German Unification in 1990 was processed by the imposition of the `western' institutional framework on the former east. Legal, administrative and fiscal systems were transferred as part of the Unification Treaty together with the West German industrial relations machinery of co-determination in collective bargaining and participation at the level of the workplace. However the fact that the two Germanies had grown in different economic, social and ideological environments over the previous 40 years raises questions about the viability of such institutional transference. Feelings of `colonisation' and frustrated expectations have been identified as western dominance of officialdom and disappointment at the product of Unification has emerged in the east. Within the public sector these problems have been accompanied with ideological purges of public servants in social policy and education after investigation of past involvement with the former GDR secret police network.
This article examines institutional transference with reference to the case of secondary education teachers. Disputes over wage equalisation, job cuts and non-recognition of former GDR teaching qualifications are examined together with attitudes of classroom teachers to the changing nature of their work, their status as teachers and their involvement as trade union participants in the German participatory system of industrial relations.
References
1.
Behrend, H. (1995) `Inglorious German Unification' in H. Behrend (ed.), German Unification: The Destruction of an Economy, London: Pluto.
2.
Berking, H. and Neckel, S. (1991) `Aussenseiter als Politiker: Restruktierung und Identititen neuer lokaler Eliten in einer ostdeutschen gemeinde', Sozialer Welt, 42, 3.
3.
Bluhm, K (1995) `Kommentar: Arbeitsorientierungen im Umbruch' in D. Dathe (ed.), Wege aus der Krise derArbeitsgeselschaft. Berlin: Hans B6ckler Stiftung and Sozialwissenschafldichenzentrum.
4.
Bispinck, R. (1995) `Tarifangleichung in kleinen Schritten', WSI Mistlungen, 3.
5.
Childs, D. (1988) The GDR: Moscow's German Alty, London: Unwin Hyman.
6.
Dennis, M. (1993) Social and Economic Modernisation in Eastern Germany from Honecker to Kohl, London and New York: Pinter.
7.
Eidam, F-M. and Oswald, H. (1993) `Reformfaihig durch den Osten', in G. Leifet aL (eds), Reform des DGB.
8.
Ettl, W. and Heikenroth, A. (1995) `Strukturwandel, Verbandabstinenz, Tarifflucht: Zur Lage ostdeutscher Unternehmen und Arbeitgeberverbände', Working Paper 95/3. Berlin: Max-Planck-Gesselschaft Arbeitsgruppetransformationsprozeß.
9.
Fantasia, R. (1989) Cultures of Solidarity, Berkeley: California University Press.
10.
Fichter, M. (1993) `A House Divided: A view of German Unification as it has affected organised labour', German Politics, 2, 1, 21-39.
11.
Fichter, M. (1997) `Trade Union members: a vanishing species in post-Unification Germany?', German Studies Review, 20, 1, 83-104.
12.
Frege, C. (1995) Union Membership Relations in post-socialist east Germany: who participates in collective action?, Paper presented to the British Universities Industrial Relations Association Conference, Durham, England, June 1995.
13.
Frege, C. (1997) `Does economic transformation undermine union collectivism? The case of East German textile workers', Industrial Relations journal, 28, 3, 163-175.
14.
Götz, K. (1995) `Administrative Reconstruction in the New Uander: The Federal Dimension', paper presented to the Workshop State and Civil society in the new German Lander, London School of Economics, 8-9 December 1995.
15.
Heering, W. and Schroder, K. (1995) `Vom Arbeitskollektiv zur Sozial-partnerschaft', in R. Schmidt and B. Lutz (eds), Chancen und risikender industriellen Restruktierung in Ostdeutschland, Berlin: Akadamie.
16.
Hegewisch, A. and Tóth, A. (1997) `Searching for correlation: trade unions and employee relations at enterprise level in the Czech Republic, Hungary and Poland', Paper presented to the IIRA European Congress, Dublin, August.
17.
Heidenreich, M. (1991) `Zur Doppelstruktur planwirtschaftlichen Handelns in der DDR', Zeitschrift fur Soziologie, 20, 6, 411-429.
18.
Hondrich, K., Joost, A., Koch-Arzberger, C. and Wörndl, B. (1993) Arbeitgeber West, Arbeitnehmer Ost: Vereinigung im Konflikt, Berlin: Aufbau Taschenbuch.
19.
Hoyer, H-D. (1996) Lehrer im Transformationsprozeβ, Weinheim and Munich: Max-Traeger-Stiftung, Juventa.
20.
Hyman, R. (1996) Institutional Transfer: Industrial Relations in eastern Germany, Berlin: WZB.
21.
Jander, M. and Lutz, S. (1991) `Betriebsrate in der ehemaligen DDR - eine vernachlassigte Institution', Berliner arbeitshefte und Berichte zur sozialwissenschafdliche Forschung, 66, Zentral Institut fiir Sozialwissenschaftliche Forschung, FU, Berlin.
22.
Kelly, J. and Kelly, C. (1992) `Industrial Action' in J. Hartley and G. M. Stephenson (eds), Employee Relations: the Psychology of Influence and Control at Work, Oxford: Blackwell.
23.
Kelly, J. and Nicholson, N. (1980) `The causation of strikes: a review of theoretical approaches and the potential contribution of social psychology', Human Relations Journal, 33, 12, 853-883.
24.
Koch, K. (1995) `The German Works Council and Collective Bargaining Development since Unification', German Politics, 4, 3, 145-155.
25.
Koch, T. (1992) `Deutungs und Handlungsmuskernsozialer Akteure im Transformationprozess - Lehrer in Koepenick' in Wissenschafdiche Mitteilungen aus dem Berliner Institutffuer Sozialwissenschaftliche Studien, Heft 8.
26.
Kreißig, V. and Preusche, E. (1992) `Mitbestimmung in den neuen Bundeslandern auf Betrieblicher Ebene', in WSI Mittedungen, 9.
27.
Lehmbruch, G. (1994) `Institutionen, Interessen und sektorale Variationen in der Transformationsdynamik der politischen Oekonomie Ostdeutschlands', JYournalfar Sozialforschung, 34, 1, 21-45.
28.
Lenhardt, G., Stock, M. and Tiedke, M. (1992) `Zur transformation der lehrerolle in der ehemaligen DDR', in Soziologie in Deutschland und die Transformation groJier gesellschaftlicher Systeme, Berlin: Akademie.
29.
Lohr, K., Robenhack, S. and Schmidt, E. (1995) `Industrielle Beziehungen im Wandel', in R. Schmidt and B. Lutz (eds), Chancen und Risiken der industriellen Restruktierung in Ostdeutschand, Berlin: Akademie.
30.
Lowitt, T. (1982) `The working class and trade union structures in eastern Europe', British Journal of Industrial Relations, 20, 67-75.
31.
Martens, H. (1994) `Gewerkschaftlicher Organisationsaufbau und Mitbestimmung in Ost-Deutschland', in R. Hoffmanet al. (eds), Problemstart: Politischer und sozialer Wandel in den neuen Bundesldndern, Cologne; Bund.
32.
Matthies, H., Muckenberger, U., Offe, C., Peter, E. and Raasch, S. (1994) Arbeit 2000, Reinbeck: Rowohlt.
33.
McAdam, D. (1988) `Micromobilisation contexts and recruitment to activism', International Social Movement Research, Vol. 1, pp. 125-154.
34.
Morgenroth, C., Niemayer, E. and Hollman, R. (1994) Realistische Utopien: Beteiigungsgewerkschaft als Zukunfitsperpektive, Cologne: Bund Verlag.
35.
Muller, B. (1993) `Der Mythos von faulen Ossi: Deutsche-deutsche Voruteile und die Erfahrungen mit der Marktwirtschaft in drei Ostberliner Betrieben', in PROKLA: Zeitschriftfar kritische Sozialwissenschat, Heft 91.23.
36.
Niedermayer, O. and von Beyme, K. (eds.) (1994) Politische Kultur in Ost- und West Deutschland, Berlin: Akademie.
37.
Osterland, M. (1994) `Coping with Democracy: the Re-institution of local self-government in eastern Germany', European Urban and Regional Studies, 1, 1, 5-17.
38.
Page, J. (1985) `Education under the Honeckers', in D. Childs (ed.), Honecker's Germany, London: Allen and Unwin.
39.
Sachs, J. (1993) Poland's Jump to the Market Economy, Cambridge, Mass.: MIT Press.
40.
Sesselmeier, W. (1991) `Brauchen Unternehmer in der ehemaligen DDR Mitbestimmung?' in W. Sesselmeier (ed.), Probleme der Einheit, Marburg: Metropolis.
41.
Stagner, R. and Eflal, B. (1982) `Internal union Dynamics during a Strike: a quasi-experimental study', Journal of Applied Psychology, 67, 1, 37-44.
42.
Thompson, P. and Smith, C. (1992) `Socialism and the Labour Process', in C. Smith and P. Thompson (eds), Labour in Transition: the Labour Process in Eastern Europe and China, London: Routledge.
43.
Upchurch, M. (1995) `After Unification: Trade Unions and Industrial Relations in eastern Germany', Industrial Relations Journal, 26, 4, 280-292.
44.
von Beyme, K. (1994) `Verfehlte Vereinigung - verpasste Reformen? Zur Problematik der Evaluation der Vereinigungspolitik in Deutschland seit 1989', Journal far Sozialforschung, 34, 1, 249-269.
45.
Voskamp, U. and Wittke, V. (1991) `Industrial restructuring in the former GDR: barriers to adaptive reform become downward development spirals', Politics and Society, 19, 3, 341-371.
46.
Wiesenthal, H. (1992) `Sturz in die Moderne: Der Sonderstatus der DDR in den Transformationsprozessen Osteuropas', in M. Brie and D. Klein (eds), Zwischen den Zeiten, Hamburg: VSA Verlag.
47.
Wiesenthal, H. (1994) `East Germany as a unique case of societal transformation: main characteristics and emergent misconceptions'Arbeitspapiere 94/8, Berlin: Max-Planck-Gesellschaft, Arbeitsgruppetransformationprozesse in den neuen Bundeslindern, Humboldt Universityt.
48.
Zapf, W. (1992) `Die Transformation in der ehemaligen DDR und die soziologische Theorie der Modernisierung', Berlin: WZB Papers,92-104.
49.
Zimmerman, H. (ed.) (1985) DDR Handbuch, 1985, Cologne: Verlag Wissenschaft.
