Problems in the Study of the Transnational Business Community

Abstract

In responding to Kentor and Jang’s article, the authors point to methodological problems that have led them to underestimate the level of interlocking in their reference year (1983), and thus to exaggerate the extent of the shift towards transnational interlocking. The authors also argue that Kentor and Jang fail to adequately theorize the social processes that produce corporate interlocks, and to place the practice of interlocking within its specific historical settings. It is only on the basis of sound conceptualization, valid empirical data and detailed, contextualized analysis that the contours and character of the emerging transnational business community can be ascertained.

Keywords

globalization methodology transnational class formation transnational corporate interlocks

References

Barnes, Roy C. and Ritter, Emily R. (2001) ‘Networks of Corporate Interlocking: 1962–1995’ , Critical Sociology 27(2): 192–220 .

Bryan, Dick (1995) The Chase Across the Globe: International Accumulation and the Contradictions for Nation States. Boulder, CO: Westview Press .

Carroll, William K. (2002) ‘Does Disorganized Capitalism Disorganize Corporate Networks?’ , Canadian Journal of Sociology 27(3): 339–371 .

Carroll, William K. (2004) Corporate Power in a Globalizing World. Toronto: Oxford University Press .

Carroll, William K. and Carson, Colin (2003) ‘The Network of Global Corporations and Elite Policy Groups: A Structure for Transnational Capitalist Class Formation?’ , Global Networks 3(1): 29–57 ; revised version available at: http://csf.colorado.edu/jwsr/archive/vol9/number1/index.shtml

Carroll, William K. and Fennema, Meindert (2002) ‘Is There a Transnational Business Community?’ , International Sociology 17(3): 393–419 .

Clement, Wallace (1977) Continental Corporate Power. Toronto: McClelland and Stewart .

Davis, G. F. and Mizruchi, M. S. (1999) ‘The Money Center Cannot Hold: Commercial Banks in the US System of Corporate Governance’ , Administrative Science Quarterly 44(2): 215–239 .

Fennema, Meindert (1982) International Networks of Banks and Industry. Boston, MA: Martinus Nijhoff .

10.

Marx, Karl and Engels, Frederick (1974) ‘Manifesto of the Communist Party’, in Karl Marx and Frederick Engels: Selected Works, pp. 35–63. New York: International Publishers .

11.

Mills, C. Wright (1959) The Sociological Imagination. New York: Oxford University Press .

12.

Scott, John (1997) Corporate Business and Capitalist Classes. New York: Oxford University Press .

13.

Sklair, Leslie (2001) The Transnational Capitalist Class. Oxford: Blackwell .

14.

Stokman, Frans N. and Wasseur, Frans W. (1985) ‘National Networks in 1976: A Structural Comparison’, in Frans N. Stokman , Rolf Ziegler and John Scott (eds) Networks of Corporate Power: A Comparative Analysis of Ten Countries, pp. 21–43. Cambridge: Polity Press .

15.

Stokman, Frans N. , Ziegler, Rolf and Scott, John , eds (1985) Networks of Corporate Power. Cambridge: Polity Press .

16.

Van der Pijl, Kees (1984) The Making of an Atlantic Ruling Class. London: Verso .

17.

Windolf, Paul (2002) Corporate Networks in Europe and the United States. New York: Oxford University Press .