The moment of municipal feminism: gender and class in 1980s local government

Abstract

This paper discusses the tensions in the relationship between munici pal feminism, the urban left and the trade union movement and identi fies the period from 1983 to 1987 as the 'moment of municipal femin. ism'. It argues that since that period the concept of equal opportunities has narrowed considerably. It shows that inequalities between women working for local authorities have widened appreciably, even though the rhetoric of local authority management increasingly echoes municipal feminist critiques of hierarchical management

References

Apter, T.

(1993) Professional Progress. Why Women Still Don't Have Wives, Basmgstoke: Macmillan.

Bagilhole, B.

(1993) 'Managing to be fair. implementing equal opportunities m a local authority', Local Government Studies, Vol 19:2, Summer.

Banks, T.

(1980) 'The lessons of the GLC 1973-1977', LondonLabour Briefing, 5 September

Boddy, M.

and

Fudge, C.

(1984) Local Socialism, London. Macmillan.

Branson, N.

(1979) Poplarism 1919-1925, London : Lawrence and Wishart.

Bruegel, I.

(1985) 'Will women lose out again', New Socialist, May.

Bruegel, I.

and

Perrons, D.

(1996) 'Where do the costs of unequal opportunities lie ?' Gender, Work, Organisation, Vol 2:3, pp110-121

Cockburn, C.

(1977) The Local State, London: Pluto Press.

Cockburn, C.

(1991) In the Way of Women, LondonMacmillan.

Cooper, D.

(1992/3) 'Off the banner and onto the agenda: the emergence of a new municipal lesbian and gay politics 1979-86', Critical Social Policy, 36: Winter

10.

Coyle, A.

(1989) 'The limits of change: Local Government and equal opportunities for women', Public Administration, 67, pp39-50.

11.

Craig, M.

and

Pavey, D.

(1990) Client Managers. Developing the Role and the Organisation, LGTB.

Crompton, R.

and

Le Feuvre, N.

(eds) in

Witz, A.

and

Savage, M.

Gender and Bureaucracy, Oxford. Blackwell (Soc. Rev ).

12.

Cse

(1981) London Edinburgh weekend return group, In and Against the State, Pluto

13.

Directorate of Construction Services (DCS)

( 1987) DLO Training, LondonBorough of Hackney.

Duncan, S.

and

Goodwm, M.

(1988) The Local State and Uneven Development. Behind the Local Government Crtsts , Cambridge : Polity.

14.

Edwards, J.

(1988-9) 'Local Government Women's Committees', Critical Social Policy, 8, pp50-64.

15.

Geddes, M.

(1988) 'The capitalist state and the local economy', Capital and Class, 35, pp85-120.

16.

GLC Public Services and Fire Bngade Committee 1227 Equal Opportunities Strategy, 17 May 1985.

Goss, S.

(1984) 'Women's initiatives in Local Government' in (eds)

Boddy, M.

and

Fudge, C

Local Socialism, London. Macmillan.

17.

Graves, P.

(1994) Labour Women Women in British working-class politics 1918-1939, Cambridge: CUP

18.

Halford, S.

(1992) 'Feminist Challenge in a patnarchai orgamsation: the experience of women's initiatives in local government and the implications for feminist perspectives on state institutions', in (eds)

Witz, A

and

Savage, M

Gender and Bureaucracy, OxfordBlackwell (Soc Rev ), pp155-85.

19.

Halford, S.

(1993) The Gendered Dynamics of Local Government Organisation, 9th UCCC, Sheffield.

20.

Halford, S.

(1989) 'Spatial divisions and women's initiatives in local government', Geoforum, 20, pp161-74

21.

Halford, S.

and

Savage, M.

(1995) 'Restructuring organisations, changing people' , Work, Employment and Soctety, 9:1, pp97-122.

22.

Hodge, M.

(1985) 'Ratecapped councils deficit: unity can win', LondonLabour Briefing, Apnl

23.

Hollis, P.

(1987) Ladies Elect Women in English Local Government 1865-1914, Oxford. Clarendon Press .

Jewson, N.

and

Mason, D.

Modes of discrimination in the recruitment process: formalisation, fairness and efficiency', Sociology , 20, 1, pp43-63

24.

Kean, H.

(1985) 'Local government. the way forward', Socialist Organiser, 12 June

25.

Kean, H.

(1991) 'Managing education. the local authority dimension' , Journal of Education Policy, Vol 6, No 2.

26.

Labour Research (1993) November, p9.

27.

Lewis, J.

(1994) Observation, ESRC Women and Welfare Seminar, Apnl

28.

Lewis, G.

(1993) 'Difference, what difference ethmcity and social work', unpublished paper, ESRC Social Policy Seminar, December.

29.

Lgiu

(1988) Equalities News No 1, January.

30.

Lgiu

(1989) Compulsory Competitive Tendering and Local Management of Schools, LGIU LGMB/SOCPO (1993) Equal Opportunities in Local Government

31.

Lgmb

(1993) Taking the Lead. A National Conference for Women Working in Local Government Liddington, J (1984) The Life and Times of a Respectable Rebel, Selina Cooper 1864-1946 , London

Virago

32.

Liff, S.

and

Dale, K.

(1994) 'Formal opportunity, informal barriers. black women managers within a local authonty', Work, Employment and Society , Vol 8, No 2, pp177-98.

33.

Livingstone, K.

(1987) If Voting Changed Anything They'd Abolish It, London: Collins

34.

London Equal Value Steering Group

(1987) A Question of Earnings, London.

35.

London Strategic Policy Unit (LSPU)

(1988) Keeping it Clean, LSPU.

36.

Lovenduski, J.

and

Randall, V.

(1993) Contemporary Feminist Politics, Oxford: OUP

37.

Lucas, B.K.

and

Richards, P.G.

(1978) A History of Local Government in the C20th, London: George Allen & Unwm

38.

Mackintosh, M.

and

Wainwright, H.

(1987) A Taste of Power, London. Verso.

39.

Maddock, S.

(1993) 'Barriers to women are barriers to local government' , Local Government Studies, 19(3), pp341-50.

40.

McDonnell, J.

(1985) 'Open up the second front', LondonLabour Briefing, National Supplement, March.

41.

Mitchell, G.

(1977) The Hard Way Up. The Autobiography of Hannah Mitchell , London. Virago.

42.

Morphet, J.

(1992) 'Women local authority chief executives: roots and routes', Local Government Policy Making, 19(3), pp3-14.

43.

Morphet, J.

(1993) The Role of Chief Executives in Local Government , London: Longman.

44.

Murray, R.

(1987) Breaking with Bureaucracy Ownership control and Nationalisation, Manchester

CLES

45.

Newman, J.

(1993) 'Women, management and change', Local Government Policy Making, 20(2), pp38-43

46.

Newman, J.

(1994) 'The limits of management: gender and the politics of change' in (eds)

Clarke, J.

Cochrane, A

and

McLaughlin, E.

Managing Social Policy, London: Sage.

47.

Opportunity 2000 (1993) Second Year Report, London: Business m the Community.

48.

Pond, C.

(c1985) Low Pay What Can Local Authorities Do? London: Low Pay Unit.

49.

Paul, J.

(1986) Where There's Muck There's Money. A Report on Cleaning in London, Industry and Employment Branch, Greater London Council

50.

Perrigo, S.

(1989) 'Feminist Pohtics in the 1980s', PSA conference paper, Warwick

University

51.

Phillips, J.

(1989) We didn't expect to learn so much. a report on training for school cleaners in preparation for compulsory competitive tendering' , LondonBorough of Ealing.

52.

Powell, W.

(1991) 'Neither market nor hierarchy, network forms of organisation', in (eds)

Thompson, G. et al

Markets, Hierarchies and Networks, London. Sage, pp265-76

53.

Riley, K.

and

White, J.

(1994)'Pathways to leadership issues for women chief executives ', Public Management and Money, July-September, pp39-43

54.

Roelofs, S.

(1983) 'GLC women's committee - femocratisation or feminism ?', LondonLabour Briefing, April.

55.

Rowbotham, S.

(1989) The Past is Before Us, London . Pandora.

56.

Rowbotham, S.

et al. (1979) Beyond the Fragments, Newcastle Socialist Centre

57.

Rubinstein, D.

(1986) Before the Suffragettes Women's Emancipation in the 1890s, Bnghton: Harvester

Scase, R.

and

Goffee, R.

(1990) 'Women in management: towards a research agenda' , Internatconal Journal of Human Resources Management, Vol 1, No 1

58.

Stone, I.

(1988) Equal Opportunities in Local Government, EOC/HMSO

59.

Thompson, P.

(1967) Socialists, Liberals and Labour The Struggle for London 1885-1914, London, RKP

Venness, K.

(1982) 'Camden, Southwark, Hackney, Haringey Unite behind fortress Islington', London Labour Bnefing, 20 June.

60.

Wacjman, J.

(1996) 'The gender relations of management', in

Crompton, R.

Galhe, D

and

Purcell, K.

Corporate Restructuring and Labour Markets, London. Routledge .

61.

Wainwright, H.

(1987) Labour A Tale of Two Parties, London: Hogarth.

62.

Walsh, K.

et al (1993) Competition and Service, HMSO

63.

Watson, S.

(1992a) 'Femocratic feminisms', in (eds)

Witz, A.

and

Savage, M.

Gender and Bureaucracy, Oxford: Blackwell (Soc Rev ), pp186-206.

64.

Watson, S.

(1992b) Is Sir Humphrey Dead?, Bristol , School of Advanced Urban Studies

65.

Witz, A.

and

Savage, M.

(1992) 'The gender of orgamsations' , in (eds)

Witz, A

and

Savage, M

(1992) Gender and Bureaucracy, OxfordBlackwell, pp3-64