Repetitive Transcranial Magnetic Stimulation over the Dorsolateral Prefrontal Cortex for Treating Posttraumatic Stress Disorder: An Exploratory Meta-Analysis of Randomized,Double-Blind and Sham-Controlled Trials

Abstract

French

Objective:

Repetitive transcranial magnetic stimulation (rTMS) applied to the dorsolateral prefrontal cortex (DLPFC) has yielded promising results as a treatment for posttraumatic stress disorder (PTSD). However, to date, no quantitative review of its clinical utility has been published.

Method:

We searched for randomized and sham-controlled trials from 1995 to March 2013 using MEDLINE, Embase, PsycINFO, CENTRAL, and SCOPUS. We then performed an exploratory random effects meta-analysis.

Results:

Studies on rTMS applied to the right DLPFC included 64 adults with PTSD. The pooled Hedges g effect size for pre and post changes in clinician-rated and self-reported PTSD symptoms were, respectively, 1.65 (P < 0.001) and 1.91 (P < 0.001), indicating significant and large-sized differences in outcome favouring active rTMS. Also, there were significant pre and post decreases with active rTMS in overall anxiety (Hedges g = 1.24; P = 0.02) and depressive (Hedges g = 0.85; P < 0.001) symptoms. Dropout rates at study end did not differ between active and sham rTMS groups. Regarding rTMS applied to the left DLPFC, there is only one study published to date (using a high frequency protocol), and its results showed that active rTMS seems to be superior overall to sham rTMS.

Conclusions:

Our exploratory meta-analysis shows that active rTMS applied to the DLPFC seems to be effective and acceptable for treating PTSD. However, the small number of subjects included in the analyses limits the generalizability of these findings. Future studies should include larger samples and deliver optimized stimulation parameters.

Keywords

posttraumatic stress disorder repetitive transcranial magnetic stimulation meta-analysis randomized controlled trials efficacy acceptability

References

Kessler

Berglund

Demler

, Lifetime prevalence and age-of-onset distributions of DSM-IV disorders in the National Comorbidity Survey Replication. Arch Gen Psychiatry. 2005;62:593–602.

Kessler

Sonnega

Bromet

, Posttraumatic stress disorder in the National Comorbidity Survey. Arch Gen Psychiatry. 1995;52:1048–1060.

Bisson

. Post-traumatic stress disorder. BMJ. 2007;334:789–793.

Stein

Seedat

Iversen

, Post-traumatic stress disorder: Medicine and politics. Lancet. 2007;369:139–144.

Brunello

Davidson

Deahl

, Posttraumatic stress disorder: Diagnosis and epidemiology, comorbidity and social consequences, biology and treatment. Neuropsychobiology. 2001;43:150–162.

Solomon

Davidson

. Trauma: Prevalence, impairment, service use, and cost. J Clin Psychiatry. 1997;58(Suppl 9):5–11.

Ipser

Stein

. Evidence-based pharmacotherapy of post-traumatic stress disorder (PTSD). Int J Neuropsychopharmacol. 2012;15:825–840.

Ponniah

Hollon

. Empirically supported psychological treatments for adult acute stress disorder and posttraumatic stress disorder: A review. Depress Anxiety. 2009;26:1086–1109.

Van Etten

Taylor

Comparative efficacy of treatment for posttraumatic stress disorder: A meta-analysis. Clin Psychol Psychother. 1998;5:126–144.

10.

Novakovic

Sher

Lapidus

, Brain stimulation in posttraumatic stress disorder. Eur J Psychotraumatol. 2011;2. doi: 10.3402/ejpt.v2i0.5609. Epub 2011 Oct 17.

11.

George

Post

. Daily left prefrontal repetitive transcranial magnetic stimulation for acute treatment of medication-resistant depression. Am J Psychiatry. 2011;168:356–364.

12.

Rosa

Lisanby

. Somatic treatments for mood disorders. Neuropsychopharmacology. 2012;37:102–116.

13.

Berlim

Van den Eynde

Perdomo

, Response, remission and dropout rates following high frequency repetitive transcranial magnetic stimulation (rTMS) for treating major depression: A systematic review and meta-analysis of randomized, double-blind and sham-controlled trials. Psychol Med. 2014;44:225–239.

14.

Slotema

Aleman

Daskalakis

, Meta-analysis of repetitive transcranial magnetic stimulation in the treatment of auditory verbal hallucinations: Update and effects after one month. Schizophr Res. 2012; 142:40–45.

15.

Patel

Spreng

Shin

, Neurocircuitry models of posttraumatic stress disorder and beyond: A meta-analysis of functional neuroimaging studies. Neurosci Biobehav Rev. 2012;36:2130–2142.

16.

Hayes

Mikedis

. Quantitative meta-analysis of neural activity in posttraumatic stress disorder. Biol Mood Anxiety Disord. 2012;2:9.

17.

Etkin

Wager

. Functional neuroimaging of anxiety: A meta-analysis of emotional processing in PTSD, social anxiety disorder, and specific phobia. Am J Psychiatry. 2007;164:1476–1488.

18.

Moore

. Cognitive abnormalities in posttraumatic stress disorder. Curr Opin Psychiatry. 2009;22:19–24.

19.

McNally

. Cognitive abnormalities in post-traumatic stress disorder. Trends Cogn Sci. 2006;10:271–277.

20.

Vanderhasselt

De Raedt

Baeken

, The influence of rTMS over the right dorsolateral prefrontal cortex on intentional set switching. Exp Brain Res. 2006;172:561–565.

21.

Wagner

Rihs

Mosimann

, Repetitive transcranial magnetic stimulation of the dorsolateral prefrontal cortex affects divided attention immediately after cessation of stimulation. J Psychiatr Res. 2006;40:315–321.

22.

Osaka

Otsuka

Hirose

, Transcranial magnetic stimulation (TMS) applied to left dorsolateral prefrontal cortex disrupts verbal working memory performance in humans. Neurosci Lett. 2007;418:232–235.

23.

Sandrini

Rossini

Miniussi

Lateralized contribution of prefrontal cortex in controlling task-irrelevant information during verbal and spatial working memory tasks: Rtms evidence. Neuropsychologia. 2008;46:2056–2063.

24.

Turriziani

Smirni

Oliveri

, The role of the prefrontal cortex in familiarity and recollection processes during verbal and non-verbal recognition memory: An rTMS study. Neuroimage. 2010;52:348–357.

25.

Hwang

Kim

Park

, Acute high-frequency rTMS of the left dorsolateral prefrontal cortex and attentional control in healthy young men. Brain Res. 2010;1329:152–158.

26.

Vanderhasselt

De Raedt

Leyman

, Acute effects of repetitive transcranial magnetic stimulation on attentional control are related to antidepressant outcomes. J Psychiatry Neurosci. 2009;34:119–126.

27.

van't Wout

Kahn

Sanfey

, Repetitive transcranial magnetic stimulation over the right dorsolateral prefrontal cortex affects strategic decision-making. Neuroreport. 2005;16:1849–1852.

28.

Philiastides

Auksztulewicz

Heekeren

, Causal role of dorsolateral prefrontal cortex in human perceptual decision making. Curr Biol. 2011;21:980–983.

29.

McCann

Kimbrell

Morgan

, Repetitive transcranial magnetic stimulation for posttraumatic stress disorder. Arch Gen Psychiatry. 1998;55:276–279.

30.

Grisaru

Amir

Cohen

, Effect of transcranial magnetic stimulation in posttraumatic stress disorder: A preliminary study. Biol Psychiatry. 1998;44:52–55.

31.

Boggio

Rocha

Oliveira

, Noninvasive brain stimulation with high-frequency and low-intensity repetitive transcranial magnetic stimulation treatment for posttraumatic stress disorder. J Clin Psychiatry. 2010;71:992–999.

32.

Cohen

Kaplan

Kotler

, Repetitive transcranial magnetic stimulation of the right dorsolateral prefrontal cortex in posttraumatic stress disorder: A double-blind, placebo-controlled study. Am J Psychiatry. 2004;161:515–524.

33.

Watts

B V

Landon

Groft

, A sham controlled study of repetitive transcranial magnetic stimulation for posttraumatic stress disorder. Brain Stimul. 2012;5:38–43.

34.

Rosenberg

Mehndiratta

, Repetitive transcranial magnetic stimulation treatment of comorbid posttraumatic stress disorder and major depression. J Neuropsychiatry Clin Neurosci. 2002;14:270–276.

35.

Higgins

JPT

Green

Cochrane handbook for systematic reviews of interventions. 1st ed. West Sussex (GB): John Wiley & Sons Ltd; 2008.

36.

American Psychiatric Association (APA). Diagnostic and statistical manual of mental disorders (DSM-IV). 4th ed. Washington (DC): APA; 1994.

37.

World Health Organization (WHO). The ICD-10 Classification of Mental and Behavioural Disorders: Clinical descriptions and diagnostic guidelines. 10th ed. Geneva (CH): WHO; 1992.

38.

Davidson

Colket

. The eight-item treatment-outcome post-traumatic stress disorder scale: A brief measure to assess treatment outcome in post-traumatic stress disorder. Int Clin Psychopharmacol. 1997;12:41–45.

39.

Wilkins

Lang

Norman

. Synthesis of the psychometric properties of the PTSD checklist (PCL) military, civilian, and specific versions. Depress Anxiety. 2011;28:596–606.

40.

Hamilton

The assessment of anxiety states by rating. Br J Med Psychol. 1959;32:50–55.

41.

Kendall

Finch

Jr Auerbach

, The State-Trait Anxiety Inventory: A systematic evaluation. J Consult Clin Psychol. 1976;44:406–412.

42.

Hamilton

A rating scale for depression. J Neurol Neurosurg Psychiatry. 1960;23:56–62.

43.

Beck

Ward

Mendelson

, An inventory for measuring depression. Arch Gen Psychiatry. 1961;4:561–571.

44.

Jadad

Moore

Carroll

, Assessing the quality of reports of randomized clinical trials: Is blinding necessary? Control Clin Trials. 1996;17:1–12.

45.

Boutron

Guittet

Estellat

, Reporting methods of blinding in randomized trials assessing nonpharmacological treatments. PLoS Med. 2007;4:e61.

46.

Riley

Higgins

Deeks

. Interpretation of random effects meta-analyses. BMJ. 2011;342:d549.

47.

Fergusson

Aaron

Guyatt

, Post-randomisation exclusions: The intention to treat principle and excluding patients from analysis. BMJ. 2002;325:652–654.

48.

Rosenthal

Meta-analytic procedures for social research. Newbury Park (CA): Sage Publications; 1993.

49.

Furukawa

Barbui

Cipriani

, Imputing missing standard deviations in meta-analyses can provide accurate results. J Clin Epidemiol. 2006;59:7–10.

50.

Borenstein

Hedges

Higgins

JPT

, Introduction to meta-analysis. West Sussex (GB): Wiley & Sons Ltd; 2009.

51.

Grissom

Kim

. Effect sizes for research—univariate and multivariate application. New York (NY): Routledge; 2012.

52.

Cooper

Hedges

Valentine

. The handbook of research synthesis and meta-analysis. New York (NY): Russell Sage Foundation Publications; 2009.

53.

Rosenthal

The file drawer problem and tolerance for null results. Psychol Bull. 1979;86:638–641.

54.

Egger

Davey Smith

Schneider

, Bias in meta-analysis detected by a simple, graphical test. BMJ. 1997;315:629–634.

55.

Rothstein

Sutton

Borenstein

Publication bias in meta-analysis: Prevention, assessment and adjustments. 1st ed. London (GB): John Wiley & Sons Ltd; 2005.

56.

Hoogendam

Ramakers

Di Lazzaro

Physiology of repetitive transcranial magnetic stimulation of the human brain. Brain Stimul. 2010;3:95–118.

57.

Bestmann

The physiological basis of transcranial magnetic stimulation. Trends Cogn Sci. 2008;12:81–83.

58.

Iyer

Schleper

Wassermann

. Priming stimulation enhances the depressant effect of low-frequency repetitive transcranial magnetic stimulation. J Neurosci. 2003;23:10867–10872.

59.

Touge

Gerschlager

Brown

, Are the after-effects of low-frequency rTMS on motor cortex excitability due to changes in the efficacy of cortical synapses? Clin Neurophysiol. 2001;112:2138–2145.

60.

Weisz

Steidle

Lorenz

Formerly known as inhibitory: Effects of 1-Hz rTMS on auditory cortex are state-dependent. Eur J Neurosci. 2012;36:2077–2087.

61.

Daskalakis

Moller

Christensen

, The effects of repetitive transcranial magnetic stimulation on cortical inhibition in healthy human subjects. Exp Brain Res. 2006;174:403–412.

62.

Pare

Duvarci

Amygdala microcircuits mediating fear expression and extinction. Curr Opin Neurobiol. 2012;22:717–723.

63.

Mahan

Ressler

. Fear conditioning, synaptic plasticity and the amygdala: Implications for posttraumatic stress disorder. Trends Neurosci. 2012;35:24–35.

64.

Kim

Loucks

Palmer

, The structural and functional connectivity of the amygdala: From normal emotion to pathological anxiety. Behav Brain Res. 2011;223:403–410.

65.

Shin

Handwerger

Is posttraumatic stress disorder a stress-induced fear circuitry disorder?

J Trauma Stress. 2009;22:409–415.

66.

Powers

Halpern

Ferenschak

, A meta-analytic review of prolonged exposure for posttraumatic stress disorder. Clin Psychol Rev. 2010;30:635–641.

67.

Pae

Lim

Peindl

, The atypical antipsychotics olanzapine and risperidone in the treatment of posttraumatic stress disorder: A meta-analysis of randomized, double-blind, placebo-controlled clinical trials. Int Clin Psychopharmacol. 2008;23:1–8.

68.

Peterchev

Wagner

Miranda

, Fundamentals of transcranial electric and magnetic stimulation dose: Definition, selection, and reporting practices. Brain Stimul. 2012;5:435–453.

69.

George

Aston-Jones

Noninvasive techniques for probing neurocircuitry and treating illness: Vagus nerve stimulation (VNS), transcranial magnetic stimulation (TMS) and transcranial direct current stimulation (tDCS). Neuropsychopharmacology. 2010;35:301–316.

70.

Matthews

Honey

Bullmore

. Applications of fMRI in translational medicine and clinical practice. Nat Rev Neurosci. 2006;7:732–744.

71.

Khodayari-Rostamabad

Reilly

Hasey

, Using pre-treatment electroencephalography data to predict response to transcranial magnetic stimulation therapy for major depression. Conf Proc IEEE Eng Med Biol Soc. 2011;2011:6418–6421.

72.

Isserles

Shalev

Roth

, Effectiveness of deep transcranial magnetic stimulation combined with a brief exposure procedure in post-traumatic stress disorder—a pilot study. Brain Stimul. 2013; 6(3):377–383. doi: 10.1016/j.brs.2012.07.008. Epub 2012 Aug 18.

73.

Huang

Y-Z

Edwards

Rounis

, Theta burst stimulation of the human motor cortex. Neuron. 2005;45:201–206.

74.

Rossi

Hallett

Rossini

, Safety, ethical considerations, and application guidelines for the use of transcranial magnetic stimulation in clinical practice and research. Clin Neurophysiol. 2009;120:2008–2039.

75.

Berlim

Broadbent

Van den Eynde

Blinding integrity in clinical trials of high frequency repetitive transcranial magnetic stimulation (rTMS) for depression: A meta-analysis. Int J Neuropsychopharmacol. 2013;16(5):1173–1181. doi: 10.1017/S1461145712001691. Epub 2013 Feb 11.

76.

Schonfeldt-Lecuona

Lefaucheur

Cardenas-Morales

, The value of neuronavigated rTMS for the treatment of depression. Neurophysiol Clin. 2010;40:37–43.

77.

Wassermann

Zimmermann

Transcranial magnetic brain stimulation: Therapeutic promises and scientific gaps. Pharmacol Ther. 2012;133:98–107.

78.

Ioannidis

. Interpretation of tests of heterogeneity and bias in meta-analysis. J Eval Clin Pract. 2008;14:951–957.

79.

Machii

Cohen

Ramos-Estebanez

, Safety of rTMS to non-motor cortical areas in healthy participants and patients. Clin Neurophysiol. 2006;117:455–471.