Sustainable Development in a U.S. Context: Analysis and Implications

Abstract

Since the introduction of the concept of “sustainable development” by the World Commission on Environment and Development in 1987, a number of programs and policies have been offered, enacted, and pursued that profess to those ideals. The extent to which they actually accord with them, however, is the subject of a growing body of debate and literature. Some critics have argued that despite its promise, the concept of sustainable development has merely been reformulated and used to continue promoting the goal of economic growth as the primary measure of progress. This viewpoint argues that sustainable development can never be more than sustainable economic growth under the current growth development paradigm. This article examines these arguments through an analysis of sustainable development as pursued in the United States. It focuses on the sustainable development component of the U.S. government's comprehensive approach to solving urban problems through the creation of empowerment zones.

References

Allardice

D. R.

, Mattoon

R. H.

, & Test

W.A.

(1996). Brownfield redevelopment and urban economies. Available: http://gopher.grea…d/per/cflmay95.txt

Byrne

, & Rich

(1992). Toward a political economy of global change: Energy, environment, and development in the greenhouse. In Byrne

and Rich

(Eds.), Energy and environment: The policy challenge (pp. 269-300). New Brunswick, NJ: Transaction.

Camden, NJ/Philadelphia, PA Empowerment Zone: Executive Summary. (1996). Available: http://www.ezec.gov/ezec/NJ/phili.html

The Clinton Administration Proposes a Second Round of Empowerment Zones and Enterprise Communities. (1996). Available: http://www.ezec.gov/about/round2.html Clinton: Prez Rails Against GOP, Pushes Brownfields Plan. (1996, March 12). Greenwire 5(210). Available: http://www.ecology…RTICLES/gwo312.htm

Crenshaw

, & Peller

(1993). Reel time/real justice. In Gooding-Williams

(Ed.), Reading Rodney King: Reading urban uprising (pp. 56-70). New York. Routledge.

Daly

H.E.

(1990). Sustainable growth: An impossibility theorem. Development 3 (4), 45-47.

The Ecologist. (1993). Whose common future: Reclaiming the commons. Philadelphia, PA: New Society.

Ellul

(1964). The technological society. New York: Random House/Vintage.

Empowerment Zone/Enterprise Community Fact Sheet. (1996). Avaiable: http://www.ezec.gov/about/ezfact.html

10.

Environmental Protection Agency (EPA). (1996). The brownfields action agenda. Available: http://www.epa.gov…f/ascii/action.txt

11.

EPA “Brownfields” Project Designed to Aid Developers of Contaminated Properties. Available: http://venable.com/govern/brwnflds.htm

12.

Executive Order No. 12852. (1996). Available: http://www.whitehouse.go…nfo/executive-order.html

13.

Foster

J.B.

(1994). The vulnerable planet: A short economic history of the environment. New York: Monthly Review Press.

14.

Foster

J.B.

(1996). Sustainable development of what? Capitalism, Nature, and Socialism 7 (3), 129-132.

15.

Frankenfeld

P.J.

(1992). Technological citizenship: A normative framework for risk studies. Science, Technology, and Human Values 17 (4), 459-484.

16.

Gaventa

(1980). Power and powerlessness. Urbana: University of Illinois Press.

17.

Greenfields vs. Brownfields. (1996). Available: http://habitat.ced…5apr/msg00017.html

18.

Iannone

D.T.

(1996). Redeveloping urban brownfields. Land Lines 7(6). Available: http://www.igc.apc…coln/brownfld.html

19.

Kinsley

M. J.

, & Hunter

L.L.

(1996). Paying for growth, prospering from development. Center of Excellence for Sustainable Development. Available: http://www.sustaianble.doe.gov/articles/paying4growth/index.html

20.

Lohman

(1995). Whose common future? In Conca

Alberty

, & Dabelko (Eds.), Green planet blues: Enviornmental politics from Stockholm to Rio. (pp. 222-226). Boulder, CO: Westview.

21.

Los Angeles City/County, California Supplemental Empowerment Zone: Executive Summary. (1996). Available: http://www.ezec.gov/ezec/CA/la_sez.html

22.

Marshall

(1938). Principles of economics. London: Macmillan. (Original work published 1890)

23.

Marx

(1906). Capital, A critique of political economy. In The process of capitalist production (Vol. 1; pp. 405-422, 430-478). New York: Random House. (Original work published 1867)

24.

Mumford

(1934). Technics and civilization. New York: Harcourt Brace

25.

Mumford

(1964). Authoritarian and democratic technics. Technology and Culture 5, 1-8.

26.

Noble

D.F.

(1983). Present tense technology: Technology's politics. Democracy 3 (2), 8-24.

27.

Norgaard

(1994). Development betrayed: The end of progress and a coevolutionary revisioning of the future. New York: Routledge.

28.

Office of Solid Waste and Emergency Response. (1996a). Answers to frequently asked questions about brownfields. Available: http://www.epa.gov…s/bf/answers.htm#1

29.

Office of Solid Waste and Emergency Response. (1996b). Brownfield national pilots. Available: http://www.epa.gov…sps/bf/natl.htm#de

30.

The President's Community Enterprise Board. (1994, January). Building communities together: Empowerment zones and enterprise communities application guide. HUD—1445—CPD.

31.

President's Council on Sustainable Development (PCSD). (1996). Available: http://www.whiteho…info/overview.html

32.

Rosenberg

(1972). Technology and American economic growth. New York: Sharpe.

33.

Schwartz-Cowan

(1985). The industrial revolution in the home. In MacKenzie

& Wajcam

(Eds.), The social shaping of technology (pp. 181-201). Milton Keynes: Open University Press.

34.

Shiva

(1992). The violence of the green revolution: The world agriculture, ecology, and politics. London: Zed.

35.

Silber

(1996). When cleanliness isn't a virtue. Bank of America. Available: http://xwww.bankam…unity/env_d18.html

36.

Sokolski

A.M.

(1996, March 12). Brownfields tax incentive plan unveiled by Clinton. Available: http://www.envirob…daily/96031202.htm

37.

Winner

(1982). Energy regimes and the ideology of efficiency. In Daniels & Rose (Eds.), Energy and transport (pp. 261-276).

38.

Winner

(1986). The whale and the reactor: A search for limits in an age of high technology. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.

39.

World Commission on Environment and Development (WCED). (1987). Our common future. New York: Oxford University Press.

40.

World Resources Institute. Policies and institutions: Natural resources accounting. In World Resources 1990-1991 (pp. 231-239). New York: Oxford University Press.

41.

Zimmerman

A.D.

(1995). Toward a more democratic ethic of technological governance. Science, Technology, and Human Values 20 (1), 86-107.