Abstract
Background
Diffusion tensor imaging (DTI) of peripheral nerves may provide additional information about nerve involvement in muscular disorders, but is considered difficult due to different optimal scan parameters tailored to magnetic resonance (MR) signal properties of muscle and neural tissues.
Purpose
To assess the feasibility of sciatic nerve DTI using two different approaches of region of interest (ROI)-localization in DTI scans with b-values 500 s/mm2, in participants with muscular disorders and in controls.
Material and Methods
DTI of the thigh was conducted on a 3T system in ten patients (6 men, 4 women; mean age =54 ± 15 years) with neuromuscular disorders and ten controls. T1-weighted (T1W) images were co-registered to fractional anisotropy (FA) color-encoded images. The apparent diffusion coefficient (ADC), FA, and fiber track length (FTL) were analyzed by two operators using a freehand ROI and a single-point ROI covering the sciatic nerve. Interclass correlation coefficient (ICC) and Bland–Altman analysis were used for evaluation of inter-operator and inter-technical agreement, respectively.
Results
Three-dimensional visualization of sciatic nerve fiber was achievable using both techniques. The ICC of DTI metrics showed excellent inter-operator agreement both in patients and controls. Bland–Altman analysis revealed good agreement of both techniques. A maximum FTL was achieved using the single-point ROI technique, but with a lower inter-operator agreement (ICC = 0.99 vs. 0.83). The ADC and maximum FTL were significantly decreased in patients compared to controls.
Conclusion
Both ROI localization techniques are feasible to analyze the sciatic nerve in the setting of muscular disease. A maximum FTL is reached using the single-point ROI, however, at the cost of lower inter-operator agreement.
Keywords
Introduction
Diffusion tensor imaging (DTI), which is already well-established for evaluation of the central nervous system, is also an evolving technique for the assessment of diffusion and fiber coherence in neuromuscular diseases (1). Diffusion weighted imaging (DWI) and DTI use the principle of Brownian motion, the phenomenon of water diffusion within a certain medium or environment. Molecular motion is affected by intrinsic properties of biological tissues, reflecting both the tissue architecture and microstructure. Anisotropic diffusion occurs in densely packed tissue structures, reflecting a greater diffusion in certain directions as seen along axons or in skeletal muscle, whereas isotropic diffusion is characterized by equal diffusion in all directions, e.g. as seen in cerebrospinal fluid. Taking advantage of the characteristic diffusion properties of different tissues, DTI allows a spatial description of the medium studied (2). Recent studies evaluating DTI of skeletal muscle in chronic muscular dystrophies found significant alterations of apparent diffusion coefficient (ADC) and fractional anisotropy (FA) in the affected muscles, which seemed to be influenced by the grade of muscular fatty infiltration and degeneration (3,4). Magnetic resonance (MR) neurography allows further insights into the axonal integrity of neuronal tissues (5–7). A reduction of FA is frequently observed in conditions of axonal degeneration due to trauma or inflammation, probably reflecting an increase of the isotropic water diffusion due to a loss of nerve tissue integrity (8–14). The structural integrity of the nerve fiber as well as the coherence of the fiber is more sensitively reflected by the FA than the apparent diffusion coefficient (10,15). Previous studies evaluating histopathological and DTI analysis on peripheral nerves found a stronger correlation of axonal density and axonal diameter with FA values than with myelin density and myelin thickness. Furthermore, previous studies on chronic inflammatory demyelinating polyradiculoneuropathies (CIDP) found strong correlations between anisotropy and electrophysiological action potential amplitudes, which is thought to correlate with axonal damage (16). The joint application of peripheral nerve DTI and skeletal muscle DTI is considered challenging as the two techniques require different imaging parameters for optimal visualization. Whereas low b-values in the range of 400–500 s/mm2 and a minimum number of diffusion gradient directions (NDGD) have been proposed for accurate DTI of the skeletal muscle (17), optimal DTI acquisitions use b-values 800–1200 s/mm2 for peripheral nerve MR neurography. Sequences of higher b-values are considered to be more diffusion-weighted than sequences with lower b-values. Despite a supposed longer fiber track length (FTL) and higher image quality of tractography, higher b-values have also been shown to be more susceptible to artifacts due to a lower signal-to-noise ratio (SNR) of acquired images (18–23).
The aim of this study was to assess the feasibility sciatic nerve DTI adapted for skeletal muscle in various muscular dystrophies and myopathies in comparison to controls, by using two different approaches of region of interest (ROI) localization: a freehand ROI and a single-point ROI technique.
Material and Methods
Study population
The local ethics committee approved the study and written consent was obtained from each volunteer and patient. Ten healthy volunteers (7 men, 3 women; age =41 ± 15 years) served as a control group. None of the controls reported recent trauma or discomfort of the limb muscles. There was no history of hereditary neuromuscular disorders.
Physiognomic data of patient study group including data of muscle fatty infiltration averaged on representative thigh muscles.
VL, vastus lateralis muscle; VI, vastus intermedius muscle; ADM, adductor magnus muscle.
Magnetic resonance imaging (MRI)
Sequence parameters for T2 and T1 weighted imaging and DTI.
Image analysis
Analysis of DTI metrics was performed by two operators (SK with four years of MRI training and JY with 12 years of MRI training) blinded to clinical, e.g. electrophysiological, information. Pathological macroscopic alterations of the sciatic nerve, like edema and swelling, were visualized and assessed by the fat-suppressed high-resolution T2W and T1W Dixon sequences. Geometrically co-registered axial T1W imaging and DTI data were used as anatomical reference to identify the sciatic nerve structure (Fig. 1). MR neurography was performed using the manufacturer’s workstation and software (FiberTrak; release V2.1.3 Philips Healthcare, Cleveland, OH, USA). In both techniques (freehand ROI and single-point ROI), diffusion images were registered to the b = 0 image prior to performing fiber tracking. For fiber tracking, the software employed a fiber assignment by continuous tracking (FACT) method with thresholds previously defined by Mori et al. (24–26).
Example of ROI localization for sciatic nerve MR neurography in a 74-year-old male patient with diagnosed myotonic dystrophy type 2 on a T1W axial image. (a) Freehand ROI localization method; (b) single-point ROI localization method.
In each patient and control, three ROIs were chosen for the extrapelvic sciatic nerve caudal to the greater sciatic foramen and proximal to the popliteal fossa, where the sciatic nerve branches into the common fibular and the tibial nerve.
For the freehand ROI technique, a ROI was manually drawn onto the outer border of the sciatic nerve, avoiding surrounding areas of connective and adipose tissue (Fig. 1a).
In a second approach, here called single-point ROI technique, a single voxel within the nerve was selected and processed for fiber tracking (Fig. 1b).
The maximum FTL, FA, and ADC of the sciatic nerve were calculated automatically by the software, using a single pixel-based ROI-line propagation technique (FA threshold =0.2, direction threshold =5.0°).
Muscle fat fraction (MFF%): The MFF% was obtained in four thigh muscles (rectus femoris [RF], semitendinosus [ST], biceps femoris [BF], and gracilis [G] muscle) using two-point modified Dixon-based MRI (2pt-MRIDIXON) with chemical-shift-encoded reconstruction of the fat and water signal (27,28). Using custom imaging software (OsiriX; version 6.5; Pixmeo), the signal intensities (SI) of three ROIs covering the whole muscle were drawn in the fat (SIFAT) and water-only (SIWATER) image of the proximal, middle and distal part of the RF, ST, BF, and G muscle. An additional ROI was placed in the subcutaneous fat for normalization.
The MFF% was calculated using the following algorithm:
Statistical analysis
Statistical analysis was performed using GraphPad Prism 6.0f (GraphPad Software, La Jolla, CA, USA) and SPSS Statistics 22 software (IBM Inc. SPSS Statistics, Armonk, NY, USA). Normal distribution of data was assessed using the Shapiro–Wilk normality test. DTI metrics (ADC, FA, FTL) were expressed as the mean ± standard deviation of each single value. The MFF% of all four muscles analyzed was presented as median and interquartile range. Paired Student’s t test was conducted for comparison of DTI metrics in patients and controls. Data differences were considered statistically significant if a significance level α = 0.05 was reached.
The concordance of the freehand ROI and single-point ROI techniques in patients and controls was analyzed using paired Student’s t-test and Bland–Altman plotting (29). Inter-operator agreement was assessed for the single-point and freehand ROI technique in patients and controls using intra-class correlation (ICC). An ICC value of >0.81 was considered excellent agreement, ICC 0.61–0.80 substantial agreement, ICC 0.41–0.60 moderate agreement, ICC 0.21–0.40 fair agreement, and ICC < 0.20 slight agreement.
Results
In controls and in patients, no sign of nerve disease or trauma was detected in the initial anatomical T1W and T2W imaging. All patients showed a variable degree of muscular atrophy with concomitant muscular fatty infiltration (Table 1). Mild to moderate muscular edema on T2W Dixon images with fat suppression was observed in 4/10 patients, restricted to the vastus and adductor magnus muscle groups (Table 1). Three-dimensional MR neurography of the co-registered axial DTI-T1W imaging was produced without visible artifacts in patients with mild to moderate degrees of muscular wasting and fatty infiltration and controls (Figs. 2–4).
MR neurography of the sciatic nerve in a 30-year-old healthy male control (median muscle fat fraction <5.0%). Manually drawn ROI using axial T1W imaging (a, d), b0 images (b, e), rotated T1W imaging for visualization of fiber tracks. (a–c) Freehand ROI localization, (d–f) single-point ROI localization. MR neurography of the sciatic nerve in a 73-year-old male patient with diagnosed myotonic dystrophy type 2 and a moderate increase of muscular fatty tissue (MFF of 8.6%). Manually drawn ROI using axial T1W imaging (a, d), b0 images (b, e), rotated T1W imaging for visualization of fiber tracks. (a–c) Freehand ROI localization; (d–f) single-point ROI localization. MR neurography of the sciatic nerve in a 49-year-old female patient with diagnosed facioscapulohumeral muscular dystrophy and a high grade of muscular fatty infiltration (MFF 45.1%). Manually drawn ROI using axial T1W imaging (a, d), b0 images (b, e), rotated T1W imaging for visualization of fiber tracks. (a–c) Freehand ROI localization, (d–f) single-point ROI localization.


Inter-operator agreement of DTI metrics.
All data are presented as mean ± standard deviation.
The inter-operator-agreement is presented as ICC (95% CI).
ADC, apparent diffusion coefficient (mm2/s × 10−3); FA, fractional anisotropy; FTL, fiber track length (mm); ICC, intra-class correlation.
The Bland–Altman analysis for comparison of the freehand ROI versus the single-point ROI showed very good agreement in patients and controls with a bias of −0.0007 ± 0.09 mm2/s × 10−3 (95% limits of agreement =−0.18 to 0.18 mm2/s × 10−3) and a bias of −0.01 ± 0.04 (95% limits of agreement =–0.09 to 0.07) for assessment of the ADC and FA, respectively. No significant inter-technical difference was found in the freehand ROI method compared to the single-point ROI method in patients or controls (ADC P = 0.3; FA P = 0.7). The Bland–Altman analysis for DTI metrics in patients and controls is illustrated in Fig. 5.
Bland–Altman analysis for comparison of freehand ROI and single-point ROI method of the sciatic nerve in patients and controls. Bias (black line), 95% limits of agreement (dotted line). (a) ADC value difference with a bias at 0.0007 ± 0.09 mm2/s × 10−3 and 95% limits of agreement from –0.18 to 0.18 mm2/s × 10−3. (b) FA value difference with a bias at –0.01 ± 0.04 and 95% limits of agreement from –0.09 to 0.07. (c) FTL difference with a bias at –20.83 ± 21.54 mm and 95% limits of agreement from –63.05 to 21.39 mm.
Mean ADC was significantly diminished in patients when averaged between the observers (freehand ROI: patients =1.42 ± 0.13 mm2/s × 10−3, controls =1.62 ± 0.13 mm2/s × 10−3; P = 0.002). No significant group difference was observed for FA (freehand ROI: patients = 0.46 ± 0.08, controls = 0.43 ± 0.05; P = 0.21).
Using both the freehand and single-point ROI techniques, the mean FTL was significantly shortened in patients compared to controls (freehand ROI: patients= 78.6 ± 25.2 mm, controls =110.2 ± 25.2 mm; P = 0.01). In general, the FTL obtained by the single-point ROI technique (patients = 95.1 ± 22.7 mm; controls =135.3 ± 26.5 mm) resulted in a longer continuous track length compared to the freehand ROI method, especially in the control group (bias =–25.1 ± 16.8; 95% limits of agreement =–58.1 to 7.8).
Discussion
In this study, we analyzed the feasibility of sciatic nerve MR neurography in patients with different types of myopathies and muscular dystrophies, which are associated with skeletal muscular wasting and concomitant increase of fat and connective tissue. To confirm the visual aspect of muscle wasting and fatty infiltration, muscle fat fractions were analyzed on representative muscle groups. Because of the rarity of muscular dystrophies and myopathies, we chose a patient cohort with diseases exhibiting probably similar levels of fatty replacement and muscle wasting, without known or previously described alterations of DTI or electrodiagnostic analysis of peripheral nerves.
Although recent studies emphasize the utilization of b-values > 1000 s/mm2 for optimal nerve fiber visualization, the rationale of using a b-value of 500 s/mm2 in this study was to test whether a single examination protocol, adjusted for properties of muscle tissue, could be of use to visualize peripheral nerves included in the examination field and to assess any co-existing nerve pathology. Referring to previous studies describing a lowering of the SNR with higher diffusion sensitivity, we supposed that an imaging protocol with lower b-values might be less prone to artifact (as SNR is degraded by fatty infiltration) and more time-efficient especially for immobilized patients (7,10,20). The results obtained in this study confirm good visualization and excellent inter-operator agreement for peripheral nerve MR neurography at b-values 500 s/mm2 in patients and controls. The herein applied single-point as well as freehand ROI technique revealed comparable DTI metrics (FA and ADC). The single-point method detected slightly higher ADC values and higher maximum FTL in controls and patients. Whereas the single-point ROI method reflects the signal from a single image voxel chosen for tractography, the freehand ROI localization utilizes image voxels of the entire nerve structure including peri- and epineural tissue.
Comparing patients to healthy controls, both ROI localization techniques applied here showed a reduction of the sciatic nerve ADC and maximum FTL in patients, but without significant alteration of mean FA. The shortening of the fiber under the applied technical algorithms suggests that either the FA dropped along the tract below the determined FA threshold of 0.2 for fiber termination, or the direction of the track changed more than 5° between neighboring image slices. Because of the increased standard deviation of FA in patients versus controls, the nerve fibers in patients are more heterogeneous with segments of variably lower and higher FA. A reduction of FA was frequently observed in conditions of axonal damage, rather than demyelination (16).
FA and ADC values obtained in this study and previous published studies are highly variable, depending on several factors including b-values, number of gradient directions, voxel size and number of acquisitions in the DTI acquisition protocol (30). In comparison to previous studies analyzing the sciatic nerve in different polyneuropathies, the observed elevation of ADC and associated decrease of FA in polyneuropathy described by Vaeggemose et al. (8) and Mathys et al. (11) was not detected in our patient cohort. On the contrary, the relation of ADC and FA values in this study was shifted, with a decrease in ADC and unchanged to slight increase in FA values. The disagreement is most likely caused by different disease conditions. A decrease in ADC indicates greater restriction of water diffusion in nerve cells, which can be consistent with cytotoxic edema.
We speculate that the findings obtained here reflect a shifted appearance of the epineurium and perineurium in patients rather than a measurable defect of axonal fiber integrity, which could influence the extent but not direction of free water diffusion.
This study has some limitations. As this study focuses on the technical comparison of peripheral nerve DTI in neuromuscular disorders, the selected study cohort bears the limitation of heterogeneous disease, though all share a progressive loss of muscle associated with a variable degree of fatty infiltration. Future studies could focus on disease-specific DTI metrics under the technical conditions applied here. Another limitation of this study is that diffusion images with higher b-values than 500 s/mm2 were not acquired for comparison. These limitations can be addressed in future studies.
In conclusion, both the freehand ROI and single-point ROI localization in DTI adapted for skeletal muscles are feasible and reproducible complementary MR tools to analyze peripheral nerves in neuromuscular disease. A maximum FTL can be achieved using the single-point ROI technique, however at cost of a reduced inter-observer agreement. Future studies focusing on disease-specific cohorts will be of interest.
Footnotes
Declaration of Conflicting Interests
The author(s) declared no potential conflicts of interest with respect to the research, authorship, and/or publication of this article.
Funding
The author(s) received no financial support for the research, authorship, and/or publication of this article.
