The Relationship Between Dogmatism Scores and Performance Ratings Among Adult Educators

Abstract

As a part of a larger research undertaking concerned with identify ing variables which contribute to high performance among adult educators, particularly Extension personnel, this study was ad dressed to an examination of the relationship between dogmatism (open-closed-mindedness) and job performance. Data were col lected by mail questionnaires from 486 out of 503 (96.6%) county Extension workers with major responsibility for adult education programs in agriculture in five states. Dogmatism was measured by the Rokeach Dogmatism Scale (Form E) included in the ques tionnaire. Performance was determined by supervisor ratings using the paired comparison technique.

The data revealed a slight negative relationship (gamma = -.19) between dogmatism and performance. This relationship was affected by the age and level of education of the respondents. Open-minded agents tended to be rated higher in performance than the close-minded.

References

Conway, James A. "Personality Variables and Problem Solving Groups," Administrator's Notebook, XII (1963).

Fillenbaum, S.N. and Jackman, A. "Dogmatism and Anxiety in Relation to Problem Solving: An Extension of Rokeach's Results," Journal of Abnormal and Social Psychology, LXIII (1961 ), pp. 212-214.

Hays, William L. Statistics for Psychologists (New York: Holt, Rinehart and Winston, Inc., 1963).

Kemp, C. Gratton. "Effect of Dogmatism on Critical Thinking," School Science and Mathematics, LX (April, 1960), pp. 314-319.

Kemp, C. Gratton. "Improvement of Critical Thinking in Relation to Open-Closed Belief System," Journal of Experimental Education, XXXI (1963), pp. 321-323.

Klausmeier, Herbert J. and Goodwin, William. Learning and Human Abilities, Second Edition (New York: Harper and Row, Publishers , 1966).

Lawshe, C.H. and Kephart, N.C. Manual for Use with the Lawshe-Kephart Personnel Comparison System (Occupational Research Center, Purdue University, Lafayette, Indiana, July, 1963).

Restle, Frank ; Andrew, Martha ; and Rokeach , Milton. "Differences Between Open- and Closed-Minded Subjects on Learning Set and Oddity Problems," Journal of Abnormal And Social Psychology, LXCIII (1964), pp. 648-654.

Rokeach, Milton. The Open and Closed Mind. (New York: Basic Books, Inc., 1960).