls with a UV protection cover, the surface solar collector is a glass cover on a metal sheet plate with a low environmental impact absorbent film made with materials derived from combustion (López-Sosa et al., 2020, 2022), and the drying trays are made of food grade aluminum and mesh (Figure 7(a)–(d)). The device works indirectly the sun's rays reach a solar absorbing cover made of black galvanized sheet, which transfers the heat to the drying chamber where the trays containing medicinal plants are located. In the thermographic analysis, it can be noted that the thermal accumulation is adequate in the drying chamber and the temperature gradient distribution descends from the cover (Figure 7(e) and (f)). The developed system is passive, so it does not require orientation to the sun.

The thermal efficiency of the device was 23.8%, with a standard deviation of ±5%, considering the tests and different plants introduced, as well as 3% ± 0.7% for the exergy efficiency. This behavior achieved a homogeneous drying process. During the test days from September to December 2022 carried out in communities on the P'urhépecha plateau (Michoacán), the drying process removed more than 80% of the humidity of the introduced plants (Figure 8(a)–(c)). T1 and T2 represent the temperature in the solar collector of the dryer that reaches values close to 100 °C, T3 and T4 are the temperatures in the drying chamber with values greater than 50 °C, and TE is the ambient temperature outside the dryer (Figure 8(d)–(f)). The simulation results are consistent with the field tests of the dryer. With full load capacity, drying was homogeneous, and the resulting product met the requirements necessary by traditional doctors (Figure 5(g)), textures and humidity like those achieved with the sun during several days of exposure. The drying time was approximately 5 h with normal irradiance, drying which was achieved in 1 day by average irradiance of 5 kWh/m². This technology is at the Intercultural Indigenous University of Michoacán, in the indigenous community of San Francisco Pichátaro, in the Municipality of Tingambato, Michoacán, where the 11 traditional doctors provide their services and have access to this technology. The manufacturing cost of the device is 40 dollars, and its materials can be variable substituted by those that are within the user's reach. It is a technology that is easy to manipulate and weighs less than 10 kilograms of mass and is easy to replicate.

The resistance to the change from traditional medicine to modern health thinking does not omit the design of instruments and tools that allow the potential of the use of medicinal plants to be generated. That is why the creation of a solar dryer allows not only to continue the dehydration used by traditional doctors who cultivate, extract, prune, and process medicinal plants to address local health problems, from their perspective and community medical practice and cosmoperceptive. It also represents a dialogic proposal to address a need jointly, community-academia, which does not imply a change in the cognitive system of traditional medicine but on the contrary, being a dryer made with materials of daily use, allows to ingrain a sustainable perspective on the knowledge of the disease/plant drying/health process as an improvement scheme in traditional medicine; as has been shown with the use of technological co-creation assisted by the DT methodology to collaboratively give rise to an immediate attention technology from the user's perspective. The creation of this device allows for efficiency in drying time, enabling the assurance and continuity of traditional medicine that favors the sustainability of ancestral knowledge and the preservation of natural resources from effective and harmonized management from a community vision (Pardo de Santayana and Gómez Pellón, 2003).

Unlike the different linear innovation approaches to understand and solve a problem in a given context, the use of the DT methodology is an important factor to analyze the understanding and interaction with users when proposing the co-development of technological innovation based on the resolution of problems focused on a need (Andalusia and Bermejo-mart, 2020). It is considered a process that requires time and patience to generate greater efficiency. Once this methodology phase is completed, the design of the indirect solar dryer passively provides a link with the user to generate an appropriate feasibility framework, based on knowledge and observations of real-life situations. There are other works that promote DT as a tool to obtain an interactive and user-centered approach to problem solving (Buhl et al., 2019), which from an eco-technological perspective can be defined in five key factors: problem formulation, user approach, visualization, experimentation, and interaction with the final product.

Currently, the DT methodology has aroused greater interest in work that focuses on multidisciplinary teams that adopt an activity oriented to the needs of users in order to build viable solutions to the different problems they face (Jeanne Liedtka, 2011). In this way, the DT approach becomes a useful tool for formulating problems related to the real needs that users have.

The implementation of a passively indirect solar dryer for the dehydration of medicinal plants in the Púrhérepecha Plateau and the lake area of Pátzcuaro is an alternative technology that allows us to change the traditional conservation techniques of medicinal plants that cause their deterioration or scarcity in a way greatly accelerated by changes in climatological variability. This type of dryer, unlike others, is simple to manufacture and has low costs in local materials compared to active solar dryers (Bhanudas et al., 2020). The thermal and exergetic efficiency, as well as the temperature of the solar collector and the drying chamber that the solar dryer managed to have, is viable and efficient to achieve the dehydration of the plants most used in traditional P'urhépecha medicine, by removing more than 80% humidity. For example, Seretse et al., 2019 built a passive solar dryer with temperatures in the drying chamber between 43.6°C and 79.2°C with 4 h of continuous solar radiation at a maximum ambient temperature of 27.5°C. The drying efficiency was 18 to 30% and the exergetic efficiency was 4.5%. Besides, Hatami et al., (2019) designed an indirect solar dryer by performing a thermal and exergetic analysis, as well as of the air velocity, the thickness of the glass cover and the length of the collector.

Therefore, the implementation of the passive indirect solar dryer is a viable alternative for drying medicinal plants, however, as commented by Matavel et al., 2021, the physical and thermal properties must be evaluated, as well as the use of an appropriate methodology to obtain results with greater certainty about the potential benefits of this type of alternative technologies so as not to generate economic losses and disuse due to technological innovation, which in the particular case, this proposal aims to complement traditional technological development schemes and promote eco-technological processes from a participatory approach.

Conclusions

This research showed the development of a solar drying system with composite geometry, based on the DT methodology, which was articulated with a technological co-development process, concluding from this methodological interaction the following:

The components of the methodologies were grouped as follows: (a) the definition of empathy made it possible to identify the need for drying medicinal plants and a thermal process required for their attention, (b) the ideation allowed the sizing of the task of drying, (c) the prototyping considered the design, simulation and construction of the equipment with affordable materials for users, (d) the iteration process was carried out through minimal adaptations and the thermal characterization of the solar dryer, and (e) finally the testing of the technology is carried out with continuous use to meet the identified need, therefore, traditional doctors now have access to the dryer for dehydrating medicinal plants.

The proposal generated a device that operates with a renewable energy source, to meet a local energy need, and from the methodologies used (DT and Technological Development) considered a consensual and participatory perspective, as well as a sustainability approach in the use of materials and the functionality of the technology. Thus, this proposal showed an alternative way of generating technologies designed from and with the user, without neglecting functionality and efficiency.

The developed device was characterized through an analysis of the efficiency of the first and second law of thermodynamics, and has a thermal efficiency of 28% and 3% exergetic efficiency, reaching temperatures in the drying chamber of more than 50°C and achieving the removal of more than 80% of moisture from organic matter during 1 day of operation at maximum capacity, in the main medicinal plants used by the target population (traditional doctors), Valeriana spp, Agastache mexicana and Opuntia spp., in compliance with the required needs.

The device is a passive system susceptible to improvements in the solar energy monitoring and storage process, easy to use and with highly durable materials, with a cost of 40USD, whose materials can be adaptable and is a technology that is easy to replicate, which it is currently in use by 11 traditional doctors.

As future work, it is expected to estimate the cost-benefit relationship of the technology, explore the characterization of the functional substances of medicinal plants dried with the developed device, and evaluate the monitoring of its use by traditional doctors in the region. Finally, it is highlighted that the dryer maintains a co-creation scheme, and it is expected that it can be used by various traditional doctors to optimize the processing practice of other medicinal plants, whose dehydration will be explored in future works.

Footnotes

Acknowledgments

The authors thank the traditional doctors of the Universidad Intercultural Indígena de Michoacán for their support in carrying out this research. We also thank PRODEP 2023, to the CONAHCYT Project 319333, the Intercultural Universidad Intercultural Indígena de Michoacán and the Escuela Nacional de Estudios Superiores Unidad Morelia for the technical support for this research.

Author contributions

Natalia Núñez-Montiel: conceptualization, experimental design, experimentation, and writing of results. Jorge Cira-Ramos: conceptualization, experimental design and experimentation. Juan Carlos Corral-Huacuz: analysis of the state of the art of the subject and writing of results. Mario Morales-Máximo: technical design and simulation. Luis Bernardo López Sosa: conceptualization, research methodology, experimental design, writing of results, and writing of the manuscript. Carlos A. García: supervision and writing of the manuscript. Arturo Aguilera-Mandujano: calibration of the experimental equipment and writing of the manuscript. Cesar Ricardo Arias Navarrete: data processing, experimentation and writing of results. María del Carmen Rodríguez-Magallón: analysis of the state of the art of the subject and writing of results. All authors reviewed the manuscript.

Declaration of conflicting interests

The author(s) declared no potential conflicts of interest with respect to the research, authorship, and/or publication of this article.

Funding

The author(s) received no financial support for the research, authorship, and/or publication of this article.

ORCID iD

Luis Bernardo López Sosa

References

Akpinar

(2010) Drying of mint leaves in a solar dryer and under open sun: Modelling, performance analyses. Energy Conversion and Management 51(12): 2407–2418. Elsevier Ltd.

Bermejo-Martín

Rodríguez-Monroy

(2020) Design Thinking Methodology to Achieve Household Engagement in Urban Water Sustainability in the City. Water 12 (7): 1–19.

Bermúdez

Oliveira-Miranda

Velázquez

(2005) La Investigación Etnobotánica Sobre Plantas Medicinales : Una Revisión De Sus Objetivos Y Enfoques Actuales Alexis Bermúdez, María a . Oliveira-Miranda. Interciencia 30(8): 453–459.

Bhanudas

Chandramohan

Raju

VRK

, et al. (2020) A review on indirect type solar dryers for agricultural crops – Dryer setup, its performance, energy storage and important highlights. Applied Energy 258(October 2019): 114005. Elsevier.

Bosque

Muneta

Rey

, et al. (2021) Using design thinking to improve cook stoves development in Mexico. Sustainability (Switzerland) 13(7): 1–12.

Brown

(2009) Change by Design: How Design Thinking Transforms Organizations and Inspires Innovation. In: harpercollins (ed.) Markets, Globalization & Development Review. 1st ed. New York, USA.

Bucio-Sistos

Bernardo López-Sosa

Morales-Máximo

(2022) Multiparametric analysis of three construction systems considering sustainability indicators: Environmental, economic and energy-functional. Informes de la Construcción 567(2022): 1–12.

Buhl

Schmidt-keilich

Muster

, et al. (2019) Design thinking for sustainability : Why and how design thinking can foster sustainability-oriented innovation development. Journal of Cleaner Production 231(2019): 1248–1257.

Chavan

Yakupitiyage

Kumar

(2011) Drying performance, quality characteristics, and financial evaluation of Indian Mackerel (Rastrilliger kangurta) dried by a solar tunnel dryer. Thammasat International Journal of Science and Technology 2(16): 11–25.

10.

Ding

Zhao

, et al. (2012) Effect of drying methods on volatiles of Chinese ginger (Zingiber officinale Roscoe). Food and Bioproducts Processing 90(3): 515–524.

11.

EL-Mesery

EL-Seesy

, et al. (2022) Recent developments in solar drying technology of food and agricultural products: A review. Renewable and Sustainable Energy Reviews 157(December 2021): 112070. Elsevier Ltd.

12.

El-Sebaii

Shalaby

(2012) Solar drying of agricultural products: A review. Renewable and Sustainable Energy Reviews 16(1): 37–43. Elsevier Ltd.

13.

Gabriela Orozco-Gutiérrez, Hipólito Jesús Muñoz Flores, Ignacio Vidales Fernández MAR y RSG (2014) Somatic embryogenesis of Satureja macrostema (Benth.) Briq. a purepecha people traditional medicinal plant in Michoacan, Mexico. Foresta Veracruzana 13 (2): 13–18.

14.

Gilago

Chandramohan

(2022) Performance evaluation of natural and forced convection indirect type solar dryers during drying ivy gourd: An experimental study. Renewable Energy 182(2022): 934–945.

15.

Pardo de Santayana M and Gómez Pellón

(2003) Etnobotánica: Aprovechamiento tradicional de plantas y patrimonio cultural. Anales del jardín botánico de Madrid 60(1): 171–182.

16.

Hatami

Payehaneh

Mehrpanahi

(2019) Energy and exergy analysis of an indirect solar dryer based on a dynamic model. Journal of Cleaner Production 244(2020): 1–14.

17.

Hepbasli

EHKA

(2007) Exergetic evaluation of drying of laurel leaves in a vertical ground-source heat pump drying cabinet. International Journal of Energy Research 31(2007): 245–258.

18.

Hernán

Santos

(2016) Tecnologías Para Incluir (IESCT. Universidad Nacional de Quilmesed.). Primera. Buenos Aires: Lenguaje Claro.

19.

Jeanne Liedtka

(2011) Designing for Growth. A Design Thinking Toolkit for Managers (Columbia-University-Pressed.). Chichester, NY, USA: Columbia Business School Publishing.

20.

Kabeel

Hamed

Omara

, et al. (2017) Solar air heaters: Design configurations, improvement methods and applications – A detailed review. Renewable and Sustainable Energy Reviews 70(December): 1189–1206. Elsevier Ltd.

21.

Khallaf

AEM

El-Sebaii

(2022) Review on drying of the medicinal plants (herbs) using solar energy applications. Heat and Mass Transfer/Waerme- und Stoffuebertragung 58(8): 1411–1428. Springer Berlin Heidelberg.

22.

Kumar Jangde

Singh

Vellingri Arjunan

(2022) Efficient solar drying techniques: A review. Evironmental Science and Pollution Research 29(2022): 50970–50983.

23.

León

Lazos

(2014) Hacia Un Modelo Intercultural de Sociedad del Conocimiento en México.Trilogía Ciencia Tecnología Sociedad 8(15): 151–155.

24.

López-Sosa

González-Avilés

Hernández-Ramírez

, et al. (2020) Ecological solar absorber coating: A proposal for the use of residual biomass and recycled materials for energy conversion. Solar Energy 202(March): 238–248. Elsevier.

25.

López-Sosa

Núñez-González

Beltrán

, et al. (2019) A new methodology for the development of appropriate technology: A case study for the development of a wood solar dryer. Sustainability (Switzerland) 11(20), MDPI AG.

26.

López-Sosa

Ortíz-Carrión

Espinoza-Gómez

, et al. (2021) Solar air heating system with low environmental impact materials: Mathematical model and optothermal characterization. Sustainable Energy Technologies and Assessments 47(2021): 1–14.

27.

López-Sosa

Zárate-Medina

González-Avilés

, et al. (2022) Into the net zero emissions and climate change control: From solid carbon waste to effective solar convertors. Carbon 191(2022): 362–373.

28.

Ortíz-Moreno Masera

Raúl O

, et al. (2014) La Ecotecnología en Mexico. Imagia, first edition, México .

29.

Matavel

Hoffmann

Rybak

, et al. (2021) Discover Sustainability Passive solar dryers as sustainable alternatives for drying agricultural produce in sub - Saharan Africa: advances and challenges. Discover Sustainability 2(40): 1–15.

30.

Medina Huerta

(2021) La medicina tradicional p’urhépecha, sus trayectorias y las formas de organización comunitaria de las mujeres en Angahuan, Michoacán. Thesis of Master, in El Colegio de Michoacán: 1–226.

31.

Morales-Máximo

Rutiaga-Quiñones

Masera

, et al. (2022) Briquettes from Pinus spp. Residues : Energy Savings and Emissions Mitigation in the Rural Sector. Energies 15(9): 3419.

32.

Morales

JÁR

González-Avilés

Campuzano

, et al. (2020) T’imani a multifunctional Solar System to provide cooking and water heating rural energy needs. Energies 13(13).

33.

Mugi

Chandramohan

(2021) Energy and exergy analysis of forced and natural convection indirect solar dryers: Estimation of exergy inflow, outflow, losses, exergy efficiencies and sustainability indicators from drying experiments. Journal of Cleaner Production 282(2021): 1–15.

34.

Ramezanizadeh

Nazari

Ahmadi

, et al. (2018) A review on the solar applications of thermosyphons. Mathematical Modelling of Engineering Problems 5(4): 275–280.

35.

Seretse

Agarwal

Matlhogonolo

, et al. (2019) Article Thermodynamic Performance Evolution of an Inexpensive Prototype Solar Collector for 1 Kw Domestic Sthw Heating System in Botswana. IIOAB JOURNAL 10(5) :1–8.

36.

Sharma

Chen

Vu Lan

(2009) Solar-energy drying systems: A review. Renewable and Sustainable Energy Reviews 13(6-7): 1185–1210.

37.

Sosa

LBL

Avilés

Pérez

, et al. (2014) Rural Solar Cookers, an alternative to reduce the timber resource extraction through the use of renewable energy sources: Technology transfer and monitoring project. Energy Procedia, 57(2014): 1593–1602.

38.

UNESCO-ONU-Fundación Celestina Pérez de Almada (2005) Guia de uso de secaderos solares para frutas, legumbres, hortalizas, plantas medicinales y carnes. Asunción, Paraguay: 1-42.

39.

Valdes-Barrón

Riveros-Rosas

Arancibia-Bulnes

, et al. (2014) The solar resource assessment in Mexico: State of the art. Energy Procedia 57(2014): 1299–1308.