A comparison of two measures of quality of life: their sensitivity and validity for patients with advanced cancer

Abstract

We compared two measures that have been used by professionals to assess the quality of life and care of patients wtih advanced cancer. The Support Team Assessment Schedule (STAS) is an instrument for palliative cancer support teams to record and evaluate their care; the Hebrew Rehabilitation Centre for the Aged Quality of Life (HRCA-QL) index was used in the National Hospice Study (USA) to assess patients with advanced cancer. STAS has 17 items, each scaled 0 (best) to 4 (worst), and HRCA-QL has five items scaled 0 (worst) to 2 (best). The STAS and the HRCA-QL were assessed contemporaneously by the members of one support team on 128 consecutive patients referred over 17 months. Seventy-four patients spent more than four weeks in care. Ratings for four out of five HRCA-QL items deteriorated significantly in the four to six weeks before death. HRCA-QL index items correlated with similar STAS items. Correlations were highest at referral, especially in patients seen more than four weeks before death (e.g. symptom control (STAS) with health (HRCA-QL) Spearman's p = -0.64) and the HRCA-QL total was correlated with STAS subtotal of six items (p = -0.45). There were few correlations at death. The findings support the validity of both measures for the aspects compared, but indicated that STAS was more sensitive to changes in patients in the last six weeks of life.

Keywords

hospices neoplasms outcomes (non-MeSH)quality assurance health care quality of life reproducibility of results terminal care

References

Spitzer WO , Dobson AJ , Hall J. et al. Measuring the quality of life of cancer patients: a concise QL index for use by physicians. J Chronic Dis 1981; 34: 585-97.

De Haes JCJM, Van Kippenberg Fce , Neijt JP Measuring psychological and physical distress in cancer patients: structure and application of the Rotterdam Symptom Checklist . Br J Cancer 1990; 62: 1034-38.

Aaronson NK , Ahmedai S. , Bergman B. et al. The European Organisation for Research and Treatment of Cancer QLQ-C30: a quality of life instrument for use in international clinical trials in oncology. J Natl Cancer Inst 1993; 85: 365-66.

Greer DS , Mor V. , Morris JN , Sherwood S. , Kidder D. , Birnbaum H. An alternative in terminal care: results of the National Hospice Study. J Chronic Dis 1986; 39: 9-26.

Mount BM , Scott JF Whither hospice evaluation? J Chronic Dis 1983; 36: 731-36.

Higginson I. , McCarthy M.

Validity of the support team assessment schedule: do staff's ratings reflect those made by patients or their families?

Palliat Med 1993;7:219-28.

Higginson I. Clinical audit in palliative care. Oxford: Radcliffe Medical Press, 1993.

Bates T. , Hoy AM , Clarke DG , Laird PP The St Thomas' Hospital terminal care support team: a new concept of hospice care. Lancet 1981; i: 1201-203.

Ward Awm.

Home care services - an alternative to hospices?

Community Med 1987; 9: 47-54.

10.

Higginson I. , Wade A. , McCarthy M. Palliative care: views of patients and their families. Br Med J 1990; 301: 277-81.

11.

Moser CA , Kalton G. Survey Methods in Social Investigation, second edition. London: Heinemann, 1971.

12.

Streiner DL , Norman GR Health measurement scales. A practical guide to their development and use . Oxford: Oxford University Press , 1989.

13.

Addington-Hall JM , MacDonald LD , Anderson HR Can the Spitzer Quality of Life Index help to reduce prognostic uncertainty in terminal cancer? Br J Cancer 1990; 62: 659-69.

14.

Morris JN , Sherwood S. Quality of life of cancer patients at different stages in their disease trajectory . J Chronic Dis 1987; 40: 545-53.

15.

Lunt B. , Neale C. A comparison of hospice and hospital care for terminally ill cancer patients and their families. A comparison of care goals set by staff, (Paper D). Southampton: Department of Community Medicine, University of Southampton, 1985.

16.

Maguire P. , Selby P. Assessing quality of life in cancer patients. Br J Cancer 1989; 60: 437-40.

17.

MacAdam DB , Smith M. An initial assessment of suffering in terminal illness. Palliat Med 1987; 1: 37-47.

18.

Ganz PA , Schag AC , Cheng HL Assessing the quality of life - a study in newly diagnosed breast cancer patients . J Clin Epidemiol 1990; 43: 75-86.

19.

Schag CC , Heinrich RL , Ganz PA Cancer inventory of problem situations: an instrument for assessing cancer patients' rehabilitation needs. J Psychosoc Oncol 1983; 1: 11-24.

20.

McHorney C. , Ware J. , Rogers W. , Raczek A. , Lu A. , Lu J. The validity and relative precision of MOS short and long form health status scales and Dartmouth COOP charts. Med Care 1992; 30: 253-65.