The applicability, validity and usefulness of Karl Popper’s ‘Three Worlds’ epistemology is examined, with specific reference to health-care information and knowledge. It is concluded that Popper’s ideas provide a valuable way of understanding this domain and that, in particular, Popper’s controversial ‘World 3’ of objective knowledge is a valid concept.
References
1.
[1] B.C. Brookes , The foundations of information science. Part 1: philosophical aspects , Journal of Information Science2 (1980), 125-133 .
2.
[2] B.C. Brookes , The fundamental problem of information science. In: Informatics 2 ( Aslib, London , 1974), pp. 42-49.
3.
[3] R. Abbott , Information transfer and cognitive mismatch: a Popperian model for studies of public understanding , Journal of Information Science23(2) (1997) 129-137 .
4.
[4] R. Capurro , What is information science for? A philosophical reflection. In: P. Vakkari and B. Cronin (eds), Conceptions of Library and Information Science: Historical, Empirical and Theoretical Persepctives ( Taylor Graham, London , 1992), pp. 82-96.
5.
[5] R. Capurro , Hermeneutik der Fachinformation ( Alber, Frieburg , 1986).
6.
[6] W. Chongde , Popper’s theory of ‘three worlds’ and information science [in Chinese] , Journal of Information, Communication and Library Science4(1) (1997), 26-31 .
7.
[7] C. Cole , The activity of understanding a problem during interaction with an ‘enabling’ information retrieval system: modelling information flow , Journal of the American Society for Information Science50(6) (1999), 544-552 .
8.
[8] C. Cole and B. Mandelblatt , Using Kintsch’s discourse comprehension theory to model the user’s coding of an informative message from an enabling information retrieval system , Journal of the American Society for Information Science51(11) (2000) 1033-1046 .
9.
[9] R. Davies , The creation of new knowledge by information retrieval and classification , Journal of Documentation45(4) (1989) 273-301 .
10.
[10] J. Essers and Schreinmakers , Nonaka’s subjectivist conception of knowledge in corporate knowledge management , Knowledge Organisation24(1) (1997) 24-32 .
11.
[11] J. Fiscella , Embedded philosophy: a case for librarian-ship as philosophy in practice , International Journal of Applied Philosophy4 (1989) 61-66 .
12.
[12] P.L. Galina , Karl Popper’s 3 Worlds and some considerations for information science . In: Proceedings of the 11th Annual Conference of the Canadian Association for Information Science, Perth (CAIS, Ontario, 1983), pp. 195-203 .
13.
[13] P. Ingwersen , Psychological aspects of information retrieval , Social Science Information Studies4(2-3) (1984) 83-95 .
14.
[14] U. Jochum , Zur neopositivistischen bibliothekstheorie [On neopositivistic library theory] , Bibliothek Forschung und Praxis18(3) (1994) 388-394 .
15.
[15] K. McGarry , The Changing Context of Information: an Introductory Analysis, 2nd edn ( Library Association, London , 1993).
16.
[16] K. McGarry , Epilogue: differing views of knowledge. In: A.J. Meadows (ed.), Knowledge and Communication: Essays on the Information Chain, London: Library Association , 1991), pp. 132-152.
17.
[17] S.D. Neill , The dilemma of the subjective in information organisation and retrieval , Journal of Documentation43(3) (1987) 193-211 .
18.
[18] S.D. Neill , The reference process and the philosophy of Karl Popper , Research Quarterly24(3) (1985) 309-319 .
19.
[19] S.D. Neill , Brookes, Popper and objective knowledge , Journal of Information Science4(1) (1982) 33-39 .
20.
[20] J.Z. Nitecki , Metalibrarianship: a Model for the Intellectual Foundations of Library Information Science, ERIC Report Number DE363346, chapter 6 (1993). Available as www.du.edu/LIS/collab/library/nitecki/metalibrarianship/ch-06.htm (accessed 23 August 2001).
21.
[21] D. Rudd , Do we really need World III? Information science with or without Popper , Journal of Information Science7(3) (1983) 99-105 .
22.
[22] A. Serrai , Funzioni e valori della bibliografia. [The functions and values of bibliography.]Bibliotecario1996(1) 5-11 .
23.
[23] A. Serrai, Temi di attualita bibliotecaria (Burzone, Rome, 1981).
24.
[24] D.R. Swanson , Libraries and the growth of knowledge , Library Quarterly50(1) (1980) 112-134 .
25.
[25] K.J. Weintraub , The humanistic scholar and the library , Library Quarterly50(1) (1980) 22-39 .
26.
[26] Swanson DR, Fish oil, Reynaud’s syndrome and undiscovered public knowledge , Perspectives in Biology and Medicine30 (1986) 7-18 .
[28] D.R. Swanson , Medical knowledge as a potential source of new knowledge , Bulletin of the Medical Libraries Association78(1) (1990) 29-37 .
29.
[29] B.R. Gaines , Methodology in the large: modeling is all there is , Systems Research1(2) (1984) 91-103 .
30.
[30] B.R. Gaines , Computers in world three , Proceedings of the International Conference on Cybernetics and Society, Part III (IEEE, New York, 1978), pp. 1515-1521 .
31.
[31] M.L.G. Shaw and B.R. Gaines , A cognitive model for intelligent information systems. In: R. Davies (ed.), Intelligent Information Systems: Progress and Prospects ( Ellis Horwood, Chichester , 1986).
32.
[32] P. Checkland , Systems Thinking, Systems Practice ( John Wiley, Chichester , 1981).
33.
[33] S.K. Probert , The metaphysical assumptions of the (main) soft systems methodology advocates. In: R.L. Winder , S.K. Probert and I.A. Beeson (eds), Philosophical Aspects of Information Systems ( Taylor and Francis, London , 1997), pp. 131-150.
34.
[34] B.R.Gaines , A conceptual framework for person-computer interaction in distributed systems , IEEE Transactions Systems, Man and CyberneticsSMC-18(4) (1988) 532-541 .
35.
[35] B.R. Gaines , HCI in the Next Millenium: Supporting the World Mind , paper presented at Interact’99 (1999). Available at http://citeseer.nj.nec.com/387298.html (accessed 23 August 2001).
36.
[36] C. Lamontagne and J. Bourdeau , Towards an epistemology for guided discovery tutoring: the Popperian connection . In: Proceedings of the Second International Conference on Intelligent Tutoring Systems (Springer, Berlin, 1992), pp. 92-102 .
37.
[37] J.R. Moehr , Health informatics - a scientific challenge , Methods of Information in Medicine33(3) (1994) 250-253 .
38.
[38] K.E. Pettigrew and L. McKechnie , The use of theory in information science research , Journal of the American Society for Information Science52(1) (2001) 62-73 .
39.
[39] C. Urquhart , Personal knowledge: a clinical perspective from the VALUE and EVINCE projects in health library and information services , Journal of Documentation54(4) (1998) 420-442 .
40.
[40] M.S. Blois , Conceptual issues in computer-aided diagnosis and the hierarchical nature of medical knowledge , Journal of Medicine and Philosophy8(1) (1983) 29-50 .
41.
[41] R. Smith , What clinical information do doctors need?British Medical Journal313(7064) (1996) 1062-1068 .
42.
[42] K.R. Popper , Objective Knowledge; an Evolutionary Approach, revised edition ( Oxford University Press, Oxford , 1979), Chapters 3 and 4.
43.
[43] K.R. Popper , Knowledge and the shaping of reality: the search for a better world. In: In Search of a Better World: Lectures and Essays from Thirty Years ( Routledge, London , 1992), pp. 3-29.
44.
[44] K.R. Popper , An objective theory of historical understanding. In: In Search of a Better World: Lectures and Essays from Thirty Years ( Routledge, London , 1992), pp. 161-172.
45.
[45] K.R. Popper , Unended Quest: an Intellectual Autobiography, revised edition ( Routledge, London , 1992), particularly Chapters 38 and 39.
46.
[46] K.R. Popper , Notes of a realist on the mind-body problem. In: All Life is Problem Solving ( Routledge, London , 1992), pp. 23-35.
47.
[47] K.R. Popper , Epistemology without a knowing subject. In: B. Van Rootselaar (ed.), Logic, Methodology and Philosophy of Science III, Amsterdam: North-Holland, Amsterdam , 1999), pp. 333-373.
48.
[48] B. Magee , Popper ( Fontana, London , 1973), especially Chapters 4 and 5.
49.
[49] A. O’Hear , Karl Popper ( Routledge, London , 1980), Chapter 9.
50.
[50] M.A. Notturno , Science and the Open Society; the Future of Karl Popper’s Philosophy ( Central European University Press, Budapest , 2000), Chapter 7.
51.
[51] D. Baird , Encapsulating knowledge: the direct reading spectrometer , Techné - Society for Philosophy and Technology3(3) (1998). Available at: http://scholar.lib.vt.ejournals/SPT/v3n3/html/BAIRD.html (accessed 22 August 2001).
52.
[52] P.K. Moser and A. Van der Nat , Human Knowledge: Classical and Contemporary Aproaches ( Oxford University Press, New York , 1987).
53.
[53] J.D. Barrow , Pi in the Sky; Counting, Thinking and Being ( Oxford University Press, Oxford , 1992).
54.
[54] M.K. Buckland , Information as knowledge , Journal of the American Society for Information Science2(3-4) (1991) 351-360 .
55.
[55] D.C. Slawson , A.F. Shaughnessy and J.H. Bennett , Becoming a medical information master , Journal of Family Practice38(5) (1994) 505-513 .
56.
[56] J.C. Wyatt , Knowledge for the clinician. 4. Keeping up: continuing education or lifelong learning? , Journal of the Royal Society of Medicine93(7) (2000) 369-372 .
57.
[57] J.C. Wyatt , Use and sources of medical knowledge , Lancet338(8779) (1991) 1368-1372 .
58.
[58] J.C. Wyatt , Knowledge for the clinician. 5. Reading journals and monitoring the published work , Journal of the Royal Society of Medicine93(8) (2000) 423-427 .
59.
[59] R. Kiley, Number of medical journals, posting to the LIS-MEDICAL mailing list 4 September 2000. Available from the archives at: www.jiscmail.ac.uk (accessed 25 August 2001).
60.
[60] B.L. Humphreys and D.E. McCutcheon , Growth patterns in the National Library of Medicine’s serials collection and in Index Medicus journals 1966-1985 , Bulletin of the Medical Libraries Association82(1) (1994) 18-24 .
61.
[61] M.S. Blois , Information and Medicine. The Nature of Medical Descriptors ( University of California Press, Berkely, CA , 1994).
62.
[62] S.J. Tanebaum , Knowing and acting in medical practice: the epistemological politics of outcomes research , Journal of Health Politics, Policy and Law19(1) (1994) 27-44 .
63.
[63] K. Malterud , The art and science of clinical knowledge: evidence beyond measures and numbers , Lancet358 (2001) 397-400 .
64.
[64] D.J. Weatherall , Scientific method and the art of healing. In: The Oxford Textbook of Medicine ( Oxford University Press, Oxford , 1996), Chapter 2.1.
65.
[65] M. Polanyi , Personal Knowledge ( Routledge and Kegan Paul, London , 1958).
66.
[66] M. Polanyi , The Tacit Dimension ( Doubleday, Garden City, New York , 1966).
67.
[67] M. Polanyi , The tacit dimension. In: L. Prusak (ed.), Knowledge in Organizations ( Butterworth-Heinemann, Boston, MA , 1997), pp. 135-146.
68.
[68] S. Richmond , The two cultures problem , paper presented at the 20th World Congress of Philosophy, Boston, MA (1998). Available at: www.bu.edu/wcp/Papers/Scie/ScieRich.htm (accessed 23 August 2001).
69.
[69] S. Antrobus , Developing the nurse as a knowledge worker in health - learning the artistry of practice , Journal of Advanced Nursing25(4) (1997) 829-835 .
70.
[70] J.C. Wyatt , Management of explicit and tacit knowledge , Journal of the Royal Society of Medicine94(1) (2001) 6-9 .
71.
[71] RCN , The Value of Nursing ( Royal College of Nursing, London , 1992).
72.
[72] R.M. Hamm , Clinical intuition and clinical analysis: expertise and the cognitive continuum. In: J. Dowie and A. Elstein (eds), Professional Judgement: a Reader in Clinical Decision Making ( Cambridge University Press, Cambridge , 1988), pp. 78-105.
73.
[73] V.L. Patel , J.F. Arocha and D.R. Kaufman , Expertise and tacit knowledge in medicine. In: R.J. Sternberg and J.A. Horvath (eds), Tacit Knowledge in Professional Practice ( Lawrence Erlbaum Associates, Mahwah, NJ , 1999), pp. 75-99.
74.
[74] J.J. Cimino , Development of expertise in medical practice. In: RJ Sternberg and JA Horvath (eds), Tacit Knowledge in Professional Practice ( Lawrence Erlbaum AssociatesMahwah NJ , 1999), pp. 101-118.
75.
[75] J.F. Arocha and V.L. Patel , Monitoring knowledge and problem solving performance in medicine . In: Proceedings of the Fifth World Conference on Computers in Education, (Elsevier, Amsterdam,1990), pp. 327-332 .
76.
[76] V.L. Patel , J.F. Arocha and D.R. Kaufman , Diagnostic reasoning and expertise , The Psychology of Learning and Motivation: Advances in Research and Theory31 (1994) 137-252 .
77.
[77] V. Florance , Medical knowledge for clinical problem solving: a structural analysis of clinical questions , Bulletin of the Medical Libraries Association80(2) (1992) 140-149 .
78.
[78] R. Davis , C.J. Urquhart , J. Smith , C. Massiter and J.B. Hepworth , Establishing the Value of Information to Nursing Continuing Education: Report of the EVINCE Project, British Library RIC Report no. 44 ( British Library, Boston Spa , 1997).
79.
[79] C. Urquhart and J.B. Hepworth , The Value to Clinical Decision Making of Information Supplied by the NHS Library and Information Services, British Library Research and Development Report no. 6205 ( British Library, Boston Spa , 1995).
80.
[80] D.L. Sackettet al. , Evidence based medicine: what it is and what it isn’t , British Medical Journal312(7023) (1996) 71-71 .
81.
[81] J.C. Wyatt , Same information, different decisions: format counts , British Medical Journal318(7197) (1999) 1501-1502 .
82.
[82] K. Malterud , The legitimacy of clinical knowledge: towards a medical epistemology embracing the art of medicine , Theoretical Medicine16(2) (1995) 183-198 .
83.
[83] J.W. Elyet al. , Analysis of questions asked by family doctors regarding patient care , British Medical Journal319(7206) (1999) 358-361 .
84.
[84] D.R. Swanson , Intervening in the life cycle of scientific knowledge , Library Trends41(4) (1993) 606-631 .
85.
[85] S.G. Paukeret al. , Towards the simulation of clinical cognition. Taking a present illness by computer , American Journal of Medicine60(7) (1976) 981-996 .
86.
[86] H. Walker , Classification and coding. In: R. Sheaf and V. Peel (eds), Managing Health Service Information Systems ( Open University Press, Buckingham , 1995), Chapter 9.
87.
[87] P. Jones , Introduction to Coding and Classification (2001). Available at: www.p-jones.demon.co.uk/infselct.htm (accessed 24 August 2001).
88.
[88] W. Hirs , The use of terminological principles and methods in medicine. In: H.B. Sonnevald and K.L. Loening (eds), Terminology; Applications in Interdisciplinary Communication ( John Benjamins, Amsterdam , 1993), pp. 223-240.
89.
[89] S. He , Translingual alteration of conceptual information in medical translation: a crosslanguage analysis between English and Chinese , Journal of the American Society for Information Science51(11) (2000) 1047-1060 .
90.
[90] S. Jenny , Medicine and medical concepts , Forschende Komplementarmedizin6(1) (1999) 60-65 .
91.
[91] A.M. Rassinouxet al. , Modeling concepts in medicine for medical language understanding , Methods of Information in Medicine37(4-5) (1998) 361-372 .
92.
[92] D.A. Evanset al. , Toward representations for medical concepts , Medical Decision Making11(4 Suppl) (1991) S102-S108 .
93.
[93] S. Loh , J.P.M. de Oliveira and F.L. Gastal , Knowledge discovery in textual documentation: qualitative and quantitative aspects , Journal of Documentation57(5) (2001) 577-590 .
94.
[94] D.R. Swanson , N.R. Smalheiser and A. Bookstein , Information discovery from complementary literatures: categorising viruses as potential weapons , Journal of the American Society for Information Science and Technology52(10) (2001) 797-812 .
95.
[95] D.R. Swanson and N.R. Smalheiser , Implicit text linkages between Medline records: using Arrowsmith as an aid to scientific discovery , Library Trends48(1) (1999) 48-59 .
96.
[96] N.R. Smalheiser and D.R. Swanson , Using ARROW-SMITH: a computer-assisted approach to formulating and assessing scientific hypotheses , Computer Methods and Programs in Biomedicine57(3) (1998) 149-153 .
97.
[97] D.R. Swanson and N.R. Smalheiser , An interactive system for finding complementary literatures: a stimulus to scientific discovery , Artificial Intelligence91(2) (1997) 183-203 .
98.
[98] D.R. Swanson , A second example of mutually isolated medical literatures related by implicit, unnoticed connections , Journal of the American Society for Information Science40(6) (1989) 432-435 .
99.
[99] D.R. Swanson , Online search for logically-related noninteractive medical literatures - a systematic trial-and-error strategy , Journal of the American Society for Information Science40(5) (1989) 356-358 .
100.
[100] M.D. Gordon and S. Dumais , Using latent semantic indexing for literature based discovery , Journal of the American Society for Information Science49 (1998) 674-685 .
101.
[101] M.D. Gordon and R.K. Lindsay , Toward discovery support systems: a replication, re-examination and extension of Swanson’s work on literature-based discovery of a connection between Raynaud’s and fish oil , Journal of the American Society for Information Science47 (1996) 116-128 .
102.
[102] M. Weeberet al. , Using concepts in literature-based discovery: simulating Swanson’s Raynaud-fish oil and migraine-magnesium discoveries , Journal of the American Society for Information Science52(7) (2001) 548-557 .
103.
[103] K.A. Cory , Discovering hidden analogies in an online humanities database , Computers and the Humanities31(1) (1997) 1-12 .
104.
[104] C. Cookson , Bookstore find aids cancer fight , Financial Times 31 June 2000.
