This paper deals with the meaning of war as it is articulated in war veterans' life stories and with the interpretive-phenomenological mechanisms through which the war experience is integrated into the course of their lives.
The research is based on 63 life stories of Jewish Israeli men (all names are pseudonyms) who fought in the 1973 Yom Kippur War as part of their regular military service, in a variety of roles; half of them held combat positions and half were support staff. The stories were chosen from a clearly defined social group: middle-class, educated and secular men. The analysis of their life stories was derived from a phenomenological conceptual framework. The claim of this paper is that just as war is institutionalised and normalised into the Israeli macrosocial order, so too the individual integrates and co-opts it into his personal biography. Israeli soldiers do not represent the experience of war as a traumatic experience but rather as a `normalised experience' in their lives, contrary to the findings reported in the general literature about war veterans. The life stories reveal two interpretive-phenomenological mechanisms used by interviewees in normalising the war experience: the contiguous (the experience is integrated in the course of life by means of previous social knowledge) interpretation of war and the dual interpretation (the war is simultaneously part of and outside life) of war.
References
1.
AZARYA, V. 1989. `Civil Education in the Israeli Armed Forces', in Krauz, E. (ed.), Education in a Comparative Context.New Brunswick: Transaction Publishers, pp. 119-147.
2.
BAR-TAL, D. and ZOLTAK, S.1989. `The Reflection of the Character of the Arab and Jewish-Arab Relations in Readers', Megamot32 (3): 301-317.
3.
BEN-ARI, E. 1992. Conflict in the Military World View: An Ethnography of An Israeli Infantry Battalion.Jerusalem: H.S. Truman Research Institute and Shain Centre.
4.
BERGER, P. and LUCKMANN, T. 1975. The Social Construction of Reality.Harmondsworth: Penguin.
5.
BERTAUX, D. and KOHLI, M.1984. `The Life History Approach: A Continental View', Annual Review of Sociology10: 215-237.
6.
BET-EL, I. and BEN-AMOS, A. 1995. `Rituals of Democracy: Ceremonies of Commemoration in Israeli Schools', paper presented at the Annual Meeting of the Israeli Anthropological Association, 4 January 1995, Ein-Gedi.
7.
BRUNER, J.1987. `Life as Narrative'.Social Research54 (1): 12-32.
8.
CARD, J. 1983. Life After Vietnam.Toronto: Lexington Books.
9.
COHLER, B.J. 1982. `Personal Narrative and Life Course', in Baltes, P.B. and Brim, O., (eds) Life-Span Development and Behavior.New York: Academic Press, pp. 206-241.
10.
CORRADI, C.1991. `Text, Context and Individual Meaning: Rethinking Life Stories in Hermeneutic Framework', Discourse and Society2 (1): 105-118.
11.
CRAPANZANO, V.1984. `Life History', American Anthropologist86: 953-959.
12.
DANISH, S.J. , SMYER, M.A. and NOWAK, C.A. 1980. `Developmental Intervention: Enhancing Life-Event Processes', in Baltes, P.B. and Brim, O.G., (eds) Life-Span Development.New York: Academic Press, Vol. 3, pp. 339-366.
FIGLEY, C.R. 1978. `The Psychology Adjustment Among Vietnam Veterans: An Overview of Research', in Figley, C.R., (ed.) Stress Disorders Among Vietnam Veterans.New York: Bruner Mazzel, pp. 57-70.
15.
FIGLEY, C.R. and LEVENTMAN, S. eds 1980. Strangers at Home.New York: Praeger.
16.
FRANK, G. and VANDERBURGH, R.M. 1986. `Cross Cultural Use of Life History Methods in Gerontology', in Fry, C.L. and Keith, J., (eds) New Methods For Old Age Research.MA: Bergegnan Garey, pp. 185-212.
17.
GAL, R. 1986. The Portrait of the Israeli Soldier.New York: Greenwood Press.
18.
HANDELMAN, D. and KATZ, E. 1991. `State Ceremonies In Israel: Remembrance Day and Independence Day', in Handelman, D., (ed.) Models and Mirrors: Towards an Anthropology of Public Events.Cambridge: Cambridge University Press. pp. 191-233.
19.
HELMAN, S. 1993. `Conscientious Objection to Military Service as an Attempt to Redefine the Contents of Citizenship', unpublished PhD thesis, Hebrew University of Jerusalem [in Hebrew].
20.
HERZOG, H. and SHAMIR, R.1994. `Negotiated Society? Media Discourse on Israeli Jewish/Arab Relations'.Israel Social Science Research9 (1/2): 55-88.
21.
HOROWITZ, D. 1993. The Heavens and the Earth: A Self-Portrait of the 1948 Generation.Jerusalem: Keter [in Hebrew].
22.
HOROWITZ, D. and LISSAK, M. 1989. Trouble in Utopia.Albany: SUNY Press, pp. 195-231.
23.
KATRIEL, T. 1991. `Picnics in a Military Zone: Rituals of Parenting and the Politics of Consensus', in Katriel, T., (ed.) Communal Webs.New York: SUNY Press, pp. 71-91.
24.
KATZ, E.et al. 1992. Leisure Culture in Israel: Changes in Patterns of Cultural Activity 70-90.Jerusalem: Louis Guttman Israel Institute of Applied Social Research.
25.
KIMMERLING, B. 1985. The Interrupted System.New Brunswick: Transaction Publishers.
26.
KIMMERLING, B.1993. `Patterns of Militarism in Israel'.European Journal of Sociology2: 1-28.
27.
LAUFER, R.S. 1988a. `The Aftermath of War: Adult Socialization and Political Development', in Sigel, R.S., (ed.) Political Learning in Adulthood.Chicago, IL: University of Chicago Press, pp. 415-457.
28.
LAUFER, R.S. 1988b. `The Serial Self', in Wilson, J.P., (ed.) Human Adaptation to Extreme Stress.New York: Plenum Press, pp. 33-53.
29.
LEVINGER, E. 1993. War Memorials in Israel.Tel Aviv: Hakibbutz Hameuchad [in Hebrew].
30.
LIEBLICH, A. 1989. Transition to Adulthood During Military Service: The Israeli Case.Albany: SUNY Press.
31.
LIFTON, R.J. 1973. Home From the War.New York: Simon and Schuster.
32.
LISSAK, M. 1971. `The Israel Defence Forces as an Agent of Socialization: A Research in Expansion in Democratic Society', in Van Glis, M.R., (ed.) The Perceived Role of the Military.Rotterdam: Rotterdam University Press, pp. 327-339.
33.
LOMSKY-FEDER, E. 1994. `Patterns of Participation in War and the Constructions of War in the Life-Course: Life Stories of Israeli Veterans From the Yom Kippur War', unpublished PhD thesis, Hebrew University of Jerusalem [in Hebrew].
34.
MERON, D. 1992. Facing the Silent Brother.Jerusalem: Keter [in Hebrew].
35.
MILGRAM, N.A. 1986. `An Attribution Analysis of War-Related Stress: Modes of Coping and Helping', in Milgram, N.A., (ed.) Stress and Coping in Time.New York: Brunner/Mazel, pp. 9-25.
36.
MINTZ, A. 1984. `The Military Industrial Complex: The Israeli Case', in Lissak, M., (ed.) Israeli Society and its Defence Establishment.London: Frankcass, pp. 103-127.
37.
MODELL, J. and HAGGERTY, T.1991. `The Social Impact of War'.Annual Review of Sociology17: 205-224.
38.
MOSSE, G.L. 1990. Fallen Soldiers: Reshaping the Memory of World Wars.Oxford: Oxford University Press.
39.
MYERHOFF, B. 1980. `Life History Among the Elderly: Performance, Visibility and Remembering', in Back, K.W., (ed.) Life Course: Integrative Theories and Exemplary Population. AAAS Selected Symposium 41.Boulder, CO: Westview Press, pp. 133-153.
40.
NATANSON, M. 1962. Literature, Philosophy and the Social Sciences.The Hague: Martinus Nijhoff, pp. 55-61.
41.
OFRAT, G.1991. `The Fading of the Khaki'.Studio27: 6-11.
42.
RAPOPORT T. and LOMSKY-FEDER, E. 1994. `Israel', in Hurrelman, K., (ed.) International Handbook of Adolescence.Westport, CT: Greenwood Press, pp. 207-223.
43.
REESE, H.W. and MCCLUSKEY, K.A. 1984. `Dimensions of Historical Constancy and Change', in McCluskey, K.A. and Reese, H.W., (eds) Life-Span Developmental Psychology.New York: Academic Press, pp. 17-45.
44.
ROSENTHAL, G.1991. `German War Memories: Narrability and the Biographical and Social Functions of Remembering'.Oral History (autumn): 34-41.
45.
RYFF, C.D. 1984. `Personality Development From the Inside: The Subjective Experience of Change in Adulthood and Aging', in Baltes, P.B. and Brim, O.G., (eds) Life-Span Development and Behavior.New York: Academic Press, pp. 243-279.
46.
SARBIN, T.R. 1986. `The Narrative as A Root Metaphor for Psychology', in Sarbin, T.R. (ed.) Narrative Psychology.New York: Praeger, pp. 3-21.
47.
SCHUTZ, A.1944. `The Homecomer'.American Journal of Sociology50 (5): 369-375.
48.
SCHUTZ, A. 1970. On Phenomenology and Social Relations.Chicago, IL: University of Chicago Press.
49.
SCHUTZ, A. and LUCKMANN, T. 1974. The Structure of the Life-World.London: Heinemann.
50.
SCHUTZE, F.1992. `Pressure and Guilt: War Experiences of a Young German Soldier and Their Biographical Implications'.. International Sociology7: 187-207, 347-367.
51.
SHAKED, G. 1993. `Hebrew Narrative Fiction 1880-1990, 5. Jerusalem: Keter (in Hebrew).
52.
SIVAN, E. 1991. The 1948 Generation: Myth, Profile And Memory.Tel Aviv: Maarachot (in Hebrew).
53.
SYNA-DESIVILYA, H. 1991. War Experiences In the Israeli Veterans' Lives: A Life Course Perspective.Zikhron Ya'akov: Israeli Institute For Military Studies.
54.
TZALMONA, Y.1991. `Hummus with Whipped Cream?'.Mishkafayim19: 9-14.
55.
WATSON, L.C.1976. `Understanding a Life History as a Subjective Document'.Ethos4 (1): 95-131.
