Analytic Hierarchy Process for Selection of Erp Software for Manufacturing Companies

Abstract

Enterprise Resource Planning (ERP) systems are popular as an IT enabled tool, which integrates different functional areas of business. ERP systems are implemented as a total business solution that supports major functionalities of business. However, many of the implementations are not success stories. Most post implementation problems are due to the inappropriate selection of systems.

This paper describes multi-criteria decision model using Analytic Hierarchy Process for the selection of ERP systems for manufacturing companies. First, ERP evaluation criteria are developed by using past literature and through a questionnaire distributed among Sri Lankan manufacturing companies. Seven major criteria are identified and under each criterion several sub-criteria are identified. Selection of the best suited ERP system leads to a multi-criteria decision making problem as ERP systems should be evaluated based upon many criteria. Using the identified main and sub criteria, an Analytic Hierarchy Process (AHP) model is developed for ranking the ERP software. An example of a case is presented to show the actual implementation of AHP model. Expert Choice software is used to solve this AHP model.

Keywords

Enterprise Resource Planning Analytic Hierarchy Process Multi-criteria Decision Making

References

Al-Mashari

(2000), “Constructs of Process Change Management in ERP Context: A Focus on SAP R/3”, Proceedings of the Sixth Americas Conference on Information Systems ( Chung

M. H.

, Ed), Long Beach, CA. pp. 977–980.

Appleton

E. L.

(1997), “How to Survive ERP”, Datamation, 43, pp. 50–53.

Caldwell

Stein

(1998), “Beyond ERP: New IT Agenda”, Information Week, November, 30.

Davenport

(2000), Mission Critical – Realising the Promise of Enterprise Systems, Harvard Business School Press, Boston, M.A.

Donovan

R. M

(2000), “Why the Controversy Over ROI from ERP?” Mid Range ERP, http://www.midrangeerp.com (Accessed on January, 2005).

Fitzgerald

(1998), “Evaluating Information Systems Projects: A Multi-Dimensional Approach”, Journal of Information Technology, 13, pp. 15–27.

Gable

Stewart

(1999), “SAP R/3 Implementation Issues for Small to Medium Enterprises”, Proceedings of the Fifth Americas Conference on Information Systems, Milwaukee, Wisconsin, pp. 779–781.

Hecht

(1997), “Management Resources-Choose the Right ERP Software”, Plugin Datamation. 4, pp. 31–42.

Hill

(1998), “It Just Takes Work”, Manufacturing Systems, Selecting and Implementing Enterprise Solutions Supplement, pp. A2–A10.

10.

Kuiper

Tipton

(1998), “Steak Vs Sizzle”, Manufacturing Systems, Selecting and Implementing Enterprise Solutions Supplement, pp. A18–A25.

11.

Laudon

K. C.

Laudon

J. P.

(1998), Management Information Systems – New Approaches to Organisation and Technology, Prentice Hall, (5th Ed.), London.

12.

Marion

(1998), “Systems Sizing: Nobody Gets It Right”, Datamation, December, http://itmanagement.earthweb.com/entdev/article.php (Accessed, January 2008).

13.

Prosser

Canty

(1998), “Proof of Concept: An Efficient Way to Shop”, APICS-The Performance Advantage, 8.6, pp. 50–52.

14.

Roger

(1987), “Justification of FMS with the Analytical Hierarchy Process”, Journal of Manufacturing, 7.3, pp. 175–182.

15.

Saaty

T. L.

(1980), Analytic Hierarchy Process, McGrawHill, New York, NY.

16.

Sadagopan

(1999), “Software Features-Frequently Asked Questions on ERP in India”, http://www.iibmnet.ernet.in/ss/erp-faq/index.html (Accessed, January 2008).

17.

Shankarnarayanan

(1999), “ERP Systems – Using IT to Gain a Competitive Advantage”, http://www.expressindia.com/newads/bsl/advant.htm (Accessed, March 2008).

18.

Slater

(1999), “An ERP Package for You.and You.and You.and even You”, CIO Magazine, February 15, http://www.cio.com.au/index.php/id;1843371685 (Accessed, March 2008).

19.

Sperry

(1998), “Implementation: A Vital Criteria in ERP System Selection”, Manufacturing and Distribution Issues, Grant Thornton Newsletter for Industrial Companies, 9.3, pp. 3–5.

20.

Stedman

(1999), “Survey: ERP Costs More than Measurable ROI”, http://www.computerworld.com/news/1999/story/0,11280,35232,00.html (Accessed, April 2008).

21.

Teltumbde

(2000), “A Framework for Evaluating ERP Projects”, International Journal of Production Research, 38, pp. 4507–4520.