Culturally Responsive Differentiated Instruction: Narrowing Gaps between Best Pedagogical Practices Benefiting All Learners

Abstract

Background/Context

Because of its special education association, differentiated instruction (DI) is a topic of concern for many educators working with culturally and linguistically diverse (CLD) learners, whereby bilingual, multicultural, and culturally responsive teaching (CRT) is considered more appropriate for responding to cultural and linguistic diversity. Furthermore, although the literature base on DI recognizes cultural and linguistic diversity, it offers little in terms of ways to address these differences.

Purpose/Objective/Research Question/Focus of Study

The focus of this contribution is to assist the educational community in recognizing pedagogical differences, while finding common ground, in identifying complementary teaching practices for all students, including culturally diverse students and English language learners (ELLs). CRT and DI provide frameworks with which to discuss a reconciliation of both theory-to-practice approaches with the hope that a common framework will better serve educators and preservice teachers working with diverse students in complex multidimensional classrooms.

Setting

This research took place at two CLD elementary schools serving ELLs in North San Diego County, California. Schools were chosen because both are reaching high levels of academic achievement and are closing achievement gaps, dispelling the myth that high levels of poverty and/or CLD student populations lead to lower student achievement.

Research Design

The research design employed was a qualitative case study.

Data Collection and Analysis

Over 5 years, observations, recorded conversations among teachers, administrators, students, and parents, and supporting documents collected from both schools were initially coded by reading through responses and documents. Using a qualitative analysis procedure, codes were generated to identify data relevant to general features of DI and CRT. This was followed by more focused coding wherein previous codes were reviewed, erroneous information was eliminated, and smaller codes were then combined into larger ones. Finally, codes were organized into larger themes identified and grounded by DI and CRT literature.

Conclusions/Recommendations

The best teaching practices are those that consider all learners in a classroom setting and pay close attention to differences inherent to academic, cultural, linguistic, and socioeconomic diversity. Through a closer examination of two different, seemingly distinct, theoretical models that have rarely been linked or reconciled, educators may be able to determine what is appropriate for particular groups of students in particular classrooms in particular locales. In implementing school reform efforts to improve student achievement, reconciliation of best teaching practices and the creation of hybrid pedagogies are critical in addressing a future of an increasingly diverse country and global community.

References

Abrahams

R. D.

, & Troike

R. C.

(Eds.). (1972). Language and cultural diversity in American education. Englewood Cliffs, NJ: Prentice Hall.

Allan

(1991). Ability grouping research reviews: What do they say about grouping and the gifted? Educational Leadership, 48 6, 60—65.

Aragon

(1973). An impediment to cultural pluralism: Culturally deficient educators attempting to teach culturally different children. In Stent

M. D.

Hazard

W. R.

, & Rivlin

H. N.

(Eds.), Cultural pluralism in education: A mandate for change (pp. 77—84). New York: Appleton-Century-Crofts.

Artiles

A. J.

, & Ortiz

A. O.

(Eds.). (2002). English language learners with special education needs (pp. 133—157). Washington, DC, and McHenry, IL: Center for Applied Linguistics and Delta Systems.

Artiles

A. J.

, & Trent

S. C.

(1997). Building a knowledge base on culturally diverse students with learning disabilities: The need to enrich research with a sociocultural perspective. Learning Disabilities Research and Practice, 12, 80—81.

K. H.

, & Kawakami

A. J.

(1994). Cultural congruence in instruction. In Hollins

E. R.

King

J. E.

, & Hayman

W. C.

(Eds.), Teaching diverse populations: Formulating a knowledge base (pp. 5—23). Albany: State University of New York Press.

Baca

, & Cervantes

(Eds.). (2004). The bilingual special education interface (4th ed.). Upper Saddle River, NJ: Merrill.

Banks

J. A.

(1975). Teaching ethnic studies: Key issues and concepts. Social Studies, 66 3, 107—113.

Banks

J. A.

, & Banks

C. A. M.

(Eds.). (2004). Handbook of research on multicultural education (2nd ed.). San Francisco: Jossey-Bass.

10.

Banks

J. A.

Cookson

Gay

Hawley

W. D.

Irvine

J. J.

Nieto

(2001). Diversity within unity: Essential principles for teaching and learning in a multicultural. Phi Delta Kappan, 83, 196—203.

11.

Berger

S. L.

(1991). Differentiating curriculum for gifted students. Reston, VA.: ERIC Clearinghouse on Handicapped and Gifted Children. (ERIC ED342175). Retrieved February 22, 2007, from http://eric.ed.gov/ERICWebPortal/custom/portlets/recordDetails/detailmini.jsp?_nfpb=true&_&ERICExtSearch_SearchValue_0=ED342175&ERICExtSearch_SearchType_0=eric_accno&accno=ED342175

12.

Bloom

B. S.

(1956). Taxonomy of educational objectives: The classification of educational goals. Handbook I: Cognitive domain (n. pag.). New York: Longmans, Green.

13.

Bruner

J. S.

(1966). Towards a theory of instruction. New York: Norton.

14.

Chamot

A. U.

(1995). Implementing the cognitive academic language approach: CALLA in Arlington, Virginia. Bilingual Research Journal, 19, 379—394.

15.

Cole

(1996). Cultural psychology: A once and future discipline. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.

16.

Cuban

(1972). Ethnic content and “White” instruction. Phi Delta Kappan, 53, 270—273.

17.

Darling-Hammond

(1997). The right to learn: A blueprint for creating schools that work. San Francisco: Jossey-Bass.

18.

Delpit

(1995). Other people's children. New York: New York Press.

19.

Doherty

R. W.

Hilberg

R. S.

Pinal

, & Tharp

R. G.

(2003). Five standards and standard achievement. NABE Journal of Research and Practice, 1 1, 1—24.

20.

Feldhusen

H. J.

(1993). Individualized teaching of the gifted in regular classrooms. In Maker

C. J.

(Ed.), Critical issues in gifted education, vol 3: Programs for the gifted in regular classrooms (pp. 263—273). Austin TX: PRO-ED.

21.

Feldhusen

(1989). Program models for gifted education. In Feldhusen

Van Tassel-Baska

, & Seeley

(Eds.), Excellence in educating the gifted (pp. 103—122). Denver, CO: Love Publishing.

22.

Feldhusen

Hansen

, & Kennedy

(1989). Curriculum development for GCT teachers. GCT, 12 6, 1219.

23.

Forbes

J. A.

(1973). Teaching Native American values and cultures. In Teaching ethnic studies: Concepts and strategies (pp. 200—219). Washington, DC: National Council for the Social Studies.

24.

Freire

(1985). The politics of education: culture, power, and liberation (D. Macedo, Trans.). South Hadley, MA: Bergin.

25.

Fung

(1998). Meeting the instructional needs of Chinese American and Asian English language development and at-risk students. In Ooka Pang

, & Cheng

L. L.

(Eds.), Struggling to be heard: The unmet needs of Asian Pacific American children (197—221). Albany: State University of New York Press.

26.

Gardner

(1983). Frames of mind: The theory of multiple intelligences. New York: Basic Books.

27.

Gardner

(1995). Reflections on multiple intelligences: Myths and messages. Phi Delta Kappan, 77, 200—203, 206–209.

28.

Gardner

(1999). The disciplined mind: What all students should understand. New York: Simon and Schuster.

29.

Gay

(1975). Organizing and designing culturally pluralistic curriculum. Educational Leadership, 33, 176—183.

30.

Gay

(2000). Culturally responsive teaching: Theory, research, and practice. New York: Teachers College Press.

31.

Glesne

(2005). Becoming qualitative researchers: An introduction (3rd ed.). Boston: Pearson.

32.

Goldstein

(1999). The relational zone: The role of caring relationships in the co-construction of mind. American Educational Research Journal, 36, 647—673.

33.

Golnick

, & Chinn

(2004). Multicultural education in a pluralistic society. Columbus, OH: Merrill Prentice Hall.

34.

Gonzalez

Moll

L. C.

Floyd-Tennery

Rivera

Rendon

, & Amanti

(1993). Funds of knowledge for teaching in Latino households. Urban Education, 2, 443—470.

35.

Guild

P. B.

, & Garger

(1998). What is differentiated instruction? In marching to different drummers (2nd ed., p. 2). Alexandria, VA: Association for Supervision and Curriculum Development.

36.

Gutierrez

K. D.

, & Rogoff

(2003). Cultural ways of learning: Individual traits or repertoires of practice? Educational Researcher, 32 5, 19—25.

37.

Hall

Strangman

, & Meyer

(2003). Differentiated instruction and implications for UDL implementation. Retrieved February 22, 2007, from the Access Center Web site: http://www.k8accesscenter.org/training_resources/udl/diffinstruction.asp

38.

Heacox

(2001). Differentiating instruction in the regular classroom. Minneapolis, MN: Freespirit.

39.

Holloway

J. H.

(2000). Preparing teachers for differentiated instruction. Educational Leadership, 58, 82—83.

40.

Irvine

J. J.

(2002). In search of wholeness: African American teachers and their culturally specific classroom practices. New York: Palgrave.

41.

Johnson

D. W.

, & Johnson

R. T.

(2002). Ensuring diversity is positive: Cooperative community, constructive conflict, and civic values. In Thousand

J. S.

Villa

R. A.

, & Nevin

A. I.

(Eds.), Creativity and collaborative learning: The practical guide to empowering students, teachers, and families (2nd ed., pp. 197—208). Baltimore: Paul H. Brookes.

42.

Jordan

(1995). Creating cultures of schooling: Historical and conceptual background of the KEEP/rough rock project. The Bilingual Research Journal, 19, 83—100.

43.

Kalbfleisch

M. L.

(1997). So why bother? The usefulness of applied science to the general public. Brainstorm: A Journal of Mind and Brain Science, 3 1, 2—5.

44.

King

(1994). The purpose of schooling for African American children: Including cultural knowledge. In Hollins

E. R.

King

J. E.

, & Hayman

W. C.

(Eds.), Teaching diverse populations: Formulating a knowledge base (pp. 25—66). Albany: State University of New York Press.

45.

Kulik

J. A.

, & Kulik

C. C.

(1992). Meta-analytic findings on grouping programs. Gifted Child Quarterly, 36, 73—77.

46.

Ladson-Billings

(1994). The dreamkeepers: Successful teachers of African American children. San Francisco: Jossey-Bass.

47.

Ladson-Billings

(2000). Fighting for our lives: Preparing teachers to teach African American students. Journal of Teacher Education, 51, 206—214.

48.

Ladson-Billings

(2001). Crossing over to Canaan: The journey of new teachers in diverse classrooms. San Francisco: Jossey-Bass.

49.

Lawrence-Brown

(2004). Differentiated instruction. American Secondary Education, 32 3, 34—62.

50.

Litton

E. F.

(1999). Learning in America: The Filipino-American sociocultural perspective. In Park

, & Chi

M. M.

(Eds.), Asian-American education: Prospects and challenges (pp. 131—154). Westport, CT: Bergin and Garvey.

51.

Maker

C. J.

(1982). Curriculum development for the gifted. Rockville, MD: Aspen.

52.

Maker

C. J.

, & Nielson

A. B.

(1996). Curriculum development and teaching strategies for gifted learners (2nd ed.). Austin, TX: PRO-ED.

53.

Maker

C. J.

, & Schiever

S. W.

(1989). Critical issues in gifted education: Defensible programs for cultural and ethnic minorities (Vol. 2). Austin, TX: PRO-ED.

54.

McCarty

T. L.

(2002). A place to be Navajo: Rough rock and the struggle for self-determination in indigenous schooling. Mahwah, NJ: Erlbaum.

55.

Moll

(1990). Vygotsky and education: Instructional implications and applications of sociohistorical psychology. New York: Cambridge University Press.

56.

Moll

(1992). Literacy research into communities and classrooms: A sociocultural approach. In Beach

Green

, & Shanahan

(Eds.), Multidisciplinary perspectives in literacy research (pp. 47—73). Urbana, IL: National Council of Teachers of English.

57.

Moll

L. C.

Amanti

Neff

, & González

(1992). Funds of knowledge for teaching: Using a qualitative approach to connect homes and classrooms. Theory Into Practice, 31, 132—141.

58.

Moll

L. C.

, & Greenberg

(1990). Creating zones of possibilities: Combining social contexts for instruction. In Moll

L. C.

(Ed.), Vygotsky and education (pp. 319—348). Cambridge, England: Cambridge University Press.

59.

Morelli

Rogoff

, & Angelillo

(2003). Cultural variation in children's access to work or involvement in specialized child-focused activities. International Journal of Behavioral Development, 27, 264—274.

60.

Nieto

(2004). Affirming diversity: The sociopolitical context of multicultural education (4th ed.). White Plains, NY: Longman.

61.

Oakes

(1985). Keeping track: How schools structure inequality. New Haven, CT: Yale University Press.

62.

Oakes

(1990). Multiplying inequalities: The effects of races, social class, and tracking on opportunities to learn mathematics and science. Santa Monica, CA: RAND.

63.

Obiakor

F. E.

(2007). Multicultural special education: effective intervention for today's schools. Intervention in School and Clinic, 42, 148—155.

64.

Ooka Pang

(2005). Multicultural education: A caring-centered approach (2nd ed.). Boston: McGraw-Hill.

65.

Padron

Y. N.

, & Waxman

H. C.

(1999). Classroom observations of the five standards of effective teaching in urban classrooms with English language learners. Teaching and Change, 7, 79—100.

66.

Padron

Y. N.

Waxman

H. C.

, & Rivera

H. H.

(2002). Educating Hispanic students: Effective instructional practices (Practitioner Brief No. 5). Retrieved October 10, 2004, from Center for Applied Linguistics Web site: http://www.cal.org/crede/Pubs/PracBrief5.htm

67.

Randi

, & Corno

(2005). Teaching and learner variation. In Tomlinson

, & Winne

(Eds.), Pedagogy: Teaching for learning. Monograph series II: Psychological aspects of education (No. 3, pp. 47—69). Leicester, England: British Psychological Society.

68.

Rivera

, & Zehler

A. M.

(1991). Assuring the academic success of language minority students: Collaboration in teaching and learning. Journal of Education, 173, 52—77.

69.

Santamaría

L. J.

(2003, March). Multicultural education, English language learners, and academic achievement in elementary school: Moving theory into practice. Paper presented at the 2003 American Educational Research Association annual meeting, Chicago, IL.

70.

Santamaría

L. J.

Fletcher

T. V.

, & Bos

C. S.

(2002). Effective pedagogy for English language learners in inclusive classrooms. In Ortiz

, & Artiles

(Eds.), English language learners with special education needs (pp. 133—157). Washington, DC: Center for Applied Linguistics (CAL).

71.

Santamaría

L. J.

, & Thousand

J. A.

(2004). Collaboration, co-teaching, and differentiated instruction a process-oriented approach to whole schooling. International Journal of Whole Schooling, 1 1, 13—27.

72.

Slavin

R. E.

(1986). Ability grouping and student achievement in elementary schools: A best-evidence synthesis (Report No. 1). Baltimore: Johns Hopkins University, Center for Research on Elementary and Middle Schools.

73.

Slavin

R. E.

(1987). Ability grouping and achievement in elementary schools: A best-evidence synthesis. Review of Educational Research, 57, 293—336.

74.

Slavin

R. E.

(1990). Achievement effects of ability grouping in secondary schools: A best-evidence synthesis. Review of Educational Research, 60, 471—499.

75.

Smith

G. P.

(1998). Common sense about uncommon knowledge: The knowledge bases for diversity. Washington, DC: American Association of Colleges for Teacher Education.

76.

Strauss

, & Corbin

(1990). Basics of qualitative research: Grounded theory procedures and techniques. Newbury Park, CA: Sage.

77.

Strong

Perini

Silver

, & Thomas

(2004). Creating a differentiated mathematics classroom. Educational Leadership, 61 5. Retrieved May 2, 2004, from http://www.ascd.org/publications/ed_lead/200402/toc.html

78.

Taba

(1962). Curriculum development: Theory and practice. New York: Harcourt, Brace, and World.

79.

Tharp

R. G.

Estrada

Dalton

S. S.

, & Yamaguchi

(2000). Teaching transformed: Achieving excellence, fairness, inclusion, and harmony. Boulder, CO: Westview Press.

80.

Tharp

R. G.

, & Gallimore

(1988). Rousing minds to life: Teaching, learning, and schooling in social contexts. New York: Cambridge University Press.

81.

Theroux

(2001). Enhance learning with technology: Differentiating instruction. Retrieved September 10, 2007, from http://members.shaw.ca/priscillatheroux/differentiating.html

82.

Tomlinson

C. A.

(1995). Differentiating instruction for advanced learners in the mixed-ability middle school classroom. Reston, VA: ERIC Clearinghouse on Disabilities and Gifted Education. (ERIC Document Reproduction Service No. ED389141)

83.

Tomlinson

C. A.

(1999). The differentiated classroom: Responding to the needs of all learners. Alexandria, VA: Association for Supervision and Curriculum Development.

84.

Tomlinson

C. A.

(2000). Differentiation of instruction in the elementary grades. Reston, VA: ERIC Digest. (ERIC Document Reproduction Service No. ED443572)

85.

Tomlinson

C. A.

(2001). How to differentiate instruction in mixed-ability classrooms. (2nd ed.) Alexandria, VA: Association for Supervision and Curriculum Development.

86.

Tomlinson

C. A.

Brimijoin

, & Narvaez

(2008). The differentiated school: Making revolutionary changes in teaching and learning. Alexandria, VA: Association for Supervision and Curriculum Development.

87.

Tomlinson

C. A.

(2003). Fulfilling the promise of the differentiated classroom: Strategies and tools for responsive teaching. Alexandria, VA: Association for Supervision and Curriculum Development.

88.

Tomlinson

C. A.

, & Allan

S. D.

(2000). Leadership for differentiating schools and classrooms. Alexandria, VA: Association for Supervision and Curriculum Development.

89.

Tomlinson

C. A.

, & Kalbfleisch

M. L.

(1998). Teach me, teach my brain: A call for differentiated classrooms. Educational Leadership, 56 3, 52—55.

90.

Van Tassel-Baska

(1989). Appropriate curriculum for the gifted. In Feldhusen

Van Tassel-Baska

, & Seeley

(Eds.), Excellence in educating the gifted (pp. 175—191). Denver, CO: Love Publishing.

91.

Van Tassel-Baska

(1992). Educational decision making on acceleration and grouping. Gifted Child Quarterly, 36, 68—72.

92.

Vaughn

Bos

, & Schumm

(2000). Teaching exceptional, diverse, and at-risk students in the general education classroom (2nd ed.). Boston: Allyn and Bacon.

93.

Vygotsky

(1978). Mind in society: The development of higher psychological processes (M. Cole, V. John-Steiner, S. Scribner, & E. Souberman, Trans.). Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.

94.

Waldron

, & McCleskey

(1998). The effects of an inclusive school program on students with mild and severe learning disabilities. Exceptional Children, 64, 395—405.

95.

Weinstein

R. S.

(1996). High standards in a tracked system of schooling: For which students and with what educational supports? Educational Researcher, 25 8, 16—19.

96.

Wertsch

J. V.

(1991). Voices of the mind: A sociocultural approach to mediated action. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.

97.

Winebrener

(1992). Teaching gifted kids in the regular classroom. Minneapolis, MN: Free Spirit.