Abstract
A national multicenter study identified 17 South African children with vertically acquired HIV-1 infection and HIV-associated vasculopathy. Five of the children (all indigenous African ancestry) had progressive vascular disease, consistent with moyamoya syndrome. Median presentation age 5.8 years (range 2.2-11). The children with moyamoya syndrome presented with abnormal CD4 counts and raised viral loads. Clinical features included motor deficits, neuroregression, and intellectual disability. Neuroimaging supported progressive vascular disease with preceding clinically silent disease course. Neurologic recovery occurred in 1 patient with improved CD4 counts. Four of the 5 children presented during the era when access to antiretroviral therapy was limited, suggesting that with improved management of HIV-1, progressive vasculopathy is less prevalent. However the insidious disease course illustrated indicates that the syndrome can progress “silently,” and manifest with misleading phenotypes such as cognitive delay or regression. Sub-Saharan Africa has limited access to neuroimaging and affected children may be underdiagnosed.
Over the last decade children with HIV-infection acquired perinatally through vertical transmission are surviving longer. 1 This correlates with improved access to health care, nutritional support and antiretroviral therapies. As children live longer, complications that were previously not recognized in this age group are becoming apparent. 2
Stroke occurs in people with HIV infection due to opportunistic infections, vasculopathy, cardioembolism, and coagulopathy. The term “HIV-associated vasculopathy” relates to various cerebrovascular changes, which include stenosis and aneurysm formation, vasculitis, and accelerated atherosclerosis. 3 This complication may be caused directly or indirectly by HIV infection. The pathogenesis remains a subject of debate.
Moyamoya disease is a rare cerebrovascular disorder of unknown origin due to an occlusion or narrowing of the distal internal carotid, or proximal middle, or anterior cerebral arteries, associated with the development of collateral network at the base of the brain. 4 There is a bimodal age distribution with pediatric patients presenting around 5 years of age mainly with ischemic stroke, and in adults around 40 years of age with ischemic events and or intracranial bleeding. Clinical signs can be diverse including headache, seizures, motor, sensory, speech and visual deficits, syncope, personality changes, involuntary movements, disturbances of consciousness, and intellectual disability. 5 -7 A radiographic picture resembling the disease and referred to as “moyamoya syndrome” occurs with systemic infections, autoimmune, hematological, metabolic or genetic disorders, neoplasm, head trauma, or irradiation to the head. 4
While there are several reports of adults with HIV-1 infection who developed moyamoya syndrome, only 2 case reports were identified in HIV-infected children. 8 -12 Awareness of the presentation and evolution of moyamoya syndrome in children with HIV-1 infection, and the therapeutic implications are important to permit early intervention and improve outcome.
This report describes the South African experience of children presenting with HIV-associated vasculopathy and delineates a subgroup with moyamoya syndrome.
Methodology
The 7 tertiary centers in South Africa with pediatric neurology units were enrolled in a multicenter national study. These hospitals provide the referral routes for complex neurology patients and have the capacity to screen children with cerebrovascular disease. Each center reviewed their patient databases for children managed between 2000 and 2015 with HIV infection and vascular disease. Children with HIV-associated vasculopathy were included based on the finding of any abnormality of the intracranial or extracranial cerebral blood vessels that resulted directly or indirectly from HIV infection, excluding vasculitis associated with opportunistic infection or neoplastic involvement of the vessels. 3
From this group of children, those with moyamoya syndrome were selected.
The care for all children admitted with cerebrovascular disease was in-line with standard international investigation and management guidelines. 13 In relation to the HIV infection, response to antiretroviral therapy was determined by serial viral load measurement. A viral load <400 copies/mL was indicative of effective control of viral replication. . Within the tertiary teaching hospitals children with acquired neurological symptomatology and HIV-1 infection undergo neuroimaging as part of their basic screening. All patients have an emergency CT scan at presentation and subsequently proceed to magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) (1.5 Tesla machine). Specialists from each center documented the presenting features, risk factors and clinical outcomes of children with cerebral HIV-associated vasculopathy with particular focus on the information of those with moyamoya syndrome. The neuroimaging was re-reviewed by the same radiologist (NW) to ensure consistency with prior reports.
The authors describe the demographics, past medical history, HIV-1 management including age at HIV diagnosis, antiretroviral therapy, and viral load and CD4 count responses, presenting clinical features of moyamoya syndrome, neuroimaging findings, and ongoing clinical and imaging outcomes to understand the course of this condition.
Results
Between 2002 and 2015, 17 children presented with cerebral HIV-associated vasculopathy from 3 out of the 7 centers. The remaining 4 centers did not identify any cases referred to their neurology units. The study group are summarized in Table 1. Five children had moyamoya syndrome, 10 had isolated stroke which did not progress to moyamoya syndrome and 2 children had dissections of the carotid artery. No children had cerebral aneurysms at presentation with stroke.
Summary of the Study Cohort of Children With HIV-Associated Vasculopathy Referred to Pediatric Neurology Services in South Africa Between 2000 and 2015.
Abbreviations: Chol, cholesterol; C3, complement C3; F, female; IRIS, immune reconstitution inflammatory syndrome; M, male; TG, triglyceride.
Table 2 details the key features of the children with moyamoya syndrome. All 5 children (4 girls) with moyamoya syndrome were of indigenous African ancestry and acquired HIV-1 infection through vertical transmission. Median age of presentation was 5.8 years (range 2.2 - 11 years). Four presented between 2002 and 2010, and 1 in 2015, when their HIV infection was inadequately suppressed, because either HIV-1 infection was not diagnosed (n = 3) or treatment with antiretroviral therapy was suboptimal (n = 2). Four of the children had no evidence of another cause for their vascular complications, the fifth had dual pathology. Patient 1 presented at 11 years of age with acute right hemiplegia, preceded by transient ischemic attacks. She developed neuroregression 1 year later. Antiretroviral therapy was not available in the government sector at that time and her mother declined antiretroviral therapy enrolment into available research studies and nongovernment organization care programs. She defaulted further intervention and follow-up. Patient 2 presented at 10 years of age, having received antiretroviral therapy from age 3.5 years. His course was characterized by recurrent systemic illnesses and failure to thrive, and he experienced frequent periods of poor viral suppression. He was converted to second-line antiretroviral therapy at 7 years of age and from this point onward his viral load and CD4 count results improved. Persistent global developmental delay and behavioral issues led to neurology referral at 10 years of age. Neuroimaging at this age confirmed long-standing moyamoya syndrome (Figure 1a). He remained static following this presentation with no new neurologic events. Patient 3 was able to access antiretroviral therapy from 3 years of age. Her antiretroviral therapy was discontinued when she was 5 years and 9 months old and she presented a month later when no longer virally suppressed with a left hemiplegia. Neuroimaging confirmed moyamoya syndrome while her clinical profile was limited to focal motor dysfunction (Figures 1b and 1c). Following the reintroduction of antiretroviral therapy and viral suppression her focal neurology improved and no further events have occurred. Patient 4 presented at 3 years of age with a right arm monoparesis, HIV infection was diagnosed on this admission and she was not virally suppressed. She commenced antiretroviral therapy and became virally suppressed with no further stroke-like events but she did have learning difficulties and behavioral problems. Patient 5 presented in 2015 aged 2.2 years. She was known to have Down syndrome. Her mother had tested HIV positive at birth. Accordingly the child received prevention of mother to child transmission therapy and was HIV polymerase chain reaction negative at 3 months of age. But her mother stopped her own antiretroviral therapy and continued to exclusively breastfeed, she died in September 2015 without divulging these medical issues to the child’s father. The father assumed his daughter’s developmental delay and hypotonia was related to Down syndrome. His daughter had never had any AIDS defining illnesses until she presented acutely at 2.2 years with a left hemiplegia and HIV infection was then diagnosed. In addition to the compounding aspects of her Down syndrome and HIV infection she was also anemic. She is awaiting surgical intervention after commencing antiretroviral therapy.
Summary of Children With Moyamoya Syndrome and HIV-1 Infections (Present Study and Published Cases).
Abbreviations: ACA, anterior cerebral artery; AFB, acid fast bacilli; ANCA, antineutrophil cytoplasmic autoantibodies; ANF, antinuclear factor; ART, antiretroviral therapy; ASOT, anti-streptolysin O titre; CD4, number of CD4 T lymphocyte cells; CMV, cytomegalovirus; CRP, C-reactive protein; CSF, cerebrospinal fluid; CT, computed tomography; dsDNA, double stranded DNA; ECG, electrocardiogram; ECHO, echocardiogram; ESR, erythrocyte sedimentation rate; HB, hemoglobin; HSV, herpes simplex virus; ICA, internal carotid artery; Ig, immunoglobulin; IgG, immunoglobulin G; IgM, immunoglobulin M; L, left; LDL, viral load that is below the lower detection limit (<400 copies/mL); MCA, middle cerebral artery; MCH, mean corpuscular hemoglobin; MCV, mean corpuscular volume; MRA, magnetic resonance angiography; MRI, magnetic resonance imaging; N/A, not applicable; PCA, posterior cerebal artery; R, right; RF, rheumatoid factor; RPR, rapid plasma reagent screening for syphilis; TB, tuberculosis; TIA, transient ischemic attack; USA, United States of America; VDRL, Venereal Disease Research Laboratory test for syphilis.

Neuroimaging from patients 2 and 3 with moyamoya syndrome. (a) T2-weighted axial MRI of patient 2 demonstrating intense “net-like” collateral formation in the circle of Willis and ambient wing cisterns (1) with chronic infarcts in the left temporal lobe with gliosis (2) and a large lacune in the midbrain. Also note attenuation of the right MCA (3). (b) T2-weighted axial MRI of patient 3 demonstrating less intense collateral formation around the circle of Willis but with severe attenuation of the right MCA (1). (c) The corresponding MRA of patient 3 demonstrates complete occlusion of the right MCA (1), both ACAs (2), and narrowing of the distal ICAs with attenuation of the M2 segment of the left MCA (3). Abbreviations: ACA, anterior cerebral artery; ICA, internal carotid artery; MCA, middle cerebral artery; MRA, magnetic resonance angiography; MRI, magnetic resonance imaging.
Neurosurgical intervention of burr holes and synangiosis of the brain via the external circulation was considered indicated based on experience in children with Down syndrome and moyamoya syndrome. 14 All the children with moyamoya syndrome had neuroimaging evidence of preceding vascular events, which appeared to be silent. Manifestations were not restricted to the motor system but included cognitive impairment and/or regression.
Between 2002 and 2011 10 additional HIV-1-infected children (7 male; median age 7 years, range 2 years and 3 months to 11 years of age) presented with acute ischemic stroke (3 left and 6 right hemiplegias, and another child with regression). These children did not progress to moyamoya syndrome and were diagnosed with isolated cerebral HIV-associated vasculopathy.
The children with moyamoya did not have other HIV related factors which could have predisposed them to stroke, their main common factor was poor viral suppression. While the children with isolated events and no evidence of progression in vasculopathy, had more variable viral suppression, and 9 out of the 10 had additional factors which could have predisposed them to stroke (Table 1). While the study group of children with Moyamoya syndrome is small, improvement or stable course was evident for patients 2, 3 and 4 following maintained viral suppression.
Discussion
The authors describe 17 children with HIV-associated vasculopathy, 5 of this cohort had moyamoya syndrome, a serious and rarely reported complication of HIV-1 infection (Table 2). Two other pediatric cases of moyamoya syndrome are published and their details are also summarized in Table 2. 9,12
Most children in this report presented to neurology services between 5 and 13 years ago. From April 2004 the South African National Department of Health rolled out antiretroviral therapy in the public sector and antiretroviral therapy became widely available to HIV-infected children. No further cases of moyamoya syndrome have presented in the last 5 years, except for the child with the additional risk factor of Down syndrome. 15 The implication could be that improved access to antiretroviral therapy restricted the development of HIV vasculopathies and their progression to moyamoya syndrome. Beyond HIV-1 infection, there were no other causes evident for their vascular presentation.
The children in this series had evidence of silent disease progression before their acute presentation(patients 3-5) and well as illustrating misleading phenotypes such as HIV encephalopathy (patient 2). Vascular progression can be ongoing in HIV-infected children who are not adequately virally suppressed. 9,12 There should be a low threshold for performing isolated and even serial MRI in the “work-up” of children with HIV-1 to enable early detection and intervention.
Without widespread access to neuroimaging it is not possible to provide an accurate estimate of the prevalence and incidence of moyamoya syndrome in HIV-infected children. Furthermore, with improving HIV care, the incidence of progressive HIV-1 vasculopathy may be lower in settings with high antiretroviral therapy coverage. Across sub-Saharan Africa while the incidence of pediatric HIV-1 infection has declined appreciably because of the widespread use of interventions to prevent mother-to-child transmission, HIV prevalence among children has remained high (340,000 HIV-infected children less than 15 years of age in South Africa at the end of 2014), access to antiretroviral therapy is not reliable and screening by MRI a scarce resource. There may be other children with HIV-1 not assessed who lack diagnostic closure.
Where moyamoya syndrome is identified, serial imaging should be considered because it can evolve “silently.” 9 Children with neurocognitive regression are often considered to have HIV encephalopathy but patients 1 and 2 illustrated that this assumption is not always true. Without neuroimaging their progressive vascular disease would have been missed. Even in South Africa where MRI is available, there are resource limitations which affected the completeness of the neuroimaging performed in the authors’ patients.
There was overlap in the clinical presentations of the 10 children with isolated acute ischemic strokes compared to the children with moyamoya disease, in that these children presented with isolated motor deficits. Without access to neuroimaging patients 1, 3, 4, and 5 could have been considered to have acute ischemic stroke, and the underlying moyamoya not suspected until the children re-presented with further manifestations.
Patient 5 was also complex and illustrated the layering effect often seen in Africa where dual pathologies are common, in this case it cannot be definitively stated which was the primary cause for the moyamoya syndrome, the Down syndrome, or the HIV-1 infection. It is possible that both played a part in the clinical expression. 15 This most recent patient with progressive vascular disease was not diagnosed with HIV until her presentation with stroke because her mother elected not to disclose her status to her family or to comply with antiretroviral therapy. The time of the child’s seroconversion is not known and she may have had poor viral suppression for some time before presentation with stroke.
The underlying pathogenesis of HIV vasculopathy is not elucidated but immune dysregulation including proinflammatory cytokine imbalances induced by HIV-1 infection may alter endothelial function and induce endothelial cell damage. 8 In addition antiretroviral therapy may induce dyslipidaemia and is implicated in endothelial damage and the acceleration of atherosclerotic disease. 8 Whether these effects contribute to the development of moyamoya syndrome remains unclear.
Limitations of this study are that this it is a retrospective study and as such lacked prospective recruitment following standardized screens of large populations of children with HIV. Rather the study related to the reactive responses to children presenting to specialized services, which required recognition of cerebrovascular disease and referral pathways to be in place. These are lacking and a major challenge across the country. Further the capacity of centers to comprehensively screen patients is another challenge in itself. Even tertiary centers in South Africa have limited access to neuroimaging, often with long waiting lists. Children with subtle hemiplegia can be missed in the context of busy infectious diseases services where the main focus relates to control of viral load and more global health care. 2
While overall health and adequate blood CD4 count and viral load are important in the care for children with HIV-1 and moyamoya syndrome, there are novel interventions in the field of moyamoya disease and syndrome that could be considered. 16 Therapies have been evaluated in patients with other etiologies for moyamoya syndrome, or moyamoya disease, but are yet to be trialed in affected children with HIV-1 disease. Establishing whether interventions such as burr holes are beneficial would be important for developing consensus management recommendations in these patients. 16
Footnotes
Acknowledgments
The authors acknowledge Gail Scher, John Rodda (Johannesburg), Izelle Smuts (Pretoria), Tiziana Aduc (Johannesburg), and Andre Venter (Bloemfontein) for reviewing their patient databases for evidence of additional patients across public and private sectors.
Author Contributions
CKH wrote the original draft, completed the literature search, assisted with patient data collection, and summarized the cases. ASC, RG, RVT, and LM contributed to the patient data collection. NW provided critical advice relating to the neuroimaging, reviewed all neuroimaging studies, and provided key images from the affected children. AN provided advice on terminology and proofread the manuscript. BE provided advice on HIV treatment aspects of the manuscript, provided a critique of the content, and proofread the final version. JMW conceptualized the study, supervised the data collection, contributed to the manuscript content, and approved the final version.
Declaration of Conflicting Interests
The authors declared no potential conflicts of interest with respect to the research, authorship, and/or publication of this article.
Funding
The authors received no financial support for the research, authorship, and/or publication of this article.
Ethical Approval
The University of Cape Town Faculty of Health Sciences Research and Ethics approved the project (R499/2015).
References
Supplementary Material
Please find the following supplemental material available below.
For Open Access articles published under a Creative Commons License, all supplemental material carries the same license as the article it is associated with.
For non-Open Access articles published, all supplemental material carries a non-exclusive license, and permission requests for re-use of supplemental material or any part of supplemental material shall be sent directly to the copyright owner as specified in the copyright notice associated with the article.
