Reincarnation of libraries via metaverse: A pathway for a sustainable knowledge system in the digital age

Abstract

The evolution of metaverse libraries offers a transformative pathway for redefining knowledge systems in the digital age. This study delves into the seamless integration of enduring library principles with the expansive capabilities of the metaverse, envisioning a harmonious coexistence that preserves traditional library values while propelling knowledge dissemination, inclusivity, and collaboration to new heights. Real-world case studies provide valuable insights into successful metaverse library implementations and offer lessons for future endeavors. By seamlessly merging traditional library attributes with immersive digital experiences, metaverse libraries can offer tailored learning journeys, foster global collaboration, and ensure secure content distribution. However, the landscape is not without challenges, such as privacy concerns, digital literacy gaps, and the imperative of inclusivity, all of which require thoughtful interdisciplinary collaboration. This evolution underscores the significance of preserving the essence of physical libraries while embracing the potential of the metaverse. Through adept navigation of these complexities, metaverse libraries have the capacity to revolutionize education, nurture collaboration, and ensure equitable access to knowledge in a dynamic and interconnected digital landscape.

Keywords

Libraries metaverse metaverse library reincarnation sustainable knowledge system traditional library

Introduction

In a swiftly evolving era of technological progress and digital transformation, the traditional functions of libraries as guardians of knowledge and cultural heritage are undergoing a significant transformation. The intersection of virtual reality, augmented reality, and interconnected digital realms has given birth to the concept of the “metaverse” an expansive digital realm where individuals can interact, socialize, and interact with information in innovative ways. In this dynamic environment, the idea of reincarnating libraries assumes a central role, offering an inventive and revolutionary route toward establishing a sustainable knowledge framework suitable for the contemporary era. This paper delves into the amalgamation of enduring library principles with the limitless opportunities of the metaverse, envisioning a seamless coexistence that not only conserves the essence of physical libraries but also propels the dissemination of knowledge, inclusivity, and collaborative efforts into an era of boundless potential. As we embark on this exploration, this paper uncovers the multifaceted aspects that herald the emergence of libraries within the metaverse as a profound response to the evolving necessities of a global society in search of accessible, interactive, and enduring wellsprings of knowledge.

The concept of reincarnating libraries

In an age characterized by rapid technological progress and the continuous expansion of the digital realm, the traditional concept of libraries is undergoing a profound transformation. This shift is attributed to the rise of the metaverse a connected virtual reality environment which has sparked discussions about the potential revitalization of libraries within this innovative digital domain (Sun et al., 2021). Libraries have traditionally held the role of preserving knowledge and cultural heritage, providing physical spaces for learning, research, and community interaction (Zhou, 2022). However, the increasing digitization of our world has highlighted the limitations of physical libraries in terms of accessibility, scalability, and interactive features. In contrast, the metaverse offers a vast and interconnected digital space that introduces fresh opportunities for engaging with information, resources, and a global community of learners and researchers.

The concept of reincarnating libraries within the metaverse envisions a transformation where the distinctive attributes of the metaverse are employed to redefine and enhance the library experience. This vision encompasses the creation of virtual libraries that faithfully capture the atmosphere of traditional libraries, incorporating interactive bookshelves, collaborative areas, and other recognizable elements. Moreover, the metaverse allows for the development of dynamic and personalized learning environments, empowering users to navigate through a diverse range of digital resources, participate in lively virtual discussions, and engage in immersive educational experiences. The multifaceted advantages of bringing libraries into the metaverse are noteworthy. Access to information becomes inherently more inclusive and universally available, fostering connections among individuals from diverse geographic backgrounds (Sun et al., 2021). The metaverse’s ability to overcome geographical limitations creates an atmosphere that encourages cross-cultural interactions and supports the worldwide spread of information. In this evolving setting, the notion of metaverse libraries has come to the forefront, utilizing the immersive characteristics of the metaverse to noticeably amplify user involvement and memory retention. As a result, this enhancement positively impacts the overall quality of both learning and research endeavours.

The emergence and advantage of metaverse libraries

The rise of metaverse libraries represents a remarkable confluence of technological innovation and educational transformation within the context of the broader metaverse concept. As the metaverse evolves, integrating augmented reality, virtual reality, and interconnected digital landscapes, the emergence of metaverse libraries is demonstrating the potential to redefine traditional modes of accessing and engaging with information. The metaverse, as an intricate digital universe, offers unprecedented opportunities for reimagining information consumption and knowledge dissemination. Metaverse libraries capitalize on this potential by creating virtual realms where users can explore, collaborate, and learn in ways that transcend the constraints of physical libraries. This evolution heralds a new era in education and research. Central to the appeal of metaverse libraries is their capacity to democratize access to information on a global scale. By embracing the digital realm, these libraries effectively transcend geographical boundaries, making knowledge universally accessible. This inclusivity promotes cross-cultural interactions and enriches learning experiences through the exchange of diverse perspectives (Feitosa et al., 2022).

The immersive nature of metaverse libraries significantly enhances user engagement and knowledge retention. The incorporation of interactive features, such as multimedia resources, virtual study groups, and dynamic simulations, captivates users’ attention and nurtures active participation (Alkhawaldeh and Khasawneh, 2023). This immersive learning environment has the potential to enhance comprehension, critical thinking, and collaboration, ultimately improving the quality of education and research endeavours. However, this paradigm shift also raises important ethical considerations. Privacy and data security must be vigilantly safeguarded within metaverse libraries to ensure users’ information remains protected in this digital terrain. Additionally, promoting digital literacy becomes imperative as users navigate these innovative platforms (Yaqoob et al., 2023). In this landscape of unprecedented possibilities, thoughtful navigation is crucial. As we embrace metaverse libraries, it's vital to address concerns of inclusivity and accessibility. Ethical frameworks should guide the design and implementation of these libraries, ensuring that the benefits of this transformative endeavour are shared equitably across global communities.

Building inclusive metaverse knowledge systems

Promoting inclusivity within metaverse knowledge systems holds a pivotal role in the ongoing evolution of the metaverse concept. As virtual landscapes continue to integrate and immerse users, the imperative to ensure equal access to information, resources, and opportunities becomes increasingly apparent. This drive for inclusivity extends to metaverse knowledge systems, encompassing a variety of virtual learning environments, libraries, and collaborative spaces intrinsic to the metaverse. The desire for inclusivity within metaverse knowledge systems seamlessly aligns with the overarching societal objective of bridging digital disparities and championing equitable access to education and information. Notably, research conducted by Hussain et al. (2023) underscores the concept of the “second-level digital divide,” emphasizing disparities in individuals’ online skills and usage trends. Addressing this divide assumes significant significance in the metaverse landscape, where participation should be uninhibited by factors such as socioeconomic status, geographical location, or technological infrastructure.

Dwivedi et al. (2023) noted that the aspiration of inclusive metaverse knowledge systems revolves around providing meaningful engagement opportunities for all individuals within these digital domains. This principle seamlessly aligns with the United Nations Sustainable Development Goal 4 (SDG 4), dedicated to promoting inclusive and equitable quality education. By meticulously designing metaverse libraries, educational spheres, and learning experiences that prioritize accessibility, usability, and diversity, a conducive environment emerges where individuals of diverse abilities, backgrounds, and circumstances can actively participate and derive benefits. This endeavour aligns with the stance of the World Summit on the Information Society (WSIS), which has acknowledged the significance of addressing digital divides and advancing digital inclusivity (Dai and Lin, 2023). Their framework underscores the necessity of ensuring that all individuals and communities can partake in the advantages of the information society. This framework is seamlessly transposed onto the metaverse context, where fostering inclusivity necessitates overcoming obstacles like technological barriers, linguistic constraints, and digital literacy gaps.

A crucial element in achieving inclusive metaverse knowledge systems involves collaboration with experts in accessibility, digital education, and user experience. By adhering to the principles of universal design and embracing a diverse array of user perspectives, metaverse environments can be cultivated to be accommodating, adaptable, and devoid of barriers. This approach perfectly resonates with the overarching vision of moulding a metaverse that empowers individuals, nurtures collaborative learning, and contributes to the realization of a more equitable knowledge-based society.

Challenges and considerations

As we delve into this intricate territory, it becomes evident that while the metaverse offers boundless possibilities, it also brings forth a series of pivotal challenges that warrant careful consideration and adept navigation.

1. Privacy and Security: The metaverse’s immersive realms usher in an era where user privacy and data security are paramount. Within the context of metaverse libraries, this translates into a fundamental need to establish robust mechanisms that safeguard user’s personal information and ensure that their interactions remain secure. This involves implementing encryption protocols, stringent access controls, and comprehensive data protection measures (Letafati and Otoum, 2023). By doing so, users can explore metaverse libraries with the confidence that their privacy is respected.

2. Digital Literacy: As metaverse libraries offer a novel way to engage with knowledge, the need for digital literacy becomes pivotal. Users must possess the skills to navigate these digital domains adeptly, critically evaluate information, and harness the potential of these immersive environments (Pellegrino et al., 2023). Bridging the gap in digital literacy ensures that individuals can navigate the metaverse libraries effectively, maximizing their learning experiences and interactions.

3. Equitable Access: The promise of metaverse libraries lies in their capacity to provide equal access to information to individuals worldwide. However, the challenge is to ensure that this access is genuinely equitable, transcending geographical, socio-economic, and technological barriers (Annoni et al., 2023). Achieving this balance requires proactive efforts to create an inclusive digital space that caters to diverse user backgrounds and circumstances.

4. Authenticity and Credibility: Within the metaverse, where the lines between reality and virtuality blur, the challenge of maintaining the authenticity and credibility of information surfaces prominently. Particularly within metaverse libraries, the assurance of accurate and reliable content becomes essential to prevent the spread of misinformation (Sami et al., 2023). Rigorous fact-checking procedures and mechanisms for content verification are instrumental in upholding the integrity of knowledge dissemination.

5. Ethical Content Creation: Metaverse libraries usher in a realm of user-generated content, underscoring the importance of ethical content creation. Striking a balance between creative expression and responsible content is paramount to fostering an environment that nurtures both innovation and ethical standards (Sami et al., 2023). This ethical compass guides creators and ensures that the metaverse libraries remain spaces of constructive engagement.

6. Collaboration and Interaction: In the metaverse, the landscape of collaboration takes on new dimensions, demanding a reevaluation of how effective collaboration can be facilitated without overwhelming users (Koohang et al., 2023). Metaverse libraries must find the delicate equilibrium between immersive engagement and user comfort, providing platforms that allow meaningful collaboration while respecting individual preferences.

As we navigate these challenges and considerations, interdisciplinary collaboration emerges as a cornerstone. Experts across diverse domains, from cybersecurity to education and beyond, must collaborate harmoniously to develop strategies that preserve the potential of metaverse libraries while addressing the intricate challenges they entail. By thoughtfully addressing these complexities, we can shape metaverse libraries into empowering spaces that cultivate digital literacy, respect privacy, and foster meaningful engagement within the dynamic metaverse landscape.

Technological infrastructure and implementation

The success of metaverse libraries hinges on a robust technological foundation, intricately weaving together high-speed connectivity, efficient data processing, and smooth interactions (Sami et al., 2023). This infrastructure is not merely supportive, but essential, infusing vitality into dynamic content delivery, real-time collaborations, and the intricate interactions that define the metaverse. As these libraries expand, the need for scalability becomes paramount. A versatile architecture is pivotal to ensuring optimal performance during periods of high usage, achieved through the dynamic allocation of resources to maintain an uninterrupted user experience. The captivating essence of metaverse libraries lies in their ability to provide immersive experiences that bridge the gap between physical and digital realms, facilitated by cutting-edge virtual reality (VR) and augmented reality (AR) technologies (Huang et al., 2023). The technical infrastructure is pivotal in enabling this, supporting high-quality visuals, interactive simulations, and smooth transitions across virtual environments.

User-friendly navigation is crucial, with adaptable interfaces catering to various devices. Effective management of the significant data flow, encompassing interactions and content uploads, necessitates advanced data management and storage solutions to ensure organization, accessibility, and security. Metaverse libraries often seamlessly integrate with external platforms, applications, and databases, facilitated by the technological infrastructure’s interoperability (Richter and Richter, 2023). Inclusivity, often underestimated, is nurtured through diverse accessibility interfaces, ensuring that all users can partake in the marvels of the metaverse. Given the paramount importance of cybersecurity and data privacy, the infrastructure implements robust protective measures, encryption, and authentication. Collaboration among technology specialists, designers, content creators, and educators shapes the orchestration of metaverse libraries, culminating in cutting-edge experiences achieved through the seamless integration of emerging technologies.

Learning from real-world examples

In our quest to harness the transformative potential of metaverse libraries, embarking on a journey of discovery through real-world case studies offers a valuable roadmap. These case studies provide practical insights, shedding light on successful implementations and unveiling lessons that illuminate our path forward. By delving into these tangible examples, we can deepen our understanding of the metaverse’s capabilities and its power to reshape the landscape of knowledge dissemination. One compelling case study worth examining is the Bibliotheca Alexandrina in Egypt, a modern tribute to the ancient Library of Alexandria. This institution has embraced the metaverse concept by seamlessly integrating traditional library functions with the immersive capacities of digital environments. Within this innovative framework, users can explore historical manuscripts, access a wealth of scholarly resources, and engage in global dialogues, all within the expansive digital realm of the metaverse. This case serves as a prime example of how the convergence of traditional and digital elements can give rise to a rich learning environment that transcends the confines of physical boundaries (Lyytinen et al., 2016).

Similarly, the Open Metaverse Foundation’s ambitious endeavour to establish interconnected metaverse libraries across various platforms exemplifies the power of collaborative efforts in creating inclusive knowledge spaces. This visionary project fosters partnerships among technology companies, content creators, and educational institutions, envisioning a metaverse where knowledge knows no geographical or socioeconomic barriers. Such a collaborative approach aligns seamlessly with the overarching mission of metaverse libraries to bridge digital divides and democratize access to information (Sami et al., 2023). The “Molinsky Library” project, pioneered by Stanford University, offers an intriguing perspective on the integration of augmented reality (AR) within educational contexts via metaverse libraries. By infusing AR elements into physical library spaces, this initiative empowers students to interact with historical artefacts, manuscripts, and artworks in unprecedented ways. This convergence of the physical and digital realms not only enhances the quality of learning experiences but also showcases the transformative potential of metaverse libraries in reshaping educational paradigms (Koohang et al., 2023).

These real-world case studies underscore the paramount importance of collaboration, innovation, and adaptability in the realm of metaverse libraries. They emphasize the need to seamlessly merge the strengths of traditional libraries with the immersive capabilities of the metaverse. Furthermore, these case studies spotlight the pivotal significance of user-centric design and accessibility, ensuring that individuals of all abilities and backgrounds can partake in the metaverse’s boundless potential (Scoulas, 2021). As we continue our expedition into the realm of metaverse libraries, these case studies serve as beacons of inspiration, guiding our efforts to cultivate environments that foster learning, collaboration, and exploration within the limitless horizons of the metaverse.

Preserving the essence of physical libraries

In today’s rapidly evolving digital landscape, preserving the essence of physical libraries is both a significant challenge and an opportunity. Traditional libraries, with their history, tranquil reading spaces, and tactile book experience, are revered as knowledge and cultural havens (Scoulas, 2021). Yet, as we enter the unexplored metaverse, a digitally interconnected realm of experiences (Sami et al., 2023) a question arises: How can we ensure the spirit of physical libraries thrives in this new frontier? The aim is not to replace physical treasures but to seamlessly blend the metaverse with the enduring principles of traditional libraries. Whispered discussions, contemplative ambience, and serendipitous discoveries weave the fabric of physical libraries. To recreate these aspects in the metaverse, digital spaces must exude the same warmth, depth, and authenticity.

Preserving the tactile connection to knowledge is crucial. Physical libraries offer the unique experience of holding a book, feeling its weight, and turning pages. Though the metaverse is virtual, haptic feedback technology can recreate this engagement (Buhalis et al., 2020). Imagine a metaverse library where users virtually “pick up” a book, feeling subtle vibrations as they “turn” pages a bridge between physical and digital. The sense of community cultivated in physical libraries is priceless (Bittremieux et al., 2022). The metaverse should provide spaces for real-time discussions, virtual book clubs, and collaborative projects, mirroring centuries of intellectual exchange. Just as physical libraries have been gathering spots, metaverse libraries can evolve into hubs of shared learning. Challenges include user privacy, accessibility, and an authentic virtual atmosphere. Collaborative efforts are vital to navigate these and craft metaverse libraries embodying tradition’s spirit.

Transitioning to metaverse libraries

In the ever-evolving digital landscape, the concept of libraries is standing on the brink of a transformative journey. The shift from conventional brick-and-mortar libraries to the immersive realm of metaverse libraries marks a significant evolution, encapsulating the very essence of learning and knowledge-sharing in an interconnected digital age (Dwivedi et al., 2022). This transition goes beyond mere physical displacement; it delves into the core of how we engage with information, collaborate, and steer the course of education. Central to this transition is the integration of cutting-edge technologies that enable unparalleled immersive experiences. The metaverse, a complex amalgamation of virtual reality, augmented reality, and interconnected digital realms, serves as the foundation for the emergence of metaverse libraries (Sami et al., 2022). The objective is to seamlessly transpose the tangible aspects of traditional libraries into the digital domain. Within these virtual spaces, users navigate digital bookshelves, engage in real-time discussions, and partake in collaborative endeavours within a vast global network of learners.

This transition, however, demands a careful balance between innovation and tradition. While metaverse libraries introduce novel modes of engagement, preserving the timeless values of libraries remains crucial. The tranquillity of contemplation, the thrill of exploration, and the essence of shared learning must be meticulously interwoven into metaverse libraries. By incorporating elements reminiscent of physical libraries, this transition maintains the familiar while embracing the boundless possibilities of the metaverse. Nonetheless, this shift encompasses more than just technological change it’s a paradigm shift. Universal accessibility takes precedence. The democratization of metaverse library access bridges the digital divide, ensuring that knowledge is accessible to all, echoing the egalitarian ideals of traditional libraries (Tella et al., 2023). Amid this transition, privacy and security hold paramount importance. The intricate digital interactions within the metaverse necessitate robust safeguards to shield user data. Collaborative efforts across technology, privacy, and ethical domains are essential to establish a secure and reliable environment.

Future possibilities and prospects

In the ever-expanding realm of technology, the concept of metaverse libraries presents a horizon of future possibilities that could reshape knowledge sharing, collaborative endeavours, and immersive learning experiences. This transformative evolution transcends traditional library boundaries, embracing the metaverse’s potential to usher in a new era of interconnected and dynamic knowledge spaces. Foremost among these possibilities is the potential for personalized learning journeys. Metaverse libraries can harness advanced algorithms and artificial intelligence to curate educational content and resources based on individual preferences and learning styles (Fernandez, 2022). Imagine a metaverse library that not only offers an extensive range of materials but also tailors a personalized curriculum according to each user’s academic interests, fostering an engaging and impactful learning adventure. Additionally, the collaborative power of metaverse libraries knows no bounds. Individuals from diverse corners of the world can converge in virtual environments, transcending geographical limitations to engage in real-time discussions, interactive projects, and knowledge exchange (Bakar et al., 2022). This global collaborative ecosystem not only enriches learning but also nurtures cross-cultural understanding and innovation.

The potential for emerging technologies such as blockchain to revolutionize content authentication and distribution within metaverse libraries is promising (Joy et al., 2022). Through blockchain-based systems, libraries can uphold the integrity of digital assets, prevent unauthorized modifications, and ensure secure transactions of copyrighted materials, fostering trust and accountability in the virtual realm. Augmented reality (AR) and virtual reality (VR) advancements offer enticing possibilities for experiential learning within metaverse libraries. Immersive simulations, historical reconstructions, and interactive educational games can transport users to different eras, cultures, and scientific phenomena, providing hands-on encounters with knowledge (De la Plata et al., 2023). However, alongside these exciting prospects, come critical considerations. Ethical concerns surrounding data privacy, content moderation, and algorithmic biases must be paramount in the development of metaverse libraries. Sustaining inclusive, secure, and diverse virtual spaces requires a deliberate and interdisciplinary approach (Falloon, 2020).

Conclusion

In conclusion, the evolution of metaverse libraries offers a significant opportunity to redefine how we engage with knowledge in the digital era. The shift from traditional libraries to metaverse libraries represents a transformative change that blends innovation with the fundamental principles of libraries. This evolution is driven by advanced technologies that facilitate immersive and inclusive learning experiences. Metaverse libraries hold the potential for personalized learning, global collaboration, and equal access to knowledge. They can tailor educational content according to individual preferences and encourage cross-cultural interactions on a global scale. Technological advancements like blockchain contribute to content integrity, while augmented and virtual reality provide immersive educational encounters. However, this transition also raises ethical concerns, encompassing privacy, data security, and content authenticity. It’s imperative to ensure that metaverse libraries remain open to all, adhere to ethical standards, and maintain accessibility.

Addressing these challenges necessitates interdisciplinary collaboration. Experts from diverse fields must unite to develop metaverse libraries that empower individuals, cultivate collaboration, and promote a more equitable knowledge society. As we embark on this transformative journey, real-world examples such as the Bibliotheca Alexandrina and the Open Metaverse Foundation’s initiatives offer valuable insights. These instances underscore the significance of user-centric design, accessibility, and inclusivity. In essence, metaverse libraries usher in a dynamic future where learning knows no bounds and knowledge is accessible to everyone, irrespective of their background. By navigating challenges thoughtfully and embracing innovation, we have the potential to shape metaverse libraries into influential tools that enhance education, foster collaboration, and retain the timeless essence of libraries in the digital age.

Footnotes

Declaration of conflicting interests

The author(s) declared no potential conflicts of interest with respect to the research, authorship, and/or publication of this article.

Funding

The author(s) received no financial support for the research, authorship, and/or publication of this article.

ORCID iD

Yusuf Ayodeji Ajani

Author biographies

Yusuf Ayodeji Ajani, A postgraduate student of Department of Library and Information Science, University of Ilorin Nigeria.

Rexwhite Tega Enakrire is a renowned researcher at University of South Africa, Pretoria.

Bolaji David Oladokun is a researcher and a lecturer in the department of Library and Information Technology, Federal University of Technology, Ikot Abasi, Akwa Ibom State, Nigeria.

Musediq Tunji Bashorun is a Lecturer at the Department of Library and Information Science, University of Ilorin, Nigeria.

References

Alkhawaldeh

Khasawneh

MAS

(2023) Exploring virtual reality as a transformative tool for enhancing learning abilities in students with disabilities. Journal of Namibian Studies: History Politics Culture 35: 861–882.

Annoni

Nativi

Çöltekin

, et al. (2023) Digital earth: yesterday, today, and tomorrow. International Journal of Digital Earth 16(1): 1022–1072.

Abu Bakar

Hussin

Angchun

, et al. (2022) Roles of library in the metaverse. Environment-Behaviour Proceedings Journal 7(SI10): 269–273.

Bittremieux

Wang

Dorrestein

(2022) The critical role that spectral libraries play in capturing the metabolomics community knowledge. Metabolomics: Official journal of the Metabolomic Society 18(12): 94.

Buhalis

Leung

Lin

(2023) Metaverse as a disruptive technology revolutionising tourism management and marketing. Tourism Management 97: 104724.

Dai

Lin

(2023) How can information be ‘barrier-free’? a critical reading of china’s web accessibility policies in the 21st century. Disability & Society 8(12): 1–23. doi: 10.1080/09687599.2023.2222894

Rueda Márquez de la Plata

Cruz Franco

Ramos Sánchez

(2023) Applications of virtual and augmented reality technology to teaching and research in construction and its graphic expression. Sustainability 15(12): 9628.

Dwivedi

Kshetri

Hughes

, et al. (2023) Exploring the Darkverse: a multi-perspective analysis of the negative societal impacts of the metaverse. Information Systems Frontiers 25: 2071–2114.

Falloon

(2020) From digital literacy to digital competence: the teacher digital competency (TDC) framework. Educational Technology Research & Development 68: 2449–2472.

10.

Feitosa

Hagenbuch

Patel

, et al. (2022) Performing in diverse settings: a diversity, equity, and inclusion approach to culture. International Journal of Cross Cultural Management 22(3): 433–457.

11.

Fernandez

(2022) Facebook, meta, the metaverse and libraries. Library Hi Tech News 39(4): 1–3.

12.

Huang

Gao

(2023) The metaverse era: the fourth transformation in the age of internet communication. In: Value Realization in the Phygital Reality Market: Consumption and Service Under Conflation of the Physical, Digital, and Virtual Worlds. Singapore: Springer Nature Singapore, 99–123.

13.

Hussain

Wen

Jiang

, et al. (2023) Analyzing the role of ICT in bridging the digital divide: A transitional analytical framework for ICT access to impact. Library Hi Tech. doi: 10.1108/LHT-06-2021-0194

14.

Joy

Zhu

Peña

, et al. (2022) Digital future of luxury brands: metaverse, digital fashion, and non‐fungible tokens. Strategic Change 31(3): 337–343.

15.

Koohang

Nord

Ooi

, et al. (2023) Shaping the metaverse into reality: a holistic multidisciplinary understanding of opportunities, challenges, and avenues for future investigation. Journal of Computer Information Systems 63: 735–765.

16.

Letafati

Otoum

(2023) On the privacy and security for e-health services in the metaverse: an overview. Ad Hoc Networks 150: 103262.

17.

Lyytinen

Yoo

Boland

Jr (2016) Digital product innovation within four classes of innovation networks. Information Systems Journal 26(1): 47–75.

18.

Pellegrino

Stasi

Wang

(2023) Exploring the intersection of sustainable consumption and the metaverse: a review of current literature and future research directions. Heliyon 9: e19190.

19.

Richter

(2023) What is a novel about the metaverse? International Journal of Information Management 73: 102684.

20.

Sami

Hammoud

Arafeh

, et al. (2023) The metaverse: survey, trends, novel pipeline ecosystem & future directions. arXiv preprint arXiv:2304.09240.

21.

Scoulas

(2021) College students’ perceptions on sense of belonging and inclusion at the academic library during COVID-19. The Journal of Academic Librarianship 47(6): 102460.

22.

Sun

Gan

Chen

, et al. (2022) Big data meets metaverse: a survey. arXiv preprint arXiv:2210.16282.

23.

Tella

Ajani

Ailaku

(2023) Libraries in the metaverse: the need for metaliteracy for digital librarians and digital age library users. Library Hi Tech News. doi: 10.1108/LHTN-06-2023-0094

24.

Yaqoob

Salah

Jayaraman

, et al. (2023) Metaverse applications in smart cities: enabling technologies, opportunities, challenges, and future directions. Internet of Things 23: 100884.

25.

Zhou

(2022) The role of libraries in distance learning during COVID-19. Information Development 38(2): 227–238.