In August 1875 in a Bankruptcy matter being heard at the Summer Assizes at Bristol in
England, Mr Justice Quain gave vent to his spleen over the accounting profession's
increasing hold on jurisdiction over bankruptcy matters. His remarks were not
necessary for the decision but he found some support from the jury and the press of
the day. In making his remarks he seems to have been echoing the sentiments of the
legal profession of the time. The case itself was pedestrian-but the attention of
the Daily Telegraph and the rebuttals in the accounting press give some insight into
the struggle by accountants for professional recognition and the clash between the
accounting and legal professions over jurisdiction in the latter half of the
nineteenth century.
Accountant, The, Various issues including October 1874,
December 1874, 13 March 1875, 21 & 28 August 1875, 4, 11 & 18
September 1875, 3 June 1876.
2.
Bankruptcy Act1869 (United Kingdom).
3.
Boys, P.
, (1994), "The Origins and Evolution of the Accountancy
Profession", in
Habgood, W.
(ed.), (1994), Chartered Accountants in England and Wales. A Guide to
Historical Records,
Manchester: Manchester University Press
, pp.1-63.
4.
Brown, L.
, (1985), Victorian News and Newspapers,
Oxford: Clarendon Press
.
5.
Brown, R.
, (1905), A History of Accounting and Accountants,
Edinburgh: T.C. & E.C. Jack
.
6.
Claridge, W.W.
, (1920), "President's Address" [to the Society of
Incorporated Accountants and Auditors], The Accountant, 29
May, pp.644-646.
7.
Cooper, E.
, (1921), "Fifty Seven Years in an Accountant's
Office", The Accountant, 22 October, pp.553-563.
8.
Cornwell, S.V.P.
, (1993),
"The Nature of a Bristol Accountancy Practice During the 1820s: Some Comments"
, Accounting, Business and Financial History, Vol.3,
No.2, pp.
155-164
.
9.
Edwards, J.R.
, (1989), A History of Financial Accounting,
London: Routledge
.
10.
Goldman, L.
, (1986),
"The Social Science Association, 1857-1886: A Context For Mid-Victorian Liberalism"
, The English Historical Review, Vol.101, pp.
95-134
.
11.
Hansard, third series, 1868-1869, CXCV, columns
162, 164
12.
Hansard, third series, 1876, CCXXIX, columns 1500-1506.
13.
ICAS
, (1954), A History of the Chartered Accountants of Scotland
from the Earliest Times to 1954,
Edinburgh: The ICAS
.
14.
Jeel, E.F.
, (1937), "Some Reflections on the Evolution of the
Practice of Accounting in Great Britain", The Accountant, 10
April, pp.521-529.
15.
Kedslie, M.J.M.
, (1990),
"Mutual Self Interest-A Unifying Force: The Dominance of Social Closure
Over Social Background"
, The Accounting Historians Journal, Vol.17,
No.2, pp.
1-19
.
16.
Kitchen, J.
, (1982), "Auditing Past Development and Current
Practice", in
Hopwood, A.G.
,
Bromwich, M.
and
Shaw, J.
(eds.), (1982), Auditing Research: Issues and Opportunities,
London: Pitman Books
, pp.25-51.
17.
Law Times, The, 6 December 1879, December 1884.
18.
Lee, T.
, (1995),
"The Professionalisation of Accounting: A History of Protecting the Public
Interest in a Self-Interested Way"
, Accounting, Auditing and Accountability Journal,
Vol.8, No.4, pp.
48-69
.
19.
Lester, M.V.
, (1995), Victorian Insolvency. Bankruptcy, Imprisonment for
Debt, and Company Winding-up in Nineteenth Century England,
Oxford: Clarendon Press
.
20.
McClelland, J.
, (1874), "Chartered Accountants in Scotland",
The Accountant, December, pp.6-7.
21.
MacDonald, K.M.
, (1995), The Sociology of the Professions,
London: Sage Publications
.
22.
Millerson, G.
, (1964), The Qualifying Associations-A Study in
Professionalisation,
London: Routledge & Kegan Paul
.
23.
Most, K.S.
, (1993), The Future of the Accounting Profession-A Global
Perspective,
Westport: Quorum Books
.
24.
Reid, J.L.
, (1894),
"A Needed Profession"
, The North American Review, Vol.69, pp.
510-512
.
25.
Robinson H.W.
, (1964), A History of Accountants in Ireland,
Dublin: The Institute of Chartered Accountants
in Ireland
.
26.
Shackleton, K.
, (1995),
"Scottish Chartered Accountants: Internal and External Relationships 1853-1916"
, Accounting, Auditing and Accountability Journal,
Vol.8, No.2, pp.
18-46
.
27.
Solicitors' Journal and Reporter, The, 24 March 1877, p.
394-394
.
28.
Sugarman, D.
, (1995), "Who Colonized Whom? Historical Reflections on
the Intersection Between Law, Lawyers and Accountants in England", in
Dezalay, Y.
&
Sugarman, D.
(eds.), (1995), Professional Competition and Professional
Power Lawyers, Accountants and the Social Construction of Markets,
London: Routledge
, pp.226-237.
29.
Times, The, 9 January 1868, 16 August 1875.
30.
Walker, S.P.
, (1995),
"The Genesis of Professional Organization in Scotland: A Contextual Analysis"
, Accounting, Organizations and Society, Vol.20,
No.4, pp.
285-310
.
31.
Walker, S.P.
, (1996),
"The Criminal Upperworld and the Mergence of a Disciplinary Code in the
Early Chartered Accountancy Profession"
, Accounting History, NS Vol.1, No.2,
November, pp.
7-35
.
32.
West, B.P.
, (1996),
"The Professionalisation of Accountancy"
, Accounting History, NS Vol.1, No.1,
May, pp.
77-103
.
33.
Woolf, A.H.
, (1912), A Short History of Accountants and Accounting,
London: Gee & Co. (Publishers) Ltd.
