Civil and common-law traditions treat surviving spouses and children differently. The surviving spouse has come to be increasingly protected in common-law and civil law countries. But civil law countries restrict testamentary freedom to protect the shares of children, whereas common-law countries allow the children to be disinherited. The gulf between common-law and civil law countries is, however, in the process of being closed by sociolegal practice and law reforms. In practice, nuclear family members (the spouse and children) everywhere remain the most frequent beneficiaries of inheritances. The attribution of individualist or traditionalist traits to legal concepts of inheritance seems to be futile when legal history is taken into account. The social consequences of inheritance rules depend on the specific historical, social, and economic conditions under which the rules function.
References
1.
Alan Watson, Legal Transplants (Edinburgh: Scottish Academic Press, 1974).
2.
Heinrich Dörner, Industrialisierung und Familienrecht (Berlin: Duncker und Humblot, 1974).
3.
John Eekelaar , "The End of an Era?" Journal of Family History28 (2003): 108-122 (this issue).
4.
Illegitimate and legitimate children receive equal portions. Eekelaar, "The End of an Era?"
5.
Mary Ann Glendon, The New Family and the New Property (Toronto: Butterworth, 1981).
6.
Emile Durkheim, Physikder Sitten und des Rechts (Frankfurt: Suhrkamp, 1991).
7.
Max Rheinstein, Das Erbrecht von Familienangehörigen in positivrechtlicher und rechtspolitischer Sicht (Frankfurt: Metzner, 1971).
8.
André Burguière and François Lebrun , "Die Vielfalt der Familienmodelle in Europa," in Geschichte der Familie, vol. 3 of Neuzeit, eds. André Burguière, Christiane Klapisch-Zuber , Martine Segalen, and Francoise Zonabend (Frankfurt/Main : Campus, 1997), 13-118.
9.
Claudine Attias-Donfut, Les solidarités entre générations (Paris: Nathan, 1996).
10.
Richard Tilly and Charles Tilly, "Agenda for European Economic History," Journal of Economic History (1971 ): 184-98.
11.
Jürgen Kocka , Familie und soziale Plazierung ( Opladen: Westdeutscher Verlag, 1980 ).
12.
Anne Gotman , Hériter (Paris: Presses Universitaires de France, 1988).
13.
Hans Stöker , "Die Neuordnung der gesetzlichen Erbfolge im Spiegel des mutmaßlichen Erblasserwillens," Zeitschrift für das gesamte Familienrecht (1971): 609-18.
14.
Alexander Freytag , "Das neue Erbrecht der DDR aus Sicht des BGB " (Ph.D. diss., Freiburg University, 1981).
15.
Wolfgang Friedmann , Recht und sozialer Wandel ( Frankfurt: Europäische Verlagsanstalt, 1969).
16.
Emmanuel Le Roy Ladurie, "Structures familiales et coutume d'héritage ," Annales E.S.C. (1985): 825-46.
17.
Gotman, Hériter, 84-85.
18.
Pierre Bourdieu , "Les stratégies matrimoniales dans le système de reproduction," Annales E.S.C. (1972 ): 1105-25.
19.
Since the 1980s, only members of the nuclear family are protected by a compulsory share in the inheritance. The last remaining distinctions between marital and nonmarital children were abolished in 1998.
20.
Helmut Coing , "Empfiehlt es sich, das gesetzliche Erbrecht und Pflichtteilsrecht neu zu regeln?" Verhandlungen des deutschen Juristentages (1972): A1-A55.
21.
Georg W.F. Hegel, Rechtsphilosophie (Stuttgart: Fromann-Holzboog , 1973).
22.
Gotman, Hériter.
23.
Heinz Wagner, Das geteilte Eigentum (Breslau: G. Märtin, 1938).
24.
Jörn Eckert, Der Kampf um die Familienfideikommisse in Deutschland (Frankfurt/ Main: Lang, 1992).
Rolf Schwarz , "Das Verhältnis zwischen dem Landwirtschaftserbrecht und dem allgemeinen Erbrecht des BGB" (Ph.D. diss., Marburg University, 1988).
27.
Bernold Brendel , Das Problem der weichenden Erben im Anerbenrecht (Berlin: de Gruyter, 1959).
28.
Irmgard Guss , "Über den Ursprung des Anerbenrechts" (Ph.D. diss., Greifswald University, 1935).
29.
Jack Goody, Joan Thirsk, and Edward Thompson, eds., Family and Inheritance (Cambridge, UK: Cambridge University Press, 1976).
30.
Georges Augustins , Comment se perpétuer? (Nanterre : Société d'ethnologie, 1989).
31.
Werner Tetiwa , "Grundzüge und Bedeutung des Estate Planning im Recht der USA" (Ph.D. diss., Münster University, 1975).
32.
Carole Shammas , Marylynn Salmon, and Michel Dahlin, Inheritance in America (New Brunswick, NJ: Rutgers University Press, 1987).
33.
Max Rheinstein , Cases and Other Materials on the Law of Decedents' Estates (Indianapolis, IN: Bobbs-Merrill Co., 1947).
34.
Helene Shapo , "A Tale of Two Systems: Anglo-American Problems in the Modernization of Inheritance Legislation," Tennessee Law Review (1993): 707.
35.
For example, David Bradley, "Convergence in Family Law: Mirrors, Transplants and Political Economy," Maastricht Journal of European Law (1999): 127-50.
36.
Frédéric Le Play, La réforme sociale en France ( Paris: Plon, 1887).
37.
Hans W. Riehl, Die Naturgeschichte des deutschen Volkes , ed. Günther Ipsen ( Stuttgart: Körner, 1939).
38.
For example, Burguière and Lebrun, "Die Vielfalt."
39.
Georges Macfarlane , The Origins of English Individualism (Oxford, UK: Blackwell, 1978).
40.
Eileen Spring , Law, Land and Family (Chapel Hill: University of North Carolina Press, 1993).
41.
For example, Rheinstein, Cases.
42.
Ludwig Fick , Die bäuerliche Erbfolge im Rechtsrheinischen (Stuttgart : Cotta, 1895).
43.
Burguière and Lebrun, "Die Vielfalt."
44.
Gunter Ipsen , Das Landvolk (Hamburg: Hanseatische Verlagsanstalt, 1933).
45.
Even the old Germanic tribes residing in southern Germany gave equal portions to all children, regardless of their sex, with the difference that female children received movables and male children immovables.
46.
Karl von Amira , Germanisches Erbrecht ( Berlin : de Gruyter, 1977).
Bernhard Farber , Conceptions of Kinship ( New York: Elsevier, 1981).
49.
Ibid.; Thomas Rauscher, Reformfragen des gesetzlichen Erb- und Pflichtteilrechts, vol. 2 ( Regensburg: S. Roeder Verlag, 1993 ), 141.
50.
The English common-law descent line is very similar to the German civil law descent line.
51.
Farber, Conceptions of Kinship; Germaine Tillion, The Republic of Cousins (London : Al Saqi Books, 1983).
52.
England: Janet Finch, Jennifer Mason, Judith Masson, Lorraine Wallis, and Lynn Hayes, Wills, Inheritance and Families (Oxford, UK: Clarendon, 1996); United States: Remi Clignet, Death, Deeds and Descendants (New York: Aldine de Gruyter, 1992); France: Jérôme Accordo, "Successions et donations en 1994," Insee Premiere (1994): 1-4; Germany: Paul Rotering, Rechtstatsächliches zum Inhalt eröffneter Verfügungen von Todes wegen (Frankfurt/ Main: Lang, 1986).
53.
Anne Laferrère and Daniel Verger, "La transmission du patrimoine entre les generations," La Societé Francaise (1993): 377-84; Marianne Kosmann, Wie Frauen erben (Opladen: Leske und Budrich, 1998).
54.
Marvin B. Sussman , Judit N. Cates, and David T. Smith, The Family and Inheritance (New York: Russell Sage Foundation , 1970).
55.
Rotering, Rechtstatsächliches.
56.
Dieter Leipold , "Wandlungen in den Grundlagen des Erbrechts ," Archiv für die zivilistische Praxis (1980 ): 160-237.
57.
Laferrère and Verger, "La transmission."
58.
Shapo, "Tale."
59.
Finch, Wills.
60.
Cristy G. Lomenzo, "A Goal Based Approach to Drafting Intestacy Provisions for Heirs Other Than Surviving Spouses," Hastings Law Journal (1995): 941.
61.
The influence of taxes on succession strategies is not investigated.
62.
Hugues Fulchiron , "Die Weitergabe von Vermögen in Fortsetzungsfamilien ," in Fortsetzungsfamilien, eds. Marie-Therèse Meulders and Irène Théry (Konstanz : Universitätsverlag, 1998), 331-55.
